Attempts to change the British House of Lords into a second chamber of the nations and regions: explaining a history af failed reforms

Abstract

The House of Lords is the world’s longest-established and probably best-known second chamber. Wholly unelected, with most members appointed for life, it appears a vestige of the ‘elite’ form of bicameralism once common throughout Europe. Hence calls for major reform are commonplace. However successful changes have been piecemeal and rare. Meanwhile the UK is not federal, but is nonetheless a ‘union state’, comprising the territories of England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, each with its own distinct governing arrangements. These were most recently boosted by the 1997 Labour government’s devolution programme. Hence for decades, and particularly the last 20 years, devolution and Lords reform have both been on the UK’s political agenda. Throughout this time attempts to create a ‘second chamber of the nations and regions’ have repeatedly failed. This paper reviews the proposals made, and the obstacles they faced - drawing lessons for Britain, and territorial bicameralism more widely.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Alliance Party of Northern Ireland (1999), Submission to the Royal Commission on the Reform of the House of Lords, (Belfast: Alliance Party of Northern Ireland).

  • Ballinger Chris, 2012, The House of Lords 1911-2011: A Century of Non-Reform, Hart, Oxford.

  • Bogdanor Vernon, 1997, Power to the People: A Guide to Constitutional Reform, Victor Gollancz, London.

  • Bogdanor Vernon, 1999a, Devolution in the United Kingdom, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • Bogdanor Vernon, 1999b, Evidence to the Royal Commission on the Reform of the House of Lords, University of Oxford , Oxford.

  • Bogdanor Vernon, 2009, The New British Constitution, Hart, Oxford.

  • Bogdanor Vernon, 2010, 'The West Lothian Question', Parliamentary Affairs, LXIII(1): 156-72.

  • Brown Gordon, 2014, My Scotland, Our Britain: A Future Worth Sharing, Simon & Schuster, London.

  • Bryce James, 1918, Report of the Conference on Reform of the Second Chamber - Letter from Viscount Bryce to the Prime Minister (Cd 9038), HMSO, London.

  • Cabinet Office, 1999, Modernising Parliament: Reforming the House of Lords, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Cabinet Office, 2007, The House of Lords: Reform, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Cabinet Office, 2011, House of Lords Reform Draft Bill, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Coakley John, 2014, 'The Strange Revival of Bicameralism', Journal of Legislative Studies, XX(4): 542-72.

  • Cook, R. (2003), The Point of Departure (London: Simon and Schuster).

  • Crowther-Hunt, N. and Peacock, A. T. (1973), The Report of the Royal Commission on the Constitution 1969- 1973 (Volume II): Memorandum of Dissent (London: The Stationery Office).

  • Daintith, T. (1974), 'Kilbrandon: The Ship That Launched a Thousand Faces?', The Modern Law Review, 37(5), 544-55.

  • Department for Constitutional Affairs (2003), Constitutional Reform: Next Steps for the House of Lords, (London: The Stationery Office).

  • Gover Daniel and Kenny Michael, 2016, Finding the Good in EVEL: An Evaluation of "English Votes for English Laws" in the House of Commons, Centre on Constitutional Change, Edinburgh.

  • Hazell Robert (ed), 2006, The English Question, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

  • Joint Committee on House of Lords Reform, 2002, House of Lords Reform (First Report of Session 2002- 03), House of Commons and House of Lords, London.

  • Joint Committee on the Draft House of Lords Reform Bill, 2012, Draft House of Lords Reform Bill (Report of Session 2010-12, Volume I), House of Commons and House of Lords, London.

  • Juberias Carlos Flores, 1999, 'A House in Search of a Role: The Senado of Spain', in Patterson Samuel C. & Mughan Anthony (eds), Senates: Bicameralism in the Contemporary World, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, 260-300.

  • Labour List, 2014, 'Miliband Announces Plans to Scrap the Lords - and Introduce an Elected Senate of Nations and Regions', [https://labourlist.org/2014/10/miliband-announces-plans-to-scrap-the-lords-andintroduce-an-elected-senate-of-nations-and-regions/, accessed 6 April 2018].

  • Labour Party, 1997, New Labour: Because Britain Deserves Better, Labour Party, London.

  • Labour Party, 2001, Ambitions for Britain: Labour's Manifesto 2001, Labour Party, London.

  • Labour Party, 2015, The Labour Party Manifesto 2015, Labour Party, London.

  • Liberal Democrats, 1999, Modernising Parliament, Reforming the House of Lords: The Liberal Democrat Evidence to the Royal Commission, Liberal Democrats, London.

  • Liberal Democrats, 2001, Manifesto: General Election 2001, Liberal Democrats, London.

