Nevşehir Castle Region in Turkey Interpreted by the Use of Seismic Surface Wave and Electrical Resistance Measurements Together

Open access


The underground city beneath the Nevşehir Castle located in the middle of Cappadocia region in Turkey with approximately cone shape is investigated by jointly utilizing the modern geophysical techniques of seismic surface waves and electrical resistivity. The systematic void structure under the Nevşehir Castle of Cappadocia, which is known to have widespread underground cities, is studied by the use of 33 separate two-dimensional profiles ~4-km long where electrical resistivities and seismic surface waves are concurrently measured. Seismic surface wave measurements are inverted to establish the shear-wave velocity distribution while resistivity measurements are inverted to resolve the resistivity distribution. Several high-resistivity anomalies with a depth range 8-20 m point to a systematic void structure beneath the Nevşehir Castle. We were able to effectively isolate the void structure from the embedding structure since the currently employed resistivity instrument has provided us high resolution quality measurements. Associated with the high resistivity anomalies there exist low-velocity depth zones acquired from the surface wave inversions also pointing to a systematic void structure where three-dimensional visualization techniques are used to show the extension of the void structure under the studied area.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] S. Imposa S. Grassi S.D. Raimondo G. Patti G. Lombardo F. Panzera “Seismic refraction tomography surveys as amethod for voids detection: an application to the archaeological park of Cava Ispica Sicily Italy” International Journal of Architectural Heritage pp 1–10 2017. 10.1080/15583058.2017.1419311.

  • [2] A.K. Bharti S.K. Pal P. Priyam V.K. Pathak R. Kumar S.K. Ranjan “Detection of illegal mine voids using electrical resistivity tomography: The case-study of Raniganj coal field (India)” Engineering Geology vol. 213 pp. 120–132 2016.

  • [3] M. van Schoor “Detection of sinkholes using 2D electrical resistivity imaging” Journal of Applied Geophysics vol. 50 pp. 393–399 2002.

  • [4] T. Mochales A.M. Casas E.L. Pueyo O. Pueyo M.T. Román A. Pocoví M.A. Soriano D. Ansón “Detection of underground cavities by combining gravity magnetic and ground penetrating radar surveys: a case study from the Zaragoza area NE Spain. Environ Geol. vol. 53 pp. 1067–1077 2008.

  • [5] D.K. Butler “Microgravimetric and gravity gradient techniques for detection of subsurface cavities” Geophysics vol. 49 pp. 1084–1096 1984.

  • [6] J.L. Davis A.P. Annan “Ground penetrating radar for high resolution mapping of soil and rock stratigraphy” Geophysical Prospecting vol. 37 pp. 531–551 1989.

  • [7] V. Pazzi M. Ceccatelli T. Gracchi E.B. Masi R. Fanti “Assessing subsoil void hazards along a road system using H/V measurements ERTs and IPTs to support local decision makers” Near Surface Geophysics vol. 16 pp. 282–297 2018.

  • [8] M. Himi I. Casado A. Sendros R. Lovera L. Rivero A. Casas “Assessing preferential seepage and monitoring mortar injection through an earthen dam settled over a gypsiferous substrate using combined geophysical methods” Engineering Geology vol. 246 pp. 212–221 2018.

  • [9] N. Darıcı S. Özel “Examination of the structural characteristics arising in gypsums by the GPR and MASW methods (Sivas Turkey)” Natural Hazards vol. 93 pp. 661–676 2018.

  • [10] T. Qin Y. Zhao S. Hu C. An W. Bi S. Ge L. Capineri T. Bohlen “An Interactive Integrated Interpretation of GPR and Rayleigh Wave Data Based on the Genetic Algorithm” Surveys in Geophysics pp. 1–26 2019. 10.1007/s10712-019-09543-x.

  • [11] B. Butchibabu P.K. Khan P.C. Jha “Foundation evaluation of underground metro rail station using geophysical and geotechnical investigations” Engineering Geology vol. 248 pp. 140–154 2019.

  • [12] F. Santos A. Alfonso “Detection and 2D modeling of cavities using pole-dipole array” Environmental Geology vol. 48 pp. 108–116 2005.

  • [13] G. El-Qady M. Hafez M. Abdalla “Imaging subsurface cavities using geoelectric tomography and ground-penetrating radar” Journal of Cave Karst studies vol. 67 pp. 174–181 2005.

  • [14] G. Leucci L. De Giorgi “Integrated geophysical surveys to assess the structural conditions of a karstic cave of archaeological importance” Nat. Hazard Earth Sys. vol. 5 pp. 17–22 2005.

