From procedural disagreement to joint scrutiny? The Interparliamentary Conference on Stability, Economic Coordination and Governance

Abstract

The provision of Article 13 TSCG to create an Interparliamentary Conference was the starting point for long discussions after which national parliaments and the European Parliament eventually reached a compromise. This article pursues a two-fold objective: It first examines the different phases of interparliamentary negotiations from 2012 to 2015. On the basis of a distinction between three competing models for interparliamentary cooperation, the article shows that the two models of EP-led scrutiny and creating a collective parliamentary counterweight did not prevail: Parliaments agreed that the new Interparliamentary Conference on Stability, Economic Coordination and Governance (SECG) would follow the ‘standard’ interparliamentary conference (COSAC model). In terms of national parliaments’ actual participation, the lowest common denominator compromise has not changed the numbers of participating MPs: Attendance records are stable over time, the size of national delegations continues to vary and participating MPs are still twice as likely to be members of Budget or Finance committees than to be members of European affairs committees.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • • Assemblée nationale, 2012, ‘Rapport d’information sur le projet de loi de ratification du Traité sur la stabilité, la coordination et la gouvernance au sein de l’Union économique et monétaire’, N° 202, Assemblée nationale, Paris.

  • • Bengtson Christina, 2007, ‘Interparliamentary cooperation within Europe’, in O’Brennan John and Raunio Tapio (eds), National Parliaments within the Enlarged European Union, Routledge, London, 46-65.

  • • Benz Arthur, 2011, ‘Linking Multiple Demoi: Inter-parliamentary Relations in the EU’, Hagener Online-Beiträge zu den Europäischen Verfassungswissenschaften, XII(1).

  • • Cooper Ian, 2016, ‘The politicization of interparliamentary relations in the EU: Constructing and contesting the “Article 13 Conference” on economic governance’, Comparative European Politics, XIV(2): 196-214.

  • • Cooper Ian, 2017, ‘The Emerging Order of Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Post-Lisbon EU’, in Jancic Davor (ed), National Parliaments after the Lisbon Treaty and the Euro Crisis, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 227-246.

  • • Costa Olivier and Latek Marta, 2001, ‘Paradoxes and limits of interparliamentary cooperation in the European Union’, Journal of European Integration, XXIII(2): 139-164.

  • • Crum Ben, 2018, ‘Parliamentary accountability in multilevel governance: what role for parliaments in post-crisis EU economic governance?’, Journal of European Public Policy, XXV(2): 268-286.

  • • Crum Ben and Fossum John E., 2009, ‘The Multilevel Parliamentary Field: a framework for theorizing representative democracy in the EU’, European Political Science Review, I(02): 249-271.

  • • Crum Ben and Fossum John E., 2013a, ‘Conclusion: Towards a Democratic Multilevel Parliamentary Field?’, in Crum Ben and Fossum John E. (eds), Practices of inter-parliamentary coordination in international politics the European Union and beyond, ECPR Press, Colchester, 251-268.

  • • Crum Ben and Fossum John E., 2013b, ‘Practices of interparliamentary coordination in international politics: the European Union and beyond’, in Crum Ben and Fossum John E. (eds), Practices of inter-parliamentary coordination in international politics the European Union and beyond, ECPR Press, Colchester, 1-14.

  • • Curtin Deirdre, 2014, ‘Challenging Executive Dominance in European Democracy’, The Modern Law Review, LXXVII(1): 1-32.

  • • Dawson Mark and de Witte Floris, 2013, ‘Constitutional Balance in the EU after the Euro-Crisis’, The Modern Law Review, LXXVI(5): 817-844.

  • • Deubner Christian, 2013, The Difficult Role of Parliaments in the Reformed Governance of the Economic and Monetary Union, Foundation for European Progressive Studies.

  • • Deutscher Bundestag, 2013, ‘Letter by the Head of the German delegation, Nobert Barthle’, http://renginiai.lrs.lt/renginiai/EventDocument/0f6147e3-6125-40b9-93d8-edc7c31e085f/Barthle_Lithuanian%20Presidency_EN_courtesy%20translation.pdf.

