A ‘second youth’ for the EU Speakers’ Conference? A critical appraisal of its ‘quasi-constitutional’ role

Open access

Abstract

The EU Speakers’ Conference has experienced a ‘second youth’ after the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon by playing a ‘quasi-constitutional’ role in inter-parliamentary cooperation, and in particular by trying to exercise a rule-making function over the many inter-parliamentary venues of the EU’s system of government. The fulfilment of such a function has certainly not been made any easier as a consequence of the constitutional constraints surrounding the positions of the Speakers and Presidents of the European and Member States’ (MS) Parliaments, with a considerable variety in terms of powers and decision-making capacity among the MS and the EU. Despite these limitations, the ‘quasi-constitutional’ role of the EU Speakers’ Conference has mainly consisted of approving guidelines, if not directly rules of procedure, for other inter-parliamentary venues. It has also been argued that the coordinating function of the EU Speakers’ Conference can be much more effective when looking at its ‘quasi-constitutional’ role, and also in its function of joint parliamentary scrutiny in the EU, if it is aimed at enhancing the rational organisation of inter-parliamentary activities in terms of timing, agendas and ex-post supervision of the results, in the absence of any other possible alternative to the Speakers’ leadership.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • • Avril Pierre Gicquel Jean and Gicquel Jean-Eric 2014 Droit parlementaire 5th edition Montchrestien Paris.

  • • Baraggia Antonia 2016 ‘Bicameralism and Interparliamentary Cooperation’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 93-111.

  • • Bellamy Richard and Kröger Sandra 2016 ‘The politicization of European integration: National Parliaments and the democratic disconnect’ Comparative European Politics XIV(2): 125-130.

  • • Cannizzaro Enzo 2009 ‘Il ruolo dei Parlamenti nazionali nel processo di integrazione europea: in margine ad uno scritto inedito di Leopoldo Elia’ Il diritto dell’Unione europea XIV(2): 457-464.

  • • Cooper Ian 2014 ‘Parliamentary oversight of the EU after the crisis: on the creation of the «Article 13» interparliamentary Conference’ LUISS SOG Working Papers 21/2014.

  • • Cooper Ian 2016 ‘The Interparliamentary Conference on Stability Economic Coordination and Governance in the European Union (the “Article 13 Conference”)’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 247-267.

  • • Cooper Ian 2017 ‘The Emerging Order of Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Post-Lisbon EU in Jancic Davor (ed) National Parliaments after the Lisbon Treaty and the Euro Crisis. Resilience or Resignation? Oxford University Press Oxford 227-246.

  • • Costa Olivier 2013 ‘The President of the European Parliament’ in Lippolis Vincenzo and Lupo Nicola (eds) Le trasformazioni del ruolo dei Presidenti delle Camere Jovene Napoli 143-162.

  • • Curtin Deirdre 2014 ‘Challenging Executive Dominance in European Democracy’ Modern Law Review LXXVII(1): 1-32.

  • • Cygan Adam 2016 ‘COSAC: Birth Evolution Failures and Perspectives’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 207-226.

  • • Elia Leopoldo 1975 ‘Relazione di sintesi sul tema: contributo delle assemblee parlamentari nazionali alla presa di coscienza europea ed alla costruzione comunitaria’ on the occasion of the Conference of the Speakers of the European parliamentary assemblies held in Rome Palazzo Montecitorio on 26-27 September 1975; now in 2009 Il diritto dell’Unione europea XIV(2): 465-477.

  • • Eppler Annegret and Maurer Andreas 2017 ‘Parliamentary scrutiny as a function of interparliamentary cooperation among subnational parliaments’ The Journal of Legislative Studies XXIII(2): 238-259.

  • • Esposito Antonio 2014 ‘La cooperazione interparlamentare: principi strumenti e prospettive’ in Lupo Nicola and Manzella Andrea (eds) Il sistema parlamentare euro-nazionale. Lezioni Giappichelli Torino 133-182.

  • • Fasone Cristina 2009 ‘I Parlamenti degli Stati membri dell’Unione europea nel decision-making comunitario’ in Decaro Carmela and Lupo Nicola (eds) Il ‘dialogo’ tra parlamenti: obiettivi e risultati LUP Roma 159-244.

  • • Fasone Cristina 2016 ‘Ruling the (Dis-)Oder of Interparliamentary Cooperation? The EU Speakers’ Conference’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 269-289.

  • • Fasone Cristina and Lupo Nicola 2016 ‘Conclusion. Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Framework of a Euro-national Parliamentary System’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 345-360.

  • • Fromage Diane 2016 ‘Increasing Inter-Parliamentary Cooperation in the European Union: Current Trends and Challenges’ European Public Law XXII(4): 749-772.

  • • Fromage Diane 2017 ‘The New Joint Parliamentary Scrutiny Group for Europol: Old Wine in New Bottles?’ BlogActiv EU 17 June http://eutarn.blogactiv.eu/2017/06/17/the-new-joint-parliamentary-scrutiny-group-for-europol-old-wine-in-new-bottles/.

  • • Gianfrancesco Eduardo Lupo Nicola and Rivosecchi Guido (eds) 2014 I Presidenti di Assemblea parlamentare. Un ruolo in trasformazione Il Mulino Bologna.

