A Decision Logic Approach to Mill’s Eliminative Induction

Open access


The subject of the paper is a contemporary interpretation of J.S. Mill’s elimination method using selected concepts of Zdzisław Pawlak’s decision logic. The aim of the interpretation is to reformulate the original rules (canons) of Mill’s induction so that they correspond more precisely to his concept of cause as a complex sufficient condition. In the first part of the paper, we turn to Mill’s writings and justify the thesis that in his understanding the cause is an aggregation of circumstances, and not a single circumstance; next, we point out that Mill’s original canons (for example the canon of agreement and the canon of difference) do not allow causes-aggregations to be singled out from empirical data. In the second part of this paper, we present such aspects of Z. Pawlak’s decision logic that serve as the basis for the formalisation of the method of eliminative induction. We describe exhaustively the schema of induction that involves a gradual - divided into three stages - simplification of a set of implications corresponding to the observed dependencies [system of potential causes, effect]. The simplification is deductive because it maintains consistency within the set of implications. We show that such schema is ideal for isolating complex causes (aggregations of circumstances), ultimately described using complex conditional formulas of decision logic.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Ajdukiewicz K. (1974). Pragmatic logic. Trans. from the Polish by Olgierd Wojtasiewicz. Dordrecht Boston Warsaw: PWN.

  • Ajdukiewicz K. (1985). Klasyfikacja rozumowań [Classification of Reasoning]. In: K. Ajdukiewicz Język i poznanie [Language and Cognition]. Warsaw: PWN vol. 2.

  • Bolc L. Cytowski J. Stacewicz P. (1996). O logice i wnioskowaniu przybliżonym [On rough logic and rough reasoning]. Prace IPI PAN issue 822 Warsaw: Wydawnictwo IPI PAN.

  • Borkowski L. (1970). Logika formalna [Formal Logic]. Warsaw: PWN.

  • Ducheyne S. (2008). J.S. Mill’s Canons of Induction: From true causes to provisional ones. History and Philosophy of Logic 29 (4) 361-376.

  • Ingarden R. (1974). ¨Uber die kausale Struktur der reale Welt. Der Streit um die Existenz der Welt III. T¨ubingen: Max Niemeyer.

  • Kotarbiński T. (1990). Elementy teorii poznania logiki formalnej i metodologii nauk [Elements of the Theory of Knowledge Formal Logic and Methodology of Science]. Wrocław: Ossolineum & Wydawnictwo PAN.

  • Kotarbiński T. (1985). Wykłady z dziejow logiki [Lectures on the History of Logic]. Wrocław: Ossolineum & Wydawnictwo PAN.

  • Krajewski W. (1967). Związek przyczynowy [The Causal Nexus]. Warsaw: PWN.

  • Lejewski C. (1984). Consistency of Leśniewski’s Mereology. In J. T. J. Srzednicki V. F. Rickey (Eds.) Leśniewski’s Systems. Ontology and Mereology (pp. 231-238). Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers Wrocław: Ossolineum.

  • Leśniewski S. (1992). On the foundations of mathematics. In: S. Leśniewski Collected Works Dordrecht: Kluwer 1992 (On various ways of understanding the words ‘Class’ and ‘Collection’ [1927] pp. 207-226; On ‘Foundations of the General Theory of Sets. I.’ [1928] pp. 227-263).

  • Łoś J. (1948). Podstawy analizy metodologicznej kanonow Milla [The Foundations of the methodological analysis of Mill’s canons]. Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Skłodowska vol. 2 269-301.

  • Mackie J. L. (1967). Mill’s Methods of Induction. In: P. Edwards (Ed.) The Encyclopedia of Philosophy vol. 5 (pp. 324-332). New York: Macmillan.

  • Mill J. S. (1851). System of Logic Ratiocinative and Inductive Being A Connected View of The Principles of The Evidence and The Methods of Scientific Investigation. London: John W. Parker West Strand.

  • Pawlak Z. (1983). Systemy informacyjne: podstawy teoretyczne [Information Systems: Theoretical Foundations]. Warsaw: WNT.

  • Pawlak Z. (1991). Rough Sets - Theoretical Aspects on Reasoning about Data. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

  • Pawlak Z. Skowron A. (2007). Rudiments of rough sets. In: Peters J. F. Skowron A. (Eds.) Information Sciences vol. 177(1) 3-27.

  • Skorupski J. (1989). John Stuart Mill. London: Routledge pp. 167-202.

  • Skowron A. Suraj Z. (Eds.). (2013). Rough Sets and Intelligent Systems. Professor Zdzislaw Pawlak in Memoriam. Series Intelligent Systems Reference Library Springer 2013.

  • Słowiński R. (Ed.). (1992). Intelligent Decision Support. Handbook of Applications and Advances of the Rough Sets Theory. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

  • Sobociński B. (1984). Studies in Leśniewski’s Mereology. In: J.T.J. Srzednicki V.F. Rickey (Eds.) Leśniewski’s Systems. Ontology and Mereology (pp. 217-227). Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers Wrocław: Ossolineum.

  • Szaniawski K. (1959). O indukcji eliminacyjnej [On Eliminating Induction]. In: Fragmenty filozoficzne [Philosophical Fragments] 2nd series. Warsaw: PWN.

  • von Wright G. H. (1951). A Treatise on Induction and Probability. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

  • Whitehead A. N. (1919). An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Natural Knowledge. Cambridge: The University Press.

  • Wilson F. (1983). Mill’s ‘Proof’ of Utility and the Composition of Causes. Journal of Business Ethics 3 135-158

Journal information
Impact Factor

Cite Score 2018: 0.29

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.138
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.358

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 182 76 5
PDF Downloads 101 59 4