  • • Esposito Antonio, 2016, ‘The Role of COSAC in EU Interparliamentary Cooperation: An (Endless) Quest for an Identity’, in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds), Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 325-333.

  • • European Parliament, 2012, Report with recommendations to the Commission on the report of the Presidents of the European Council, the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the Eurogroup ‘Towards a genuine Economic and Monetary Union’.

  • • Fabbrini Sergio, 2013, Intergovermentalism and its Outcomes: the Implications of the Euro Crisis on the European Union, LUISS School of Government.

  • • Fasone Cristina, 2012, The struggle of the European Parliament to participate in the new Economic Governance, RSCAS 2012/45, EUI Working Papers.

  • • Fasone Cristina, 2016, ‘Ruling the (Dis-)order of Interparliamentary Cooperation? The EU Speakers’ Conference’, in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds), Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 269-289.

  • • Fasone Cristina, 2018, ‘Has Euro-crisis law affected the power balance in national parliaments? A comparative analysis on the role of committees’, Politique européenne, LIX(1): 24-57.

  • • Fasone Cristina and Lupo Nicola, 2016, ‘Conclusion. Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Framework of a Euro-national Parliamentary System’, in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds), Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution, Parliamentary Democracy in Europe, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 345-360.

  • • Folketing, 2013, ‘Joint letter of 15 Chairpersons of European Affairs Committees to the Speakers’ Conference, 08/04/2013’, <www.ipex.eu/IPEXL-WEB/dossier/files/download/082dbcc53dbcb6ed013e07d2d31930a6.do>.

  • • Fromage Diane, 2016a, ‘Standing Committees in Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Post-Lisbon Era: Towards the End of the European Affairs Committee’s Predominance?’, in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds), Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 113-130.

  • • Fromage Diane, 2016b, European Economic Governance and Parliamentary Involvement: Some Shortcomings of the Article 13 Conference and a Solution, Les Cahiers européens N°01/2016, Centre d’Etudes européennes de Sciences Po.

  • • Gattermann Katjana, Högenauer Anna-Lena, and Huff Ariella, 2016, ‘Research note: studying a new phase of europeanisation of national parliaments’, European Political Science, XV(1): 89-107.

  • • Griglio Elena and Lupo Nicola, 2018, ‘The Conference on Stability, Economic Coordination and Governance: Filling the Gaps of Parliamentary Oversight in the EU’, Journal of European Integration, XL(3): 358-373.

  • • Hallerberg Mark, Marzinotto Benedicta, and Wolff Guntram B., 2018, ‘Explaining the evolving role of national parliaments under the European Semester’, Journal of European Public Policy, XXV(2): 250-267.

  • • Hefftler Claudia and Gattermann Katjana, 2015, ‘Interparliamentary Cooperation in the European Union: Patterns, Problems and Potential’, in Hefftler Claudia, Neuhold Christine, Rozenberg Olivier, and Smith Julie (eds), The Palgrave Handbook of National Parliaments and the European Union, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 94-115.

  • • Hennette Stéphanie, et al., 2017, Pour un traité de démocratisation de l’Europe, Éditions du Seuil, Paris.

  • • Herranz-Surrallés Anna, 2014, ‘The EU’s Multilevel Parliamentary (Battle)Field: Inter-parliamentary Cooperation and Conflict in Foreign and Security Policy’, West European Politics, XXXVII(5): 957-975.

  • • Hix Simon, 2014, ‘Democratizing a Macroeconomic Union in Europe’, in Cramme Olaf and Hobolt Sara B. (eds), Democratic Politics in a European Union Under Stress, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 180-198.

  • • Jančić Davor, 2016, ‘National Parliaments and EU Fiscal Integration’, European Law Journal, XXII(2): 225-249.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin, 2013, The new Inter-parliamentary Conference on Economic and Financial Governance, Policy Paper n°100, Notre Europe - Jacques Delors Institute.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin, 2014, ‘Possibilities for Upgrading Inter-parliamentary Cooperation after the 2014 European Elections’, Polish Quarterly of International Affairs, XXIII(1): 57-68.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin, 2015, ‘Inter-parliamentary cooperation and its challenges: The case of Economic and Financial Governance’, in Fabbrini Federico, Ballin Ernst Hirsch, and Somsen Hans (eds), What Form of Government for the EU and the Eurozone?, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 271-288.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin, 2016, National parliaments, surveillance mechanisms and ownership in the Euro Area, Studies and Reports n°110, Jacques Delors Institut - Berlin.