  • [15] P.J. Gibson P. Lyle D.M. George “Application of resistivity and magnetometry geophysical techniques for near-surface investigations in karstic terranes in Ireland” Journal of Cave Karst studies vol. 66 pp. 35–38 2004.

  • [16] Q.Y. Zhou H. Matsui J.N. Shimada “Characterization of the unsaturated zone around a cavity in fractured rocks using electrical resistivity tomography” Journal of Hydrological Research vol. 42 pp. 25–31 2004.

  • [17] E. Cardarelli C. Marrone L. Orlando “Evaluation of tunnel stability using integrated geophysical methods” Journal of Applied Geophysics vol. 52 pp. 93–102 2003.

  • [18] S. Foti S. Parolai D. Albarello M. Picozzi “Application of Surface-Wave Methods for Seismic Site Characterization” Surveys in Geophysics vol. 32 pp. 777–825 2011.

  • [19] Y. Luo J. Xia J. Liu Y. Xu Q. Liu “Research on the middle-of-receiver-spread assumption of the MASW method” Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering vol. 29 pp. 71–79 2009.

  • [20] F. Tallavó G. Cascante M. Pandey “Experimental and numerical analysis of MASW tests for detection of buried timber trestles” Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering vol. 29 pp. 91–102 2009.

  • [21] A. Nasseri-Moghaddama G. Cascante C. Phillips D.J. Hutchinsond “Effects of underground cavities on Rayleigh waves-Field and numerical experiments” Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering vol. 27 pp. 300–313 2007.

  • [22] J. Xia J.E. Nyquist Y. Xu M.J.S. Roth R.D. Miller “Feasibility of detecting near-surface feature with Rayleigh-wave diffraction” Journal of Applied Geophysics vol. 62 pp. 244–253 2007.

  • [23] J.L. Le Pennec A. Temel J.L. Froger S. Sen A. Gourgaud J.L. Bourdier “Stratigraphy and age of the Cappadocia ignimbrites Turkey: reconciling field constraints with paleontologic radiochronologic geochemical and paleomagnetic data” Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research vol. 141 pp. 45–64 2005.

  • [24] A. Temel M.N. Gündoğdu A. Gourgaud J.L. Le Pennec “Ignimbrites of Cappadocia (Central Anatolia Turkey): petrology and geochemistry” Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research vol. 85 pp. 447–471 1998.

  • [25] Ö. Aydan R. Ulusay “Geotechnical and geoenvironmental characteristics of man-made underground structures in Cappadocia Turkey” Engineering Geology vol. 69 pp. 245–272 2003.

  • [26] M.Ö. Mutlu “Geology and Joint Analysis of the Derinkuyu and Kaymakli Underground Cities of Cappadocia Turkey” A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences of Middle East Technical University 2008.

  • [27] M. Korkanç “The Effect of Geomechanical Properties of Ignimbrites on Their Usage as Building Stone: Nevşehir Stone. Jeoloji Mühendisliği Dergisi in Turkish” vol. 31 pp. 49–60 2007.

  • [28] S. Yordkayhun J.N. Suwan “A university-developed seismic source for shallow seismic surveys” Journal of Applied Geophysics vol. 82 pp. 110–118 2012.

  • [29] N. Coşkun Ö. Çakır M. Erduran Y.A. Kutlu A. Yalçın “Preliminary Investigation of Underground Settlements of Nevşehir Castle Region Using 2.5-D Electrical Resistivity Tomography: Cappadocia Turkey” Arabian Journal of Geosciences vol. 9 pp. 717–739 2016.

  • [30] C.B. Park R.D. Miller J. Xia “Multichannel analysis of surface waves” Geophysics vol. 64 pp. 800–808 1999.

  • [31] J. Xia R.D. Miller C.B. Park “Estimation of near-surface shear-wave velocity by inversion of Rayleigh waves” Geophysics vol. 64 pp. 691–700 1999.

  • [32] S. Nazarian K.H. Stokoe II W.R. Hudson “Use of spectral analysis of surface waves method for determination of moduli and thicknesses of pavement systems” Transportation Research Record vol. 930 pp. 38–45 1983.

  • [33] R.B. Herrmann “Computer Programs in Seismology User’s Manual” St. Louis University Misssouri 2002.

  • [34] G.A. McMechan M.J. Yedlin “Analysis of dispersive waves by wave field transformation” Geophysics vol. 46 pp. 869–874 1981.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 115 115 37
PDF Downloads 107 107 30