The Stranger and Others: The Life and Legacy of the Japanese Ethnologist Oka Masao

Abstract

Oka Masao (1898–1982) was a leading figure in the establishment of Japanese ethnology (cultural anthropology) since the 1930s and taught many of the next generation of ethnologists from Japan. He travelled to Vienna in 1929 to learn the methodology for studying the ethnogenesis of his own country, putting forward theories that questioned tennō-ideology of the time and became highly influential. During the war, he pushed for the establishment of an Ethnic Research Institute (Minken) to support the government in their ethnic policy in the occupied territories. Oka was also the founder of Japanese Studies at the University of Vienna in 1938. Despite these important—and at time controversial—roles, he is relatively unknown today. This article introduces recent scholarship on Oka’s life and legacy. It raises important questions about the role of ethnologists in politically sensitive times and counter-balances the Anglo-American narrative of the history of ethnology or social and cultural anthropology of Japan.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Benedict, Ruth. 1946. The Chrysanthemum and the Sword: Patterns of Japanese Culture. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

  • Christy, Alan. 2012. A Discipline on Foot: Inventing Japanese Native Ethnography. Plymouth: Rowan & Littlefield Publishers.

  • Chun, Kyung-Soo. 2016. “Why did GHQ Bring Oka’s Dissertation from Vienna to Tokyo?” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 129–151.

  • Coleridge, William. 2019. “Tetsudō: Japan’s Railway Pan-Asianism 1905–1945.” B.A. thesis, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom.

  • Erker, Linda, Andreas Huber, and Klaus Taschwer. 2017. “Von der ‘Pflegestätte nationalsozialistischer Opposition’ zur ‘äußerst bedrohlichen Nebenregierung.’ Der Deutsche Klub vor und nach dem ‘Anschluss’ 1938.” Zeitgeschichte, 44 (2), pp. 78–134.

  • Fukui, Katsuyoshi. 2004. “Oka Masao.” In Vered Amit, ed., Biographical Dictionary of Social and Cultural Anthropology. London: Routledge, p. 387.

  • Gingrich, Andre and Peter Rohrbacher, eds. Forthcoming. Völkerkunde aus Wien zur NS-Zeit. Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.

  • Haruna, Mikio 春名幹男. 2000. Himitsu no fairu: CIA no tainichi kōsaku 1 秘密のファイル:CIA の対日工作・上 [Secret Files: CIA Activities towards Japan 1]. Tōkyō 東京: Kyōdō Tsūshinsha 共同通信社.

  • Hohenwart-Gerlachstein, Anna. 1983. “In Memoriam Masao Oka.” Bulletin of the International Committee on Urgent Anthropological and Ethnological Research, 25, pp. 11–16.

  • Huber, Andreas. 2017. “Katholisch-deutschnationale Eliten: Cartellverband, Deutscher Klub und ihre Mitglieder in der Hochschullehrerschaft der Universität Wien 1932–1950.” In Frank-Michael Kuhlemann and Michael Schäfer, eds., Kreise, Bünde, Intellektuellennetzwerke: Formen bürgerlicher Vergesellschaftung und politischer Kommunikation 1890–1960. Bielefeld: Transcript, pp. 189–220.

  • Ishikawa, Hideshi, Josef Kreiner, Sasaki Ken’ichi, and Yoshimura Takehiko, eds. 2016. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Origins of Oka Masao’s Anthropological Scholarship, Meiji University, November 27, 2015. Bonn: Bier’sche Verlagsanstalt.

  • Kluckhohn, Clyde. 1936. “Some Reflections on the Method and Theory of the Kulturkreislehre.” American Anthropologist, 38 (2), pp. 157–196.

  • Köck, Stefan. 2017 [published 2019]. “Antisemitismus und Denunziantentum als einzige Option? Ramming, Gundert und die Frage nach Handlungsspielräumen für Japanologen in der national-sozialistischen Diktatur.” Bochum Yearbook of East Asian Studies (BJOAF), 40, pp. 133–153.

  • Kodansha Encyclopedia of Japan. 1999. “Marebito [客人 ].” Japan Knowledge Library; online: https://japanknowledge.com/library/en/ (accessed: September 2, 2019).