  • Lodici Claudio, 1999, 'Parliamentary Autonomy: The Italian Senato', in Patterson Samuel C. & Mughan Anthony (eds), Senates: Bicameralism in the Contemporary World, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, 225-259.

  • Loewenberg Gerhard 2011, On Legislatures: The Puzzle of Representation, Paradigm, Boulder.

  • Lord Chancellor's Department, 2001, The House of Lords - Completing the Reform, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Lord Speaker's Committee on the Size of the House, 2017, Report of the Lord Speaker's Committee on the Size of the House, House of Lords, London.

  • Marriott J.A.R., 1910, Second Chambers: An Inductive Study in Political Science, Clarendon, Oxford.

  • McLean Iain, 1999, Modernising Parliament, Reforming the House of Lords: Evidence to the Royal Commission, University of Oxford, Oxford.

  • McLean Iain, Spirling Arthur and Russell Meg, 2003, 'None of the Above: The UK House of Commons Votes on Reforming the House of Lords', The Political Quarterly, LXXIV(3): 298-310.

  • Ministry of Justice, 2008, An Elected Second Chamber: Further Reform of the House of Lords, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Mitchell James, 2009, Devolution in the UK, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

  • Mughan Anthony and Patterson Samuel C., 1999, 'Senates: A Comparative Perspective' in Patterson

  • Samuel C. & Mughan Anthony (eds), Senates: Bicameralism in the Contemporary World, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, 1-31.

  • Owen David, 2016, 'A Federal UK Council', [http://www.lorddavidowen.co.uk/wpcontent/uploads/2016/11/A-federal-UK-Council-2.pdf, accessed 6 April 2018].

  • Patterson Samuel C. and Mughan Anthony, 1999, 'Senates and the Theory of Bicameralism', in Patterson Samuel C. & Mughan Anthony (eds), Senates: Bicameralism in the Contemporary World, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, 333-349.

  • Plaid Cymru, 1999, Reform of the House of Lords: An Initial Response to the Royal Commission's Consultation Paper, Plaid Cymru, Cardiff.

  • Public Administration Select Committee, 2002, The Second Chamber: Continuing the Reform (Fifth Report of Session 2001-02), House of Commons, London.

  • Royal Commission on the Constitution, 1973, The Report of the Royal Commission on the Constitution 1969- 1973 (Volume I), The Stationery Office, London.

  • Royal Commission on the Reform of the House of Lords, 2000, A House for the Future, The Stationery Office, London.

  • Russell Meg, 2000, Reforming the House of Lords: Lessons from Overseas, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • Russell Meg, 2001, 'The Territorial Role of Second Chambers', Journal of Legislative Studies, VII(1), 105-18.

  • Russell Meg, 2013, The Contemporary House of Lords: Westminster Bicameralism Revived, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • Russell Meg and Cornes Richard, 2001, 'The Royal Commission on Reform of the House of Lords: A House for the Future?', Modern Law Review, LXIV(1): 82-99.

  • Russell Meg and Hazell Robert, 2000, Commentary on the Wakeham Report on Reform of the House of Lords, Constitution Unit, London.

  • Russell Meg and Sandford Mark, 2002, 'Why Are Second Chambers So Difficult to Reform?', Journal of Legislative Studies, VIII(3): 79-89.

  • Russell Meg and Sheldon Jack, 2018, Options for an English Parliament, Constitution Unit, London.

  • Sandford Mark, 2013, The Abolition of Regional Government (SN/PC/05842), House of Commons Library, London.

  • Sandford Mark, 2016, Devolution to Local Government in England (Briefing Paper 07029), House of Commons Library, London.

  • Scottish National Party, 1999, Submission to the Royal Commission on the Reform of the House of Lords, Scottish National Party, Edinburgh.

  • Steel David, 2013, 'Scotland and the Lords after 2014', [https://www.libdemvoice.org/david-steelscotland-and-the-lords-after-2014-full-speech-37010.html, accessed 6 April 2018]. · Swenden Wilfried and McEwen Nicola, 2014, 'UK Devolution in the Shadow of Hierarchy Intergovernmental Relations and Party Politics', Comparative European Politics, XII(4/5): 488-509.

  • Tsebelis George and Money Jeannette, 1997, Bicameralism, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

  • Tyler Paul, Clarke Kenneth, Cook Robin, Wright Tony and Young George, 2005, Reforming the House of Lords: Breaking the Deadlock, Constitution Unit, London.

  • Welsh Government, 2017, Brexit and Devolution: Securing Wales' Future, Welsh Government, Cardiff.

OPEN ACCESS

Journal + Issues

Search