Climate Change Policy in Chinese Online Media Discourse: The Case of the Debate on the Copenhagen Climate Summit 2009

Open access

Abstract

This paper discusses the debate in Chinese online media on both climate change policy and the 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen (COP15). Based on the results of a discourse analysis of Chinese language weblogs, the paper argues that at the time of COP15 there was a dominant single discourse coalition, while also identifying alternative discourse formations. The main reasons for this discursive structure seem to be the ways in which actors are participating in the political process, the sensitivity of the topic of climate change in the Chinese discussion, and the influence of foreign debates.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Aden Nathaniel T. and Jonathan E. Sinton. “Environmental Implications of Energy Policy in China.” In Environmental Politics 15/2 2006 pp. 248-270

  • Bamman David Brendan O’Connor and Noah A. Smith. “Censorship and Deletion Practices in Chinese Social Media.” In First Monday 17/3-5 March 2012 http://www.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/3943/3169 accessed March 2012

  • Canada Centre for Global Security Studies/Citizen Lab at Munk School of Global Affairs University of Toronto. “Casting a Wider Net: Lessons Learned in Delivering BBC Content on the Censored Internet.” 11 October 2011 http://munkschool.utoronto.ca/downloads/casting.pdf accessed October 2011

  • Cann Cynthia W. Michael C. Cann and Gao Shangquan. “China’s Road to Sustainable Development: An Overview.” In China’s Environment and the Challenge of Sustainable Development edited by Kirsten A. Day. Armonk and London: M. E. Sharpe 2005 pp. 3-34

  • CCICED. “Qìhòu biànhuà guójiā píngū bàogào’ zhāiyào” 《气候变化国家评估报告》摘要 [Abstract of the National Climate Report] 24 April 2007 http://www.cciced.net/ztbd/yzh/2007nyzhy/hywj_7364/201210/t20121019_239749.html accessed May 2015

  • CCICED. “China’s Pathway Towards a Low Carbon Economy: CCICED Policy Research Report 209.” 2009 http://www.cciced.net/encciced/policyr/Taskforces/phase4/tflce/200911/P020091124512243707328.pdf accessed August 2011

  • CFE NGO Add Green Environmental Centre [Tiānlǜ Huánbǎo Zhōngxīn 添绿环保中心]. “Měi jīmì - weìxīng zhàopiàn jiēshì jídì bīngchuān jiāsù xiāoróng jiāshēn èliè qìhòu” 【美机密公开】卫星照片揭示极地冰川加速消融,加深恶劣气候 [Disclosing a Beautiful Secret: Satellite Images Show that Polar Glaciers Melt Faster and Deepen Disgusting Climate] 20 September 2009 http://zhishi.iiearth.blog.163.com/blog/static/109354191200972053444540/ accessed January 2015

  • Chen Huang Jinxia Wang and Huang Jikun. “Policy Support Social Capital and Farmers’ Adaption to Drought in China.” In Global Environmental Change 24 2014 pp. 193-202

  • China Daily. “China to Develop Low-carbon Economy.” 3 March 2010 http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2010-03/01/content_9521265.htm accessed August 2011

  • Chinese Civil Society Replies to Climate change. “COP huìyì dì èrcì: Zhōngguó hěn shēngqì xiǎodǎoguó hǎn jiùmìng” COP 会议第二次:中国很生气,小岛国喊救命 [Second COP Meeting: China is Angry Small Island States Call for Help]. 9 December 2009 http://ccsccvip.blog.sohu.com/139196179.html accessed July 2014

  • Christoff Peter. “Cold Climate in Copenhagen: China and the United States at COP15”. In Environmental Politics 19/4 2010 pp. 637-656

  • Climate Tracker. “9 rì 29 yuè - Màngǔ Liánhéguó qìhòu huìyì cìrì” 9 月29 日- 曼谷联合国气候 会议次日 [29 September - The Next Day of Bangkok Climate Talks]. 16 November 2009 http://climatetracker.blog.sohu.com/136918541.html accessed July 2014

