CFD Analysis of the Fluid Particles Distribution by Means of Aviation Technique

Open access


The article describes a computational study, using CFD models, of droplet spray dispersal in the wake of a ‘Turbo Kruk’ airplane up to 500 m downstream. The CFD Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) models use a Lagrangian (droplet phase) and Eulerian (fluid phase) procedure to predict the droplet trajectories trough the turbulent aircraft wake. The methods described in the work have the potential to improve current models for aerial spraying and will help in the development of new spraying procedures. In this study, the CFD models are used to describe the phenomenon of sprays released from atomizers mounted on the plane. A parametric study of the aircraft model examines the effects of crosswind on the aircraft’s vortex structures and the resulting droplet trajectories. The study shows, that such influence is underestimated in the current models. A comparison of the present results to AGDISP predictions is provided.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] Ashley H. and Landahl M.T. 1965 Aerodynamics of Wing and Bodies Reading Addison-Wesley Publishing Co.

  • [2] Atias M. and Weihs D. 1984 “Motion of Aircraft Trailing Vortices Near the Ground” Journal of Aircraft 21(10) pp. 783-786.

  • [3] Bache D.H. and Sayer W.J.D. 1975 “Transport of Aerial Spray. A Model of Aerial Dispersion” Agricultural Meteorology 15 pp. 257-271.

  • [4] Bilanin A.J. Teske M.E. and Barry J.W. 1989 “AgDisp: the Aircraft Spray Dispersion Model Code Development and Experimental Validation” Trans. ASAE 32 pp. 327-334.

  • [5] Bird S.L. Perry S.G. Ray S.L. and Teske M.E. 2002 “Evaluation of the AgDISP Aerial Spray Algorithms in the AgDRIFT Model” Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 21 pp. 672-681.

  • [6] Boothroyd R.G. 1971 Flowing Gas-Solid Suspensions London: Chapman and Hall.

  • [7] Bragg M.B. 1986 “A Numerical Simulation of the Dispersal of Liquids from Aircraft” Trans. of the ASAE 29 pp. 10-15.

  • [8] SAS IP 2013 ANSYS Fluent Theory Guide ANSYS.

  • [9] Cramer H.E. Bjorklund J.R. Record E.A. Dumbauld R.K. Swanson R.N. Faulkner J.E. and Tingle A.G. 1972 “Development of Dosage Models and Concepts” Report DTCTR-72-609-1. Dugway Utah: U.S. Army Dugway Proving Ground.

  • [10] Деревянко В.С. 1974 Влияние аэродинамических возмущений на процессы авиационного опыливания и опрыскивания Москва: Tранспорт.

  • [11] Duan B. Yenodol W.G. and Mierzejewski K. 1992 “Statistical Comparison of the AGDISP Model with Deposit Data” Atmos. Environ. A 26(9) pp. 1635-1642.

  • [12] Dumbauld R.K. Bjorklund J.R. and Saterlie S.F. 1980 “Computer Models for Prediction Aircraft Spray Dispersion and Deposition Above and Within Forest Canopies: User’s Manual for the FSCBG Computer Program” Report 80-11. Davis Cal.: USDA Forest Service.

  • [13] Dziubiński A. Jaśkowski P. Seredyn T. 2016 “CFD Analysis of Agricultural Aircraft Aerodynamic Characteristics” Transactions of the Institute of Aviation No. 4(245) pp. 321-337.

  • [14] Dziubiński A. Stalewski W. and Żółtak J. 2008 “Examples of Fluent Applications in Helicopter Flight Safety Analysis” (in Polish: „Przykłady zastosowania pakietu Fluent w analizach bezpieczeństwa lotu śmigłowców”) Transactions of the Institute of Aviation No. 194-195 pp. 146-157.

  • [15] ESDU No. 72026 1972 Characteristics of the Wind Speed in the Lower of the Atmosphere Near the Ground: Strong Winds London: Neutral Atmosphere.

  • [16] Frost W. and Huang K.H. 1981 “Monte Carlo Model for Aircraft Applications of Pesticides” ASAE Paper No. 811507. St. Joseph Mich.: ASAE.

  • [17] Gaidos R.E. Patel M.R. Valcore D.L. and Fears R.D. 1990 “Prediction of Spray Drift Deposition from Aerial Applications of Pesticides” ASAE Paper No. AA90007. St. Joseph Mich.: ASAE/NAAA.

  • [18] Harvey J.K. and Perry F.J. 1971 “Flow Field Produced by Trailing Vortices in the Vicinity of Ground” AIAA Journal 9(8) pp. 1659-1660.

  • [19] Hewitt A.J. 2001 “Drift Filtration by Natural and Artificial Collectors: A Literature Review” Stewart Agricultural Research Services Inc.

  • [20] Himel C.M. Loats H. and Bailey G.W. 1990 “Pesticide Sources to the Soil and Principles of Spray Physics” Madison: SSSA Book Series 2. Wisc.: SSSA pp. 7-50.

  • [21] Kamiński S. 1970 „Problems of Spray Drift in Plant Protection Treatments Performed by Aviation Technique” (in Polish: „Analiza parametrów charakteryzujących rozpylanie ciekłych środków ochrony roślin”) Report 4.31.15 Institute of Aviation Warszawa.

