Janus – A New Approach to Air Combat Pilot Training

Open access

Abstract

Advanced jet training still relies on old concepts and solutions that are no longer efficient when considering the current and forthcoming changes in air combat. The cost of those old solutions to develop and maintain combat pilot skills are important, adding even more constraints to the training limitations. The requirement of having a trainer aircraft able to perform also light combat aircraft operational mission is adding unnecessary complexity and cost without any real operational advantages to air combat mission training.

Thanks to emerging technologies, the JANUS project will study the feasibility of a brand-new concept of agile manoeuvrable training aircraft and an integrated training system, able to provide a live, virtual and constructive environment. The JANUS concept is based on a lightweight, low-cost, high energy aircraft associated to a ground based Integrated Training System providing simulated and emulated signals, simulated and real opponents, combined with real-time feedback on pilot’s physiological characteristics: traditionally embedded sensors are replaced with emulated signals, simulated opponents are proposed to the pilot, enabling out of sight engagement. JANUS is also providing new cost effective and more realistic solutions for “Red air aircraft” missions, organised in so-called “Aggressor Squadrons”.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] EDIDP (European Defence Industrial Development Programme) EDIDP-ACC-CJTP-2019 Call identifier: Call EDIDP-ACC-2019 Brussels European Commission;

  • [2] http://aviationweek.com/defense/multimission-concept-lightweight-advanced-trainers accessed May 11 2016;

  • [3] APP Aircraft Performance Program (trade mark) developed and source code owned (not released) by ALR. Commercial product. ALR Zurich Switzerland;

  • [4] Hillaker H. YF-16 Design Concept and Philosophy Paper presented at 23 Israel Annual Conference on Aviation and Astronautics 11-12 Feb. 1981 Edited by Univ.Michigan April 1991.

  • [5] Whitford R. Design for Air Combat Jane’s Publishing Company Ltd London 1987.

  • [6] Asselin M. An Introduction to Aircraft Performance AIAA Inc. Reston VA 1997.

  • [7] Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Aerodynamics of Manoeuvring Aircraft Canadian Aeronautics and Space Journal Vol.38 No.3 Sept.1992 pp.106-115.

  • [8] Herbst W.B. Supermanoeuvrability Proc. of AFOSR-FJSRL Workshop on Unsteady Separated Flow. Colorado Springs August 1983.

  • [9] Robinson B.A. Barnett R.M. Agrawal S. Simple Numerical Criterion for Vortex Breakdown AIAA Journal Vol.32 No.1 1994 pp.116-122.

  • [10] Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Aerodynamic Coupling between Lateral and Longitudinal Degrees of Freedom AIAA Journal Vol.12 No.12 1977 pp.1792-1799.

  • [11] Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Dynamic Stability Testing of Aircraft - Needs Versus Capabilities Prog.Aerospace Sci. Vol.16 No.4 1975 pp.431-447.

  • [12] Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Aerodynamic Aspects of Aircraft Dynamics at High Angles of Attack Jour.of Aircraft Vol.20 No.9 Sept.1983 pp.737-752.

  • [13] Rom J. High Angle of Attack Aeodynamics Springer-Verlag Berlin 1992.

  • [14] Gordnier R.E. Computation of Vortex Breakdown on a Rolling Delta Wing Jour.of Aircraft Vol.32 No.3 pp.686-688.

  • [15] Gordnier R. Computation of Delta Wing Roll Maneuvers Jour.of Aircraft Vol.32 No.3 May-June 1995 pp.486-492.

  • [16] Kandil O. Chuang H. Computation of Vortex-Dominated Flow for a Delta Wing Undergoing Pitching Oscillation Jour. of Aircraft Vol.28 No.9 Sept.1990 pp.1589-1595.

  • [17] Kandil O. Chuang H. Influence of Numerical Dissipation on Computational Euler Equations for Vortex-Dominated Flows AIAA Journal Vol.25 Nov.1987 pp.1426-1434.

  • [18] Kandil O. Recent Advances in Multidisciplinary Aeronautical Problems of Fluid/Structures/Dynamics Interaction Proceedings of Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1997 Part I pp. 15-34.

