Modal Competition and Complementarity: Cost Optimization at End-User Level

Dan M. Costescu 1
  • 1 University Politehnica of Bucharest, , Romania


The paper aims to identify possible methods for balancing the allocation of transport flow on modal subsystems in order to efficiently use the infrastructures and reduce the negative effects of today’s unbalance. The aspects of intermodal competition are reviewed, considering the economic concepts regarding the substitutability of transportation services, conformation degree to the perfect competition model and the nature of cross elasticity demand.

A top-down analysis over the whole infrastructure assembly is performed. The results, under the presumption of valid work hypothesis, indicated that for further analysis the set of networks transferring material flows can be assumed as disconnected from the other networks sets transferring energy, informational and values flows.

The second part of the paper develops, for that disconnected networks, a generalized cost optimization model for multimodal transportation, where the comfort and safety are accounted. Thus, the performance of the existing algorithms based only on trip length, trip duration and energy consumption can be significantly improved. Additionally, the author proposes three new independent types of modal analysis that allow end-users and companies involved in transport organization to optimize their modal choice and the whole transport process organization.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1]. M. STEADIESEIFI, N.P. DELLAERT, W. NUIJTEN, T. VAN WOENSEL, R.RAOUFI: ”Multimodal freight transportation planning: A literature review”, European Journal of Operational Research, 233, 1–15, 2014.

  • [2]. E. BOUGNA, Y. CROZET: ”Towards a liberalised European rail transport: analysing and modelling the impact of competition on productive efficiency”, Research in Transportation Economics, Vol. 59, 358-367, 2016.

  • [3]. Z. TOMES: ”Do European reforms increase modal shares of railways?”, Transport Policy, Vol. 60,143–151, 2017.

  • [4]. A. KORZHENEVYCH, N. DEHNEN, J. BRÖCKER, M. HOLTKAMP, H. MEIER, G. GIBSON, A. VARMA, V. COX: ”Update of the Handbook on External Costs of Transport“, Ricardo - AEA, European Commission – DG Mobility and Transport, MOVE/D3/2011/571, 2014.

  • [5]. P. HEYNE, P.J. BOETKE, D.L. PRYCHITKO: “The Economic Way of Thinking” (13th Ed.), Pearson Publishing, 2014.

  • [6]. Ş. RAICU: ”Transport Systems”, Ed. AGIR, Bucharest, 2007. (In Romanian)

  • [7]. J. PERLOFF: ”Microeconomics”, Pearson Education, 2012.

  • [8]. R.S. PINDYCK, D.L. RUBINFELD: “Microeconomics” (6th Ed.). Pearson Prentice Hall, 2005.

  • [9]. Ş. RAICU, M. POPA: “Strategy of transport infrastructure development - Modeling of objective development”, Proceedings of the Vth Academic Days of Timis, Modern concepts regarding the design, building and maintenance of transport infrastructure, Timisoara, Romania, 1997. (In Romanian)

  • [10]. D.M. COSTESCU: “Re-balancing the national transport system”, in “Documentary files: Transportation and Infrastructure – Concepts and operational tools”, Club Romania Publishing, 2018a.

  • [11]. A. VENABLES, J. LAIRD, H. OVERMAN: ”Transport Investment and Economic Performance: Implications for Project Appraisal”, Department for Transport, UK,, 2014.

  • [12]. P.C. MELO, D.J. GRAHAM, R. BRAGE-ARDAO: ”The productivity of transport infrastructure investment: A meta-analysis of empirical evidence”, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 43 (5), pp. 695-706, 2013.

  • [13]. S. D. BHATTA, M. P. DRENNAN: ”The Economic Benefits of Public Investment in Transportation: A Review of Recent Literature”, Journal of Planning Education and Research. 22(3), 288-296, 2003.

  • [14]. D.M. COSTESCU: “Investing in railways”, Railway Pro, Bucharest, 2016.

  • [15]. D.M. COSTESCU: “Completing and implementation of the Romanian General Transport Master Plan”, in “Documentary files: Transportation and Infrastructure – Concepts and Operational Tools”, Club Romania Publishing House, 2018b.

  • [16]. D.M. COSTESCU: “Asset management a complex tool for railway infrastructure companies restructuring”, Proceedings of “UIC Global Asset Management, Global Conferences”, organized by Union Internationale de Chemin de Fer under the high patronage of United Nation Organization, Paris, 2017.

  • [17]. M.G.H. BELL, Y. IIDA: “Transportation network analysis”, Chichester, John Wiley & Sons, 1997.

  • [18]. R.L. ACKOFF, M.W. SASIENI: “Basis of operational research”, Ed. Tehnică, București, 1975.(In Romanian)

  • [19]. G.A. FROIS: „Political economy”, Humanitas, 1994.

  • [20]. D.M. COSTESCU: “Building the new railway economy, Challenges & Opportunities”, “Railway Days” Conference, Bucharest, 2015.

  • [21]. H. LINK, A. STUHLEMMER, M. HARALDSSON, P. ABRANTES. P. WHEAT, S. IWNICKI, C. NASH, A.SMITH: ”Catrin Study – P1”, in „Cost allocation for Transport Infrastructure”, FP6, 2008.

  • [22]. L. HUILLIER: “Le cout du transport”, Cujas, Paris, 1965.

  • [23]. E. QUINET: „Principes d’economie des transports”, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1990.

  • [24]. B. JOURQUIN, S. LIMBOURG: „Equilibrium Traffic Assignment on Large Virtual Networks, Implementation issues and limits for Multi-Modal Freight Transport”, European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Reseach, Vol. 3, 2006.


Journal + Issues