  • Kondō, Masanori 近藤正憲. 1998. “Mitsui Takaharu no tai Tōō bunka jigyō: Hangarī no kēsu o chūshin ni 三井高陽の対東欧文化事業 : ハンガリーのケースを中心に [Mitsui Takaharu’s Cultural Engagement in Eastern Europe: The Case of Hungary].” Chiba daigaku shakai bunka kagaku kenkyū 千葉大学大学院社会文化科学研究科 [Social Science and Humanities, Chiba University], 2, pp. 33–63.

  • Kovács, Isabella. 1987. “Historische Dokumentation der ungarisch-japanischen Kulturbeziehungen von ihren Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Vienna, Austria.

  • Kreiner, Josef. 1998. “Alexander Slawik zum Gedenken (27.12.1900–19.4.1997).” Nachrichten der Ostasiatischen Gesellschaft NOAG, 161–162, pp. 1–5.

  • Kreiner, Josef. 2012. “Oka Masao (1898–1982) und sein Werk Kulturschichten in Alt-Japan.” In Josef Kreiner, ed., Oka Masao: Kulturschichten in Alt-Japan. Bonn: Bier’sche Verlagsanstalt, IX–XXXVI.

  • Kreiner, Josef. 2013. “Die Gründung des Instituts für Japankunde an der Universität Wien.” In In-grid Getreuer-Kargl and Sepp Linhart, eds., Die Republik Österreich und Japan während der Zwischenkriegszeit 1918–1938 (1945). Wien: Abteilung für Japanologie des Instituts für Ostasienwissenschaften der Universität Wien, pp. 217–253.

  • Kreiner, Josef. 2016. “Oka Masao: The Man and His Footprints in Japanese Ethnology and Viennese Japanology.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 3–39.

  • Kreiner, Josef. 2017. “Brief Remarks on Paradigm Shifts in Japanese Anthropology during the 20th Century.” Global Perspectives on Japan, 1, pp. 23–65.

  • Linhart, Sepp. 2016. “Oka Masao Meets Wilhelm Schmidt and Wilhelm Koppers: From the Country of Eight Million Gods to a Country of One Almighty God Belief.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 153–172.

  • Marschall, Wolfgang. 2016. “The Viennese Roots of Oka Masao.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 79–98.

  • Menghin, Oswald. 1940. Weltgeschichte der Steinzeit. 2nd edition. Wien: A. Schroll & Co.

  • Meshcheryakov, Aleksander N. 2018. “Ethnologist Yanagita Kunio: Long Road to Recognition.” Russian Japanology Review, 1, pp. 72–90.

  • Minerva ミネルヴァ. 1937. “Gakkai ōrai: APE no tanjō 学会往来:APE の誕生 [Research Associations, News].” Minerva, February, p. 36.

  • Nakamura, Daisuke. 2016. “Oka Masao’s Theories on the Japanese Ethnogenesis with Special Reference to Migrations from the South.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 211–232.

  • Nakane, Chie 中根千枝. 1963. “Oka Masao sensei no purofaiiru 岡正雄先生のプロファイル [Professor Oka Masao’s Profile].” In Oka Masao kyōju kanreki kinen bunshū henshū iinkai 岡正雄 教授還暦記念文集編集委員会, ed., Minzokugaku nōto: Oka Masao kyōju kanreki kinen bunshū 民族ノート:岡正雄教授還暦記念文集 [Notes on Ethnology: Festschrift for Professor Oka Masao]. Tōkyō 東京: Heibonsha 平凡社, pp. 331–350.

  • Nakao, Katsumi. 2005. “The Imperial Past of the Anthropology of Japan.” In Jennifer Robertson, ed., A Companion to the Anthropology of Japan. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 19–35.

  • Nakao, Katsumi. 2016. “Clyde Kuckhohn: Political Position and his Tactics for Applied Anthropology in the US.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 61–98.

  • Oka, Masao 岡正雄. 1941. “Ōshū ni okeru minzoku kenkyū 欧州に於ける民族研究 [Ethnic Research in Europe].” Kaizō 改造 [Renewal], 8, pp. 64–66.