  • [19] Menzies M. Kandil O. Natural Rolling Responces of a Delta Wing in Transonic and Subsonic Flows AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference AIAA-96-3391 pp.246-254 San Diego 1996.

  • [20] Kandil O. Kandil H. S.Massey Simulation of Tail Buffet Using Delta Wing Vertical Tail Configuration AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference AIAA-93-3688 pp.566-577 Monterery 1993.

  • [21] Kandil O. Sheta E. Massey S. Buffet Responses of a Vertical Tail in Vortex Breakdown Flows AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference AIAA-95-3464 pp.345-360 Baltimore 1995.

  • [22] Kandil O. Massey S. Sheta E. Aerostructural Vortical Flow Interactions with Applications to F/A-18 and F-117 Tail Buffet High-Angle-of-Attack Technology Conference NASA Langley Research Center Hampton VA Sept.1996 (20 p.).

  • [23] Hsu C. Liu C. Numerical Study of Vortex-Dominated Flows for Wings at High Incidence and Sideslip Jour. of Aircraft Vol.29 No.3 May-June 1992 pp.396-403.

  • [24] Lopez J. Axisymmetric Vortex Breakdown J.Fluid Mech. (1990) Vol.221 Part 1. Confined Swirling Flow: pp.533-552 Part 2. Physical Mechanisms: pp.553-576.

  • [25] Strohmeyer D. Orlowski M. Longo J. Hummel D. Bergmann A. An Analysis of Vortex Breakdown Predicted by the Euler Equations ICAS Proceedings 96-1.6.3. pp.1189-1200 Sorento 1996.

  • [26] Boffadossi M. Calculation of Vortex Breakdown over „delta” Wing by a Vortex-Lattice Method ICAS Proc. of 20th Congress Sorrento Sept.1996 pp.1201-1210.

  • [27] Robinson B.A. Barnett R.M. Agrawal S. Simple Numerical Criterion for Vortex Breakdown AIAA Journal Vol.32 No.1 1994 pp.116-122.

  • [28] Gursul I. Criteria for Location of Vortex Breakdown over Delta Wings Aeronautical Journal May 1995 pp.194-196.

  • [29] Luckring J. Aerodynamics of Strake-Wing Interaction Journ. of Aircraft Vol.16 No.11 Nov.1979 pp.756-762.

  • [30] Polhamus E.C. A Concept of the Vortex Lift of Sharp-Edge Delta Wing based on a Leading-Edge-Suction Analogy NASA TN D-3767 1966.

  • [31] Polhamus E.C. Predictions of Vortex-Lift Characterisctics by a Leading-Edge Suction Analogy Journ.of Aircraft Vol.8 No.4 April 1971 pp.193-199.

  • [32] Vizel E. Gontchar A. Investigations of Aerodynamic Characteristics of Part-Scale Aircraft Model of Moderate Wing Sweep Angle and the Structure of Vortices versus the LEX’s Form-in Plane and its Parameters (In Russian) Journal - Technika Vojennogo Flota (TBФ) No.1-2 1994 pp.52-58.

  • [33] Tu E.L. Vortex-Wing Interaction of a Close-Coupled Canard Configuration Jour. of Aircraft Vol.31 No.2 1994 pp.314-321.

  • [34] Gordnier R. Visbal M. Unsteady Vortex Structure over a „delta” Wing Jour. of Aircraft Vol.31 No.1 Jan.-Feb. 1994 pp.243-248.

  • [35] Wood R. Miller D. Assessment of Preliminary Prediction Techniques for Wing Leading-Edge Vortex Flows at Supersonic Speeds Jour.of Aircraft Vol.22 No.6 June 1985 pp.473-485.

  • [36] Delery J. Aspects of Vortex Breakdown Prog. Aerospace Sci. Vol.30 pp.1-59 1994.

  • [37] Ekaterinaris J.A. Schiff L.B. Navier-Stokes Solutions for an Oscillating Double-delta Wing J. Of Aircraft 32 2 1995 pp.228-234.

  • [38] Cornelius K.C. Analysis of Vortex Bursting Utilizing Three-Dimensional Laser Measurements Journ. of Aircraft Vol.32 No.2 March-April 1995 pp.297-306.

