Gender and Overconfidence in the Kauffman Firm Survey

Open access

Abstract

While an emerging line of research has begun to examine how firm survival correlates with the psychological trait of overconfidence, almost none of this work looks at how this relationship is mediated or modified by the minority status of the individual within the area of entrepreneurship. We employ a proportional hazard survival model and analyze the Kauffman Firm Survey (KFS) of entrepreneurs during the period of 2004-2012. We find that, while overconfidence relates to firm survival, it is more strongly related to survival for female than for male entrepreneurs. Our analysis is unique in examining the trait of overconfidence for small firm survival, and it is the first that we know of to stratify the effects of this overconfidence by gender. The present work has implications for possible methods and strategies to promote the entrepreneurship of individuals from underrepresented groups, with an eye towards owner-overconfidence helping female-led firms to survive the first few years of a firm’s existence.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Ahmed A.M. (2011) Women are not always less competitive than men: Evidence from Come Dine with Me Applied Economics Letters Vol. 18 no. 12 pp. 1099-1101.

  • Atkinson S.M. Baird S.B. Frye M.B. (2003) Do female mutual fund managers manage differently? Journal of Financial Research Vol. 26 pp. 1-18.

  • Baek H.Y. Neymotin F. (2018) Entrepreneurial overconfidence and firm survival: An analysis using the Kauffman firm survey Applied Economics Letters Vol. 25 no. 16 pp. 1175-1178.

  • Baek H.Y. Neymotin F. (2016) International involvement and production efficiency among startup firms Global Economic Review Vol. 45 no. 1 pp. 42-62.

  • Birley S. (1989) Female entrepreneurs: Are they really any different? Journal of Small Business Management Vol. 27 pp. 32-37.

  • Bliss R.T. Potter M.E. (2002) Mutual fund managers: Does gender matter? Journal of Business and Economic Studies Vol. 8 pp. 1-15.

  • Cameron A.C. Trivedi P.K. (2010) Microeconomics Using Stata Taylor and Francis New York.

  • Croson R. Gneezy U. (2009) Gender differences in preferences Journal of Economic Literature Vol. 47 pp. 448–74.

  • Dabic M. Daim T. Bayraktaroglu E. Novak I. Basic M. (2012) Exploring gender differences in attitudes of university students towards entrepreneurship: An international survey International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship Vol. 4 no. 3 pp. 316-336.

  • Dwyer P.D. Gilkeson J.H. List J.A. (2002) Gender differences in revealed risk taking: evidence from mutual fund investors Economics Letters Vol. 76 pp. 145–58.

  • Estes R. Hosseini J. (1988) The Gender Gap on Wall Street: An Empirical Analysis of Confidence in Investment Decision Making The Journal of Psychology Vol. 122 no. 6 pp. 577-590.

  • Esteve-Perez S. Manez-Castillejo J.A. Rochina-Barrachina M.E. Sanchis-Llopis J.A. (2007) A survival analysis of manufacturing firms in export markets Unpublished Paper.

  • Fairlie R.W. Robb A.M. (2007) Families Human Capital and Small Business: Evidence from the Characteristics of Business Owners Survey ILR Review Vol. 60 no. 2 pp. 225-245.

  • Fielden S.L. Davidson M.J. Dawe A.J. Makin P.J. (2003) Factors inhibiting the economic growth of female owned small businesses in North West England Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development Vol. 10 no. 2 pp. 152-166.

  • Finucane M.L. Slovic P. Mertz C.K. Flynn J. Satterfield T.A. (2000) Gender race and perceived risk: The ‘White Male’ effect Health Risk and Society Vol. 2 no. 2 pp. 159-172.

  • Gneezy U. Leonard K.L. List J.A. (2009) Gender differences in competition: evidence from a matrilineal and a patriarchal society Econometrica Vol. 77 pp. 1637–64.

  • Gneezy U. Rustichini A. (2004) Executives versus teachers Unpublished Manuscript.

  • Hardies K. Breesch D. Branson J. (2013) Gender differences in overconfidence and risk taking: Do self-selection and socialization matter? Economics Letters Vol. 118 pp. 442-444.

  • Hirshleifer D. Low A. Teoh S.H. (2012) Are overconfident CEOs better innovators? Journal of Finance Vol. 4 pp. 1457-1498.

  • Hribar P. Yang H. (2015) CEO overconfidence and management forecasting Contemporary Accounting Research Vol. 33 no. 1 pp. 204-227.

  • Iqbal Z. O S. Baek H.Y. (2006) Are female executives more risk-averse than male executives? Atlantic Economic Journal Vol. 34 pp. 63-74.

  • Johnson J.E.V. Powell P.L. (1994) Decision making risk and gender: Are managers different? British Journal of Management Vol. 5 pp. 123-138.

  • Kauffman Foundation 2004-2012 Kauffman Firm Survey documentation available online at https://www.kauffman.org/microsites/kfs/data-files Last Accessed August 7 2018

  • Kirkwood J. (2009) Is a lack of self-confidence hindering women entrepreneurs? International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship Vol. 1 no. 2 pp. 118-133.

  • Koellinger P. Minniti M. Schade C. (2006) ‘I think I can I think I can’: overconfidence and entrepreneurial behavior Journal of Economic Psychology Vol. 28 pp. 502-527.

  • Koellinger P. Minniti M. Schade C. (2008) Seeing the world with different eyes: gender differences in perceptions and the propensity to start a business Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper 035/3.

  • Malmendier U. Tate G. (2005) CEO Overconfidence and Corporate Investment The Journal of Finance Vol. 60 no. 6 pp. 2661-2700.

  • Master R. Meier R. (1988) Sex differences and risk-taking propensity of entrepreneurs Journal of Small Business Management Vol. 26 pp. 31-35.

  • Nekby L. Thoursie P.S. Vahtrik L. (2008) Gender and self-selection into a competitive environment: are women more overconfident than men? Economics Letters Vol. 100 pp. 405–407.

  • Neymotin F. (2018) Educational Overconfidence and the Path to Business The Empirical Economics Letters Vol. 17 no. 7 pp. 1-10.

  • Niederle M. Vesterlund L. (2007). Do women shy away from competition? Do men compete too much? Quarterly Journal of Economics Vol. 122 no. 3 pp. 1067-1101.

  • Ofek E. Yermack D. (2000) Taking stock: Equity-based compensation and the evolution of managerial ownership Journal of Finance Vol. 55 pp. 1367-1384.

  • Rozier C.K. Thompson M. (1998) Female entrepreneurs in a female-dominated health profession: an exploratory study Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship Vol. 3 no. 2 pp. 149-163.

  • Scherer R.F. Brodzinski J.D. Wiebe F.A. (1990) Entrepreneur career selection and gender: a socialization approach Journal of Small Business Management Vol. 28 no. 2 pp. 37-42.

  • Tsaoussi A. (2008). Female Lawyers as Pragmatic Problem Solvers: Negotiation and Gender Roles in Greek Legal Practice. The Theory and Practice of Representative Negotiation Trevor Farrow Colleen Hanycz Fred Zemans eds. pp. 198-210 Emond Montgomery Publications Toronto 2008.

Search