Enzymes in Tenderization of Meat - The System of Calpains and Other Systems - a Review
Tenderness of meat is considered as the most important feature of meat quality. Three proteolytic systems present in a muscle were examined as those which can play a role in the postmortem proteolysis and tenderization: the system of calpains, lysosomal cathepsins and MCP (multicatalytic proteinase complex). There are several theories (enzymatic or non-enzymatic) explaining the tenderization process. The calpain theory of tenderization was recognized as the most probable. During tenderization the main structures of a cytoskeleton are degraded as well as myofibril and cytoskeletal proteins. Meat becomes soft and the process of tenderization is accompanied by changes in the ultrastructure (degradation of the Z-line and the I-band). Many studies show that the system of calpains (especially calpain I and calpastatin) plays a major role in postmortem proteolysis and meat tenderization. However, recent studies show that proteasomes and caspases may be responsible for this process as well. This paper includes the characterization of calpains as well as describes the construction and functioning of the system of calpains. Additionally, this article presents factors influencing the activity of calpains. It was also mentioned that other systems, such as proteasomes and caspases, may be involved in postmortem tenderization of meat.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Bernard C. Cassar-Malek I. Le Cunff M. Dubroeucq H. Renard G. Hocquette J. F. New indicators of beef sensory quality revealed by expression of specific genes. J. Agr. Food Chem. 2007 55 5229-5237.
Boehm M. L. Kendall T. L. Thompson V. F. Goll D. E. Changes in the calpains and calpastatin during post mortem storage of bovine muscle. J. Anim. Sci. 1998 76 2415-2434.
Boleman S. J. Boleman S. L. Bidner T. D. Mc Millin K. W. Monlezun C. J. Effects of postmortem time of calcium chloride injection on beef tenderness and drip cooking and total loss. Meat Sci. 1995 39 35-41.
Boleman S. J. Boleman S. L. Miller R. K. Taylor J. F. Cross H. R. Wheeler T. L. Koohmaraie M. Shackelford S. D. Miller M. F. West R. L. Johnson D. D. Savell J. W. Consumer evaluation of beef of known categories of tenderness. J. Anim. Sci. 1997 75 1521-1524.
Camou J. P. Mares S. W. Marchello J. A. Vazquez R. Taylor M. Thompson V. F. Goll D. E. Isolation and characterization of μ-calpain m-calpain and calpastatin from postmortem muscle. I. Initial steps. J. Anim. Sci. 2007 85 3400-3414.
Carragher N. O. Frame M. C. Calpain: a role in cell transformation and migration. Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol. 2002 34 1539-1543.
Casas E. White S. N. Wheeler T. L. Shackelford S. D. Koohmaraie M. Riley D. G. Chase C. C. Johnson D. D. Smith T. P. L. Effects of calpastatin and μ-calpain markers in beef cattle on tenderness traits. J. Anim. Sci. 2006 84 520-525.
Chen L. Feng X. C. Lu F. Xu X. L. Zhou G. H. Li Q. Y. Guo X. Y. Effects of camptothecin etoposide and Ca2+ on caspase-3 activity and myofibrillar disruption of chicken during postmortem ageing. Meat Sci. 2011 87 165-174.
Dahlmann B. Ruppert T. Kloetzel P. M. Kuehn L. Subtypes of 20S proteasomes from skeletal muscle. Biochimie 2001 83 295-299.
Destefanis G. Brugiapaglia A. Barge M. T. Dal Molin E. Relationship between beef consumer tenderness perception and Warner-Bratzler shear force. Meat Sci. 2008 78 153-156.
Dransfield E. Wakefield D. K. Parkman I. D. Modelling postmortem tenderisation - I: Texture of electrically stimulated and non-stimulated beef. Meat Sci. 1992a 31 57-73.
