Investigating the Failure of State Owned Enterprises (SOEs) of an Emerging Economy: A Comparative Case Study

Open access


This study investigates the failure and aftermath of state owned enterprises (SOEs) of an emerging economy, Bangladesh. Failure of SOEs of emerging economy has been investigated by many researchers during the last few decades. This study is an extension of previous research. Through the comparative case study, this study tries to explore the scenario of failure of SOEs, the causal factors of failure, remedial actions and aftermath in SOEs. The findings indicate that different authorities from the policy maker to the operating level employees cannot avoid the responsibilities for failure. Even proper restructuring within the ownership of government can drive the firm positively. It is expected that the comparative case study will help to make the decision for the concerned authorities of Bangladesh as well as the authorities of other countries of the world who are in the same position.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Adams G.B. White J.D. (1994) Dissertation research in public administration and cognate fields: An assessment of methods and quality Public Administration Review Vol. 54 no. 6 pp. 565 – 76

  • Aivazian V.A. Ge Ying. Qie Jiaping (2005) Can corporatization improve the performance of state-owned enterprises even without privatization? Journal of Corporate Finance Vol. 11 pp. 791 – 808

  • Alamgir F. Cairns G. (2014) Development or dispossession? An interpretation of global integration of public sector jute mills in Bangladesh Critical Perspectives on International Business Vol. 10 no. 3 pp. 207 – 223

  • Ariyo A. Jerome A. (1999) Privatization in Africa: An appraisal World Development Vol. 27 no. 1 pp. 201 – 213

  • Bilsen V. Konings J. (1998) Job creation job destruction and growth of newly established privatized and state-owned enterprises in transition economics: Survey evidence from Bulgaria Hungary and Romania Journal of Comparative Economics Vol. 26 pp. 429 – 445

  • Booth J. (2008) The Multimillionaire gas workers of Bangladesh The Times available online at

  • Castro J. Uhlenbruck K. (1997) Characteristics of privatization: Evidence from developed less developed and former communist countries Journal of International Business Studies Vol. 28 pp. 123 – 143

  • Chowdhury Dhiman (2001): Performance related pay in the public sector: Management’s opportunistic behavior and need for corrections Bangladesh Development Studies University of Dhaka Bangladesh

  • Chowdhury Dhiman (2004): Incentives Control and Development: Governance in private and public sector with special reference to Bangladesh University of Dhaka Bangladesh

  • Costa M.C. Jaime V. I. (2008) Organizational status and efficiency: The case of the Spanish SOE “Paradores” International Journal of Public Sector Management Vol. 21 no. 5 pp. 494 – 508

  • Dewenter K.L. Malatesta P.H. (2001) State-owned and privately owned firms: An empirical analysis of profitability leverage and labor intensity The American Economic Review Vol. 91 no. 1 pp. 320 – 334

  • Eisenhardt K.M. (1989) Building theories from case study research Academy of Management Review Vol. 14 no. 4 pp. 532 – 550

  • Gian S. Sahota (1991) An assessment of the impact of industrial policy in Bangladesh The Bangladesh Development Studies Vol. 19 no. 1/2 pp. 157 – 199

  • Gruening G. (2001) Origin and theoretical basis of new public management International Public Management Journal Vol. 4 no 1 pp. 1 – 25

  • Gouret Fabian (2007) Privatization and output behavior during the transition: Methods matter! Journal of Comparative Economics Vol. 35 pp. 3 – 34

  • Hartley K. Parker D. (1991) Privatization: a conceptual framework: A comparative analysis of developed and developing countries In A. Ott& K. Hartley (Eds.) Privatization and economic efficiency (pp. 11-25). Brookfield VT: Edward dgar

  • Hay D. Morris D. Liu G. Yao S. (1994) Economic Reform and State-Owned Enterprises in China 1979-87OUP Catalogue.

