Leading with words? Emotion and style in the language of U.S. President Clinton's public communications
Samples of U. S. President Clinton's public communications were scored with a computer program for the emotional undertones of their words, for the proportional occurrence of negations and very common words, and for the use of first and second person pronouns. The first two measures address emotion, the remaining ones style. Measures successfully discriminated (97% correct classification) formal communications from informal ones and informal communications where the President was physically present with his audience from those where he was not (90%). Classification for two sets of validation samples was very strong (90%). Measures discriminated President Clinton's Executive Orders from President G. W. Bush's. Discriminant functions based on emotional measures alone were almost as successful as those including measures of style (no more than 8% fewer correct classifications). Results are interpreted in terms of theories of persuasive presidential rhetoric.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Bligh M. C. Kohles J. C. & Meindl J. R. (2004a) Charisma under crisis: Presidential leadership rhetoric and media responses before and after the September 11th terrorist attacks. The Leadership Quarterly 15 211-239.
Bligh M. C. Kohles J. C. & Meindl J. R. (2004b) Charting the language of leadership: A methodological investigation of President Bush and the Crisis of 9/11. Journal of Applied Psychology 89 562-574.
Carey J. W. (1993) The mass media and democracy: between the modern and the postmodern. Journal of International Affairs 47 1-21.
Grant S. J. Malaviya P. & Sternthal B. (2004) The influence of negation on product evaluations. Journal of Consumer Research 31 583-591.
Halmari H. (2008) On the language of the Clinton-Dole presidential campaign debates. Journal of Language and Politics 7 247-270.
Harris J. F. (1999) Cooking up the word stew. Washington Post January 19 1999 page A6.
Jacobs L. R. Page B. I. Burns M. McAvoy G. & Ostermeier E. (2003) What presidents talk about: the Nixon case. Presidential Studies Quarterly 33 751-771.
de Landtsheer C. de Vries P. & Vertessen D. (2008) Political impression management: How metaphors sound bites appearance effectiveness and personality traits can win elections. Journal of Political Marketing 7 217-238.
Seyranian V. & Bligh M. C. (2008) Presidential charismatic leadership: exploring the rhetoric of social change. The Leadership Quarterly 19 54-76.
Sigelman L. (2001) The presentation of self in presidential life: Onstage and backstage with Johnson and Nixon. Political Communication 18 1-22.
Sigelman L. (2002) Two Reagans? Genre imperatives ghostwriters and presidential personality profiling. Political Psychology 23 839-851.
Sigelman L. & Whissell C. (2002a) "The great communicator" and "the great talker" on the radio: projecting presidential personas. Presidential Studies Quarterly 32 137-146.
Sigelman L. & Whissell C. (2002b) Projection presidential personas on the radio: An addendum on the Bushes. Presidential Studies Quarterly 32 572-576.
Simons H. W. (2000) A dilemma-centered analysis of Clinton's August 17th apologia: Implications for rhetorical theory and method. Quarterly Journal of Speech 86 438-453.
Teten R. L. (2007) "We the people" The "modern" rhetorical popular address of the presidents during the founding period. Political Research Quarterly 60 669-682.
Whissell C. (1998) A parsimonious technique for the analysis of word-use patterns in English texts and transcripts. Perceptual and Motor Skills 86 595-613.
Whissell C. (2002) The US Declaration of independence: Emotion style and authorship. 49th Parallel 9. (net journal).
Whissell C. (2009) Using the revised Dictionary of Affect in Language to quantify the emotional undertones of samples of natural language. Psychological Reports 105 509-521.
Whissell C. & Sigelman L. (2001) The times and the man as predictors of emotion and style in the inaugural addresses of U. S. presidents. Computers and the Humanities 35 255-272.
Whittington K. E. (1997) The rhetorical presidency presidential authority and President Clinton. Perspectives on Political Science 26 199-207.