Justice of ≪new man≫ in Karl Marx' vision

Open access

Abstract

This study aims to highlight the problem of justice in Karl Marx’s vision from the perspective of the critique of capitalism. Although, there is a strong dialectic in the socio-political and philosophical debates among political thinkers (including Marxists) on the existence or non-existence of a theory of justice in Marxism, the exegesis of Marxist writings reveals two types of justice (“Justice through fair distribution and Justice through the dictatorship of the proletariat”). The first aspect the study proposes is to reinforce and argue for the existence of a Marxist theory of Justice, followed by a critical analysis of how this is reflected in both socialist and communist society.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • • Cohen Gerald A. (1978) Karl Marx’s Theory of History : A Defence Editura Princeton University Press Princeton (New Jersey).

  • • Jessop Bob (2012) “Marxist Approaches to power” în E. Amenta K. Nash A. Scott eds The Wiley - Blackwell Companion to Political Sociology Editura Blackwell Oxford.

  • • Kamenka Eugen (1969) Marxism and Ethics Editura Palgrave Macmillan (St. Martin Press) New York.

  • • Marx Karl (1992) Critica Programului de la Gotha Editura Comitetului Naţional Executiv al Partidului Muncitoresc Socialist New York.

  • • Marx Karl Engels Friedrich (1966) Manifestului Comunist în Opere alese în două volume Vol. I ediţia a 3-a Editura Politică Bucureşti

  • • Rawls John (1999) A theory of Justice – (Revised) Editura The Belknap Press of Harvard Univesity Press Cambridge-Massachusetts.

  • • Tucker Robert C. (1069) The Marxian Revolutionary Idea Editura Norton Library New York 1969.

  • • Arneson Richard J. What’s Wrong with Alienation? în Ethics Vol. 91 Nr. 2 1981.

  • • Cam Taner Kayaoglu Mustafa Marx’s distinction between socialism and communism în International Journal of Human Sciences Vol. 12 Nr. 1 2015.

  • • Cohen Gerald A. Freedom Justice and Capitalism în New Left Review Nr. 126 1981.

  • • Commers Ronald Marx’s concept of justice and the two traditions in european political thought în Philosophica 33 Nr. 1 1984.

  • • Geras Norman Bringing Marx to Justice: An Addendum to a Rejoinder în New Left Review I/195 1992.

  • • Geras Norman The Controversy About Marx and Justice în New Left Review Vol. I/150 1985.

  • • Green Michael Marx Utility and Right în Political Theory Vol. 11 Nr. 3 1983.

  • • Husami Zyad. I. Marx on Distributive Justice în Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. 8 Nr. 1 1978.

  • • John A. Gueguen Origins : Karl Marx on Justice and Lawhttps://dadun.unav.edu/bitstream/10171/12551/1/PD_14_09.pdf

  • • Mehmet Kanatlı Rawlsian Theory of Justice as Fairness: A Marxist Critique în Hitit University Journal of Social Sciences Institute Vol. 8 Nr. 1 2015

  • • Nielsen Kai Marx on Justice: The Tucker-Wood Thesis Revisited în The Toronto Law Journal Vol. 38 Nr. 1 1988.

  • • Riley Patrick Marx and Morality: A Reply to Richard Miller în NOMOS Vol. XXVI 1983.

  • • Ryan Cris C. Socialist Justice and the Right to the Labour Product în Political Theory Vol. 8 Nr. 4 1980.

  • • Van de Veer Donald Marx’s Views of JusticePhilosophy and Phenomenological Research Vol. 33 Nr. 3 1973.

  • • Van der Linden Harry Marx and morality : An impossible synthesis în Theory and Society 1984 13: 1 p. 124 (trad. mea).

  • • Wood Allen W. Justice and class interests în Phi1osophica 33 Nr. 1 1984.

  • • Wood Allen W. The Marxian Critique of Justice în Philosophy & Public Affairs Nr. 1 1972.

  • • Young Garry Justice in Capitalist Production : Marx and Bourgeois Ideology în Canadian Journal of Philosophy Vol. 8 Nr. 3 1978.

  • • Raekstad Paul Marx and Justice : A Re-Examination of the Arguments în lucrarea prezentată la MANCEPT 2014 Workshops (https://www.academia.edu/8541846/Marx_and_Justice_A_Re-Examination_of_the_Arguments).

Search
Journal information
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 65 65 21
PDF Downloads 87 87 37