Algorithmic System for Identifying Bird Radio-Echo and Plotting Radar Ornithological Charts
The territory of Israel is a route for major bird migration from Europe and certain areas in Asia and Africa and back. During the period of intensive migration, the average density of birds may reach over 500 birds per a square kilometre of the air. These figures, alongside with the fact the air over the country is saturated with aircraft, makes it an urgent task to find solutions for prevention of disasters caused by aircraft-bird collisions.
In the present paper, a new algorithm is proposed aimed at identifying bird radar echoes against the background of other reflectors. The implementation of the algorithm has made it possible to improve the computerised radar system for bird monitoring developed earlier in Israel on the basis of MRL-5 meteorological radar station. The time needed for echo selection has been significantly reduced, while the trustworthiness of the ornithological data provided by the algorithm has increased. The new algorithm utilizes several echo properties that have been added to the algorithm previously developed by the authors, the most important of them being the pattern of echo movement. These properties in combination with a set of techniques used for their identification enabled to isolate the echo from moving birds against the background of other objects (ground clutter, clouds, atmospheric inhomogeneities, aircraft, etc.) at the accuracy level sufficient for operational purposes. The information on echo movement was used for plotting flight vectors (velocity and direction) of individual birds and bird groups. On the basis of movement pattern, four types of movement were distinguished: straightforward at non-uniform velocity; straightforward at uniform velocity; significant deviation from a straight line, non-uniform velocity and chaotic undirected shifts. The system enables on-line plotting of operational ornithological charts every 15-30 min, including charts that combine meteorological and bird monitoring data, to be provided to air traffic control services. This makes the proposed radar ornithological system an efficient means of maintaining air traffic safety in complicated meteorological and ornithological conditions.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Abshayev M. Burtsev I. Vaksenburg S. Shevela G. 1980. [Guide for use of the MRL-4 MRL-5 and MRL-6 radars in urban protection systems.] Hydrometeoizdat Leningrad. (In Russian).
Abshayev M. Kaplan L. Kapitannikov A. 1984. [Form reflection of meteorologic targets at the primary processing of the meteorologic radar signal.] Transactions of VGI 55. (In Russian).
Alpert P. Tannhauser D.S. Leshem Y. Kravitz A. Rabinovitch-Hadar M. 2000. Migrating soaring birds align along sea-breeze fronts; First evidence from Israel.Bull. Am. Meteorol. Soc.81 7: 1599-1601.
Atlas D. 1964. Advances in Radar Meteorology.Adv. Geophys.10: 318-468.
Bahat O. Ovadia O. 2005. Minimizing Bird-Aircraft Collisons Caused by Resident Raptors in Israel. IBSC 27th Meeting Athens Hellas 23-27 May 2005: p. 178.
Bruderer B. Joss J. 1969. Zur Registrierung and Interpretation von Echosingnaturen an enema 35 cm-Zielvervolgungstradar.Orn. Beob.66: 70-88.
Bruderer B. 1992. Radar studies on Bird migration in the south of Israel. BSCE/21 Jerusalem: pp. 269-280.
Bruderer B. Liechti F. 1995. Variation in density and height distribution of nocturnal migration in the south of Israel.Isr. J. Zool.41 3: 477-489.
Bruderer B. 1997. Migratory directions of birds under the influence of wind and topography. RIN Symposium Orientation & Navigation - Birds Humans & other animals. Oxford. 27/1-10.
Buurma L. 1999. The Royal Netherlands Air Force: Two Decades Of Bird Strike Prevention "En Route". International Seminar on Birds and Flight Safety in the Middle East Israel April 25-26 1999: pp. 71-83.
Chernikov A. 1979. [Radar clear sky echoes.] Hydrometeoizdat Leningrad: 3-40. (In Russian).
Chernikov A. Schupjatsky A. 1967. [Polarization characteristics of radar clear sky echoes.] Transactions of USSR academy of sciences atmosphere and ocean physics3 2: 136-143. (In Russian).
Dinevich L. Kapitalchuk I. Schupjatsky A. 1994. [Use of the polarization selection of radar signals for remote sounding of clouds and precipitation.] 34th Israel Annual Conference on Aerospace Science: pp. 273-277.
Dinevich L. Leshem I. Gal A. Garanin V. Kapitannikov A. 2000. Study of birds migration by means of the MRL-5 radar. Sci. Isr. - Technol. Adv. 4.
Dinevich L. Leshem Y. Pinsky M. Sterkin A. 2004. Detecting birds and estimating their velocity vectors by means of MRL-5 meteorological radar.Ring26 2: 35-53.