  • Hood C. (1995) The ‘new public management’ in the 1980s: variations on a theme. Accounting Organizations and Society Vol. 20 No. 2/3 pp. 93 – 109

  • Hood C. (1998) A public management for all seasons? Public Administration Vol. 69 pp. 3 – 19

  • Jefferson G.H. Su J. (2006) Privatization and restructuring in China: Evidence from shareholding ownership 1995-2001 Journal of Comparative Economics Vol. 34 no. 1 pp. 146 – 166

  • Jensen J.L. Rodgers R. (2001) Cumulating and intellectual gold of case study research Public Administration Review. Vol. 61 no. 2 p. 235 – 246

  • Jiang C. Yao S. Feng G. (2013) Bank ownership privatization and performance: Evidence from a transition country Journal of Banking & Finance Vol. 37 no. 9 pp. 3364-3372.

  • Kay J.A. Thompson D.J. (1986) Privatization: A policy in search of a rationale The Economic Journal Vol. 96 no. 381 pp. 18 – 32

  • Kohinoor Chemical Co. Bangladesh Ltd. (KCCL) (2013) available online at

  • Kornai Janos (2000) Ten years after the road to a free economy: The author’s self evaluation In. Pleskovic Boris Stern Nicholas (Eds.) Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economic World Bank Washington pp. 49 – 66

  • Kole S.R. Mulherin J.H. (1997) The Government as a shareholder: A case from the United States Journal of Economics and Law Vol. 40 1 – 12

  • Lopez-Calva Luis F. Sheshinski Eytan (2003) Privatization and its benefits: Theory and evidence CESifo Economic Studies Vol. 49 pp. 429 – 459

  • Maesschalck J. (2004) The impact of the new public management reform on public servant’s ethic: towards a theory Public Administration Vol. 82 no. 2 pp. 465 – 481

  • Maskin E.S. (2000) Auctions development and privatization: Efficient auctions with liquidity-constrained buyers European Economic Review Vol. 44 no. 4-6 pp. 667 – 681

  • Muhammad Anu (2002) Closure of Adamjee Jute Mills: Ominous Sign Economic and Political Weekly Vol. 37 no. 38 pp. 3895 – 3897

  • Omran M. (2004) The performance of State-owned enterprises and newly privatized firms: Does privatization really matter? World Development Vol. 32 no. 6 pp. 1019 – 1041

  • Parnini S.N. (2009) Public sector reform and good governance: The impact of foreign aid on Bangladesh Journal of Asian and African Studies Vol. 44 no.5 pp. 553 – 575

  • Road S. (1997): Investing in Egypt Committee for Middle East Trade London

  • Seawright J. Gerring J. (2008) Case selection techniques in case study research: A menu of qualitative and quantitative options Political Research Quarterly Vol. 61 no. 2 pp. 294 – 308

  • Sharma U. Lawrence S. (2015) Power politics and privatization: A tale of a teletcommunications company Critical Perspective of Accounting Vol. 28 pp. 13 – 29

  • Sheaff R. West M. (1997) Mercerization managers and moral strain: chairman directors and public service ethos in the national health service Public Administration Vol. 75 pp. 189 – 206

  • Shirley M.M. (1999) Bureaucrats in Business: The roles of privatization versus corporatization in state-owned enterprises reform World Development Vol. 27 no.1 pp. 115 – 136

  • Steward J. (2012) Multiple-case study methods in governance-related research Public Management Review Vol. 14 no. 1 pp. 67 – 82

  • The Privatization Commission of Bangladesh (PCB) Achievement in the privatization available online at

  • Toninelli P.A. (2000): The rise and fall of State-Owned enterprises in the Western World Cambridge University Press United Kingdom

  • Truth Commission for Bangladesh (TCB) (2008) British Broadcasting Corporation available online at

  • Uddin Shahzad. Hopper Trevor (2003) Accounting for privatization in Bangladesh: Testing World Bank claims Critical Perspective of Accounting Vol. 14 pp. 739 – 774

  • Vickers J. Yarrow G. (1991) Economic perspective on privatization Journal of Economic Perspective Vol. 5 pp. 111 – 132

  • White Jay D. Guy B. Adams John P. Forrester (1996) Knowledge and theory development in public administration: The role of doctoral education and research Public Administration Review Vol. 56 no. 5 pp. 441 – 452

  • World Bank (1997): The First Four Years (1994 – 1998) Bangladesh: Jute Sector Adjustment Credit Report and Recommendation