Mechanisms of Europeanisation and Compliance in Judicial Politics: Understanding the Past and Anticipating the Future

Open access

Abstract

Recent developments in Hungarian constitutional and judicial politics have given impetus to question not only the outcomes of democratisation and Europeanisation, but also the efficacy of the European Union’s compliance mechanisms. In 2010, Hungary, one of the forerunners in building democracy made the headlines with Fidesz’s attempts at adopting a new Constitution and implementing cardinal laws along with controversial institutional, cultural, religious, moral and socio-economic policies. This article attempts to depict the transformative power of the European Union within a sensitive policy area which touches upon States’ pouvoris régaliens: the independence of the judiciary.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Bodnar A. & Bojarski L. (2011) ‘Judicial Independence in Poland’ in Anja Seibert-Fohr (ed.) Judicial Independence in Transition Springer.

  • Bobek Michal 2007. ‘Iudex Ex Machina : Institutional and Mental Transitions of Central and Eastern European Judiciairies’ in Coman Ramona and Jean-Michel De Waele (eds.) Judicial Reforms in Central and Eastern European Countries Brugge: Vanden Broele.

  • Brusis M. 2005. European Union enlargement and the Europeanization of Eastern Europe: research puzzles and policy issues. In: Z. Mansfeldova V. Sparschuh and A. Wenninger eds. Patterns of Europeanization in Central and Eastern Europe Kramer: Hamburg.

  • Caporaso J. et al. 2001. Transforming Europe. Europeanization and domestic change. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.

  • Coman R. And De Waele J.M. 2007. Judicial reforms in Central and Eastern Europe from a salient to a salient research topic. In: R. Coman and J.M. De Waele eds. Judicial Reforms in Central and Eastern European Countries Buges: Vanden Broele 1-11.

  • Coman R. 2009. Reformer la justice dans un pays post-communiste. Le cas de la Roumanie Bruxelles : Editions de l’Université.

  • Dallara C. 2007. ‘Challenges to the democratic judicial reform in Serbia: Legacy of the past political actors interests and the EU vagueness’ in Coman R. & De Waele J.M. (eds). Judicial Reforms in Central and Eastern European Countries Buges: Vanden Broele.

  • Dallara C. 2008. ‘Serbia: borderline democracy?’ in Morlino L. & Magen A. (eds) Democratization and the European Union. Comparing Central and Eastern European post-communist countries New York : Routledge.

  • Domingo P. 1999. Judicial Independence and Judicial Reforms in Latin America. In: A. Schedler L. Diamond and M. F. Plattner eds. The Self-Restraining State. Power and Accountability in New Democracies. Lynne Rienner Publishers: London 151-177.

  • Febbrajo A. 2010. Legal Cultures in Transition: A System-theory Approach. In: A. Febbrajo and W. Sadurski eds. Central and Eastern Europe After Transition. Towards a New Socio-legal Semantics Ashgate 35-73.

  • Fleck Z. et al Opinion on the fundamental law of Hungary June 2011.

  • Fleck Zoltan 2011. ‘Judicial Independence in Hungary’ in Seibert-Fohr Anja (ed.) Judicial Independence in Transition Springer.

  • Friedman B. 2004. History Politics and Judicial Independence. In: S. Andras ed. Judicial Integrity Martinus Nijhoff Publishers: Leiden Boston.

  • Elster J. 1995. Forces and Mechanisms in the Constitution-Making Process Duke Law Journal 45 (2) 364-396.

  • Epstein R. A. 2005. ‘The paradoxes of enlargement’ European Political Research Vol. 4 pp. 384-394.

  • European Parliament Resolution of 10 March 2011 on Media law in Hungary.

  • European Parliament debates 17 January 2011.

  • European Commission for Democracy through Law Opinion on the new Constitution of Hungary no° 621/2011.

  • European Commission Press Release 7 March 2012.

  • European Commission 1998. Regular report from the Commission on Hungary progress towards Accession.

  • European Commission 1999. Regular report from the Commission on Hungary progress towards Accession.

  • European Commission 2001. Regular report from the Commission on Hungary progress towards Accession SEC(2001) 1748.

  • European Commission 2002. Regular report from the Commission on Hungary progress towards Accession SEC(2002) 1404.

