Anthropogenic or ecological trap: what is causing the population decline of the Lapwing Vanellus vanellus in Western Ukraine?

Open access


Ecological and anthropogenic traps exist and exert a negative effect on Lapwing populations. We believe that an anthropogenic trap is a partial or delayed manifestation of an ecological trap. In recent decades Lapwing communities have shown higher affiliation with urban landscapes, which negatively influences breeding success and the overall density of the species. It appears that the Lapwing has fallen into an anthropogenic trap, which in Ukraine is represented by agricultural landscapes. The decline in the Lapwing population is mainly caused by high intensity of agriculture, overgrazing, desolation of agricultural lands, changes in the water regime of rivers and lakes, global forestation, increasing disturbance by recreational activity and tourism, and an increase in the distribution and number of predatory mammals. Controlled burns of dead vegetation performed in late spring, household waste disposal, and construction work all contribute to the loss of breeding grounds. As a result the majority of local Lapwing populations declined during last decade, and some populations have gone completely extinct.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anon. 2002. The results of conservation activities of the company. What threatens birds? In: IBA Bulletin. Kyiv. Ukrainian Society for the Protection of Birds. pp. 3-4. (In Ukrainian).

  • Balkovskyy V.V. 2009. Hyper Drainage and secondary swamping. In: Innovative potential of Ukrainian science - XXI century: Proceedings of participants IV Ukrainian scientific-practic. Conf. Zaporizhzhya pp. 3-12. (In Ukrainian).

  • Battin J. 2004. When good animals love bad habitats: ecological traps and the conservation of animal populations. Cons. Biol. 18 (6): 1482-1491.

  • Bulakhov V.L. Gubkin A.A. Gubkin A.A. 2000. Current status of fauna waders of Dnipropetrovsk region. In: Questions of steppe forestry that forest land recultivat³on. Vol. 4. Dnipropetrovsk pp. 100-108. (In Russian).

  • Dubois P.J. Maheo R. Hotker H. 1991. Waders breeding on Wet Grassland in France. Bulletin WSG 61: 27-31.

  • Dwernychuk L.W. Boag D.A. 1972. Ducks nesting in association with gulls-an ecological trap? Can. J. of Zool. 50: 559-563.

  • Fletcher R.J. Jr. Orrock J.L. Robertson B.A. 2012. How the type of anthropogenic change alters the consequences of ecological traps. Proc. R. Soc. B. 279: 2456-2552.

  • Frikke J. 1991. Breeding Waders and Wet Grassland habitats in Denmark. Bulletin WSG 61: 42-49.

  • Gilroy J.J. Anderson G.Q.A. Grice P.V. Vickery J.A. Sutherland W.J. 2010. Mid-season shifts in the habitat associations of Yellow Wagtail Motacilla flava breeding in arable farmland. Ibis 152 (1): 90-104.

  • Gorban I. Szydlovskyi I. Khymin M. Prushynskyi M. Gorban L. 2002. Avifaune of the Ukrainian part of upper part of the Bug valley and perspectives of its protection. In: Korytarz ekologiczny doliny Bugu: Stan - Zagro¿enia - Ochrona. A. Dombrowski et. al. (eds). Warszawa pp. 197-218.

  • Horban I.M. Shydlovskyy I.V. 1999. The number of breeding waders in the west of Ukraine. In: Breeding waders of Eastern Europe - 2000. P.S. Tomkovich E.A. Lebedeva (eds).] Moscow. Vol. 2 pp. 93-105. (In Russian).

  • Kokko H. Sutherland W.J. 2001. Ecological traps in changing environments: Ecological and evolutionary consequences of a behaviourally mediated Allee effect. Evol. Ecol. Res. 3: 537-551.

  • Korobchenko M. 2011. Features of the modern distribution and storage of feed mole-rat Spalax microphthalmus (Mammalia) in eastern Ukraine. In: Zoocenosis - 2011. VI International Scientific Conference biodiversity and the role of animals in ecosystems 4-6 October 2011. Dnipropetrovsk pp. 267-270. (In Ukrainian).

  • Lebid E.A. Knysh M.P. Khomenko S.V. 1992. Fauna and ecology of waders the Sumy region. In: Problems of conservation and sustainable use of natural resources of Sumy region. Sumy pp. 76-94. (In Ukrainian).

  • Lugovoy A.E. Potish L.A. 1998. Breeding fauna and the number of waders Transcarpathian region of Ukraine. In: Breeding waders of Eastern Europe - 2000. P.S. Tomkovich E.A. Lebedeva (eds) - Moscow. Vol. 1 pp. 103-106. (In Russian).

  • Lysenko V.I. 1980. Protection of waders in Zaporizhzhya region. In: Materials 2 meeting on “Fauna and ecology of waders” (The new in studying biology and distribution of waders). - Moscow pp. 67-68.

  • Nikiforov M.E. Kozulin A.V. Grichik V.V. Tishechkin A.K. (eds). 1997. Birds of Belarus at the turn of the twenty-first century: status number distribution. Minsk pp. 54. (In Russian).

  • Panas R.M. 2004. Soil degradation: causes and ways to eliminate. Ekolhichnyj visnyk 4(26): 9-10. (In Ukrainian).

  • Shydlovskyy I. 2005. The Lapwing (Vanellus vanellus L.) in the West of Ukraine: biology population dynamics biotopic distribution. Ph.D. Thesis on specialty “Zoology”. Kyiv: Institute of Zoology of NAS of Ukraine pp. 20. (In Ukrainian).

  • Tryjanowski P. Hartel T. Báldi A. Szymañski P. Tobolka M. Herzon I. Go£awski A. Konvièka M. Hromada M. Jerzak L. Kujawa K. Lenda M. Or£owski M. Panek M. Skórka P. Sparks T.H. Tworek S. Wuczyñski A. ¯mihorski M. 2011. Conservation of farmland birds faces different challenges in western and central-eastern Europe. Acta Ornithologica 46: 1-12.

  • Zagorodniuk I. 2006. Anthropogenic traps and survival of animals in a transformed environment. In: Tribune-12. Proceedings of the Second International Interdisciplinary Conference on wildlife dedicated to the memory of F.R. Shtilmark. V.E. Boreyko (eds). Kyiv pp 160-171. (In Ukrainian).

  • Zagorodniuk I.V. 2003. The wild fauna of Kyiv and the surrounding areas and its urbanization. Vestnik Zoologii 37(5): 60-68. (In Ukrainian).

Journal information
Cited By
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 206 94 12
PDF Downloads 99 64 10