  • Conrad Björn. “China in Copenhagen: Reconciling the ‘Beijing Climate Revolution’ and the ‘Copenhagen Climate Obstinacy’.” In The China Quarterly 210 2012 pp. 435-455

  • Dong Liang Fumei Gu Tsuyoshi Fujita Yoshitsugu Hayashi and Jie Gao. “Uncovering Opportunity of Low-carbon City Promotion with Industrial System Innovation: Case Study on Industrial Symbiosis Projects in China.” In Energy Policy 65 2014 pp. 388-397

  • Dulal Hari Bansha Kalim U. Shah Chandan Sapkota and Gengaiah Uma. “Renewable Energy Diffusion in Asia: Can It Happen Without Government Support?” In Energy Policy 59 2013 pp. 301-311

  • Fischer Frank. Reframing Public Policy: Discursive Politics and Deliberative Practices. Oxford: Oxford University Press 2003

  • Garnaut Ross Frank Jotzo and Stephen Howes. “China’s Rapid Emissions Growth and Global Climate Change Policy.” In China’s Dilemma: Economic Growth the Environment and Climate Change edited by Ligang Song and Wing Thye Woo. Canberra: ANU E Press Asia Pacific Press Brookings Institution Press Social Academic Sciences Press (China) 2008 pp. 170-189

  • Gifford L. M. Daly M. Boykoff J. Boehnert K. Andrews X. Wang A. Nacu-Schmidt and L. McAllister. “World Newspaper Coverage of Climate Change or Global Warming 2004-2014.” Centre for Science and Technology Policy Research Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences University of Colorado 2014 http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/icecaps/research/media_coverage/index.html accessed July 2014

  • Gottweis Herbert. “Argumentative Policy.” In Handbook of Public Policy edited by B. Guy Peters and Jon Pierre. London: Sage 2006 pp. 461-479

  • Gong Rong-Gang and Shaochuan Shen. “How to Develop Renewable Power in China? A Costeffective Perspective.” In The Scientific World Journal 1/2014 2014 http://www.hindawi.com/journals/tswj/2014/946932/ accessed 9 November 2015

  • Guan Dabo and David M. Reiner. “Emissions Affected by Trade Among Developing Countries.” In Nature 462 12 November 2009 p. 159

  • Gunningham Neil. “A Shale Gas Revolution for China?” In Climate Policy 14/2 2014 pp. 302- 330

  • Habich Sabrina. “Environmental ‘Dam-age’ and Social Vulnerability in Southwest China: A Case of Adaptive Authoritarianism?” In The Taiwanese Political Science Review 12 2011 pp. 233-282

  • Hǎinán lóupán wǎng 海南楼盘网 [Hǎinán Real Estate Network]. “Nuòyà Fāngzhōu nǎr xúnmì? Kōngzhōng yùedú shíqī” 诺亚方舟哪儿寻觅?(空中阅读十七) [Where is Noah’s Ark? Air Reading no. 17]. 24 June 2006 http://tfw6868.blog.sohu.com/93906272.html accessed July 2014

  • He Lichao. “China’s Climate-Change Policy from Kyoto to Copenhagen: Domestic Needs and International Aspirations.” In Asian Perspective 34/3 2010 pp. 5-33

  • Hofem Andreas and Sebastian Heilmann. “Bringing the Low-carbon Agenda to China: A Study in Transnational Policy Diffusion.” In Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 42/1 2013 pp. 199-215

  • Huang Ji-kun Jing Jiang Jin-xia Wang and Ling-ling Hou. “Crop Diversification in Copying with Extreme Weather Events in China.” In Journal of Integrative Agriculture 13/4 2014 pp. 677-686

  • IPCC. “Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report.” 2007 https://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_fourth_assessment_report_synthesis_report.htm accessed May 2015

  • Jun Pang and Zou Ji. “China: Climate Change Policy Making Process.” In Climate Change in Asia: Perspectives on the Future Climate Regime edited by Yasuko Kameyama Agus P. Sari Moakti H. Soajachmoen and Norichika Kanie. Tokyo: United Nations University Press 2008 pp. 66-82

