Critical Analysis on the Amendments Discussed, Concerning Changes in Accounting Estimates

Open access


In this article, our main aim is to bring in discussion some of the most controversial points debated along the time on the use of the accounting estimates in financial reporting. More important, we have referred to the Exposure Draft recently closed for comment letters, which addressed some points that will follow to be transformed into several amendments to IAS 8. Our discussion is focused, especially on how professionals can make a clear distinction between changes in accounting estimates and changes in accounting policies. We try to underline the trinomial perspective of this subject, as the changes in accounting estimates impact, not only the financial statements, but can generate issues on auditing those estimates, or on using financial information output on the entity valuation models. Additionally, we try to emphasize the essential role of this distinction between changes in accounting estimates and changes in accounting policies.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Albrecht A. Kim K. Lee K.J. (2017) Changes in Accounting Estimates: Are the current disclosure requirements sufficient to deter managerial opportunism? working paper available on;

  • CECCAR (2013) International Financial Reporting Standards CECCAR Publishing House Bucharest;

  • Christensen H.B. Nikolaev V.V. (2012) Capital Versus Performance Covenants in Debt Contracts Journal of Accounting Research vol. 50 issue 1 pp. 75-116;

  • Dennis I. (2014) The Nature of Accounting Regulation Routledge Publishing House New York;

  • Fields T.D. Lys T.Z. Vincent L. (2001) Empirical research on accounting choice Journal of Accounting and Economics vol. 31 pp. 255-307;

  • Gebhardt G. Mora A. Wagenhofer A. (2014) Revisiting the Fundamental Concepts of IFRS Abacus vol. 50 issue 1 pp. 107-116;

  • Hail L. (2013) Financial Reporting and Firm Valuation: Relevance Lost or Relevance Regained? Accounting and Business Research vol. 43 issue 4 pp. 329-358;

  • Jianu I. (2012) Valuation in accounting. Theory and method Economic Publishing House Bucharest;

  • Kothari SP. Ramanna K. Skinner D.J. (2010) Implications for GAAP from an Analysis of Positive Research in Accounting Journal of Accounting and Economics vol. 50 issues 2-3 pp. 246-286;

  • Leuz C. Wysocki PD. (2016) The Economics of Disclosure and Financial Reporting Regulation: Evidence and Suggestions for Future Research Journal of Accounting Research vol. 54 issue 2 pp. 525-622;

  • Lev B. Li S. Sougiannis T. (2010) The Usefulness of Accounting Estimates for Predicting Cash Flows and Earnings Review of Accounting Studies vol. 15 issue 4 pp. 779-807;

  • Lo A.l. (2017) Adaptive Markets Financial Evolution at the Speed of Thought Princeton University Press NEW Jersey Canada;

  • Menzefricke U. Smieliauskas W. (2016) Are all accounting estimates auditable? Some evidence on estimated returns in pension accounting working paper available on;

  • Myddleton D.R. (2009) Margins of Error in Accounting Palgrave New York;

  • Nobes C.W. Stadler C. (2015) The qualitative characteristics of financial information and managers’ accounting decisions: evidence from IFRS policy changes Accounting and Business Research vol. 45 issue 5 pp. 572-601;