  • European Commission 2003. Comprehensive monitoring report on Hungary’s preparations for membership.

  • EU Observer MEPs voice ‘serious concern’ on Hungary’s democracy 16 February 2012.

  • EU Observer EU gives Hungary one month to fix laws 7 March 2012.

  • Exadaktylos T. and Radaelli C. 2009. Research Design in European Studies: The Case of Europeanization JCMS 47 (3) 507-530.

  • Ginsburg Nuno and Garpupa Tom 2009. “Guarding the Guardians. Judicial Councils and Judicial Independence” American Journal of Comparative Law 57 201-232.

  • Grabbe H. 2001. How does Europeanization affect CEE governance? Conditionality diffusion and diversity. Journal of European Public Policy 8 (6) 1013-1031.

  • Grabbe H. 2002. European Union Conditionality and the Acquis communautaire. International Political Science Review 23 (3) 249-268.

  • Goetz K. 2001. Making sense of post-communist central administration: modernization Europeanization or Latinization?. Journal of European Public Policy 8 (6) 1032-1051.

  • Bankuti M. Halmai G. Scheppele K. L. 2012. Hungary’s Illiberal Turn. Disabling the Constitution Journal of Democracy 23 (3) 138-146.

  • Hammerslev O. 2011. “The European Union and the United States in Eastern Europe: two ways of exporting law expertise and state power” in Y. Dezalay Y. & B. G. Garth (eds) Bryant Lawyers and the Rule of Law in an Era of Globalization Routledge.

  • Haughton T. 2007. When Does the EU Make a Difference? Conditionality and the Accession Process in Central and Eastern Europe. Political Studies Review 5 (2) 233-246.

  • Hill P. Knill Ch. 2006. ‘It’s the Bureaucracy Stupid. The Implementation of the Acquis Communautaire in the EU Candidate Countries 1999-2003’ European Union Politics 7 4.

  • Hughes J. Sasse G. Gordon C. 2004a. Conditionality and Compliance in the EU’s Eastward Enlargement: Regional Policy and the Reform of Sub-national Government. Journal of Common Market Studies 42 (3) 523-551.

  • Hughes J. Sasse G. Gordon C. 2004b. Europeanization and regionalization in the EU’s enlargement to Central and Eastern Europe: the myth of conditionality Basingstoke: Palgrave.

  • Juncos A. 2011. Europeanization by Decree? The case of Police Reform in Bosnia. JCMS 49 (2) 367-389.

  • Kotzian P. Knodt M. and Urdze S. Instruments of the EU’s external democracy promotion JCMS 49 (5) 923-1152.

  • Kochenov D. 2004. Behind the Copenhagen façade. The meaning and the structure of the Copenhagen Political Criterion of democracy and the rule of law. European Integration online Papers 8 (10) 1-36.

  • Kosar D. 2010. ‘Judicial Accountability in the (Post)Transitional Context: A Story of the Czech Republic’ in Czarnota A. & Parmentier S. (eds) (2010).

  • Ladrech R. 2010. Europeanization and National Politics. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Larkins K. 1996. Judicial Independence and Democratization: A Theoretical and Conceptual Analysis. The American Journal of Comparative Law 44 (4) 605-626.

  • Magalhaes P. C. 1999. The Politics of Judicial Reform in Eastern Europe. Comparative Politics 32 (1) 43-62.

  • Melone A. P. 1996. The Struggle for Judicial Independence and the Transition toward Democracy in Bulgaria. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 29 (2) 231-243.

  • Muller J. W. 2013. Defending Democracy within the EU Journal of Democracy 24(2) 138-149.

  • O’Dwyer C. 2006. Reforming Regional Governance in East Central Europe: Europeanization or Domestic Politics as usual. East European Politics and Societies 20(2) 219-253.

  • Open Society Institute 2001. Monitoring the EU Accession Process: Judicial Independence Budapest.

  • Parau C. 2011. “The Drive for Judicial Supremacy” in Anja Seibert-Fohr (ed.) Judicial Independence in Transition Springer.

  • Papadimitriou D. and Phinnemore D. 2004. Europeanization Conditionality and Domestic Change: The Twinning Exercice and Administrative Reform in Romania. Journal of Common Market Studies 42 (3) 619-639.

