The implementation of EU law by national administrations: Executive federalism and the principle of sincere cooperation

Open access

Abstract

This paper explores the similarities between the EU’s system of administrative implementation of its legislative acts, and the German and American systems of administrative implementation of their respective federal laws. The article will also study the connection between the principle of sincere cooperation, established in the EU Treaties, and equivalent principles which exist in federal legal orders, namely the “Bundestreue” principle. The EU system appears to be closer to the German model of federalism than the US. Despite the federal inspiration, one cannot say that the principle of sincere cooperation is a federalising influence on the EU.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • · Bignami Francesca 1999 ‘The Democratic Deficit in European Community Rulemaking: A Call for Notice and Comment in Comitology’ Harvard International Law Journal XL(2): 451-515.

  • · Blanquet Marc 1994 L’article 5 du traité C.E.E: Recherche sur les obligations de fidélité des états membres de la communauté LGDJ Paris.

  • · von Bogdandy Armin 2009 ‘Founding principles’ in von Bogdandy Armin and Bast Jürgen (eds) Principles of European Constitutional Law 2nd ed. Hart Publisher Oxford 11-55

  • · von Bogdandy Armin ‘Art. 10 EGV’ in Grabitz Eberhard Hilf Meinhard and Nettesheim Martin (eds) Das Recht der Europäischen Union C.H. Beck München nº 1-25.

  • · Cassese Sabino 1991 ‘Il sistema amministrativo europeo e la sua evoluzione’ Rivista trimestrale di diritto pubblico XLI(3): 769-774.

  • · Cassese Sabino 1997 ‘Diritto Amministrativo Comunitario e Diritti Amministrativi nazionali’ in Chiti Mario P. and Greco Guido (eds) Trattato di Diritto Amministrativo Europeo Giuffrè Milano 1 ss.

  • · Cassese Sabino 2002 ‘La signoria comunitaria sul diritto amministrativo’ Rivista italiana di diritto pubblico comunitario XII(2-3): 291-301.

  • · Cassese Sabino 2004a ‘European Administrative Proceedings’ Law & Contemporary Problems LXVIII: 21-36.

  • · Cassese Sabino 2004b ‘Il procedimento amministrativo europeo’ in Bignami Francesca and Cassese Sabino (eds) Il Procedimento Amministrativo nel Diritto Europeo Giuffrè Milano 31-52.

  • · Cassese Sabino 2006 La Globalización jurídica Marcial Pons Madrid.

  • · Chiti Mario P. 2011 Diritto amministrativo europeo 4th ed. Guiffrè Milano.

  • · Constantinesco Vlad 1987 ‘L’article 5 CEE de la bonne foi à la loyauté communautaire’ in Capotorti Francesco et al. (eds) Du Droit Internationale au Droit de l’Intégration: Liber Amicorum Pierre Pescatore Nomos Baden-Baden 97-114.

  • · Craig Paul 1997 ‘Directives: Direct Effect Indirect Effect and the Construction of National Legislation’ European Law Review XXII: 519-538.

  • · Craig Paul 2006 EU Administrative Law Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • · D’Atena Antonio 2005 ‘Modelos federales y subsidiariedad en el reparto de las competencias normativas entre Unión Europea y estados miembros’ Revista de Derecho Constitucional Europeo 3: 195-212.

  • · Dann Philipp 2004 Parlamente im Exekutivföderalismus Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

  • · von Danwitz Thomas 2008 Europäisches Verwaltungsrecht Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

  • · De Lucia Luca 2012 ‘Administrative Pluralism Horizontal Cooperation and Transnational Administrative Act’ Review of European Administrative Law V(2): 17-45.

  • · De Witte Bruno 1995 ‘Interpreting the EC Treaty like a Constitution: the role of the European Court of Justice in comparative perspective’ in Bakker R.C.L. et al. (eds) Judicial control: comparative essays on judicial review Maklu Antwerp 133-152.

  • · De Witte Bruno 2000 ‘The role of institutional principles in the judicial development of the European Union legal order’ in Snyder Francis (ed) The Europeanisation of Law - The Legal Effects of European Integration Hart Oxford 83-101.

  • · della Cananea Giacinto 2007 ‘Il diritto amministrativo europeo e i suoi principi fondamentale’ in Chiti Mario P. and Greco Guido (eds) Trattato di diritto amministrativo europeo. Parte generale Giuffrè Milano 1-63.

  • · Estella de Noriega Antonio 2000 ‘La Administración Pública Comunitaria’ in Parejo Alfonso Luis and Pérez Gorostegui E. (eds) Manual de Derecho Comunitario Editorial Universitaria Ramón Areces Madrid 95-144.

  • · Feige Konrad 1973 Der Gleichheitssatz im Recht der EWG Mohr Tübingen.

