Linear Economy Versus Circular Economy: A Comparative and Analyzer Study for Optimization of Economy for Sustainability

Open access


Upon visiting the existing literature on the subject of linear vs. circular economy, this paper finds that, the blueprint of the current economy is hardly sustainable by using the comparative benchmarking method that drained from literature. The intrinsic mechanics of the linear economy, by relying on the wasteful take - make - dispose flow, is detrimental to the environment, cannot supply the growing populace of our planet with essential services and it naturally leads to strained profitability. Elements of a plausible solution to the challenges have been around for decades, although they have only recently been compiled in to the conceptual framework of circular economy. The core ideas of Circular Economy are elimination of waste by design, respect for the social, economic and natural environment and resource-conscious business conduct. Built on the backbone of these principles, the circular economy has demonstrated to deliver tangible benefits and viability to address the economic, environmental and social challenges of our days.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Andersen MS. 1997. Evaluation of the cleaner technology programme environmental review no. 14. Environmental Protection Agency Copenhagen. [Online]. Retrieved on April 19 2017 Available at:

  • Andersen MS. 1999. Governance by green taxes: implementing clean water policies in Europe 1970-1990. In Environmental Economy Policy Studies vol. 2 no. 1 pp. 39-63. [Online]. Retrieved on April 19 2017. Available at:

  • Andersen MS. 2006. An introductory note on the environmental economics of the circular economy Springer pp. 133-134 [Online]. Retrieved on April 19 2017. Available at:

  • Benyus J. 1998. Biomimicry: innovation inspired by nature. New York : Quill 1998.

  • Boulding K. 1966. The economics of the coming spaceship Earth. In Jarrett H. (ed) Environmental quality in a growing economy. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press 1966.

  • Braungart M. - McDonough W. 2008. Cradle-to-cradle - Remaking the way we make things. New York : North Point Press 2008.

  • Circular Academ y. 2017. Circular economy: critics and challenges - How can we bridge the circularity gap? [Online]. Retrieved on February 21 2017. Available at:

  • Dobbs R. - Oppenheimer J. - Thompson F. - Brinkman M. - Zornes M. 2011. Resource revolution: Meeting the world’s energy material food and water needs. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation . 2013. Towards the circular economy. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation . 2015a. Schools of thought - performance economy. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation . 2015b. Schools of thought - industrial ecology. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation . 2015c. Schools of thought - cradle to cradle. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • European Comission. 2014. Towards a circular economy: A zero waste programme for Europe. Brussels pp. 2 2.7.2014 COM 398 final. [Online]. Retrieved on Feb 10 2017. Available at:

  • Eurostat . 2011. Waste statistics. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Genga Y. - Fua J. - Sarkisc J. - Xuea B. 2012. Towards a national circular economy indicator system in China: an evaluation and critical analysis. In Journal of Cleaner Production vol. 23 2012 no. 1 pp. 216-224.

  • Greyson J. 2016. A glance at waste-free economy. [Online]. Available at:

  • Hawken P. - Lovins A.B. - Lovins L.H. 1999. Natural capitalism: The next industrial evolution. London : Earthscan 1999.

  • Pauli G. 2009. 10 years 100 innovations 100 million jobs inspired by nature. Report to the Club of Rome. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Pearce D.W. - Turner R.K. 1989. Economics of natural resources and the environment. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press 1989.

  • Rockström J. - Steffen W. - Noone K. - Persson et al. 2009. A safe operating space for humanity. In Nature vol. 461 2009 no. 24 pp. 472-475.

  • Stahel W. 1982. Product-life factor. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • Stahel W. 2010. The performance economy 2nd ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan 2010.

  • Steffen W. - Richardson K. - Rockström J. - Cornell et al. 2015. Planetary boundaries: Guiding human development on a changing planet. In Science 347 (6223) 2015.

  • Van Ewjik Stijin. 2014. Three Challenges to the Circular Economy UCL Institute for Sustainable Resources. [Online]. Retrieved on February 26 2017. Available at:

  • World Economic Forum . 2016. From linear to circular - Accelerating a proven concept. [Online]. Accessed on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

  • WWF. 2012. Living planet report 2012 - Biodiversity biocapacity and better choices. [Online]. Retrieved on Dec 21 2016. Available at:

Journal information
Cited By
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 2814 1945 103
PDF Downloads 1933 1483 50