The precedent studies on the validity of Modus ponens and Modus tollens have been carried out with most regard to a major type of conditionals in which the conditional clause is a sufficient condition for the main clause. But we sometimes, in natural language arguments, find other types of conditionals in which the conditional clause is a necessary or necessary and sufficient condition for the main clause. In this paper I reappraise, on the basis of new definitions of Modus ponens and Modus tollens, their validity/invalidity in natural language arguments in consideration of all types of conditionals.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
[Burke 1994] Burke M. B. (1994). Denying the antecedent: A common fallacy? Informal Logic 16 pp. 23-30.
[Floridi 2009] Floridi L. (2009). Logical fallacies as informational shortcuts. Synthese 167(2) pp. 317-325.
[Fox and Das 2000] Fox J. and Das S. (2000). Safe and Sound: Artificial Intelligence in Hazardous Applications. Menlo Park CA: MIT Press.
[Godden and Walton 2004] Godden D. M. and Walton D. (2004). Denying the Antecedent as a Legitimate Argumentative Strategy: A Dialectical Model. Informal Logic 24(3) pp. 219-243.
[Groarke 2011] Groarke L. (2011). Informal Logic. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy http://www.plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/
[Layman 2002] Layman C. S. (1999). The Power of Logic. The McGraw-Hill Companies Boston.
[Moldovan 2009] Moldovan A. (2009). Pragmatic Considerations in the Interpretation of Denying the Antecedent. Informal Logic 29(3) pp. 309-326.
[Orsinger 2011] Orsinger R. R. (2011). The Role of Reasoning in Constructing a Persuasive Argument. http://www.orsinger.com/PDFFiles/constructinga-persuasive-argument.pdf
[Stone 2012] Stone M. (2012). Denying the Antecedent: Its Effective Use in Argumentation. Informal Logic 32(3) pp. 327-356
[Walton 2002] Walton D. N. (2002). Are Some Modus Ponens Arguments Deductively Invalid? Informal Logic 22(1) pp. 219-243
[Yaskorska et al. 2012] Yaskorska O. Kacprzak M. & Budzynska K. (2012) Rules for Formal and Natural Dialogues in Agent Communication. In Proceedings of the international workshop on concurrency specification and programming pp. 416-427. Berlin: Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin 267