This article describes the similarities and differences of Japanese and South Korean technical cooperation approaches in Guatemala. The literature review illustrates the transition from an initially donor-centric results chain approach towards one that is increasingly recipient-balanced due to new cooperation principles such as horizontality and demand-drivenness. Such approaches are mainly fostered by the rise of new emerging donors on the international development cooperation horizon, such as the advocates of South-South Development Cooperation (SSDC).
An analysis based on a framework by the Network of Southern Think Tanks (NeST) concludes that Japanese and Korean technical cooperation approaches are markedly similar, most notably in regard to officially proclaimed technical cooperation standards and commitments. Differences result from the degree of related implementation: Japan achieves higher results based on relative deficiencies in reporting by Korea as well as comparatively shorter bilateral Korean-Guatemalan relations. Similarities are fostered by analogous institutional and project related structures, stemming from an argued learning and simulation approach by Korea from the long-standing experiences of Japan. Lastly, it is argued that the growing assimilation of the traditional and the SSDC concept, as well as the increasing engagement of both countries in triangular cooperation contribute to the identified similarities.
Buiter, Willem. 2005. “Country Ownership: A Term Whose Time Has Gone.” In Stefan Koeberle, Harold Bedoya, Peter Silarsky, and Gero Verheyen, eds., Conditionality Revisited Concepts, Experiences, and Lessons. Washington D.C.: The World Bank, pp. 27–33.
Christensen, Zachary, Richard Nielsen, Daniel Nielson, and Michael Tierney. 2011. “Transparency Squared: The Effects of Donor Transparency on Aid Recipients’ Corruption Levels.” International Political Economy Society Meeting Paper, pp. 1–43.
CID (Council for International Development). 2012. “Ownership: A Brief Overview of Ownership within Development.” CID Fact Sheet, 8, pp. 1–2.
Coe, Jim and Juliette Majot. 2013. “Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning in NGO Advocacy: Findings from Comparative Policy Advocacy.” MEL Review Project, pp. 1–67.
Dahi, Omar and Firat Demir. 2017. “South-South and North-South Economic Exchanges: Does it Matter Who is Exchanging What and With Whom?” Journal of Economic Surveys, 31 (5), pp. 1449–1486.
Del Biondo, Karen. 2015. “Moving beyond a Donor-Recipient Relationship? Assessing Partnership in the Joint Africa-EU Strategy.” KFG Working Paper, 63, pp. 1–30.
De Oliveira, Joana. 2017. “Paths for Developing South-South Cooperation: Monitoring and Evaluation Systems.” BRICS Policy Center and South-South Cooperation Research and Policy Centre Report, pp. 1–44.
Development Finance International. 2010. “Republic of Korea (South Korea).” Country Profile Report, pp. 1–11.
Garbarino, Sabine and Jeremy Holland. 2009. “Quantitative and Qualitative Methods in Impact Evaluation and Measuring Results.” GSD-RC Governance and Social Development Resource Center Issues Paper, pp. 1–41.
Godfrey, Martin, Chan Sophal, Toshiyasu Kato, Long Piseth, Pon Dorina, Tep Saravy, Tia Savora, and So Sovannarith. 2002. “Technical Assistance and Capacity Development in an Aid-Dependent Economy: The Experience of Cambodia.” World Development, 30 (3), pp. 355–373.
Gore, Charles. 2013. “The New Development Cooperation Landscape: Actors, Approaches, Architecture.” Journal of International Development, 25, pp. 769–786.
Gray, Kevin and Barry Gills. 2016. “South-South Cooperation and the Rise of the Global South.” Third World Quarterly, 37 (4), pp. 557–574.
Haider, Huma. 2008. “Demand-Driven Technical Assistance.” GSD RC Research Report, pp. 1–13.
Holzapfel, Sarah. 2014. “The Role of Indicators in Development Cooperation: An Overview Study with a Special Focus on the Use of Key and Standard Indicators.” German Development Institute Studies, pp. 1–252.
IMF (International Monetary Fund). 2016. “Achieving More Equality and Stronger Growth in Guatemala.” IMF Dialogo al Fondo, pp. 1–3.
Kharas, Homi. 2013. “Transparency: Changing the Accountability, Engagement, and Effectiveness of Aid.” In Homi Kharas, Koji Makino, and Woojin Jung, eds., Catalyzing Development: A New Vision for Aid. Washington D.C.: Brookings Institution Press, pp. 233–259.
Kim, Hyo-Sook. 2017. “Poverty Reduction and ODA Policymaking in Japan and South Korea.” Journal of Inquiry and Research, 105, pp. 91–108.
King, Cheryl. 2014. “Partnership Effectiveness Continuum: A Research-Based Tool for Use in Developing, Assessing, and Improving Partnerships.” EDC Report, pp. 1–21.
Kondoh, Hisato. 2012. “Korea’s Pathway from Recipient to Donor: How Does Japan Matter?” In J. Sato and Y. Shimomura, eds., The Rise of Asian Donor: Japan’s Impact on the Evolution of Emerging Donors. Routledge: London, pp. 133–154.
Kondoh, Hisato. 2015. “Convergence of Aid Models in Emerging Donors? Learning Processes, Norms and Identities, and Recipients.” JICA Working Paper, 106, pp. 1–60.