  • • Kreilinger Valentin and Larhant Morgan, 2016, Does the Eurozone need a Parliament?, Policy Paper n°176, Jacques Delors Institut - Berlin.

  • • Larhant Morgan, 2005, La coopération interparlementaire dans l’UE. L’heure d’un nouveau départ?, Policy Paper, Notre Europe.

  • • Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina, 2016, Interparliamentary Cooperation in the Composite European Constitution, Hart Publishing, Oxford.

  • • Martucci Francesco, 2017, ‘The Democratic Foundations of the EMU: The European Parliament and the National Parliaments Between Cooperation and Rivalry’, in Daniele Luigi, Simone Pierluigi, and Cisotta Roberto (eds), Democracy in the EMU in the Aftermath of the Crisis, Springer International Publishing, Cham, 27-50.

  • • Neunreither Karlheinz, 1994, ‘The Democratic Deficit of the European Union: Towards Closer Cooperation between the European Parliament and the National Parliaments’, Government and Opposition, XXIX(3): 299-314.

  • • Neunreither Karlheinz, 2005, ‘The European Parliament and National Parliaments: Conflict or cooperation?’, The Journal of Legislative Studies, XI(3-4): 466-489.

  • • Neyer Jürgen, 2014, ‘Justified Multi-level Parliamentarism: Situating National Parliaments in the European Polity’, The Journal of Legislative Studies, XX(1): 125-138.

  • • Raimla E., 2016, Involvement of the National Parliaments in SCPs and NRPs – 2014, 2015 and 2016, European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies, Economic Governance Support Unit.

  • • Raunio Tapio, 2014, ‘Legislatures and Foreign Policy’, in Martin Shane, Saalfeld Thomas, and Strøm Kaare (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Legislative Studies, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 543-566.

  • • Rozenberg Olivier, 2015, La France à la recherche d’un récit européen, Question d’Europe no. 345, Fondation Robert Schuman.

  • • Rozenberg Olivier, 2017, The Role of the National Parliaments after Lisbon: Potentialities and Challenges, Study requested by the AFCO committee, European Parliament.

  • • Rozenberg Olivier and Hefftler Claudia, 2015, ‘Introduction’, in Hefftler Claudia, Neuhold Christine, Rozenberg Olivier, and Smith Julie (eds), The Palgrave Handbook of National Parliaments and the European Union, Palgrave Macmillan, London, 1-39.

  • • Schmidt Vivien A., 2015, ‘Forgotten Democratic Legitimacy: “Governing by the Rules” and “Ruling by the Numbers”‘, in Matthijs Matthias and Blyth Mark (eds), The Future of the Euro, Oxford University Press, New York, 90-115.

  • • Schöne Helmar, 2005, ‘Die teilnehmende Beobachtung als Datenerhebungsmethode in der Politikwissenschaft. Methodologische Reflexion und Werkstattbericht’, Historical Social Research/Historische Sozialforschung: 168-199.

  • • Sénat français, 2013, ‘Compte rendu de la Commission des affaires européennes, 31 janvier 2013’, http://www.senat.fr/compte-rendu-commissions/20130128/europ.html.

  • • Wagner Wolfgang, 2013, ‘Who is Coming? Attendance Patterns in the NATO and WEU Parliamentary Assemblies’, in Crum Ben and Fossum John E. (eds), Practices of inter-parliamentary coordination in international politics the European Union and beyond, ECPR Press, Colchester, 195-212.

  • • Winzen Thomas, 2017, Constitutional Preferences and Parliamentary Reform: Explaining National Parliaments’ Adaptation to European Integration, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • • Winzen Thomas, Roederer-Rynning Christilla, and Schimmelfennig Frank, 2015, ‘Parliamentary co-evolution: national parliamentary reactions to the empowerment of the European Parliament’, Journal of European Public Policy, XXII(1): 75-93.

OPEN ACCESS

Journal + Issues

Search