  • [39] Hoeijmakers H. Computational Vortex Flow Aerodynamics AGARD CP-342 1983 No. 18 pp.18.1-18.35.

  • [40] Hitzel S.M. Schmidt W. Slender Wings with Leading-Edge Vortex Separation - a Challenge for Panel-Methods and Euler-Codes AIAA Paper 83-0262 1983.

  • [41] Ericson L. Challenges in High-Alpha Vehicle Dynamics Prog. Aerospace Sci. Vol.31 pp.291-334 1995.

  • [42] Ericson L. Pitch Rate Effects on „delta” Wing Vortex Breakdown Journal of Aircraft Vol.33 No.3 May-June 1996 pp.639-642.

  • [43] Ericson L. Delta Wing Vortex Breakdown Dynamics AIAA Paper 95-0367 Jan.1995.

  • [44] Khrabrov A. Kolinko K. Experimental Investigations of the High Aspect Ratio Wing Unsteady Aerodynamics at Stall Regimes and its Mathematical Modeling Proceedings of Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Goraj Z. Warsaw 1997 Part I pp. 195-200.

  • [45] Khrabrov A. Miatov O. Experimental and Theoretical Investigations of Delta Wing High Angles of Attack Unsteady Aerodynamics Proceedings of Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Goraj Z. Warsaw 1997 Part I pp. 201-206.

  • [46] Greenwell D. Wood N. Some Observations on the Dynamic Response to Wing Motion of the Vortex Burst Phenomenon Aeronautical Journal Feb.1994 pp.49-59.

  • [47] Mabey D. Unstedy Vortex Flow Phenomena on „delta” Wings at High Angles of Incidence ICAS Proceedings 96-1.6.1. pp.1167-1176 Sorento 1996.

  • [48] Alcorn C. Croom M. Francis M. Ross H. The X-31 Aircraft: Advances in Aircraft Agility and Performance Prog. Aerospace Sci. Vol.32 pp.377-413 1996.

  • [49] Dzelnin Yu. Aircraft Stability and Maneuverability During Dynamic Departure at High Angles of Attack (In Russian) Journal - Technika Vojennogo Flota (TBФ) No 1-2 1994 pp.59-66.

  • [50] J.Rom High Angle of Attack Aerodynamics - the State of Art and Future Challenges Proceedings of Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Goraj Z. Warsaw 1997 Part I pp.41-54.

  • [51] Goraj Z. New Directions of Research in Aeronautical Engineering - Breaking the Barriers Journal of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics 4 35 1997 pp.781-812.

  • [52] Pamadi B.N. Performance Stability Dynamics and Control of Airplanes AIAA Education Series 1998.

  • [53] Payne F.M. Nelson R.C. An Experimental Study of Vortex Breakdown on a Delta Wing NASA CP-2416 1992.

  • [54] Skow A.M. Titriga A.Jr. Moore W.A. Forebody-Wing Vortex Interactions and their Influence on Departure and Spin Resistance CP-247 AGARD paper 6 1979.

  • [55] NASA Report TP 2011 Exploratory Study of the Effects of Wing-Leading Edge Modifications on the Stall/Spin Behaviour of a Light General Aviation Airplane Washington DC 1982.

  • [56] DiCarlo D.J. Glover K.E. Stewart E.C. Stough H.P. Discontinuous Wing Leading Edge to Enhance Spin Resistance Journal of Aircraft Vol.22 4 1985 pp.283-288.

  • [57] Ghmman A.H. Goraj Z. Review On The Influence Of High Angle Of Attack Aerodynamics On Aircraft Dynamic Stability Jour.Theor. Appl.Mech. 3 33 1995 pp.667-686.

  • [58] Ross A.J. Investigation of Nonlinear Motion Experienced on a Slender-Wing Research Aircraft Journal of Aircraft Vol.9 1972 pp.625-631.

  • [59] Ericson L.E. Wing Rock Generated by Forebody Vortices AIAA Paper 87-0268 1987.

  • [60] Murri D. Shah G. DiCarlo D. Actuated Forebody Strake Controls for the F 18 High Alpha Research Vehicle Journal of Aircraft Vol.32 3 May-June 1995 pp.555-562.