  • Klimek Peter Werner Bayer and Stefan Thurner. “The Blogosphere as an Excitable Social Medium: Richter’s and Omori’s Law in Media Coverage.” 2011 http://arxiv.org/pdf/1102.2091 accessed March 2011

  • Kù Yuè 酷越. “Jiànzhùshī jiàn Nuòyà fāngzhōu fang rénlèi mièjué” 建筑师建诺亚方舟防人类灭绝 [Architect Builds Noah’s Ark to Protect Humanity Against Extinguishment]. In Kù Yuè Crossover shìjué shèngyàn 酷越Crossover 视觉盛宴 [Kù Yuè Crossover Vision Banquet] 21 June 2008 http://tfw6868.blog.sohu.com/93906272.html accessed July 2007

  • Kuhn Berthold M. “Climate Protection Governance and Participation in the People’s Republic of China.” In ASIEN 133 pp. 52-71

  • Kuhn Berthold and Yangyong Zhang. “Survey of Experts on Climate Change Awareness and Public Participation in China.” In Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 43/1 2014 pp. 177-212

  • Laclau Ernesto. New Reflections on the Revolution of Our Time. London and New York: Verso 1990

  • Laclau Ernesto and Chantal Mouffe. Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. Second Edition. London and New York: Verso 2001 [1985]

  • Lewis Joanna I. “China’s Strategic Priorities in International Climate Change Negotiations.” In The Washington Quarterly 31/1 2008 pp. 155-177

  • Li Bingqin. “Governing Urban Climate Change Adaptation in China.” In Environment and Urbanization 25/2 2013 pp. 413-427

  • Li Huimin Tong Wu Xiaofan Zhao Xiao Wang and Ye Qi. “Regional Disparities and Carbon ‘Outsourcing’: The Political Economy of China’s Energy Policy.” In Energy 66 2014 pp. 950-958

  • Liu Yong. “Barriers to the Adoption of Low Carbon Production: A Multiple-Case Study of Chinese Industrial Firms.” In Energy Policy 67 2014 pp. 412-421

  • Lo Kevin. “A Critical Review of China’s Rapidly Developing Renewable Energy Efficiency Policies.” In Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 29 2014a pp. 508-516

  • Lo Kevin. “China’s Low-Carbon City Initiatives: The Implementation Gap and the Limits of the Target Responsibility System.” In Habitat International 42 2014b pp. 236-244

  • Loher Josef Falko. “Domestic Climate Change Governance in East Asia: A Comparative Analysis of Japan China and South Korea.” In Vienna Journal of East Asian Studies 3 2012 pp. 73-107

  • Loher Falko. “Tantchen Suns Kissen macht China grüner.“ In Das Reispapier 5 2013 http://www.dasreispapier.at/dasreispapierat/seiten-nicht-im-menu/artikel-singleansicht/date/tantchen-suns-kissen-macht-china-gruener/ accessed September 2013

  • Lynch Elizabeth. “Rachel Stern on China’s Environmental Rights Movement.” In China Law and Policy 6 August 2013 http://chinalawandpolicy.com/2013/08/06/rachel-stern-on-chinasenvironmental-rights-movement/ accessed October 2013

  • McGrath Matt. “China’s Per Capita Carbon Emissions Overtake EU’s.” In BBC News 21 September 2014 http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-29239194 accessed January 2015

  • NDRC. “Zhōngguó yīngduì qìhuà biànhuà guójiā fang’àn (Quánwén)”《中国应对气候变化国家 方案》(全文)[China’s National Climate Change Programme (Full Text)]. 4 June 2007 http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2007-06/04/content_6196300.htm accessed July 2015. For the English version see NDRC. “National Climate Change Program.” 4 June 2007 http://www.china.org.cn/english/environment/213624.htm accessed May 2015

