Emergence of Commodity Derivatives as Defensive Instrument in Portfolio Risk Hedging: A Case of Indian Commodity Markets

Open access


This paper empirically examines whether commodity derivatives can be used as an alternative investment asset in India where commodity markets are at emerging state and provides the same diversification benefit as they provide in developed commodity markets. In India only commodity futures are prevalent so various commodity indices representing various sectors has been used in the study. Diversification aspect of commodity derivatives has been tested initially by using correlation analysis. Compounded Daily Growth rate and Relative Standard deviation has been used as a measure of calculating risk and return of daily data of SENSEX, BOND and four Commodity Indices (MCX Comdex, MCX AGRI, MCX Metal, MCX Energy). Markowitz Efficient Frontier theory has been used to calculate portfolio risk return and Sharpe risk adjusted ratio has been used to evaluate the various portfolios. Optimal portfolio has been obtained for the combination of equity, bond and commodity and overall results of the study indicate that an investor who is risk averse will prefer to invest in combination of SENSEX, BOND & MCX Energy whereas an investor who gets utility by taking more risk for more returns will prefer to invest in combination of SENSEX, BOND & MCX Metal. Investor having inclination towards moderate risk return would tend to invest in MCX AGRI along with SENSEX and BOND.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anson M (1998) “Spot Returns Roll Yield and Diversification with Commodity” The Journal of Alternative Investments December pp. 16-32.

  • Baur D. G. and Lucey B. M.(2010) “Is Gold a Hedge or a Safe Haven? An Analysis of Stocks Bonds and Gold” The Financial Review 45 217-229.

  • Becker K and Finnerty J (2000) “Indexed Commodity Futures and the Risk and Return of Institutional Portfolios” OFOR Working Paper

  • Bodie Z (1983) “Commodity Futures as a Hedge Against Inflation” The Journal of Portfolio Management Spring pp. 12-17.

  • Bodie Z and Rosansky V (1980) “Risk and Returns in Commodity Futures” Financial Analysts Journal May-June pp. 27-39.

  • C. Mitchell Conover Gerald R Jensen Robert R Johnson Jeffrey M Mercer (2009) “Can precious metal make your portfolio shine” The Journal of Investing vol. 18 no 1 pp.75-86.

  • Cheung C. Sherman; Miu Peter (2010) “Diversification Benefits of Commodity Futures” Journal of International Financial Markets Institutions & Money Vol. 20 Issue 5 p451-474. 24p

  • Coudert V. and Raymond H. (2010) Gold and Financial Assets: Are There any Safe Havens in Bear Markets? CEPII research center Working Papers No. 2010-2013 Paris University and Paris University.

  • Edwards F and Park J (1996) “Do Managed Futures Make Good Investments?” Journal of Futures Markets Vol. 16 pp. 475-517.

  • Edwards F. R. and Caglayan (2001) M. O. Hedge Fund and Commodity Fund Investments in Bull and Bear Markets Journal of Portfolio Management 27(4) 97-108.

  • Erb C and Harvey R (2006) “The Strategic and Tactical Value of Commodity Futures” Financial Analysts Journal March-April pp. 69-97

  • Dieter H. Huang H. and Niessen A. (2008) “How do Commodity future respond to Macro Economic News” Financial Markets and Portfolio Management Volume 22 Issue 2 pp 127-146

  • Fama E. and G. Schwert (1977) “ Asset returns and inflation” Journal of Financial Economics 5 (2) 115–146.

  • Greer R J (1978) “Methods for Institutional Investment in Commodity Futures” The Journal of Derivatives Winter pp. 28-36.

  • Gorton G. and Rouwenhorst K.G. (2005) ‘Facts and fantasies about commodity futures’ Yale ICF working paper no. 04-20 pp40.

  • Gorton G. B. and Rouwenhorst (2006) “Facts and Fantasies about Commodity Futures” Financial Analysts Journal 62(2) 47-68.

  • Halpern P and Warsager R (1998) “The Performance of Energy and Non Energy Based Commodity Investment Vehicles in Periods of Inflation” The Journal of Alternative Investments Summer pp. 75-81.

  • Hartzell D. J. Hekman and M. Miles (1987) “Real estate returns and inflation” Real Estate Economics 15 (1) 617–637.

  • Hunjra A. I. Azam M. Niazi G. S. K. Butt B. Z. Rehman K. U. and Azam R.I. Risk and Return Relationship in Stock Market and Commodity Prices: A Comprehensive Study of Pakistani Markets World Applied Sciences Journal 13(3) 2011 470-481.

  • Ibbotson Associates (2006) ‘Strategic asset allocation and commodities’ pp. 57.

  • Jalil N. A. Ghani G. M. Daud J. and Ibrahim M. (2009) “Stock Price Movements : Does Change in Energy Price Matter?” Instituto Brasileiro de Estudos Empresariais e Jurídicos(IBEJ) 2(1).

  • Jensen G. Johnson R.R. and Mercer J.M. (2000) ‘Efficient use of commodity futures in diversified portfolios’ The Journal of Futures Markets vol. 20 no 5 pp. 489-506.

  • Jensen G Johnson R and Mercer J (2002) “Tactical Asset Allocation and Commodity Futures” Journal of Portfolio Management Summer pp. 100-111.

  • Jensen G et al. (2010) “Is Now the time to add Commodities to your Portfolio” Journal of Investing. Vol. 19 Issue 3 p10-19. 10p

  • Kaplan P. D. and Lummer S.L. (1998) ‘Update: GCSI collateralized futures as a hedging and diversification tool for institutional portfolios’ The Journal of Investing Winter pp. 11 - 17.

  • Park J. W. and Ratti R.A. Oil Price Shocks and Stock Markets in the medals and 13 European Countries Energy Economics 30(5) 2008 2587-2608.

  • Rubens J. M. Bond and J. Webb (1989) “The inflation-hedging effectiveness of real estate” Journal of Real Estate Research 4 (2) 45–55.

  • Satyanarayan S. and P. Varangis “Diversification Benefits of Commodity Assets in Global Portfolios” Journal of Investing Spring 1996 pp. 69-78.

  • Schneeweis T and Spurgin R (1997) “Energy Based Investment Products and Investor Asset Allocation” AIMA Newsletter June.

  • Schneeweis T and Spurgin R (2000) “Investment Benefits of the LMEX Index” Journal of Alternative Investments Spring.

  • Smimou K. (2010). Stock market and agricultural futures diversification: An international perspective. The Journal of Alternative Investments 12(4) 36-57

  • Sumner S. Johnson R. Soenen L. Spillover Effects between Gold Stocks and Bonds Journal of CENTRUM Cathedra 3(2) (2010) 106-120.

  • Wang M. L. Wang C. P. and Huang T. Y. Relationships among Oil Price Gold Price Exchange Rate and International Stock Markets International Research Journal of Finance and Economics 47 2010 82-91

  • Walid S Abanomey and lke Mathur (1999) “The Hedging Benefits of Commodity Futures in International Portfolio Diversification” The Journal of Alternative Investments Vol 2 No.3: pp51-62

  • You L. and Daigler R. T. (2013) “A Markowitz Optimization of Commodity Futures Portfolios” Journal of Future Markets Vol. 33: 343–368