  • Oka, Masao 岡正雄. 1943. “Gendai minzokugaku no shomondai 現代民族学の諸問題 [Various issues of Contemporary Ethnology].” Minzokugaku kenkyū 民族学研究 [Ethnology Studies], 1 (1), pp. 119–122.

  • Oka Masao kyōju [kanreki kinen bunshū henshū iinkai] 岡正雄教授還暦記念文集編集委員会, ed. 1963. Minzokugaku nōto: Oka Masao kyōju kanreki kinen bunshū 民族ノート:岡正雄教授 還暦記念文集 [Notes on Ethnology: Festschrift for Professor Oka Masao]. Tōkyō 東京: Heibonsha 平凡社.

  • Oka, Masao 岡正雄. 1979. Ijin sono ta: Nihon minzoku = bunka no genryū to Nihon kokka no keisei 偉人その他。日本民族=文化の源流と日本国家の形成. [Strangers and Others: The Origins of Japanese Ethnos = Culture and the Formation of the Japanese State]. Tōkyō 東京: Gensōsha 言叢社.

  • Oka, Masao 岡正雄. 1981. “Oka Masao-shi danwa 岡正雄氏談話 [Interview with Oka].” In Shibusawa Keizō denki hensan kankōkai 渋沢敬三伝記編纂刊行会, ed., Nihon ginkō denshutsugo 渋沢敬三伝記編纂刊行会編:日本銀行転出後 [After Leaving the Bank of Japan]. Tōkyō 東京: Shibusawa Keizō denki hensan kankōkai 渋沢敬三伝記編纂刊行会, pp. 664–689.

  • Oka, Masao. 2012. Kulturschichten in Alt-Japan, ed. and introduced by Josef Kreiner. Bonn: Bier’sche Verlagsanstalt.

  • Ölschleger, Hans Dieter. 2016. “Oka Masao and Alexander Slawik: Mutual Influences between Japanese and German-speaking Ethnologies.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 173–192.

  • Nakazawa Shin’ichi 中沢新一. 2008. Orikuchi Shinobu: Kodai kara kita miraijin 折口信夫:古代 から来た未来人 [Orikuchi Shinobu: The Ancient People Who Came from the Future]. Tōkyō 東京: Chikuma Purimā Shinsho ちくまプリマー新書.

  • Price, David. 2002a. “Past Wars, Present Dangers, Future Anthropologies.” Anthropology Today, 18 (1), pp. 22–23.

  • Price, David. 2002b. “Lessons from Second World War Anthropology: Peripheral, Persuasive and Ignored Contributions.” Anthropology Today, 18 (3), pp. 14–20.

  • Rivinius, Karl Josef. 2013. “Wissenschaft im Dienste der Evangelisierung: Der Beitrag der Katholischen Fu-Jen-Universität in Peking.” In Claus Arnold and Johannes Wischmeyer, eds., Transnationale Dimensionen wissenschaftlicher Theologie. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, pp. 195–236.

  • Scheid, Bernhard. 2016. “Oka Masao und das schwierige Erbe der Wiener Kulturkreislehre.” In Ralph Lützeler and Wolfram Manzenreiter, eds., Aso: Vergangenheit, Gegenwart und Zukunft eines Wiener Forschungsprojektes zum ländlichen Japan. Vienna: Abteilung für Japanologie des Instituts für Ostasienwissenschaften, University of Vienna (= Beiträge zur Japanologie 45), pp. 61–87.

  • Scheid, Bernhard. Forthcoming. “Der Ethnologe als Geburtshelfer nationaler Identität: Oka Masao und seine Netzwerke, 1935–1945.” In Andre Gingrich and Peter Rohrbacher, eds., Völkerkunde aus Wien zur NS-Zeit. Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.

  • Schirmer, Andreas. 2016. “Korean Students in Europe Related to Oka Masao: Direct and Indirect Connections.” In Ishikawa et al., pp. 99–128.

  • Schmidt, Wilhelm. 1935a. Neue Wege zur Erforschung der ethnologischen Stellung Japans [New Ways of Researching the Japanese Ethnological Position]. Tōkyō 東京: Kokusai Bunka Shinkōkai 国際文化振興会.

