State and Mafia, Differences and Similarities

Open access


The purpose of this article is to investigate about the differences and, if any, the similarities among the modern State and the mafia criminal organizations. In particular, starting from their definitions, I will try to find the differences between State and mafia, to then focus on the operational aspects of the functioning of these two organizations, with specific reference to the effect/impact that both these human constructs have on citizens’ existences, and especially on citizen’s economic lives. All this in order to understand whether it is possible to identify an objective difference – beside morals – between taxation by the modern State and extortion by criminal organizations. With this of course I do not want to argue that the mafia is in any way justifiable or absolvable, nor that it is better than the State. However, I want to investigate whether there is a real, logical reason why the State should be considered by the citizens more desirable than the criminal organizations oppressing Southern Italy, from a strictly logical point of view and not from the point of view of ethics and morality.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • 1. Bobbio N. Dialogo intorno alla repubblica. Laterza: Roma-Bari 2001.

  • 2. Clark W. M. Golder R. Golder S. Principi di scienza politica. McGrawHill: Milano 2011.

  • 3. Conticello F. L’isola che c’è. La Sicilia che si ribella al pizzo. Round Robin editrice: Roma 2008.

  • 4. De Fina G. No al pizzo. Imprenditori siciliani in trincea. Thor editrice: Palermo 2008.

  • 5. Friedman M. A Monetary History of the United States 1867–1960. Princeton University Press: Princeton 1963.

  • 6. Grasso T. Varano A. U’Pizzu. L’Italia del racket e dell’usura. Baldini Castoldi Dalai: Milano 2002.

  • 7. Hanke S. H. New Hyperinflation Index (HHIZ) puts Zimbabwe Inflation at 89.7 sextillion percent. The Cato Institute 2008.

  • 8. Hobbes Thomas Leviatano. 1651.

  • 9. La Spina A. (a cura di) I costi dell’illegalità. Mafia ed estorsioni in Sicilia. Il Mulino: Bologna 2008.

  • 10. North D. Istituzioni cambiamento istituzionale evoluzione dell’economia. Il Mulino: Bologna 2007.

  • 11. Schmitt C. Dottrina della costituzione (a cura di Caracciolo). Giuffré: Roma 1984.

  • 12. Schmitt C. Il custode della costituzione (a cura di Caracciolo). Giuffré: Roma 1981.

  • 13. Hofmann H. Legittimità contro legalità. La filosofia politica di Carl Schmitt. Edizioni Scientifiche italiane: Napoli 1999.

  • 14. Tilly C. Conflitto e democrazia in Europa. Bruno Mondadori: Milano 2007.

  • 15. Tilly C. Credit and Blame. Princeton University Press: Princeton 2008.

  • 16. Tilly C. Democracy. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge 2007.

  • 17. Tilly C. Identities Boundaries and Social Ties. Paradigm Publishers: Boulder. 2005.

  • 18. Tilly C. L’oro e la spada. Ponte alle Grazie: Milano 1993.

  • 19. Tilly C. La formazione degli stati nazionali in Europa occidentale. Il Mulino: Bologna 1984.

  • 20. Tilly C. Le rivoluzioni europee 1492-1992. Laterza: Bari 2002.

  • 21. Tilly C. Perché? La logica nascosta delle nostre azioni quotidiane. Rizzoli: Milano 2007.

  • 22. Tilly C. Regimes and Repertoires University of Chicago Press: Chigago 2006.

  • 23. Tilly C. Wood L. Social Movements 1768-2008 Paradigm Publishers: Boulder 2004.

  • 24. Vecchio A. Ricette di Legalità. Noventacento Edizioni: Milano 2009.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 769 634 4
PDF Downloads 542 469 3