Eastwood E. 1967. Radar ornithology. Methuen London: 278.
Edwards J. Houghton E.W. 1959. Radar echoing area polar. Diagrams of birds.Nature184 4692.
Doviak R. Zrnic D. 1984. Doppler Radar and Weather Observation. Acad. Press: 512 pp.
Ganja I. Zubkov M. Kotjazi M. 1991. [Radar ornithology.] Stiinza pp. 123-145. (In Russian).
Gauthreaux S.A. Sidney A. Jr. Mizrahi D.S. Belser C.G. 1998. Bird Migration and Bias of WSR-88D Wind Estimates.Weather and Forecasting13: 465-481.
Glover K. Hardy K. 1966. Dot angels: insects and birds. Proc. 12th Weather Radar Conf. Amer. Met. Soc. Boston 1966: pp. 264-268.
Gudmundsson G.A. Alerstam T. Green M. Hedenström A. 2002. Radar observations of Arctic bird migration at the Northwest Passage Canada.Arctic55 1: 21-43.
Hajovsky R. Deam A. La Grone A. 1966. Radar reflections from insects in the lower atmosphere.IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation14: 224-227.
Hardy K.R. Katz I. 1969. Probing the Atmosphere with High Power High Resolution Radars. Panel on Remote Atmospheric Probing of the National Academy of Sciences Chicago Ill.
Houghton E 1964. Detection recognition and identification of birds on radar. World conf. Radio Met. Amer. Met. Soc. Boston: pp. 14-21.
Komenda-Zehnder S. Liechti F. Bruderer B. 2002. Is reverse migration a common feature of nocturnal bird migration. An analysis of radar data from Israel.Ardea90 2: 325-334.
Kropfli R.A. 1970. Simultaneous radar and instrumented aircraft observations in a clear air turbulent layer. Prepr. 14th Radar Met. Conf. Amer. Met. Soc. Boston: pp. 117-120.
Larkin R.P. Evans W.R. Diehl R.H. 2002. Nocturnal flight calls of Dickcissels and Doppler radar echoes over south Texas in spring.J. Field Ornithol.73 1: 2-8.
Leshem Y. Gauthreaux S.A. 1996. Proposal to develop a global network to predict bird movements on a real-time and daily scale by using radars. Bird Strike Committee Europe BSCE-23/WP 50. London May 13-17 1996.
Leshem Y. Yom-Tov Y. 1996. The use of thermals by soaring migrants in Israel.Ibis138: 667-674.
Leshem Y. Yom-Tov. Y. 1998. Routes of migrating soaring birds.Ibis140: 41-52.
Lofgren G. Battan L. 1969. Polarization and vertical velocities of dot angel echoes.J. Appl. Met.1969: 948-951.
Miller M.A. Verlinde J. Gilbert C.V. Lehenbauer G.J. Tongue J.S. Clothiaux E.E. 1998. Detection of nonprecipitating clouds with the WSR-88D: a theoretical and experimental survey of capabilities and limitations.Weather and Forecasting13 4: 1046-1062.
Richardson W.J. West T. 2005. Serious Birdstrike Accidents to U.K. Military Aircraft 1923 to 2004: Numbers and Circumstances. IBSC 27th Meeting Athens Hellas 23-27 May 2005: p. 5.
Russell K.R. Gauthreaux S.A. 1998. Use of weather radar to characterize movements of roosting purple martins.Wildl. Soc. Bull.26 1: 5-16.
Schupjatsky A. 1959. [Radar dispersion by non-spherical particles.] CAO Tr.30: 39-52. (In Russian).
Skolnik M. 1970. Radar handbook. McGraw-Hill Book Company.
Stepanenko V. 1973. [Radar in meteorology.] Hydrometeoizdat Leningrad. (In Russian).
Thorpe J. 2005. Fatalities and Destroyed Civil Aircraft Due to Bird Strikes 2002 to 2004 (with an Addendum of Animal Strikes). IBSC 27th Meeting Athens Hellas 23-27 May 2005: pp. 17-24.
Venema V. Russchenberg H. 2000. Clear-air scattering observations: downdraft and angels.Physics and Chemistry of the Earth. B: Hydrology25 10-12: 1123-1128.
Zavirucha V. Saricev V. Stepanenko V Shepkin U. 1977. [Study of the dispersion characteristics of the meteorological and ornitological objects in echo-free cameras.] Proc. Main Geophysic Observatory395: 40-45. (In Russian).
Zrnic D.S. Ryzhkov A.V. 1998. Observations of insects and birds with a polarimetric radar.IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing36 2: 661-668.