Dransfield E. Etherington D. J. Taylor M. A. J. Modelling post-mortem tenderisation - II: Enzyme changes during storage of electrically stimulated and non-stimulated beef. Meat Sci. 1992b 31 75-84.
Dransfield E. Modelling post-mortem tenderisation - III: Role of calpain I in conditioning. Meat Sci. 1992c 31 85-94.
Dransfield E. Optimisation of tenderisation ageing and tenderness. Meat Sci. 1994a 36 105-121.
Dransfield E. Modelling post-mortem tenderisation - V: Inactivation of calpains. Meat Sci. 1994b 37 391-409.
Dransfield E. Meat tenderness-the μ-calpain hypothesis. 1999 in: 45th ICoMST pp. 220-228.
Dutaud D. Aubry L. Sentandreu M. A. Ouali A. Bovine muscle 20S proteasome: I. Simple purification procedure and enzymatic characterization in relation with postmortem conditions. Meat Sci. 2006 74 327-336.
Feldkamp T. J. Schroeder T. C. Lusk J. L. Determining consumer valuation of differentiated beef steak quality attributes. J. Muscle Foods 2005 16 1-15.
Frylinck L. van Wyk G. L. Smith T. P. L. Strydom P. E. van Marle-Köster E. Webb E. C. Koohmaraie M. Smith M. F. Evaluation of biochemical parameters and genetic markers for association with meat tenderness in South African feedlot cattle. Meat Sci. 2009 83 657-665.
Geesink G. H. Koohmaraie M. Postmortem proteolysis and calpain/calpastatin activity in callipyge and normal lamb biceps femoris during extended postmortem storage. J. Anim. Sci. 1999 77 1490-1501.
Geesink G. H. Taylor R. G. Bekhit A. E. D. Bickerstaffe R. Evidence against the non-enzymatic calcium theory of tenderization. Meat Sci. 2001 59 417-422.
Geesink G. H. Taylor R. G. Koohmaraie M. Calpain 3/p94 is not involved in postmortem proteolysis. J. Anim. Sci. 2005 83 1646-1652.
Geesink G. H. Kuchay S. Chishti A. H. Koohmaraie M. μ-Calpain is essential for postmortem proteolysis of muscle proteins. J. Anim. Sci. 2006 84 2834-2840.
Goll D. E. Thompson V. F. Li H. Wei W. Cong J. The calpain system. Physiol. Rev. 2003 83 731-801.
Hanna R. A. Campbell R. L. Davies P. L. Calcium-bound structure of calpain and its mechanism of inhibition by calpastatin. Nature 2008 456 409-412.
Homma N. Ikeuchi Y. Suzuki A. Levels of calpain and calpastatin in meat subjected to high pressure. Meat Sci. 1995 41 251-260.
Hope-Jones M. Strydom P. E. Frylinck L Webb E. C. The efficiency of electrical stimulation to counteract the negative effects of β-agonists on meat tenderness of feedlot cattle. Meat Sci. 2010 86 699-705.
Hopkins D. L. Thompson J. M. Inhibition of protease activity 2. Degradation of myofibrillar proteins myofibril examination of free calcium levels. Meat Sci. 2001 59 199-209.
Houbak M. B. Ertbjerg P. Therkildsen M. In vitro study to evaluate the degradation of bovine muscle proteins post-mortem by proteasome and microcalpain. Meat Sci. 2008 79 77-85.
Huang M. Huang F. Xu X. L. Zhou G. H. Influence of caspase3 selective inhibitor on proteolysis of chicken skeletal muscle proteins during post mortem aging. Food Chem. 2009 115 181-186.
Huff-Lonergan E. Mitsuhashi T. Beekman D. D. Parrish F. C. Olson D. G. Robson R. M. Proteolysis of specific muscle structural proteins by μ-calpain at low pH and temperature is similar to degradation in post mortem bovine muscle. J. Anim. Sci. 1996 74 993-1008.
