A comparison of existing forums for interparliamentary cooperation in the EU and some lessons for the future

Open access

Abstract

Interparliamentary conferences and other permanent forums for interparliamentary cooperation are blossoming in the European Union. Following more or less lengthy negotiations between national and European parliamentarians, two new conferences and a new joint parliamentary scrutiny group for Europol have been created since 2012. Against this background, this article examines to what extent the Joint parliament scrutiny group is comparable to the previously existing interparliamentary conferences. Beyond that, it asks the question as to whether any better-defined guidelines or procedures could be adopted to rationalise the process of creation of new forums for interparliamentary cooperation. It makes some concrete proposals in that direction.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • • Buzogány Aron 2013 ‘Learning from the best? Interparliamentary networks and the parliamentary scrutiny of EU decision-making’ in Crum Ben and Fossum John Erik (ed) Practices of interparliamentary coordination in international politics. The European Union and beyond ECPR press Colchester 17-32.

  • • Casalena Pier Giorgio Fasone Cristina and Lupo Nicola 2013 ‘Protocol (No. 1) on the Role of National Parliaments in the European Union’ in Blanke Hermann Josef and Mangiameli Stelio (eds) The Treaty on the European Union (TEU). A commentary Springer Heidelberg 1529-1634.

  • • Cooper Ian 2014 ‘Parliamentary Oversight of the EU after the Crisis: On the Creation of the “Article 13” Interparliamentary Conference’ LUISS Guido Carli School of Government Working Paper No. SOG-WP21/2014.

  • • Cooper Ian 2017 ‘The emerging order of interparliamentary cooperation in the post-Lisbon EU’ in Jančić Davor (ed) National parliaments after the Lisbon Treaty and the Euro crisis. Resilience or resignation? Oxford University Press Oxford 227-246.

  • • Cooper Ian forthcoming ‘The Inter-Parliamentary Conferences of the European Union: Discussion Forums or Oversight Bodies?’ in Raube Kolja Müftüler Bac Meltem and Wouters Jan (eds) Parliamentary Cooperation and Diplomacy in EU External Relations Edward Elgar Cheltenham.

  • • COSAC 2012 ‘Seventeenth Bi-annual Report on Developments in European Union - Procedures and Practices Relevant to Parliamentary Scrutiny’.

  • • Curtin Deirdre 2014 ‘Challenging Executive Dominance in European Democracy’ The Modern Law Review LXXVII(1): 1-32.

  • • Dias Pinheiro Bruno 2016 ‘The role of COSAC in the changing environment of national parliaments in the EU: an identity crisis?’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 303-310.

  • • Dias Pinheiro Bruno 2017 ‘Interparliamentary cooperation between national parliaments’ in Goldoni Marco and Jonsson Cornell Anna (eds) National and regional parliaments in the EU-legislative procedure post-Lisbon Hart Oxford 87-113.

  • • Esposito Antonio 2014 ‘La cooperazione interparlamentare: principi strumenti e prospettive’ in Manzella Andrea and Lupo Nicola (eds) Il sistema parlamentare euro-nazionale Giappichelli Torino 133-182.

  • • Fasone Cristina 2016 ‘Ruling the (dis-)order of interparliamentary cooperation? The EU Speakers’ Conference’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 269-289.

  • • Fasone Cristina 2018 ‘Towards a strengthened coordination between the EU and national budgets. A complementary role and a joint control for parliaments?’ Journal of European Integration XL(3): 265-279. Special issue on ‘National parliaments the European Parliament and the democratic legitimation of the European Union economic governance’ edited by Diane Fromage and Ton van den Brink.

  • • Fromage Diane 2015 ‘Parlamento Europeo y Parlamentos nacionales después del Tratado de Lisboa y en un contexto de crisis: ¿un acercamiento de grado diverso según el ámbito?’ in Andrés Paz and Ugartemendia Juan-Ignacio (eds) El Parlamento europeo: ¿esta vez es diferente? IVAP Guipuzcoa 223-249.

  • • Fromage Diane 2016 ‘Increasing Interparliamentary cooperation in the EU: Current Trends and Challenges’ European Public Law XXII(4): 749-772.

  • • Fromage Diane 2017 ‘Le Traité de Rome: source d’inspiration pour remédier au déficit démocratique européen?’ Percorsi costituzionali: 389-403.