  • [61] Ng T.T. Suarez C.J. Kramer B.R. Ong L.Y. Ayers B. Malcolm G.N. Forebody Vortex Control for Wing Rock Supression Journal of Aircraft Vol.31 2 1994 pp.298-305.

  • [62] Murri D.G. Nguyen L.T. Grafton S.B. Wind-Tunnel Free-Flight Investigation of a Model of a Forward-Swept-Wing Fighter Configuration NASA TP 2230 Feb.1984.

  • [63] Hsu C.H. Lan C.E. Theory of Wing Rock J.of Aircraft 1985 Vol.22 No.10 pp.920-924.

  • [64] Weissman R. Status of Design Criteria for Predicting Departure Characteristics and Spin Susceptibility Journal of Aircraft Vol.12 12 1975 pp.989-993.

  • [65] Hillaker H. YF-16 Design Concept and Philosophy Paper presented at 23 Israel Annual Conference on Aviation and Astronautics 11-12 Feb. 1981 Edited by Univ.Michigan April 1991.

  • [66] Bitten R. Operational Benefits of Thrust Vectoring (TVC) NASA CP-3149 Part 2 Vol.I 1990 pp.587-601.

  • [67] Grafton S.B. Libbey Ch.E. Dynamic Stability Derivatives of a Twin-Jet Fighter model for Angles of Attack from -10o to 110o NASA TN D-6091 Washington Jan.1971.

  • [68] Busemann A. Aerodynamic Forces at Supersonic Speeds Luftfahrtforschung Vol.12 No 6 Oct.3 1935.

  • [69] Wilson H.A. Lovell J.C. Full Scale Investigation of the Maximum Lift Flow Characteristics on an Airplane Having Approximately Triangular Planform NACA RM L6K20 Nov.1946.

  • [70] Peckham D.H. Atkinson S.A. Preliminary Results of Low Speed Wind Tunnel Test on a Gothic Wing of Aspect Ratio 1.0 Aeronautical Research Council CP 508 April 1957.

  • [71] Werle H. Sur l’eclatement des tourbillions d’apex d’une aile delta aux faibles vitesses La Recherche Aeronautique No.74 Jan/Feb 1960.

  • [72] Lambourne N.C. Bryer D.W. The Bursting of Leading Edge Vortices – Some Observationa and Discussion of the Phenomenon Report and Memoranda No.3282 Aeronautical Research Council April 1961.

  • [73] Squire H.B. Analysis of the Vortex Breakdown Phenomenon Part I Imperial College of Science and Technology Aeronautics Department Report No.102 August 1960.

  • [74] Taylor S.L. et.al. Experimental and Computational Study of the Subsonic Flow About a 75° Swept Delta Wing AIAA Paper 87-2425.

  • [75] Gordnier R.E. Visbal M.R. Numerical Simulation of the Unsteady Vortex Structure Over a Delta Wing AIAA Paper 91-1811.

  • [76] Webster W.P. Shang J.S. Numerical Simulation of Vortex Breakdown Over a Delta Wing AIAA Paper 91-1814.

  • [77] Kandil O.A. Kandil H.A. Liu C.H. Shock Vortex Interaction Over a 65° Delta Wing in Transonic Flow AIAA Paper 93-2973.

  • [78] Aerodynamic Staff of the National Physical Laboratory Technical Report by the Accident Investigation Subcommittee on the Accident to the Aeroplane G AAZK at Meopham Kent (England) on 21 July 1930 Aeronautical Research Council Report and Memoranda No.1360 1931.

  • [79] White J.A. Hood M.J. Wing Fuselage Interference Tail Buffeting and Air Flow About the Tail of a Low Wing Monoplane NACA Technical Report No.482 1934.

  • [80] Abdrashitov G. Tail Buffeting TsAGI Moscow Report No.395 1935 NACA TM 1041 1943.

  • [81] Triplett W.E. Pressure Measurement on Twin Vertical Tails in Buffeting Flow Journal of Aircraft Vol.20 No.1 1983 pp.920-925.

  • [82] Ericson G.E. et.al. Experimental Investigation of the F/A 18 Vortex Flows at Subsonic Through Transonic Speeds AIAA Paper 89 2222.

