Margins of Nationality. External ethnic citizenship and non-discrimination

Open access

Abstract

People are usually born into their political communities, and only a minority of them become member of the given community by naturalisation. Sovereign states enjoy a great margin of appreciation in defining the rules of both birthright and acquired political membership. Most states employ some form of cultural affinity-based criteria relating to ethnic identity that differentiate between applicants that seek to acquire the nationality of the state. Indeed, such distinctions seem to be growing with the revival of ethnic and nationalist aspirations that Europe has witnessed for some years. We argue that human rights principles, first and foremost non-discrimination guarantees, should be taken seriously and effectively applied to these cases of naturalisation, and show what such a scrutiny entails. While the arguments presented here should apply more generally, special attention will be paid to events that primarily triggered the authors’ interest, the case of Hungary.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Bárdi Nándor 2004 ‘“A mumusok és a kék madár” Mi történt? Miről beszél(t)ünk?’ Interview by Gyöngyi Annamária Regio 2004/4 51-84 available at http://epa.oszk.hu/00000/00036/00056/pdf/51-84.pdf (accessed: 15 Jan. 2015).

  • Bauböck Rainer 2006 Migration and Citizenship. Legal Status Rights and Political Participation University Press Amsterdam.

  • Bauböck Rainer 2007 ‘Stakeholder Citizenship and Transnational Political Participation: A Normative Evaluation of External Voting’ Fordham Law Review LXXV(4): 2393-2447

  • Bauböck Rainer 2010 ‘Dual citizenship for transborder minorities? How to respond to the Hungarian-Slovak tit-for-tat’ in Rainer Bauböck (ed) Dual citizenship for transborder minorities? How to respond to the Hungarian-Slovak tit-for-tat EUI Working Papers RSCAS 2010/75 Badia Fiesolana (FI) 1-4 available at http://cadmus.eui.eu/bitstream/handle/1814/14625/RSCAS_2010_75.corr.pdf?sequence=3 (accessed 28 Jan. 2015).

  • Blatter Joachim 2010 ‘Dual citizenship for ethnic minorities with neighbouring kin states’ EUDO Citizenship Observatory in Rainer Bauböck (ed) Dual citizenship for transborder minorities? How to respond to the Hungarian-Slovak tit-for-tat EUI Working Papers RSCAS 2010/75 Badia Fiesolana (FI) 13-18 available at http://cadmus.eui.eu/bitstream/handle/1814/14625/RSCAS_2010_75.corr.pdf?sequence=3 (accessed 28 Jan. 2015).

  • Brubaker Rogers 1996 Nationalism Reframed: Nationhood and the National Question in the New Europe Cambridge University Press Cambridge.

  • Carens Joseph H. 2000 Culture Citizenship and Community. A Contextual Exploration of Justice as Evenhandedness Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • Dumbrava Costica 2014 Nationality Citizenship and Ethno-cultural Belonging. Preferential Membership Policies in Europe Palgrave.

  • Dworkin Ronald 2011 Justice for Hedgehogs Belknap Cambridge Mass.

  • Gál Kinga 2002 ‘The Hungarian Legislation on Hungarians Living in Neighbouring Countries’ in The Protection of National Minorities by their Kin-State Venice Commission Science and technique of democracy No. 32 Council of Europe Strasbourg.

  • Halász Iván and Majtényi Balázs 2002 ‘Constitutional Regulation in Europe on the Status of Minorities living abroad’ in Minorities research (4) 135-144.

  • Iordachi Constantin 2013 Country Report: Romania EUDO Citizenship Observatory 2009 revised and updated April 2013 available at http://eudocitizenship.eu/admin/?p=file&appl=countryProfiles&f=2013-19-Romania.pdf (accessed 27 Jan. 2015).

  • Joppke Christian 2005 Selecting by Origin Ethnic Migration in the Liberal State Harvard University Press Cambridge Mass.

  • Kántor Zoltán 2004 ‘Status Law and ‘Nation Policy’: Theoretical Aspects’ in Kántor Zoltán Majtényi Balázs Ieda Osamu-Vizi and Balázs-Halász Iván (eds) The Hungarian Status Law: Nation Building and/or Minority Protection Slavic Research Center Hokkaido University Sapporo Budapest 303-309

  • Kovács M. Mária 2005 ‘The Politics of Nonresident Dual Citizenship in Hungary’ in Regio (1): 50-72.

  • Körtvélyesi Zsolt 2012 ‘From “We the People” to “We the Nation”’ in Tóth Gábor Attila (ed) Constitution for a Disunited Nation. On Hungary’s 2011 Fundamental Law CEU Press Budapest-New York.