Hughes M. C. Geary S. Dransfield E. Mc Sweeney P. L. H. O'Neill E. E. Characterization of peptides released from rabbit skeletal muscle troponin-T by μ-calpain under conditions of low temperature and high ionic strength. Meat Sci. 2001 59 61-69.
Hwang I. H. Thompson J. M. The effect of time and type of electrical stimulation on the calpain system and meat tenderness in beef longissimus dorsi muscle. Meat Sci. 2001 58 135-144.
Ilian M. A. Morton J. D. Kent M. P. Le Couteur C. E. Hickford J. Cowley R. Bickerstaffe R. Intermuscular variation in tenderness: Association with the ubiquitous and muscle-specific calpains. J. Anim. Sci. 2001 79 122-132.
Ilian M. A. Bekhit A. E. Bickerstaffe R. The relationship between meat tenderization myofibril fragmentation and autolysis of calpain 3 during post-mortem ageing. Meat Sci. 2004a 66 387-397.
Ilian M. A. Bekhit A. E. Stevenson B. Morton J. D. Isherwood P. Bickerstaffe R. Up- and down- regulation of longissimus tenderness parallels changes in the myofibril-bound calpain 3 protein. Meat Sci. 2004b 67 433-445.
Ilian M. A. Bickerstaffe R. Greaser M. L. Postmortem changes in myofibrillar-bound calpain 3 revealed by immunofluorescence microscopy. Meat Sci. 2004c 66 231-240.
Jakubiec-Puka A. The role of proteolytic calpain system in animal cell. Post. Biochem. 1993 39 251-258 (in Polish).
Jeacocke R. E. The concentrations of free magnesium and free calcium ions both increase in skeletal muscle fibres entering rigor mortis. Meat Sci. 1993 35 27-45.
Kanawa R. Ji J.-R. Takahashi K. Inactivity of μ-calpain throughout post mortem aging of meat. J. Food Sci. 2002 67 635-638.
Kemp C. M. Bardsley R. G. Parr T. Changes in caspase activity during the postmortem conditioning period and its relationship to shear force in porcine longissimus muscle. J. Anim. Sci. 2006 84 2841-2846.
Kemp C. M. Sensky P. L. Bardsley R. G. Buttery P. J. Parr T. Tenderness - An enzymatic view. Meat Sci. 2010 84 248-256.
Kent M. P. Spencer M. J. Koohmaraie M. Postmortem proteolysis is reduced in transgenic mice overexpressing calpastatin. J. Anim. Sci. 2004 82 794-801.
Kołczak T. Influence postmortem factors on beef tenderness. Gosp. Mięsna 2000 5 28-31 (in Polish).
Koohmaraie M. The role of endogenous proteases in meat tenderness. 1988 in: Proceedings of 41st Annual Reciprocal Meat Conference Wyoming USA pp. 89-100.
Koohmaraie M. The role of Ca+2 - dependent proteases (calpains) in post mortem proteolysis and meat tenderness. Biochimie 1992 74 239-245.
Koohmaraie M. Ovine skeletal muscle multicatalytic proteinase complex (proteasome): purification characterization and comparison of its effect on myofibrils with μ-calpain. J. Anim. Sci. 1992b 70 3697-3708.
Koohmaraie M. Muscle proteinases and meat ageing. Meat Sci. 1994 36 93-104.
Koohmaraie M. Biochemical factors regulating the toughening and tenderisation processes of meat. Meat Sci. 1996 43 193-201.
Koohmaraie M. Kent M. P. Shackelford S. D. Veiseth E. Wheeler T. L. Meat tenderness and muscle growth: is there any relationship? Meat Sci. 2002 62 345-352.
Koohmaraie M. Geesink G. H. Contribution of postmortem muscle biochemistry to the delivery of consistent meat quality with particular focus on the calpain system. Meat Sci. 2006 74 34-43.
Korzeniewska-Dyl I. Caspases - structure and function. Pol. Merk. Lek. 2007 138 403-407 (in Polish).