  • • Fromage Diane 2018 ‘The European Parliament in the post-crisis: An institution empowered on paper only?’ Journal of European Integration XL(3) 281-294. Special issue on ‘National parliaments the European Parliament and the democratic legitimation of the European Union economic governance’ edited by Diane Fromage and Ton van den Brink.

  • • Fryda Christiana 2016 ‘The role of the COSAC secretariat within the evolving landscape of interparliamentary cooperation: challenges for the future’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 311-317.

  • • Gattermann Katjana 2014 ‘National parliamentarians and inter-parliamentary cooperation: testing the effect of electoral institutions on their incentives to engage in European affairs’ cited by Hefftler Claudia and Gattermann Katjana 2015 ‘Interparliamentary cooperation in the European Union: Patterns problems and potential’ in Hettler Claudia et al. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook on national parliaments and the European Union Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke 94-115.

  • • Gómez Martos Francisco 2016 ‘Interparliamentary cooperation in the context of COSAC. A view from the European Parliament’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 319-324.

  • • Hefftler Claudia and Gattermann Katjana 2015 ‘Interparliamentary cooperation in the European Union: Patterns problems and potential’ in Hettler Claudia et al. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook on national parliaments and the European Union Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke 94-115.

  • • Huff Ariella 2015 ‘Executive privilege reaffirmed? Parliamentary scrutiny of the CFSP and CSDP’ West European Politics XXXVIII(2): 396-415. Special issue ‘After Lisbon: National parliaments in the European Union’ edited by Katrin Auel and Thomas Christiansen.

  • • Italian Senate 2013 ‘Risoluzione della 2a Commissione permanente sulla proposta di Regolamento del Parlamento europeo e del Consiglio che instituisce l’agenzia dell’Unione europea per la cooperazione giudiziaria penale (Eurojust) (COM(2013)535)’.

  • • Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina 2016 ‘Conclusion’ in Lupo and Fasone (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 269-289.

  • • Maurer Andreas and Wessels Wolfgang 2001 ‘National parliaments after Amsterdam: From slow adapters to national players?’ in Maurer and Wessels (eds) National parliaments on their way to Europe: Losers or latecomers? Nomos Baden-Baden 425-475.

  • • Miklin Eric 2013 ‘Inter-parliamentary cooperation in EU affairs and the Austrian Parliament: Empowering the Opposition?’ Journal of Legislative Studies XIX(1): 22-41.

  • • Neunreither Karlheinz 2005 ‘The European Parliament and National Parliaments: Conflict or cooperation?’ Journal of Legislative Studies XI(3-4): 466-489.

  • • Pinelli Cesare 2016 ‘The Convention Method’ in Lupo Nicola and Fasone Cristina (eds) Interparliamentary cooperation in the composite European constitution Hart Oxford 57-72.

  • • Ruiz de Garibay Daniel 2013 ‘Coordination practices in the parliamentary control of justice and home affairs agencies: the case of Europol’ in Crum Ben and Fossum John Erik (eds) Practices of interparliamentary coordination in international politics. The European Union and beyond ECPR press Colchester 87-103.

  • • Speakers’ Conference 2017 ‘Conclusions of the Presidency’ EU Speakers’ Conference held in Bratislava on 23-24 April 2017. Available at: http://www.ipex.eu/IPEXL-WEB/euspeakers/getspeakers.do?id=082dbcc55898c90b01589abbb37500fa.

  • • Wouters Jan and Raube Kolja 2017 ‘The many facets of parliamentary involvement and interaction in EU external relations. A multilevel tale’ in Jančić Davor (ed) National parliaments after the Lisbon Treaty and the Euro crisis. Resilience or resignation? Oxford University Press Oxford 281-298.

  • • Wouters Jan and Raube Kolja 2018 ‘Between aspirations and realities: Interparliamentary cooperation in the EU’s Common Foreign Security and Defense policies’ Politique européenne no. 59: 170-193. Special issue ‘Les parlements des Etats Membres face au(x) défi(s) européen(s)’ edited by Diane Fromage and Kolja Raube.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Target audience: researchers, academics, practitioners interested in the field of political, economic and legal issues in federal states, regional organizations, and international organizations at global level
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 21 21 8
PDF Downloads 10 10 5