  • [83] Cole S.R. Moss S.W. Doggett Jr. R.V. Some Buffet Response Characteristics of a Twin Vertical Tail Configuration NASA TM 102749 Oct.1990.

  • [84] Lee B.H.K. et.al. Wind Tunnel Investigation of Tail Buffet on the F-18 Aircraft Paper 1 AGARD Conference Proceedings No.483 1990.

  • [85] Washburn A.E. Jenkins L.N. Ferman M.A. Experimental Investigation of Vortex Fin Interaction AIAA Paper 93 0050.

  • [86] Rizk Y.M. Guruswamy G.P. Gee K. Numerical Investigation of Buffet on F 18 Aircraft AIAA Paper 92-2673.

  • [87] Kandil O.A. Kandil H.A. Massey S.J. Simulation of Tail Buffet Using Delta Wing Vertical Tail Configuration AIAA 93-3688 CP pp.566-577.

  • [88] Kandil O.A. Flanagan M.W. Vertical Tail Buffet in Vortex Breakdown Flows 5th International Symposium on Computational Fluid Dynamics Sendai Japan August 31 Sept.3 1993.

  • [89] Kandil O.A. Massey S.J. Kandil H.A. Computations of Vortex Breakdown Induced Tail Buffet Undergoing Bending and Torsional Vibrations AIAA Paper 94-1428.

  • [90] Hirsch C.: Numerical Computation of Internal and External Flows Vol 1-2 1988.

  • [91] Beam R.M. Warming R.F. An Implicit factored Scheme for the Compressible Navier Stokes Equations AIAA Journal Vol.16 No.4 1978 pp.393-402.

  • [92] Steger J.L. Warming R.F. Flux Vector Splitting of the Inviscid Gasodynamic Equations with Application to Finite Difference Methods NASA TM 78605 July 1979 (also Journal Of Comp.Physics Vol.40 No.2 April 1981 pp.263-293).

  • [93] Van Leer B. Flux Vector Splitting for the Euler Equations ICASE Report 82-30 Sept.1982 (also Lecture Notes in Physics Vol.170 1982 pp.507-512).

  • [94] Thomas J.L. Van Leer B. Walters R.W. Implicit Flux Schemes for the Euler Equations AIAA Paper 85-1680.

  • [95] Massey S.J. A Direct Numerical Simulation of Vortex Braekdown Induced Tail Buffet M.Sc. Degree Thesis Old Dominion University May 1994 (unpublished).

  • [96] Kandill O.A. Recent Advances in Multidisciplinary Aeronautical Problems of Fluids/Structures/Dynamics Interaction Proceedings of Second International Seminar RRDPAE_1996 Edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1996 pp.15-34.

  • [97] Küchemann D. The aerodynamic design of aircraft. Pergamon Press Oxford 1978.

  • [98] AGARD Conference Proceedings CP 319 Combat Aircraft Manoeuvrability Dec.1981.

  • [99] Mabey D.G. Some aspecs of aircraft dynamic loads due to flow separation. Progress in Aerospace Science No. 2 1989.

  • [100] Mabey D.G. An hypothesis for the prediction of flight penetration of ming buffeting from dynamic tests of a wind tunnel model. ARC CP 1171 1971.

  • [101] Kania W. Gnarowski W. Jóźwiak R. Stalewski W. Wysocki Z. Zwierchanowska B. Żółtak J. Aerodynamic Design and Wind Tunnel Tests of Advanced Attack Aircraft Cobra 2000 Proc.of the Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” Part I Edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1997 pp.169-174.

  • [102] Romanowski R. Low Speed Tests of the Dorsal Intake Pressure Recovery for Cobra 2000 Aircraft Proc.of the Second Seminar on „Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” Part II Edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1997 pp.63 -68.

  • [103] Holligsworth E.H. Lohen M. Determination of F 4 Aircraft Transonic Buffet Characteristics Jour. of Aircraft Vol.8. No.10 October 1971.

  • [104] Damstrom E.K. Mayes J.F. Transonic Flight and Wind Tunnel Buffet Onset Investigation of the F 8D Aircraft Jour. of Aircraft Vol.8. No.4 April 1971.