  • · Franchini Claudio 2004 ‘European principles governing national administrative proceedings’ Law & Contemporary Problems LIVIII: 183-196.

  • · González-Varas Ibáñez Santiago 2012 Tratado de Derecho Administrativo - El Derecho Administrativo Europeo II 2nd ed. Civitas/Thomson Reuters Navarra.

  • · Grodzins Morton 1966 The American System: A New View of the Government of the United States Transaction Publishers New Brunswick and London.

  • · Häberle Peter 1978 ‘Der kooperative Verfassungsstaat’ in Kaulbach Friederich and Krawietz Werner (eds) Festschrift für Helmut Schelsky Duncker & Humblot Berlin 141-177.

  • · Haibach Georg 2000 ‘The History of Comitology’ in Andenas Mads and Türk Alexander (eds) Delegated Legislation and the Role of Committees in the EC Kluwer Law International The Hague 181-216

  • · Hatje Armin 2012 ‘Art. 10 EGV’ in Schwarze Jürgen et al. (eds) EU-Kommentar 3rd ed. Nomos Baden-Baden.

  • · Hildebrandt Achim and Wolf Frieder 2008 ‘Die Potenziale des Bundesländervergleichs’ in Hildebrandt and Wolf (eds) Die Politik der Bundesländer: Staatstätigkeit im Vergleich VS Verlag Wiesbaden 11-21.

  • · Hirschman Albert 1972 Exit Voice And Loyalty Responses to Decline in Firms Organizations and States Harvard University Press Cambridge.

  • · Hofmann Herwig C.H. Rowe Alexander H. and Türk Alexander H. 2011 Administrative Law and Policy of the European Union Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • · Jarass Hans D. 1994 Grundfragen der innerstaatlichen Bedeutung des EG-Rechts C. Heymann Köln.

  • · Kadelbach Stephan 1999 Allgemeines Verwaltungsrecht unter Europäischem Einfluß Mohr Tübingen.

  • · Kadelbach Stephan 2002 ‘European Administrative Law and the Law of a Europeanized Administration’ in Joerges Christian and Dehousse Renaud (eds) Good Governance in Europe’s Integrated Market Oxford University Press Oxford 167-207.

  • · Kahl W. 2002 ‘Art. 10’ in Calliess Christoph and Ruffert Mathias (eds) Kommentar zu EU-Vertrag und EG-Vertrag 2nd ed. Luchterhand Verlag München 365-398.

  • · Keessen Andrea M. European administrative decisions. How the EU regulates products on the internal market Europa Law Publishing Amsterdam

  • · Klamert Marcus 2013 The Principle of Loyalty in EU Law Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • · Koopmans Thijmen 1991 ‘The birth of European Law at the crossroads of legal traditions’ American Journal of Comparative Law XXXIX: 493-507

  • · Lang J. Temple 1986 ‘Article 5 of the EEC Treaty: The Emergence of Constitutional Principles in the Case Law of the Court of Justice’ Fordham International Law Journal X(3): 503-537

  • · Lang J. Temple 2003 ‘Developments Issues and New Remedies - The Duties of National Authorities and Courts under Article 10 of the EC Treaty’ Fordham International Law Journal XXVII(6): 1904-1939.

  • · Lang J. Temple 2007 ‘The Development by the Court of Justice of the Duties of Cooperation of National Authorities and Community Institutions Under Article 10 EC’ Fordham International Law Journal XXXI(5): 1483-1532.

  • · Laufer Heinz and Münch Ursula 1998 Das föderative System der Bundesrepublik Deutschland Vs Verlag Wiesbaden.

  • · Lenaerts Koen and Van Nuffel Piet 2005 Constitutional Law of the European Union Thomson/Sweet & Maxwell London.

  • · Lück Michael 1992 Die Gemeinschaftstreue als allgemeines Rechtsprinzip im Recht der Europäischen Gemeinschaft Nomos Baden-Baden · Maduro Miguel Poiares 2006 A Constituição Plural. Constitucionalismo e União Europeia Principia Lisboa.

  • · Martín Delgado Isaac 2010 ‘Hacia una norma europea de procedimento administrativo’ in Nieto Garrido Eva and Martín Delgado Isaac (eds) Derecho administrativo europeo en el Tratado de Lisboa Marcial Pons Madrid 149-197.

  • · Moreno Molina Álvaro M. 1998 La ejecución administrativa del Derecho Comunitario - Régimen europeo y español Marcial Pons Madrid.

  • · Moreno Molina Álvaro M. 2000 ‘La Administración Pública de los Estados Miembros como Administración Comunitaria: Referencia a la situación Española’ in Parejo Alfonso Luis and Pérez Gorostegui E. (eds) Manual de Derecho Comunitario Editorial Universitaria Ramón Areces Madrid 145-192.