  • • Gianniti Luigi and Lupo Nicola 2016 ‘The Role of the European Parliament President in Parliamentary Diplomacy’ The Hague Journal of Diplomacy XI(2-3): 144-160.

  • • Griglio Elena 2016 ‘I Parlamenti dell’Unione europea alla prova di Europol: verso un esercizio “collettivo” del controllo parlamentare?’ Quaderni costituzionali XXXVI(3) 584-587.

  • • Griglio Elena and Lupo Nicola 2018 ‘The conference on stability economic coordination and governance: filling the gaps of parliamentary oversight in the EU’ Journal of European Integration XL(3): 358-373.

  • • Hefftler Claudia and Gattermann Katjana 2015 ‘Interparliamentary Cooperation in the European Union: Patterns Problems and Potential’ in Hefflter Claudia Neuhold Christine Rozenberg Olivier and Smith Julie (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of National Parliaments and the European Union Palgrave Basingstoke 94-115.

  • • Iacometti Miryam 2001 I Presidenti di assemblea parlamentare Giuffrè Milano.

  • • Ibrido Renato 2015 L’interpretazione del diritto parlamentare. Politica e diritto nel ‘processo’ di risoluzione dei casi regolamentari Franco Angeli Milano.

  • • Kommers Donald P. and Miller Russell A. 2012 The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany 3rd edn. Duke University Press Durham and London.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin 2015 ‘Inter-Parliamentary Cooperation and its Challenges: The Case of Economic and Financial Governance’ in Fabbrini Federico Hirsch Ballin Ernst and Somsen Han (eds) What Form of Government for the European Union and the Eurozone? Hart Publishing Oxford 271-288.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin 2017 ‘A Watchdog for Europe’s Policemen: The new Joint Parliamentary Scrutiny Group for Europol’ Policy Paper no. 197 Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin 2018 ‘The contribution of the SECG Conference’ Perspectives on Federalism – Griglio Elena and Stavridis Stelios (eds) Special Issue on Joint Parliamentary Scrutiny in the EU: The Contribution of Interparliamentary Cooperation.

  • • Leruth Benjamin Gänzle Stefan and Trondal Jarle 2017 ‘Differentiated integration and disintegration in the European Union: State-of-the-art and ways for future research’ ISL Working Paper University of Agder 1/2017.

  • • Lindseth Peter 2010 Power and Legitimacy. Reconciling Europe and the Nation-State Oxford University Press New York.

  • • Longo Fabio 2014 ‘I Presidenti di Assemblea e la politica estera: fra rappresentanza istituzionale e attivismo internazionale’ in Gianfrancesco Eduardo Lupo Nicola and Rivosecchi Guido (eds) I presidenti di assemblea parlamentare: riflessioni su un ruolo in trasformazione Il Mulino Bologna 367-387.

  • • Lupo Nicola 2010 voce ‘ ‘Presidente di Assemblea’ in Bifulco Raffaele Alfonso Celotto and Olivetti Marco (eds) Digesto delle discpline pubblicistiche UTET Torino 444-480.

  • • Manzella Andrea 1997 ‘Il parlamento’ in Amato Giuliano and Barbera Augusto (eds) Manuale di diritto pubblico 5th ed. Il Mulino Bologna 103-168.

  • • Martin Arnaud 1996 Les Présidents des Assemblées parlementaires sous la V Republique Paris LGDJ.

  • • Pinelli Cesare 2016 ‘The Convention Method’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 57-72.

  • • Raube Kolja and Fonk Daan 2018 ‘The contribution of the Conference on CFSP/CSDP’ Perspectives on Federalism – Griglio Elena and Stavridis Stelios (eds) Special Issue on Joint Parliamentary Scrutiny in the EU: The Contribution of Interparliamentary Cooperation.

  • • Romaniello Maria 2015 ‘Upper Chambers in EU Affairs. Scrutinising German and Belgian Bicameralism’ Federalismi.it 12 August available at www.federalismi.it.

  • • Russell Meg and Gover Daniel 2017 Legislation at Westminster: Parliamentary Actors and Influence in the Making of British Law Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • • Stavridis Stelios 2017 ‘Conclusions: Parliamentary Diplomacy as a Global Phenomenon’ in Stavridis Stelios and Jančić Davor (eds) Parliamentary Diplomacy in European and Global Governance Brill Nijhoff Leiden/Boston 368-387.

  • • Torre Alessandro 2000 Il magistrato di assemblea Giappichelli Torino.

  • • Torre Alessandro 2013 ‘Lo Speaker della Camera dei Comuni: evoluzione del ruolo del Presidente d’Assemblea nel Parlamento di Westminster’ in Lippolis Vincenzo and Lupo Nicola (eds) Le trasformazioni del ruolo dei Presidenti delle Camere Jovene Napoli 45-74.

  • • Van Keulen Mendeltje 2016 ‘Reshaping COSAC as a Dynamic Venue for Interparliamentary Exchange’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution Hart Publishing Oxford 335-344.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Target audience: researchers, academics, practitioners interested in the field of political, economic and legal issues in federal states, regional organizations, and international organizations at global level
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 18 18 6
PDF Downloads 10 10 6