Right To Property: From Magna Carta To The European Convention On Human Rights

Open access


Property rights are integral part of the freedom and prosperity of every person, although their centrality has often been misprized and their provenance was doubted. Yet, traces of their origin can be found in Magna Carta, signed by the King of England in 1215. It was a turning point in human rights. Namely, it enumerates what later came to be thought of as human rights. Among them was also the right of all free citizens to own and inherit property. The European Convention on Human Rights was heavily influenced by British legal traditions, including Magna Carta. Among other rights, it also guaranties the right to property as a human right. Moreover, the protection of property rights has been extended to intellectual property rights as well. Namely, the European Court of Human Rights has provided protection of intellectual property rights through the adoption of decisions that interpret the right to property, in relation to intellectual property protection claims. It has extended the human rights protection of property to the mere application for registration of the trade mark. This paper has placed its focus on the development and treatment of the right to property starting from Magna Carta to the European Convention on Human Rights, as modern version of Magna Carta. In this sense, the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights and its role and approach in the protection of the right to property will be examined as well.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Bates Ed The Evolution of the European Convention on Human Rights: From Its Inception to the Creation of a Permanent Court of Human Rights OUP Oxford 2010

  • Chapman Audrey R. A Human Rights Perspective on Intellectual Property Scientific Progress and Access to the Benefits of Science WIPO Publication No.762(I) Geneva 1999

  • Coban Ali Riza Protection of Property Rights within the European Convention of Human Rights Ashgate Publishing 2004

  • Cullet Philippe Human Rights and Intellectual Property Protection in the TRIPS Era The John Hopkins University Press Human Rights Quarterly Volume 29 No.2 2007

  • Griffits Johnatan and McDough Luke Constructing European Intellectual Property Achievements and New Perspectives Edvard Elgar Publishing Limited Cheltenham & Edvard Elgar Publishing Inc Northampton 2013

  • Grgic Aida Mataga Zvonimir Longar Matija and Vilfan Ana The Right to Property under the European Convention on Human Rights A Guide to the Implementation of the European Convention on Human Rights and Its Protocols Council of Europe 2007

  • Helfer Laurence R. The New Innovation Frontier? Intellectual Property and the European Court of Human Rights Harvard International Law Journal Volume 49 2008

  • O’Neill Johnathan Property Rights and the American Founding: An Overview Supreme Court Historical Society Volume 38 Issue 3 2013

  • Rathbone Mark The Human Rights Act: a Magna Carta for the Twenty-First Century? Political Studies Association 2014

  • Renucci Jean-François Introduction to the European Convention on Human Rights The rights guaranteed and the protection mechanism Council of Europe 2005

  • Santos Ana Eduarda Reballancing Intellectual Property in the Information Society: The Human Rights Approach Duke Law School 2013

  • Schmidtz David The Institution of Property Social Philosophy and Policy No.11 1994

  • Siegan Bernard H. Property Rights: From Magna Carta to the Fourteenth Amendment Transaction Publishers 2001

  • Спировски Игор Јуриспруденцијата на Европскиот суд за човекови права (збирка на пресуди) 2-ри Август С Штип 2007

  • Welkowitz David S. Privatizing Human Rights? Creating Intellectual Property Rights from Human Rights Principles New York University Volume 43 No.3 Article 3 2013

  • Wilson Tim Property Rights are Human Rights IPA Review Volume 67 No.I Article 2 2015

  • Magna Carta Runnymede 15.6.1215

  • Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as amended by Protocols No.11 and No.14 Rome 4.11.1950

  • Cases of the European Commission of Human Rights and the European Court of Human Rights:

  • Akkus v. Turkey July 9 1997 Reports 1997-IV

  • Anheuser-Busch Inc. v. Portugal App.No.73049/01 44 Eur. H.R. Rep. 42 [846] 855-56 (Chamber 2007) (judgement of Oct. 11 2005)

  • Anheuser-Busch Inc. v. Portugal App.No.73049/01 45 Eur. H.R. Rep. 36 [830] (Grand Chamber 2007)

  • Aral v. Turkey App.No.24563/94 (1998) (admissibility decision)

  • Dima v. Romania App.No.58472/00 para 87 (2005) (admissibility decision)

  • Draon v. France App.No.1513/13 42 Eur.H.R. Rep.40 [807] 832-33 (2006) (judgement of Oct.6 2005)

  • Fedorenko v. Ukraine App.No.25921/02 29 (2006)

  • Forrer-Niedenthal v. Germany February 20 2003 App.No. 46316/99

  • Jahn v. Germany App.No.46720/99 42 Eur.H.R.Rep.49 [1085] 1105 (Grand Chamber 2006) (judgement of June 30 2005)

  • Lenzing AG v. United Kingdom App.No.38817/97 94-A Eur. Comm’ H.R. Dec.&Rep.136 (1998)

  • Melnychuk v. Ukraine App.No.28743 para.8 (2005) (admissibility decision)

  • Motais de Narbonne v. France July 2 2002 App.No. 48161/99

  • Smith Kline & French Lab. Ltd v. Netherlands App.No.12633/87 66 Eur. Comm’ H.R. Dec.&Rep. 70 79 (1990) (admissibility decision)

  • Sporrong and Lonnroth v. Sweden September 23 1982 A 52 § 63

  • Tre Traktorer AB v. Sweden July 7 1989 A 159 § 53

  • Van Marle and Others v. the Netherlands June 26 1986 A 101

  • Wiggins v. the United Kingdom EC February 8 1978 DR 13/40

  • Zhigalev v. Russia App.No.54891/00 131 (2006)

  • Zubani v. Italy August 71996 Reports 1996-IV

Journal information
Target audience: experts in the fields of: law, economy, public administration, international relations, political sciences, languages, communication, technology sciences, and environment.
Cited By
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 735 436 23
PDF Downloads 320 220 12