Korzeniowski W. Nowak D. Ostoja H. The role of proteolytic enzymes to improve the meat tenderness. Gosp. Mięsna 1998 8 40-43 (in Polish).
Kumamoto T. Kleese W. C. Cong J. Goll D. E. Pierce P. R. Allen R. E. Localization of the Ca+2 - dependent proteinases and their inhibitor in normal fasted and denervated rat skeletal muscle. Anat. Rec. 1992 232 60-77.
Kurebayashi N. Harkins A. B. Baylor S.M. Use of fura red as an intracellular calcium indicator in frog skeletal muscle fibers. Biophys. J. 1993 64 1934-1960.
Lee S. Polidori P. Kaufman R. G. Kim B. C. Low-voltage electrical stimulation effects on proteolysis and lamb tenderness. J. Food Sci. 2000 65 786-790.
Lusk J. L. Fox J. A. Schroeder T. C. Mintert J. Koohmaraie M. In-store valuation of steak tenderness. Am. J. Agr. Econ. 2001 83 539-550.
Maribo H. Ertbjerg P. Andersson M. Barton-Gade P. Møller A. J. Electrical stimulation of pigs - effect on pH fall meat quality and Cathepsin B+L activity. Meat Sci. 1999 52 179-187.
Meyers S. N. Beever J. E. Investigating the genetic basis of pork tenderness: Genomic analysis of porcine CAST. Anim. Genet. 2008 39 531-543.
Miller M. F. Carr M. F. Ramsey C. B. Crockett K. L. Hoover L. C. Consumer thresholds for establishing the value of beef tenderness. J. Anim. Sci. 2001 79 3062-3068.
Moldoveanu T. Gehring K. Green D. R. Concerted multi-pronged attack by calpastatin to occlude the catalytic cleft of heterodimeric calpains. Nature 2008 456 404-408.
Moudilou E. N. Mouterfi N. Exbrayat J. M. Brun C. Calpains expression during Xenopus laevis development. Tissue Cell 2010 42 275-281.
Morgan J. B. Miller R. K. Mendez F. M. Hale D. S. Savell J. W. Using calcium chloride injection to improve tenderness of beef from mature cows. J. Anim. Sci. 1991 69 4469-4476.
Morton J. D. Bickerstaffe R. Kent M. P. Dransfield E. Keeley G. M. Calpain-calpastatin and toughness in M. Longissimus from electrically stimulated lamb and beef carcasses. Meat Sci. 1999 52 71-79.
Neath K. E. Del Barrio A. N. Lapitan R. M. Herrera J. R. V. Cruz L. C. Fujihara T. Muroya S. Chikuni K. Hirabayashi M. Kanai Y. Protease activity higher in postmortem water buffalo meat than Brahman beef. Meat Sci. 2007 77 389-396.
Northcutt J. K. Pringle T. D. Dickens J. A. Buhr R. J. Young L. L. Effects of age and tissue type on the calpain proteolytic system in turkey skeletal muscle. Poultry Sci. 1998 77 367-372.
Nowak D. Korzeniowski W. Influence modified conditions of ripening on meat tenderness and structural changes in skeletal muscle. Fleischwirtschaft 2004 10 100-103 (in German English abstract).
Nowak D. Methods for improving the tenderness of beef - influence metal ions and temperatures. Fleischwirtschaft 2005 11 109-111 (in German English abstract).
Olsson U. Hertzman C. Tornberg E. The influence of low temperature type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor mortis ageing and tenderness of beef muscles. Meat Sci. 1994 37 115-131.
Ouali A. Hernan Herrera-Mendez C. Coulis G. Becila S. Boudjellal A. Aubry L. Sentandreu M. A. Revisiting the conversion of muscle into meat and the underlying mechanisms. Meat Sci. 2006 74 44-58.