  • Pederzoli P. And Piana D. 2010. The Governance of the Judicial System in Europe. In: R. Coman and C. Dallara eds. Handbook on Judicial Politics Iasi: Institutul European 89-121.

  • Piana D. 2010. Judicial Accountabilities in New Europe. From Rule of Law to Quality of Justice. Ashgate.

  • Přibáň J. 2004. Reconstituting Paradise Lost: Temporality Civility and Ethnicity in Post-CommunistConstitution-Making. Law & Society Review 38 (3) 407-432.

  • Přibáň J. 2010. Constituting the Heterarchy of European Constitutionalism in the EU’s New Member States. In: In: A. Febbrajo and W. Sadurski eds. Central and Eastern Europe After Transition. Towards a New Socio-legal Semantics Ashgate 13-35.

  • Pridham G. 2006. Assessing Democratic Consolidation in Central and Eastern Europe: The European Dimension. Acta Politica 41 342-369.

  • Pogany I. 1993. Constitutional Reform in Central and Eastern Europe: Hungary’s Transition to Democracy. The International and Comparative Law Quarterly 42 (2) 332-355.

  • Ravinet P. 2011. ‚La coordination européenne «à la bolognaise»‘ Revue française de science politique 61 1.

  • Richardson J. T. 2006. Religion Constitutional Courts and Democracy in Former Communist Countries. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 603 129-138.

  • Saurugger S. (2012) “Beyond Non-Compliance with Legal Norms” in Exadaktylos T. and Radaelli C. M. (eds). Research Design in European Studies. Establishing Causality in Europeanization New York: Palgrave.

  • Sajo A. 1995. Reading the Invisible Constitution: Judicial Review in Hungary. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 15 (2) 253-267.

  • Sadurski W. 2008. Solange chapter 3’: Constitutional Courts in Central Europe—Democracy European Union. European Law Journal 14 (1) 1-35.

  • Schedler A. 1999. Retraining the State: Conflicts and Agents of Accountabiity. In: A. Schedler L. Diamond and M. F. Plattner eds. The Self-Restraining State. Power and Accountability in New Democracies. Lynne Rienner Publishers: London 333-351.

  • Scheppele K. L. 2006. Guardians of the Constitution: Constitutional Court Presidents and the Struggle for the Ruleof Law in Post-Soviet Europe. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 154 (6) 1757-1851.

  • Schimmelfennig F. Engert S. and Knobel H. 2003. Costs Commitment and COmpliance : The Impact of EU Democratic Conditionality on Latvia Slovakia and Turkey. Journal of Common Market Studies 41 (3) 495–518.

  • Schimmelfennig F. and Sedelmeier U. 2004. Governance by conditionality : EU rule transfer to the candidate countries of Central and Eastern Europe. Journal of European Public Policy 11 (4) 661–679.

  • Schönfelder Bruno (2005). “Judicial Independence in Bulgaria: A Tale of Splendour and Misery” Europe-Asia Studies 57: 1 61-92.

  • Schwartz H. 1999. Surprising Success: The New Eastern European Constitutional Courts. In: A. Schedler L. Diamond and M. F. Plattner eds. The Self-Restraining State. Power and Accountability in New Democracies. Lynne Rienner Publishers: London 195-217.

  • Seleny A. 1999. Old Political Rationalities and New Democracies: Compromise and Confrontation in Hungary and Poland. World Politics 51 484-519.

  • Sticka M. (2007) ‘Top-down control slows Czech judicial reform despite EU impetus’ in Transparency International

  • Spinner M. 2005. Aspects of democracy. Democratic consolidation in Eastern Europe: old wine in new bottles?. European Political Science 4 443-453.

  • Uitz R. 2010. Hungary : high hopes revisited. In : L. Morlino and W. Sadurski (eds) Democratization and the European Union. Comparing Central and Eastern European post-communist countries New York : Routledge 45-71.

  • Wuller J.W. 2013. Defending Democracy within the EU Journal of Democracy 24 (2) 2013 138-149.

  • Wolczuk K. 2007. Constitutional Politics. In: S. White J. Batt and Paul G. Lewis eds. Developments in Central and East European Politics Palgrave.

Search
Journal information
Cited By
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 185 72 1
PDF Downloads 91 43 0