  • [22] Leonard A. 1980 “Vortex Methods for Slow Simulation” Journal of Computational Physics No. 37 pp. 289-335.

  • [23] Łusiak T. Dziubiński A. and Szumański K. 2009 “Interference between helicopter and its surroundings experimental and numerical analysis” TASK QURTAERLY No. 13(4) p. 379-392.

  • [24] Miranda L.R. Elliot R.D. and Baker W.M. 1977 “A Generalized Vortex Lattice Method for Subsonic and Supersonic Flow Applications” NASA CR 2865.

  • [25] Moore D.W. 1974 “A Numerical Study of the Roll-up of a Finite Vortex Sheet” Journal of Fluid Mechanics No. 63(2) pp. 225-235.

  • [26] Pietruszka J. 1987 „Simulation of Spraying Performer by M18 Aircraft” (in Polish: „Symulacja procesu opryskiwania wykonanego z samolotu M18”) Mielec: Sprawozdanie nr OLO-4/99/87. OBR SK – not published.

  • [27] Pietruszka J. 1987 “Computer Simulation of Spraying from Aircraft” (in Polish: „Symulacja komputerowa procesu opryskiwania z samolotu”) Ph.D. thesis Politechnika Warszawska.

  • [28] Pietruszka J. and Rowiński R.S. 2004 “Computer Simulation of Aerial Spraying” Annual Review of gricultural Engineering No. 3(1) pp. 125-140.

  • [29] Ranz W.E. and Marschall W.R. 1952 “Evaporation from Drops” Chemical Engineering Progress 48(3) pp. 141-146 and Chemical Engineering Progress 48(4) pp. 173-180.

  • [30] Reed W.H. 1954 “An Analytical Study of the Effect of Airplane Wake on the Lateral Dispersion of Aerial Sprays” NACA Report 1196.

  • [31] Rowiński R.S. 1993 “Problems of Spray Drift in Plant Protection Using Aviation Techniques” Acta Acad. Agricult. Techn. Olst. Aed. No. 16 pp. 171-195.

  • [32] Rowiński R.S. and Ferenc M. 2000 “Some Problems Concerned with the Theory of Drift” Annual Review of Agricultural Engineering No. 2(1) pp. 148-156.

  • [33] Ryan S.D. Gerber A.D. and Holloway A.G.L. 2013 “A computational Study on Spray Dispersal in the Wake of an Aircraft” Trans. ASABE No. 56(3) pp. 847-868.

  • [34] Saputro S. and Smith D.B. 1990 “Expert System for Aerial Spray Drift” ASAE Paper No. 901018. St. Joseph Mich.: ASAE.

  • [35] Seredyn T.P. 2014 “Experimental Investigations of a Drifting Cloud of Droplets Dispersed from Aircraft” Archive of Mechanical Engineering No. 3 pp. 393-407.

  • [36] Sobczak K. 2008 „CFD Modeling of Chosen Helicopter Flight Phases in Fluent” (in Polish: „Modelowanie wybranych przypadków lotu śmigłowca z wykorzystaniem oprogramowania Fluent”) Transactions of the Institute of Aviation No. 194-195 pp. 158-165.

  • [37] Teske M.E. Bird S.L. Esterly D.M. Curbishley T.B. Ray S.L. and Perry S.G. 2002 “Ag-DRIFT: a Model for Estimating Near-field Spray Drift from Aerial Applications” Environ. Toxicol. and Chem. No. 21(3) pp. 659-671.

  • [38] Teske M.E. and Thistle H.W. 2003 “Release Height and Far-Field Limits of Lagrangian Aerial Spray Models” Trans. ASAE No. 46(4) pp. 977-983.

  • [39] Teske M.E. Thistle H.W. and Ice G.G. 2003 “Technical Advances in Modeling Aerially Applied Sprays” Trans. ASAE No. 46(4) pp. 985-996.

  • [40] Teske M.E. Thistle H.W. and Londergan R.J. 2011a “Modification of Droplet Evaporation in the Simulation of Fine Droplet Motion Using AGDISP” Trans. ASAE No. 54(2) pp. 417-421.

  • [41] Teske M.E. Thistle H.W. Schou W.C. Miller P.C.H. Strager J.M. Richardson B. Butler M.C. Barry J.W. Twardus D.B. and Thompson D.G. 2011b “A Review of Computer Models for Pesticide Deposition Prediction” Trans. ASAE No. 54(3) pp. 789-801.

  • [42] Trayford R.S. and Welch L.W. 1977 “Aerial Spraying: A Simulation of Factors Influencing the Distribution and Recovery of Liquid Droplets” Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research No. 22 pp. 183-196.

  • [43] Wallace D.J. Picot J.J.C. and Chapman T.J. 1995 “A Numerical Model for Forestry Aerial Spraying” Agric. Forestry Meteorology No. 76 pp. 19-40.

  • [44] Wickens R.H. 1977 “Calculation of Wake Vortex Trajectories for Low Flying Spraying Aircraft” Canada: National Aero Report LTR-LA-215 Nat. Res. Council.

  • [45] Williamson R.E. and Threadgill E.D. 1974 “A Simulation for the Dynamics of Evaporating Spray Droplets in Agricultural Spraying” Trans. ASAE No. 17(2) pp. 254-261.

  • [46]

  • [47]

  • [48]

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 52 52 17
PDF Downloads 37 37 15