  • Nonhoff Martin. “Soziale Marktwirtschaft als hegemoniales Projekt: Eine Übung in funktionalistischer Diskursanalyse/Social Market Economy as a Hegemonic Project: An Exercise in Functionalist Discourse Analysis.“ Lecture 1 July 2005 Paris XII Créteil http://www.johannes-angermueller.de/deutsch/ADFA/nonhoff.pdf accessed March 2011

  • Nonhoff Martin. Politischer Diskurs und Hegemonie: Das Projekt „Soziale Marktwirtschaft“. Bielefeld: Transcript 2006

  • Oberheitmann Andreas. “A New Post-Kyoto Climate Regime Based on Per-Capita Cumulative CO2-Emission Rights: Rationale Architecture and Quantitative Assessment of the Implication for the CO2-Emissions from China India and the Annex-I Countries by 2050.” In Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change 15 2010 pp. 137-168

  • Oberheitmann Andreas and Eva Sternfeld. “Climate Change in China: The Development of China’s Climate Policy and Its Integration into a New International Post-Kyoto Climate Regime.” In Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 38/3 2009 pp. 135-164

  • ONI. “Internet Filtering in China.” 2009 http://opennet.net/sites/opennet.net/files/ONI_China_2009.pdf accessed October 2011

  • Painter James. “Summoned by Science: Reporting Climate Change and Beyond Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism.” Department of Politics and International Relations University of Oxford November 2010 https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/fileadmin/documents/Publications/Challenges/Summoned_by_Science.pdf accessed October 2013

  • Qi Ye Li Ma Huanbo Zhang and Huimin Li. “Translating a Global Issue Into Local Priority: China’s Local Government Response to Climate Change.” In The Journal of Environment & Development 17/4 2008 pp. 379-400

  • Qīngqīng Lánxiang rùxīn 清清兰香入心的 BLOG “Zhǔguān + kèguān shuōshuo zhè qìhòu biànhuà” 主观+客观说说这气候变化 [Talking Subjectively and Objectively about Climate Change]. In Qīngqīng Lánxiang rùxīn de BLOG 清清兰香入心的 BLOG [Qīngqīng Lánxiang rùxīn’s BLOG] 11 January 2010 http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_4e0907ba0100g875.html accessed January 2015

  • Sausmikat Nora. “China Viewed From the European Civil Society Perspective.” In Civil Society in European-Chinese Relations edited by Nora Sausmikat and Klaus Fritsche. Essen: Asienstiftung/EU-China Civil Society Forum 2010 pp. 49-96

  • Sausmikat Nora. “Chinese Environmental Movements: Civil Society Discourses on Climate Change and Environmental Protection.” In Nature Environment and Culture in East Asia edited by Carmen Meinert. Leiden and Boston: Brill 2013 pp. 197-229

  • Schröder Miriam. Local Climate Governance in China: Hybrid Actors and Market Mechanisms. Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave Macmillan 2012

  • Stensdal Iselin. “China’s Climate-Change Policy 1988-2011: From Zero to Hero?” FNI Report 9/2012 July 2012 http://fni.no/doc&pdf/FNI-R0912.pdf accessed May 2015

  • Stensdal Iselin. “Chinese Climate-Change Policy 1988-2013: Moving On Up.” In Asian Perspective 38/1 2014 pp. 111-135

  • Tolan Sandy. “Coverage of Climate Change in Chinese Media.” Human Development Report Office Occasional Paper 38 2007 http://hdr.undp.org/en/reports/global/hdr2007-8/papers/Tolan_Sandy.pdf accessed November 2013

  • Valentine Scott Victor. “The Socio-Political Economy of Electricity Generation in China.” In Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 32 2014 pp. 416-429

  • Vidal John and David Adam. “China Overtakes US as World’s Biggest CO2 Emitter.” In The Guardian 19 June 2007 http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2007/jun/19/china.usnews accessed January 2015

  • Wang Bing Xiao-Jie Liang Hao Zhang Lu Wang and Yi-Ming Wei. “Vulnerability of Hydropower Generation to Climate Change in China: Results Based on Grey Forecasting Model.” In Energy Policy 65 2014 pp. 701-707

