Uncertainty in Historical Land-Use Reconstructions with Topographic Maps

Open access

Abstract

The paper presents the outcomes of the uncertainty investigation of a long-term forest cover change analysis in the Polish Carpathians (nearly 20,000 km2) and Swiss Alps (nearly 10,000 km2) based on topographic maps. Following Leyk et al. (2005) all possible uncertainties are grouped into three domains - production-oriented, transformation- oriented and application-oriented. We show typical examples for each uncertainty domain, encountered during the forest cover change analysis and discuss consequences for change detection. Finally, a proposal for reliability assessment is presented.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Affek A. 2011. Landscape continuity versus landscape transformation: a case study in the Wiar River catchment Polish Carpathians (1780-2000). The Problems of Landscape Ecology 30: 147-155.

  • Affek A. 2013. Georeferencing of historical maps using GIS: As exemplified by the Austrian military surveys of Galicia. Geographia Polonica 86(4): 375-390.

  • Bennett B. 2001. What is a forest? On the vagueness of certain geographic concepts. Topoi 20: 189-201.

  • Bjørke J.T. 1996. Framework for entropy-based map evaluation. Cartography and Geographic Information Systems 23(2): 78-95.

  • Fisher P. 2003. Data quality and uncertainty: Ships passing in the night! In: Shi W. Goodchild M.F. Fisher P. (eds) Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on Spatial Data Quality. Hong Kong Hong Kong Polytechnic University: 17-22.

  • Gimmi U. Lachat T. Bürgi M. 2011. Reconstructing the collapse of wetland networks in the Swiss lowlands 1850-2000. Landscape Ecology 26: 1071-1083.

  • Ginzler C. Brändli U.-B. Hägel M. 2011. Waldflächenentwicklung der letzten 120 Jahre in der Schweiz. Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Forstwesen 162: 337-343.

  • Global Forest Resources Assessment 2010. Main report FAO Forestry Paper 163 Rome FAO.

  • Goodchild M.F. 1991. Issues of quality and uncertainty. In: Muller J.C. (ed.) Advances in Cartography. London Elsevier: 113-39.

  • Gregory I.N. Ell P.S. 2007. Historical GIS. Technologies Methodologies and Scholarship. Cambridge Studies in Historical Geography. Cambridge Cambridge University Press.

  • Gregory I.N. Healey R.G. 2007. Historical GIS: structuring mapping and analyzing geographies of the past. Progress in Human Geography 31(1): 638-653.

  • Grosjean G. 1996. Geschichte der Kartographie. Geographisches Institut der Universität Bern Bern.

  • Gugerli D. Speich D. 2002. Topographien der Nation. Politik kartographische Ordnung und Landschaft im 19. Jahrhundert. Chronos Verlag Zürich.

  • Instrukcja Techniczna K-2 - Mapy topograficzne do celów gospodarczych 1980. Wyd. 2 Warszawa.

  • Instrukcja topograficzna WIG 1925. Część II techniczna. Warszawa.

  • Kaim D. 2009. Zmiany pokrycia terenu na pograniczu polsko- słowackim na przykładzie Małych Pienin. Przegląd Geograficzny 81: 93-106.

  • Kozak J. 2003. Forest cover changes in the Western Carpathians over the past 180 years: a case study from the Orawa region in Poland. Mountain Research and Development 23: 369-375.

  • Kozak J. 2010. Forest Cover Changes and Their Drivers in the Polish Carpathian Mountains Since 1800. In: Nagendra H. Southworth J. (eds) Reforesting Landscapes. Linking Pattern and Process. Landscape Series 1: 253-273 Springer Verlag.

  • Krassowski B. 1974. Polska kartografia wojskowa w latach 1918-1945. Wydawnictwo MON Warszawa.

  • Kunz M. 2006. Standaryzacja danych kartograficznych i teledetekcyjnych do analizy zmian struktury krajobrazu. Roczniki Geomatyki 6(3): 119-127.