  • Schmidt, Wilhelm. 1935b. “The Oldest Culture-Circles in Asia.” Monumenta Serica, 1 (1), pp. 1–16.

  • Shimizu, Akitoshi. 2003. “Anthropology and the Wartime Situation of the 1930s and 1940s: Masao Oka, Yoshitarō Hirano, Eiichirō Ishida and their Negotiations with the Situation.” In Shimizu Akitoshi and Jan van Bremen, eds., Wartime Japanese Anthropology in Asia and the Pacific (= Senri Ethnological Studies no. 65). Osaka: National Museum of Ethnology, pp. 49–108.

  • Shimizu, Akitoshi 清水昭俊. 2013. “Ijin, genzaigaku-teki minzokugaku, soshite shuzokushi-teki keisei: Oka Masao to Nihon-minzokugaku no tenkai 異人、現在学的民族学、そして種族史 的形成:岡正雄と日本民族学展開 [Others, Present-Oriented Ethnology, and the Historic Formation of Races].” In Josef Kreiner ヨーゼフ・クライナー, ed., Nihon minzokugaku no senzen to sengo: Oka Masao to Nihon minzokugaku no kusawake 日本民族学の戦前と戦後:岡正雄と 日本民族学の草分け [Ethnology in Prewar and Postwar Japan: Oka Masao and the Pioneers of Japanese Ethnology]. Tōkyō 東京: Tōkyōdō Shuppan 東京堂出版, pp. 67–142.

  • Shimizu, Akitoshi. 2018. “Oka, Masao (1898–1982).” In Hilary Callan, ed., The International Encyclopedia of Anthropology. New York: John Wiley & Sons. DOI: 10.1002/9781118924396.wbiea1431.

  • Slawik, Alexander. 1936. “Kultische Geheimbünde der Japaner und Germanen (eine vergleichende Studie).” Wiener Beiträge zur Kulturgeschichte und Linguistik, 4, pp. 675–763.

  • Taschwer, Klaus. 2015a. “Nachrichten von der antisemitischen Kampfzone. Die Universität Wien im Spiegel und unter dem Einfluss der Tageszeitungen, 1920–1933.” In Margarete Grandner and Thomas König, eds: Reichweiten und Außensichten. Die Universität Wien als Schnittstelle wissenschaftlicher Entwicklungen und gesellschaftlicher Umbrüche. Göttingen: Vienna University Press, pp. 99–126.

  • Taschwer, Klaus. 2015b. Hochburg des Antisemitismus. Der Niedergang der Universität Wien im 20. Jahrhundert. Wien: Czernin Verlag.

  • Umemura, Yuko. 2017. Japánok és magyarok egymásról [What Japan and Hungary Think of Each Other]. Budapest: Akadémia Kiadó.

  • van Bremen, Jan. 2003. “Wartime Anthropology: A Global Perspective.” In Shimizu Akitoshi and Jan van Bremen, eds., Wartime Japanese Anthropology in Asia and the Pacific (= Senri Ethno-logical Studies no. 65). Osaka: National Museum of Ethnology, pp. 13–48.

  • Vidyarthy, L.P. 1983. “Obituary: Masao Oka.” Current Anthropology, 24 (2), p. 268.

  • Yamashita, Shinji, J.S. Eades, and Shimizu Akitoshi. 2018. “Anthropology in Japan.” In Hilary Callan, ed., The International Encyclopedia of Anthropology. New York: John Wiley & Sons. DOI: 10.1002/9781118924396.wbiea1754.

  • Yanagida (= Yanagita), Kunio. 1944. “Die japanische Volkskunde: Ihre Vorgeschichte, Entwick-lung und gegenwärtige Lage / The Science of Japanese Folklore: Its Origin, Development and Present Condition / 日本民俗学.” Folklore Studies, 3 (2), pp. 1–76.

  • Zimoń, Henryk. 1986. “Wilhelm Schmidt’s Theory of Primitive Monotheism and its Critique within the Vienna School of Ethnology.” Anthropos, 81 (1), pp. 243–260.

OPEN ACCESS

Journal + Issues

Search