Perceived unfairness in teacher-student conflict situations: students’ point of view

Open access

Abstract

Student perceptions of injustice in the classroom can evoke destructive behavior, resistance, deception, aggression, and conflict escalation. Our study explores student experiences of unjust teacher behavior in educational settings. Students (N=99) were asked to remember a conflict they experienced during their studies. The conflict descriptions (N=78) were analysed and grouped according the type of perceived injustice (distributive, procedural, interactional) and 22 issues of unfair behaviour (Mikula et al., 1990). Our study revealed that perceived unfair grading, power demonstrations, and accusation were the most important predictors of teacher-student conflicts. Moreover students reported they experienced interactional injustice more frequently than they experienced distributive or procedural injustice.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Alm F. Colnerud G. (2015). Teachers‘ Experiences of Unfair Grading. Educational Assessment 20 (2) 132‒150.

  • Barclay L. J. Skarlicki D. P. Pugh S. D. (2005). Exploring the Role of Emotions in Injustice Perceptions and Retaliation. Journal of Applied Psychology 90 (4) 629‒643.

  • Basar M. Durdagi Akan (2013). Assessment of Class Teachers’ Dispute Resolution Applications in Conflict Environments on the Basis of Restorative Justice. International Journal of Academic Research. Part B. 5 (5) 26‒30.

  • Bendrojo ugdymo mokyklų veiklos kokybė. Nacionalinės mokyklų vertinimo agentūros metinis pranešimas. [The quality of operating of general education schools. Annual report of National Agency for School Evaluation]. Vilnius: Nacionalinė mokyklų vertinimo agentūra 2014.

  • Burns T. DiPaola M. F. (2013). A Study of Organizational Justice Organizational Citizenship Behavior and Student Achievement in High Schools. American Secondary Education 42 (1) 4 – 23.

  • Chory-Assad R. M. (2002). Classroom Justice: Perceptions of Fairness as a Predictor of Student Motivation Learning and Aggression. Communication Quarterly 50 (1) 58‒77.

  • Chory R. (2007) Enhancing Student Perceptions of Fairness: The Relationship between Instructor Credibility and Classroom Justice. Communication Education 56 (1) 89‒105.

  • Chory-Assad R. M.. Paulsel M. L. (2004). Classroom Justice: Student Aggression and Resistance as Reactions to Perceived Unfairness. Communication Education 53 (3) 253‒273.

  • Chory-Assad R. Paulsel M. L. (2004 b). Antisocial Classroom Communication: Instructor Influence and Interactional Justice as Predictors of Students Aggression. Communication Quarterly 52 (2) 98‒114.

  • Correia I. Dalbert C. (2007). Belief in a Just World Justice Concerns and Well-Being at Portuguese Schools. European Journal of Psychology of Education 22 (4) 421‒437.

  • Dalbert C. Schneidewind U. Saalbach A. (2007) Justice Judgments Concerning Grading in School. Contemporary Educational Psychology 32 420‒433.

  • Dalbert C. Stoeber J. (2006). The Personal Belief in a Just Word and Domain-Specific Beliefs about Justice at School and in the Family: a Longitudinal Study with Adolescents. International Journal of Behavioral Development 30 (3) 200‒207.

  • Deutsch M. (2014). Justice and Conflict. In P. T. Coleman M. Deutsch & E. C. Marcus (Eds.). The Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass 29‒55.

  • Donat M. Umlauft S. Dalbert C. and Kamble Sh. V. (2012). Belief in a Just World Teacher Justice and Bullying Behavior. Aggressive Behavior 38 185‒193.

  • Houston M. B. Bettencourt L. A. (1999). But That’s Not Fair! An Exploratory Study of Student Perceptions of Instructor Fairness. Journal of Marketing Education 21 (2) 84‒96.

  • Horan S.M. Chory R.M. Goodboy A.K. (2010). Understanding Students’ Classroom Justice Expereinces and Responses. Communication Education 59 (4) 453‒474.

  • Folger R. Cropanzano R. (2001). Fairness Theory: Justice as Accountability. In: J. Greenberg & R. Cropanzano (Eds.). Advances in Organizational Justice. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press 1‒55.

  • Fine-Davis M. Faas. D. (2014). Equality and Diversity in the Classroom: A Comparison of Students’ and Teachers’ Attitudes in Six European Countries. Social Indicators Research 119 (3) 1319 – 1334.