  • Leyk S. Boesch R. Weibel R. 2005. A conceptual framework for uncertainty investigation in map-based land cover change modeling. Transactions in GIS 9: 291-322.

  • Leyk S. Boesch R. Weibel R. 2006. Saliency and semantic processing - extracting forest cover from historical topographic maps. Pattern Recognition 39(5): 953-968.

  • Longley P.A. Goodchild M.F. Maguire D.J. Rhind D.W. 2001. Geographic Information: Systems and Science. Chichester John Wiley and Sons G.H. 1999. A ‘forest’ by any other name… Environmental Science & Policy 2: 125-133.

  • Ostafin K. 2009. Zmiany granicy rolno-leśnej w środkowej części Beskidu Średniego od połowy XIX wieku do 2005 roku. Wydawnictwo UJ Kraków.

  • Ostafin K. Iwanowski M. Cacko A. Kozak J. Gimmi U. Kaim D. Psomas A. Ginzler C. Ostapowicz K. in preparation. Detection of forest cover on historical topographic maps based on colour segmentation and morphological image processing.

  • Petit C.C. Lambin E.F. 2002. Impact of data integration technique on historical landuse/land-cover change: comparing historical maps with remote sensing data in the Belgian Ardennes. Landscape Ecology 17: 117-132.

  • Plewe B. 2002. The Nature of Uncertainty in Historical Geographic Information. Transactions in GIS 6: 431-456.

  • Pontius R.G. Spencer J. 2005. Uncertainty in extrapolations of predictive land change models. Environment and Planning B 32: 211-230. Przepis podstawowy o sporządzaniu map wojskowych i opisu wojskowo- geograficznego 1929. Wojskowy Instytut Geograficzny Warszawa.

  • Skaloš J. Weber M. Lipský Z. Trpáková I. Šantrůcková M. Uhlířová L. Kukla P. 2011. Using old military survey maps to analyse long-term land cover changes - Case study (Czech Republic). Applied Geography 31: 426-438.

  • Timár G. 2004. GIS integration of the second military survey sections - a solution valid on the territory of Slovakia and Hungary. Kartografické listy 12: 119-126.

  • Troll M. 2013. Dawny austriacki kataster gruntowy w bazie danych geograficznych dla Czarnohory (Karpaty Wschodnie Ukraina). GIS w nauce - Streszczenia konferencyjne KUL Lublin: 10-11. Ustawa z dnia 28 września 1991 r. o lasach. Dz.U. 101.444.

  • Veregin H. 1999. Data quality parameters. In: Longley P. Goodchild M.F. Maguire D.J. Rhind D.W. (eds) Geographical Information Systems: Principles Techniques Management and Applications (Volume 1). New York John Wiley and Sons: 177-189.

  • Walczak W. 1946. Znaki topograficzne stosowane najczęściej na mapach polskich WIG oraz najważniejsze znaki na mapach byłych zaborów. Wiedza-Zawód-Kultura Kraków.

  • Warcholik W. 2005. Rejestracja różnic w przebiegu granicy rolno-leśnej w Beskidzie Niskim na obszarze Polski i Słowacji (1933-1975) z wykorzystaniem GIS. Problemy Zagospodarowania Ziem Górskich 51: 59-69.

  • Wolski J. 2012. Błędy i niepewność w procesie tworzenia map numerycznych. Prace Komisji Krajobrazu Kulturowego 16: 15-32.

  • Wulf M. Rujner H. 2011. A GIS-based method for the reconstruction of the late eighteenth century forest vegetation in the Prignitz region (NE Germany). Landscape Ecology 26: 153-168.

  • Zhang J. Goodchild M.F. 2002. Uncertainty in Geographical Information. Taylor and Francis London.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.83

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.236
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.461

Cited By
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 291 171 2
PDF Downloads 167 122 0