Differences In Skull Size Of Harbour Porpoises, Phocoena phocoena (Cetacea), In The Sea Of Azov And The Black Sea: Evidence For Different Morphotypes And Populations

P. E. Goldin 1  and K. A. Vishnyakova 2
  • 1 The Museum of Southern Jutland, Lergravsvej, 2, Gram, 6510 Denmark
  • 2 Institute of Marine Fisheries and Oceanography, Sverdlova str., 2, Kerch, Crimea, 98300 Ukraine


There are two porpoise stocks in the northern Black Sea: the north-western (Odessa Gulf) and northeastern (Crimean and Caucasian waters); in addition, another stock is in the Sea of Azov. The Azov porpoises are distinct in their body size and biology. This research was conducted on the skulls of stranded sexually mature porpoises from the north-eastern Black Sea, north-western Black Sea and the Sea of Azov. In the north-eastern Black Sea samples, both present-day and old-time, the sexual dimorphism of the skull size was not significant, whereas in the Sea of Azov the females were significantly larger than males. The Azov skulls were strongly different from those from the Black Sea: they were larger, proportionally wider and had the wider rostra; also, there was no significant chronological variation within the Black Sea. The Azov and Black Sea samples were classified with the 100 % success with four variables. The northwestern Black Sea skulls were somewhat intermediate in their characteristics between the Azov and northeastern Black Sea samples, but they were classify ed together with other Black Sea specimens. The difference between the Azov and Black Sea skulls was greater than between many North Atlantic populations, despite the extreme geographical proximity of the two stocks. The low variation within the Black Sea supports the earlier conclusions on the lack of genetic variation: all the Black Sea stocks are expected to be genetically similar sub-populations, whereas the Azov and Marmara stocks possibly represent the genetically distant populations. The porpoises from the Black Sea and the Sea of Azov equally show the traits which characterize the subspecies Phocoena phocoena relicta, but the Black Sea porpoises appear to be more paedomorphic in terms of ontogenetic trajectories.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Abel, O. Ein Stammtype der Delphiniden aus dem Miocän der Halbinsel Taman // Jahrbuch K. K. Geolog. Reichs-Anst. — Wien, 1905. — 55. — S. 375–392.

  • Amano, M., Miyazaki, N. Geographic variation in skulls of the harbor porpoise, Phocoena phocoena // Mammalia. — 1992. — 56, N 1. — P. 133–144.

  • Barabash-Nikiforov, I. I. Cetacean fauna of the Black Sea, its composition and origin. — Voronezh : Izdatelstvo Voronezhskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, 1940. — 87 p. — Russian : Барабаш-Никифоров И. И. Фауна китообразных Чёрного моря, её состав и происхождение.

  • Brownell, R. L., Jr. Phocoena sinus // Mammalian Species. — 1983. — 198. — P. 1–3.

  • Börjesson, P., Berggren, P. Morphometric comparisons of skulls of harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) from the Baltic, Kattegat, and Skagerrak Seas // Canadian Journal of Zoology. — 1997. — 75, N 2. — P. 280–287.

  • Fontaine, M. C., Baird, S. J., Piry, S. et al. Rise of oceanographic barriers in continuous populations of a cetacean: the genetic structure of harbour porpoises in Old World waters // BMC Biology. — 2007. — 5, N 1. — 30. doi:10.1186/1741-7007-5-30.

  • Galatius, A. Sexually dimorphic proportions of the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) skeleton // Journal of Anatomy. — 2005. — 206, N 2. — P. 141–154.

  • Galatius, A., Gol’din, P. E. Geographic variation of skeletal ontogeny and skull shape in the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) // Canadian Journal of Zoology. — 2011. — 89, N 9. — P. 869–879.

  • Galatius, A., Kinze, C. C., Teilmann, J. Population structure of harbour porpoises in the Baltic region: evidence of separation based on geometric morphometric comparisons // Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom. — 2012. — 92. — P. 1669–1676.

  • Gao, A., Gaskin, D. E. Geographical variation in metric skull characters among proposed subpopulations and stocks of harbor porpoise, Phocoena phocoena, in the western North Atlantic // Marine Mammal Science. — 1996. — 12, N 4. – P. 516–527.

  • Gaskin, D. E., Blair, B. A. Age determination of harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena in the western North Atlantic // Canadian Journal of Zoology. — 1977. — 55, N 1. — P. 18–30.

  • Gol’din, P. E. Growth and body size of the harbor porpoise Phocoena phocoena (Cetacea, Phocoenidae) in the the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea // Vestnik zoologii. — 2004. — 38, N 4. — P. 59–73.

  • Gol’din, P. E. Taxonomic status of harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) from the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea // Marine mammals of the Holarctic: collection of scientific papers after the Third International Conference, Koktebel, Crimea, Ukraine. — Moscow : KMK, 2004 a. — P. 158–162. — Russian : Гольдин П. Е. Систематическое положение азовки – морской свиньи (Phocoena phocoena) Азовского и Черного морей.

  • Gol’din, P.E. Growth, proportions and variation of the skull of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) from the Sea of Azov // Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom. — 2007. — 87. — P. 271–292.