  • [105] Herbst W. Dynamics of Air Combat J.Aircraft Vol.20 No.7 July 1983 pp.594-598.

  • [106] Samoilovitch O. Aerodynamic Configurations of Contemporary and Prospective Fighters Proc.of Second Seminar on “Recent Research and Design Progress on Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw Nov. 1996 part II pp.233-246.

  • [107] Rom J. High Angle of Attack Aerodynamics the State of Art and Future Challenges Proceedings of Second Seminar on “Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Goraj Z. Warsaw 1997 Part I pp.41-54.

  • [108] Alcorn C. Croom M. Francis M. Ross H. The X 31 Aircraft: Advances in Aircraft Agility and Performance Progr. Aerosp. Sc. Vol.32 pp.377-413 1996.

  • [109] Whitford R. Fundamentals of Fighter Design Cycle 6 papers in Air International 1996-97.

  • [110] Delery J.M. Aspects of Vortex Breakdown Progr. Aerosp. Sc. 30 1994 pp.1-59.

  • [111] Lopez J. Axisymmetric Vortex Breakdown J.Fluid Mech. (1990) Vol.221 Part 1. Confined Swirling Flow: pp.533-552 Part 2. Physical Mechanisms: pp.553-576.

  • [112] Boffadossi M. Calculation of Vortex Breakdown over Delta Wing by a Vortex Lattice Method ICAS Proc. of 20th Congress Sorrento Sept.1996 pp.1201-1210.

  • [113] Robinson B.A. Barnett R.M. Agrawal S. Simple Numerical Criterion for Vortex Breakdown AIAA Journal Vol.32 No.1 1994 pp.116-122.

  • [114] Gursul I. Criteria for Location of Vortex Breakdown over Delta Wings Aeronautical Journal May 1995 pp.194-196.

  • [115] Luckring J. Aerodynamics of Strake Wing Interaction Journ.of Aircraft Vol.16 No.11 Nov.1979 pp.756-762.

  • [116] Vizel E. Gontchar A. Investigations of Aerodynamic Characteristics of Part Scale Aircraft Model of Moderate Wing Sweep Angle and the Structure of Vortices versus the LEX’s Form in Plane and its Parameters (In Russian) Journ. Technika Vojennogo Flota No 1-2 1994 pp.52-58.

  • [117] Yu Dzelnin Aircraft Stability and Maneuverability During Dynamic Departure at High Angles of Attack (In Russian) Journal - Technika Vojennogo Flota (TBФ) No 1 2 1994 pp.59-66.

  • [118] Ericsson L. Challenges in High Alpha Vehicle Dynamics Progr. Aerosp. Sc. Vol.31 pp.291-334 1995.

  • [119] Ericsson L. King H. Rapid Prediction of High Alpha Unsteady Aerodynamics of Slender Wing Aircraft Journ.of Aircraft Vol.29 No.1 Jan. Feb.1992 pp.85-92.

  • [120] Ericsson L. Pitch Rate Effects on Delta Wing Vortex Breakdown Vol.33 No.3 May-June 1996 pp.639-642.

  • [121] Ericsson L. Delta Wing Vortex Breakdown Dynamics AIAA Paper 95-0367 Jan.1995.

  • [122] Khrabrov A. Kolinko K. Experimental Investigations of the High Aspect Ratio Wing Unsteady Aerodynamics at Stall Regimes and its Mathematical Modeling Proceedings of Second Seminar on “Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1997 Part I pp. 195-200.

  • [123] Khrabrov A. Miatov O. Experimental and Theoretical Investigations of Delta Wing High Angles of Attack Unsteady Aerodynamics Proceedings of Second Seminar on “Recent Research and Design Progress in Aeronautical Engineering and its Influence on Education” edited by Z.Goraj Warsaw 1997 Part I pp. 201-206.

  • [124] Norris G. Breaking the Stall Barrier Flight International 11-17 Nov.1992 pp.34-37.

  • [125] Ghmmam A.A. Goraj Z. A Review of the Influence of High Angle of Attack Aerodynamics on Aircraft Dynamic Stability Jour.Ther.Appl.Mech. 3 33 1995 pp.667-686.