  • · Parejo Alfonso Luis 2000 ‘Los Principios Generales del Derecho Administrativo Comunitario’ in Parejo Alfonso Luis and Pérez Gorostegui E. (eds) Manual de Derecho Comunitario Editorial Universitaria Ramón Areces Madrid 39-92.

  • · Pernice Ingolf 1999 ‘Multilevel Constitutionalism and the Treaty of Amsterdam: European Constitution-Making Revisited’ Common Market Law Review XXXVI: 703-750.

  • · Ruffert Mathias 2001 ‘Der transnationale Verwaltungsakt’ Verwaltung XXXIV: 453-485.

  • · Ruffert Mathias 2011 ‘European Composite Administration: The transnational administrative act’ in Jansen Oswald and Schöndorf-Haubold B. (eds) The European Composite Administration Intersentia Cambridge 277-306.

  • · Schäfer Günther F. 2000 ‘Linking Member States and European Administrations - The Role of Committees and Comitology’ in Andenas Mads and Türk Alexander (eds) Delegated Legislation and the Role of Committees in the EC Kluwer Law International The Hague 9-11.

  • · Schatz Heribert Van Ooyen Robert C. and Werthes Sasha 2000 Wettbewerbsföderalismus. Aufstieg und Fall eines politischen Streitbegriffes Nomos Baden-Baden.

  • · Schmidt-Aßmann Eberhard 1996 ‘Verwaltungskooperation und Verwaltungskooperationsrecht in der Europäischen Gemeinschaft’ Europarecht XXXI: 270-301.

  • · Schmidt-Aßmann Eberhard 2002 ‘Europäische Verwaltung zwischen Kooperation und Hierarchie’ in Cremer Hans-Joachim et al. (eds) Tradition und Weltoffenheit des Rechts: Festschrift für Helmut Steinberger Springer Berlin and Heidelberg 1375.

  • · Schütze Robert 2009 From Dual to Cooperative Federalism - The changing structure of European Law Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • · Schütze Robert 2012 European Constitutional Law Cambridge University Press Cambridge.

  • · Schwarze Jürgen 2009 Droit administratif européen 2nd ed. Bruylant Bruxelles.

  • · Smend Rudolf 1968 ‘Ungeschriebenes Verfassungsrecht im monarchischen Bundesstaat’ in Staatsrechtliche Abhandlungen 2nd ed. Mohr Tübingen 39-69.

  • · Stern Klaus 1984 Das Staatsrecht des Bundesrepublik Deutschland I 2nd ed. Beck München.

  • · Sydow Gernot 2002 ‘Vollzug des europäischen Unionsrechts im Wege der Kooperation nationaler und europäischer Behörden’ Die öffentliche Verwaltung LII(2): 66.

  • · Tribe Lawrence H. 2000 American Constitutional Law I 3rd ed. Foundation Press Eagan.

  • · Verhoeven Maartje 2010 ‘The “Costanzo Obligation” and the Principle of National Institutional Autonomy: Supervision as a Bridge to Close the Gap?’ Review of European Administrative Law III(1): 23-64.

  • · Verhoeven Maartje 2011 The Costanzo Obligation: The Obligations of National Administrative Authorities in the Case of Incompatibility Between National Law and European Law Intersentia Amsterdam.

  • · Volden Craig 2005 ‘Intergovernmental Political Competition in American Federalism’ American Journal of Political Science XLIX(2): 327-348.

  • · Vos Ellen 2000 ‘Reforming the European Commission: What role to play for EU agencies?’ Common Market Law Review XXXVII: 1113-1134.

  • · Weiler J.H.H. 1991 ‘The Transformation of Europe’ The Yale Law Journal C(8): 2403-2483.

  • · Widdershoven Rob 2002 ‘European Administrative Law’ in Seerden René and Stroink F.A.M. (eds) Administrative Law of the European Union its Member States and the United States - A comparative analysis Intersentia Antwerpen 259-306

  • · Zenthöfer Johcen 2006 Wettbewerbsföderalismus: zur Reform des deutschen Bundesstaates nach australischem Vorbild Grasberg Bremen.

  • · Ziller Jacques 2007 ‘Introduction: les concepts d'administration directe d'administration indirecte et de co-administration et les fondements du droit administrative’ in Auby Jean-Bernard and Dutheil de la Rochère Jacqueline (eds) Droit administratif européen Bruylant Bruxelles 235.

  • · Zuleeg Manfred 2011 ‘The advantages of the European Constitution’ in von Bogdandy Armin and Bast Jürgen (eds) Principles of European Constitutional Law 2nd ed. Hart Publisher Oxford 763-786.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Target audience: researchers, academics, practitioners interested in the field of political, economic and legal issues in federal states, regional organizations, and international organizations at global level
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 322 162 8
PDF Downloads 203 137 7