Kondoh, Hisato, Takaaki Kobayashi, Hiroaki Shiga, and Jin Sato. 2010. “Diversity and Transformation of Aid Patterns in Asia’s ‘Emerging Donors.’” JICA Working Paper, 21, pp. 1–78.
Lucas, Brian. 2013. “Current Thinking on Capacity Development.” GSDRC Research Report, pp. 1–13.
Maggiorelli, Lorenzo. 2017. “Chinese Aid to Latin America and the Caribbean: Evolution and Prospect.” ELACID Artículo Resultado de Investigación, pp. 28–50.
Marx, Axel and Jadir Soares. 2013. “South Korea’s Transition from Recipient to DAC Donor: Assessing Korea’s Development Cooperation Policy.” International Development Policy, 4 (2), pp. 107–142.
Mawdsley, Emma. 2012 . “The Changing Geographies of Foreign Aid and Development Cooperation: Contributions from Gift Theory.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers New Series, 37 (2), pp. 256–272.
Mawdsley, Emma. 2012 . From Recipient to Donors: Emerging Powers and the Changing Development Landscape. London: Zed Books.
Mawdsley, Emma. 2017. “Development Geography 1: Cooperation, Competition and Convergence between ‘North’ and ‘South.’” Progress in Human Geography, 41 (1), pp. 108–117.
McGee, Rosemary. 2013. “Aid Transparency and Accountability: ‘Build it and They’ll Come?’” Development Policy Review, 31, pp. 107–124.
Menocal, Alina and Lisa Denney. 2011. “Informing the Future of Japan’s ODA. Part One: Locating Japan’s ODA within a Crowded and Shifting Marketplace.” ODI Report, pp. 1–42.
MFDR (Managing for Development Results). 2007. “Monitoring and Evaluation: Enhancing Development Results.” Third International Roundtable on Managing for Development Results in Hanoi, pp. 1–9.
Oxfam (Oxford Committee for Famine Relief). 2012. “Busan in a Nutshell: What next for the Global Partnership for Effective Development Cooperation?” Oxfam Briefing Note, pp. 1–14.
Park, Kyung Ryul. 2017. “An Analysis of Aid Information Management Systems (AIMS) in Developing Countries: Explaining the Last Two Decades.” Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences Paper, pp. 2580–2589.
Piefer, Nadine. 2014. “Triangular Cooperation: Bridging South-South and North-South Cooperation? Workshop on South-South Development Cooperation Paper, pp. 1–31.
Poate, Derek. 1997. “Measuring and Managing Results: Lessons for Development Cooperation/Performance Management.” SIDA Joint Evaluation, pp. 1–97.
Roblero Morales, Sindy. 2017. “Análisis de la Cooperación Internacional Coreana (KOICA) a partir del apoyo técnico económico a los programas de productividad y desarrollo en Guatemala.” M.A. thesis, USAC Escuela de Ciencia Política, Guatemala.
Rocha Menocal, Alina and Leni Wild. 2012. “Where Can Japanese Official Development Assistance Add Value?” Project Briefing, 71, pp. 1–4.
Rosero Moncayo, Gabriella and Diego Zorilla. 2013. “Measuring the Effectiveness of Development Cooperation at the Local Level.” UNDP Report, pp. 1–80.
SAIIA (South African Institute of International Affairs). 2015. “Developing a Conceptual Framework for South-South Cooperation.” SAIIA Working Document, pp. 1–58.
SAIIA (South African Institute of International Affairs). 2017. “A Monitoring and Evaluation Framework for South-South Cooperation.” SAIIA Working Paper March, pp. 1–28.
Sanahuja, José. 2010. “Post-Liberal Regionalism: S-S Cooperation in Latin America and the Caribbean.” In Roy Rathin and Melissa Andrade, eds., South-South Cooperation. The Same Old Game or a New Paradigm? New York: UNDP Poverty in Focus, 20, pp. 17–19.
Tortora, Piera. 2011. “Common Ground between South-South and North-South Cooperation Principles.” OECD Development Co-operation Directorate Issue Brief, pp. 1–4.
Uh, Soo Bong and Roknuzzamn Siddiky. 2017. “Does Development Aid Work? Improving Aid Effectiveness in International Development Cooperation Efforts.” Bangladesh e-Journal of Sociology, 14 (2), pp. 120–142.
UN (United Nations). 2014. “South-South Development Cooperation.” UN Background Note, pp. 1–4.
UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development). 2014. “Transfer of Technology and Knowledge Sharing for Development: Science, Technology and Innovation Issues for Developing Countries.” UNCTAD Report, pp. 1–71.
UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development). 2015. “Global Value Chains and South-South Trade. Economic Cooperation and Integration among Developing Countries.” UNCTAD Report, pp. 1–56.
UNDESA (United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs). 2018. “National Mutual Accountability and Transparency in Development Cooperation: Study on the Findings of the Fifth DCF Survey.” ECOSOC Development Cooperation Forum, pp. 1–32.
UNDP (United Nations Development Program). 2009. “Handbook on Planning, Monitoring and Evaluating for Development Results.” UNDP Handbook, pp. 1–232.