  • Goldman B. Cropanzano R. (2015). “Justice” and “fairness” are not the same thing. Journal of Organizational Behavior 36 313‒318.

  • Gouveia-Pereira M. Vala J. Palmonari A. Rubini M. (2003). School Experience Relational Justice and Ligitimation of Institutional. European Journal of Psychology of Education 18 (3) 309‒325.

  • Horan S. M. Chory R. M. & Goodboy A. K. (2010) Understanding Students’ Classroom Justice Experiences and Responses. Communication Education 59 (4) 453‒474.

  • Israelashvili M. (1997). Situational Determinants of Students’ Feeling of Injustice. Elementary School Guidance & Counseling 31 (4) 283‒293.

  • Mayer B. (2012). The Dynamics of Conflict: a Guide to Engagement and Intervention. San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons.

  • Maiese M. (2013) Principles of Justice and Fairness. (Originally published July 2003 updated by Heidi Burgess June 2013.) http://www.beyondintractability.org/essay/principles-of-justice

  • Mikula G. Schlamberger K. (1985). What People Think about an Unjust Event: Toward a Better Understanding of the Phenomenology of Experiences of Injustice. European Journal of Social Psychology 15 37‒49.

  • Mikula G. Petri B. Tanzer N. (1990). What People Regard as Unjust: Types and Structures of Everyday Experiences of Injustice. European Journal of Social Psychology 20 133‒149.

  • Paulsel M. L. Chory-Assad R. M. (2005). Perceptions of instructor interactional justice as a predictor of student resistance. Communication Research Reports 22 283‒291.

  • Peter F. Dalbert C. (2010). Do my teachers treat me justly? Implications of students’ justice experience for class climate experience. Contemporary Educational Psychology 35 297‒305.

  • Peter F. Dalbert C. Kloeckner Nils Radant Matthias (2013). Personal belief in a just world experience of teacher justice and school distress in different class contexts. European Journal of Psychology of Education 28 (4) 1221‒1235.

  • Rahim A. M. Magner N.R. Shapiro D. L. (2000). Do Justice Perceptions Influence Styles of Handling Conflict with Supervisors? What Justice Perceptions Precisely? The International Journal of Conflict Management 11 (1) 9‒31.

  • Resh N. Sabbagh C. (2014). Sense of Justice in School and Civic Attitudes. Social Psychology of Education 17 51‒72.

  • Sabbagh C. Resh N. Mor M. Vanhuysse P. (2006). Spheres of Justice within Schools: Reflections and Evidence on the Distribution of Educational Goods. Social Psychology of Education 9 97‒118.

  • Santinello M. Vieno A. De Vogli R. (2009). Primary Headache in Italian Early Adolescents: the Role of Perceived Teacher Unfairness. Headache 49 366‒374.

  • Santinello M. Vieno A. De Vogli R. (2011). Bullying in Italian Schools: the Role of Perceived Teacher Unfairness. European Journal of Psychology of Education 26 235‒246.

  • Schmidt T. A. Houston M. B. Bettencourt L. A. and Boughton P. D. (2003). The Impact of Voice and Justification on Students‘ Perceptions of Professors‘ Fairness. Journal of Marketing Education 25 (2) 177‒186.

  • Smith E. Gorard S. (2012). ‘Teachers are Kind to Those Who Have Good Marks’: a Study of Japanese Young People’s Views of Fairness and Equity in School. Compare: A Journal of Comparative & International Education 42 (1) 27‒46.

  • Tata J. (1999). Grade Distributions Grading Procedures and Students‘ Evaluations of Instructors: a Justice Perspective. The Journal of Psychology 133 (3) 263‒271.

  • Thorkildsen T. A. (1989). Justice in the Classroom: The Student‘s View. Child Development 60 323‒334.

  • Tierney R. D. (2014). Fairness as a multifaced quality in classroom assessment. Studies in Educational Evaluation 43 55‒69.

  • Young L. E. Horan S. M. Frisby B.N. (2013). Fair and Square?: An examination of the relationships among classroom justice and relational teaching messages. Communication Education 62 (4) 333‒351.

Search
Journal information
Cited By
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 542 285 17
PDF Downloads 278 202 22