  • Hammer, Ø., Harper, D. A. T., Ryan, P. D. PAST: Paleontological Statistics Soft ware Package for Education and Data Analysis // Palaeontologia Electronica. — 2001. — 4, N 1. — 9 p.

  • Huggenberger, S., Benke, H., Kinze, C. C. Geographical variation in harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) skulls: support for a separate non-migratory population in the Baltic proper // Ophelia. — 2002. — 56, N 1. — P. 1–12.

  • Kalnina, O. V., Kalnin, V. V. Genetic differentiation and reproductive relationship between the Black Sea race and the Azov Sea race of the European anchovy. 2. Genetic differences between the Black Sea race and the Azov Sea race and their intraracial heterogeneity // Genetika. — 1984. — 20, N 2. — P. 309–313. — Russian : Калнина О. В., Калнин В. В. Генетическая дифференциация и репродуктивные взаимоотношения азовской и черноморской рас европейского анчоуса. Сообщение II. Генетические отличия и внутренняя гетерогенность азовской и черноморской рас анчоуса.

  • Kleinenberg, S. E. Mammals of the Black Sea And the Sea of Azov: An Experience of Biological And Fisheries Research. — Moscow : Izdatelstvo Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1956. — 288 p. — Russian : Клейненберг С. Е. Млекопитающие Черного и Азовского морей.

  • Mikhalev, Yu. A. The peculiarities of the distribution of the harbour porpoise, Phocoena phocoena relicta (Cetacea), in the Black Sea // Vestnik zoologii. — 2005. — 39, N 6. — P. 25–35. — Russian : Михалев Ю. А. Особенности распространения морской свиньи Phocoena phocoena relicta (Cetacea) в Черном море.

  • Noldus, L. P. J. J., de Klerk, R. J. J. Growth of the skull of the harbour porpoise, Phocoena phocoena (Linnaeus, 1758), in the North Sea, after age determination based on dentinal growth layer groups // Zoologische Mededelingen. — 1984. — 58. — P. 213–228.

  • Perrin, W. F. Variation in spotted and spinner dolphin (genus Stenella) in the eastern tropical Pacific and Hawaii // Bulletin of Scripps Institute of Oceanography. — 1975. — 21. — P. 1–206.

  • Ramos, R. M., Di Beneditto, A. P. M., Siciliano, S. et al. Morphology of the franciscana (Pontoporia blainvillei) off southeastern Brazil: sexual dimorphism, growth and geographic variation // Latin American Journal of Aquatic Mammals. — 2002. — 1, N 1. — P. 129–144.

  • Tomilin, A. G. Animals of the USSR and adjacent countries. Vol. 9. Cetaceans. — Moscow : Izdatelstvo Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1957. — 756 p. — Russian : Томилин А. Г. Звери СССР и прилежащих стран. Т. 9. Китообразные.

  • Tonay, A. M., Dede, A., Öztürk, A. A., Öztürk, B. Stomach content of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) from the Turkish Western Black Sea in spring and early summer // Rapport Commission Internationale pour l’Exploration Scientifique de la Mer Méditerranée. — 2007. — 38. — P. 616.

  • Tonay, A. M., Dede, A., Maracı, Ö., Bilgin, R. A preliminary genetic study on the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) in the Turkish Seas // Journal of Black Sea/Mediterranean Environment. — 2012. — 18. — P. 83–89.

  • Viaud-Martínez, K. A., Martínez Vergara, M., Gol’din, P. E. et al. Morphological and genetic differentiation of the Black Sea harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena // Marine Ecology Progress Series. — 2007. — 338. — P. 281–294.

  • Vishnyakova, K. A., Savenko, O. V., Oleynikov, E. P. et al. Shifting of the spring migration period of the porpoises (Phocoena phocoena relicta) in the Kerch Strait and in the North-Eastern Black Sea in 2011–2012 // Trudy YugNIRO. — 2013. — 51. — P. 32–35. — Russian : Вишнякова К. А., Савенко О. В., Олейников Е. П. и др. Смещение сроков весенней миграции морских свиней в Керченском проливе и в северо-восточной части Черного моря в 2011–2012 гг.

  • Vishnyakova, K., Gol’din, P. Seasonality of strandings and bycatch of harbour porpoises in the Sea of Azov: the effects of fisheries, weather conditions and life history // ICES Journal of Marine Science. — 2015. — 72, N 3. — P. 981–991. doi: 10.1093/icesjms/fsu192

  • Zalkin, V. I. Morphological characteristics, taxonomic status and zoogeographical position of harbour porpoise from the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea // Zoologichesky zhurnal. — 1938. — 17, is. 4. — P. 706–733. — Russian : Цалкин В. И. Морфологическая характеристика, систематическое положение и зоогеографическое значение морской свиньи Азовского и Чёрного морей.

  • Zalkin, V. I. Some observations on the biology of the Azov and Black Seas dolphins // Bulletin of The Moscow Society of Naturalists, Biology. — 1940. — 49, N 1. — P. 61–70. — Russian : Цалкин В. И. Некоторые наблюдения над биологией дельфинов Азовского и Черного морей.


Journal + Issues