  • Weigelin-Schwiedrzik Susanne and Julia Ritirc. “Green GDP in China: A Discourse Analysis.” Paper revised for presentation on the AAS-ICAS Meeting: Seventy Years of Asian Studies Honolulu March 2011

  • Willats Prudence. “China Talks Climate: A Frame Analysis of Discourses and the Environment in the PRC.” M.A. thesis University of Leipzig 2013

  • WWF Action against Climate Change. “Gēběnhāgēn xiéyì bìxū gěi qìhòu biànhuà shìyìng yìtí zúgòu zhòngshí” 哥本哈根协议必须给气候变化适应议题足够重视 [Copenhagen Accord has to Attach Enough Importance to the Adaptation to Climate Change]. 15 December 2009 http://wwfclimate.blog.sohu.com/139706509.html accessed 10 July 2014

  • Xiǎo Fēixiá 小飞侠. “Qìhòu biànhuà hǎi shǔi yānmò dìqiú Qīngzàng gāoyuán jiāng shì zuì hòude Nuòyà fāngzhōu” 气候变暖海水淹没地球,青藏高原将是最后的诺亚方舟 [If at Times of Climate Change Sea Water Rises the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau will be Noah’s Last Ark]. In Xiǎo Fēixiá de bókè 小飞侠的博客 [Xiǎo Fēixiá’s Blog] 17 October 2009 http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_61c2c9e50100fgdf.html accessed July 2014

  • Xie Zhenhua. “Grasp Opportunities and Meet Challenges to Walk the Uniquely Chinese Pathway of Low-Carbon Development.” Speech at the side event of COP15 on the “China’s Pathway Towards a Low Carbon Economy and Society” Copenhagen 15 December 2009

  • Xu Wei Nader Khoshroo Henning Bjornlund and Yongyuan Yin. “Effects of ‘Grain for Green’ Reforestation Program on Rural Sustainability in China: An AHP Approach to Peasant Consensus of Public Land Use Policies.” In Stoch Environ Res Risk Assess 28 2014 pp. 867-880

  • Yang Guobin. The Power of the Internet in China: Citizen Activism Online. New York: Columbia University Press 2011

  • Yu Sha Jiyong Eom Yuyu Zhou Meredydd Evans and Leon Clarke. “Scenarios of Building Energy Demand for China with a Detailed Regional Representation.” In Energy 67 2014 pp. 284-297

  • Yuan Jiahai Yan Xu Zhang Xingping Zheng Hu and Ming Xu. “China’s Clean Energy Target: Consistency Pathways and Policy Implications.” In Energy Policy 65 2014 pp. 692-700

  • Zhang Haibin. “China and International Climate Change Negotiations”. In Welt Trends Online- Dossier March 2013 http://welttrends.de/res/uploads/Zhang_China-and-International-climatechange-negotiations.pdf accessed January 2015

  • Zhang Haiyan and Michael L. Lahr. “Can the Carbonizing Dragon Be Domesticated? Insights From a Decomposition of Energy Consumption and Intensity in China 1987-2007.” In Economic Systems Research 26/2 2014 pp. 119-140

  • Zhēnde yǒu yī wèi shén ài nǐ 真的有一位神爱你. “Tán qìhòu biànhùa” 谈气候变化 [Talking about Climate Change] 20 September 2009 http://m-a-m-u.blog.sohu.com/137365357.html accessed May 2014

  • Zhu Tao David Phipps Adam Pridgen Jedidiah R. Crandall and Dan S. Wallach. “The Velocity of Censorship: High-Fidelity Detection of Microblog Post Deletions.” Paper presented at the 22nd USENIX Security Symposium in Washington D.C. August 2013 http://arxiv.org/pdf/1303.0597v2.pdf accessed October 2013

  • http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/emis/top2010.cap accessed 10 January 2015

  • http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/emis/top2010.tot accessed 10 January 2015

  • http://noahwater.blog.sohu.com/ accessed 10 January 2015.

Search
Journal information
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 95 85 3
PDF Downloads 54 51 3