Parr T. Sensky P. L. Scothern G. P. Bardsley R. G. Buttery P. J. Wood J. D. Warkup C. Relationship between skeletal muscle - specific calpain and tenderness of conditioned porcine longissimus muscle. J. Anim. Sci. 1999 77 661-668.
Purslow P. P. Ertbjerg P. Baron C. P. Christensen M. Lawson M. A. Patterns of variation in enzyme activity and cytoskeletal proteolysis in muscle. 2001 in: 47th ICoMST pp. 38-43.
Rees M. P. Trout G. R. W arner R. D. Effect of calcium infusion on tenderness and ageing rate of pork m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum after accelerated boning. Meat Sci. 2002 61 169-179.
Sentandreu M. A. Coulis G. Ouali A. Role of muscle endopeptidases and their inhibitors in meat tenderness. Trends Food Sci. Tech. 2002 13 400-421.
Shackelford S. D. Wheeler T. L. Meade M. K. Reagan J. O. Byrnes B. L. Koohmaraie M. Consumer impressions of Tender Select beef. J. Anim. Sci. 2001 79 2605-2614.
Soares G. J. D. Areas J. A. G. Effect of electrical stimulation on post mortem biochemical characteristics and quality of longissimus dorsi thoracis muscle from buffalo (Bubalus bubalis). Meat Sci. 1995 41 369-379.
Steen D. Claeys E. Uytterhaegen L. De Smet S. Demeyer D. Early post-mortem conditions and the calpain/calpastatin system in relation to tenderness of double-muscled beef. Meat Sci. 1997 45 307-319.
Takahashi K. Structural weakening of skeletal muscle tissue during post-mortem ageing of meat: the non-enzymatic mechanism of meat tenderization. Meat Sci. 1996 43 67-80.
Taylor R. G. Geesing G. H. Thompson V. F. Koohmaraie M. Goll D. E. Is Z-disk degradation responsible for post mortem tenderization? J. Anim. Sci. 1995a 73 1351-1367.
Taylor R. G. Tassy C. Briand M. Robert N. Briand Y. Ouali A. Proteolytic activity of proteasome on myofibrillar structures. Mol. Biol. Rep. 1995b 21 71-73.
Thomson B. C. Dobbie P. M. Singh K. Speck P. A. Post-mortem kinetics of meat tenderness and the components of the calpain system in bull skeletal muscle. Meat Sci. 1996 44 151-157.
Tornberg E. Biophysical aspects of meat tenderness. Meat Sci. 43 1996 175-191.
Veeramuthu G. I. Sams A. R. Post mortem pH myofibrillar fragmentation and calpain activity in Pectoralis from electrically stimulated and muscle tensioned broiler carcasses. Poultry Sci. 1999 78 272-276.
Whipple G. Koohmaraie M. Degradation of myofibril proteins by extractable lysosomal enzymes and m-calpain and the effects of zinc chloride. J. Anim. Sci. 1991 69 4449-4460.
White S. N. Casas E. Wheeler T. L. Shackelford S. D. Koohmaraie M. Riley D. G. Chase C. C. Johnson D. D. Keele J. W. Smith T. P. L. A new single nucleotide polymorphism in CAPN1 extends the current tenderness marker test to include cattle of Bos indicus Bos taurus and crossbred descent. J. Anim. Sci. 2005 83 2001-2008.
Xian-Xing Xu Xue Shui Zhi-Hang Chen Cheng-Qi Shan Yu-Nan Hou Yuan-Guo Cheng Development and application of a real-time PCR method for pharmacokinetic and biodistribution studies of recombinant adenovirus. Mol Biotechnol. 2009 43 130-137.
Zór K. Ortiz R. Saatci E. Bardsley R. Parr T. Csöregi E. Nistor M. Label free capacitive immunosensor for detecting calpastatin - a meat tenderness biomarker. Bioelectrochemistry 2009 76 93-99.