  • Küpper Herbert 2004 ‘Hungary’s Controversial Law’ in Kántor Zoltán Majtényi Balázs Ieda Osamu Vizi Balázs and Halász Iván (eds) The Hungarian Status Law: Nation Building and/or Minority Protection Slavic Research Center Hokkaido University Sapporo Budapest 313-327.

  • Kymlicka Will 2007 Multicultural Odysseys. Navigating the New International Politics of Diversity Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • Mikola István 2006 ‘Nemcsak négy hanem húsz évre kell nyernünk’ in hvg.hu available at http://m.hvg.hu/app//valasztas2006/20060319mikola.

  • Nagel Thomas 2005 ‘The Problem of Global Justice’ in Philosophy & Public Affairs 33 (2): 113-147.

  • Pogonyi Szabolcs Kovács M. Mária Körtvélyesi Zsolt 2010 ‘The Politics of External Kin-State Citizenship in East Central Europe’ Comparative Report RSCAS/EUDO-CIT-Comp. 2010/6 European University Institute Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies EUDO Citizenship Observatory (Florence October 2010) http://eudo-citizenship.eu/docs/ECEcompreport.pdf.

  • Rawls John 1993 ‘The Law of Peoples’ in Critical Inquiry 20 (Autumn 1993): 36-68.

  • Shachar Ayelet 2012 ‘Citizenship’ in Rosenfeld Michel and Sajó András (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law Oxford University Press Oxford 1002-1019.

  • Shevel Oxana Kusá Dagmar Barbulescu Roxana 2010 ‘EUDO Citizenship Reactions in Ukraine Slovakia Romania Serbia to Hungary’s Decision to Give Access to Citizenship to Ethnic Hungarians’ May 23 2010 http://eudo-citizenship.eu/citizenship-news/306-hungarian-government-proposes-access-tocitizenship-for-ethnic-hungarians-in-neighbouring-countries.

  • Stone Geoffrey R. Seidman Louis M. Sunstein Cass R. and Tushnet Mark V. 1996 Constitutional Law Aspen Publishers.

  • Tóth Judit and Kovács M. Mária 2013 ‘Country Report: Hungary’ EUDO Citizenship Observatory 2009 revised and updated April 2013 http://eudocitizenship.eu/admin/?p=file&appl=countryProfiles&f=2013-18-Hungary.pdf.

  • Tóth Judit and Kovács M. Mária 2007 ‘Hungary: Kin-state Responsibility and Ethnic Citizenship: The Hungarian Case’ in Bauböck Rainer Perchinig Bernhard and Sievers Wiebke (eds) Citizenship Policies in the New Europe Amsterdam University Press 135-158.

  • Vink Maarten P. and de Groot Gerard-René 2010 Birthright Citizenship: Trends and Regulations in Europe EUDO Citizenship Observatory.

  • Waterbury Myra A. 2010 Between State and Nation. Diaspora Politics and Kin-state Nationalism in Hungary Palgrave Macmillan New York.

  • Bolzano Recommendations 2008 Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe High Commissioner on National Minorities The Bolzano/Bozen Recommendations on National Minorities in Inter-State Relations & Explanatory Note June 2008 http://www.osce.org/hcnm/33633.

  • Convention On Certain Questions Relating to the Conflict of Nationality Laws The Hague 12 April 1930.

  • European Convention on Nationality Council of Europe No. 166 Strasbourg 6 November 1997.

  • Venice Commission 2002 European Commission for Democracy Through Law The Protection of National Minorities by their Kin-State Report no. CDL-STD(2002)032 adopted in Athens 7-8 June 2002 http://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-STD%282002%29032-bil.

  • Case law

  • ICJ Nottebohm (Liechtenstein v. Guatemala) No. 18 General List (1955)

  • ECHR. D.H. and Others v. the Czech Republic [GC] no. 57325/00 2007

  • ECHR. Kurić and Others v. Slovenia [GC] no. 26828/06 2012

  • ECHR. Oršuš and Others v. Croatia [GC] no. 15766/03 2010

  • ECHR. Sejdić and Finci v. Bosnia and Herzegovina [GC] no. 27996/06 34836/06 2009

  • ECHR. Ünal Tekeli v. Turkey no. 29865/96 2004-X

  • Legislation

  • Act No. 21/1991 on Romanian Nationality as republished with amendments on 10 February 2010

  • Act LV of 1993 on Hungarian Nationality as amended by Act XLIV of 2010

  • Act LXII of 2001 on Hungarians Living in Neighbouring Countries

  • Act XLV of 2010 on the Testimony for National Cohesion

  • Act CCIII of 2011 on the Elections of Members of Parliament

  • Act XXXVI of 2013 on Electoral Procedure

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Target audience: researchers, academics, practitioners interested in the field of political, economic and legal issues in federal states, regional organizations, and international organizations at global level
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 245 71 1
PDF Downloads 138 57 1