  • [126] Well K.H. Faber B. Berger E. Maneuver Optimization of Aircraft Utilizing High Angles of Attack ICAS Proceedings 80-6.4. pp.257-264 1980.

  • [127] Manor D. Wentz Jr. W. Flow over Double-Delta Wing and Wing Body at High Alpha Jour.of Aircraft Vol.22 No.1 Jan.1985 pp.78-82.

  • [128] Tu E.L. Vortex Wing Interaction of a Close Coupled Canard Configuration Jour.of Aircraft Vol.31 No.2 March-April 1994 pp.314-321.

  • [129] Beyers M.E. Interpretation of Experimental High-Alfa Aerodynamics - Implications for Flight Prediction Jour. of Aircraft Vol.32 No.2 March April 1995 pp.247-261.

  • [130] Beyers M. Investigation of High Manoeuvrability Flight Vehicle Dynamics ICAS Proceedings 80 7.2. pp.278-292 1980.

  • [131] John H. Kraus W. High Angle of Attack Characteristics of Different Fighter Configurations AGARD-CP-247 Paper 2(15) 1979.

  • [132] Rom J. High Angle of Attack Aerodynamics; Subsonic Transonic and Supersonic Flows Springer Verlag New York 1992. Week & Space Technology Aug.8 1994 p.54.

  • [133] Chambers J.R.Overview of Stall/Spin Technology AIAA Paper 80-1580 Danvers Aug.1980.

  • [134] Goraj Z. Aerodynamics For High AOA And Introduction Of Polish Aviation Study Proceedings of The 35th Aircraft Symposium Tokyo 1997 pp.177-180.

  • [135] Tu E.L. Effect of Canard Deflection on Close-Coupled Canard-Wing-Body Aerodynamics Jour.of Aircraft Vol.31 No.1 Jan.-Feb. 1994 pp.138-145.

  • [136] Hummel D. Oelker H. Effects of Canard Position on Aerodynamic Characteristics of a Close Coupled Canard Configuration at Low Speed Z.Flugwiss. Weltraumforsch.15 (1991) pp.74-88.

  • [137] Kendall E.R. Learjet G. The Minimum Induced Drag Longitudinal Trim and Static Longitudinal Stability of Two Surface and Three Surface Airplanes AIAA-84-2164.

  • [138] Ericsson L. Cobra Maneuver Unsteady Aerodynamic Considerations Jour.of Aircraft Vol.32. No.1 pp.214-216.

  • [139] Ransom S. Configuration Development of a Research Aircraft with Post Stall Manoeuvrability J.Aircraft Vol.20 No.7 July 1983 pp.599-605.

  • [140] Gütter R. Friehmelt H. Haiplik R. Tactical Utility of the X 31A Using Post Stall Technologies ICAS Proceedings 96-3.7.5. pp.1574-1583 Sorento 1996.

  • [141] Grafton S.B. Libbey Ch.E. Dynamic Stability Derivatives of a Twin Jet Fighter model for Angles of Attack from 10° to 110° NASA TN D 6091 Washington Jan.1971.

  • [142] Grafton S.B. Anglin E.L. Dynamic Stability Derivatives at Angle of Attack from -5° to 90° for the Variable Sweep Fighter Configuration with Twin Vertical Tails NASA TN D-6909 Washington Oct.1972.

  • [143] Goraj Z. High Angles Of Attack Flight Dynamics Of Contemporary And Prospective Fighters As A Function Of Their Configuration And Aerodynamics. Proceedings of 21th Congress of the International Council of the Aeronautical Sciences ICAS-98-1.7.5 13-18 September 1998 Melbourne.

  • [144] Fomin A. Su 27 Flanker Story. Air Fleet Russian Air Force Aircraft & Space Review Publisher: RA Intervestnik 2000.

  • [145] Goraj Z. Aerodynamics & Dynamics of Manoeuvrable Aircraft with Elements of Computing Scientific Series of Institute of Aviation Vol.13 473 pages Warsaw 2001 (in Polish).

Search
Journal information
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 61 61 29
PDF Downloads 61 61 28