In general, it is agreed that effective leadership requires a certain degree of proximity, either physical or mental, which enables leaders to maintain control over their followers and communicate their vision. Although we agree with the leadership proximity principles which states that leaders are able to efficiently serve only those people with whom they interact frequently, in this article we focus instead on the disadvantages of being too close and the way in which close proximity can actually hurt the effectiveness of leadership. The main effects that we discuss regard the way in which proximity and familiarity allow followers to see the weaknesses and faults of the leader much more easily and thus diminish the leader’s heroic aura, and the emotional bias that results from a leader being too familiar with his followers which will impede the process of rational decision making. As a result, we argue that there exists a functional proximity which allows the leader the necessary space in which to perform effective identity work and to hide the backstage aspects of leadership, while also allowing him an emotional buffer zone which will enable him to maintain the ability to see clearly and make rational decisions.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Allman J.M Hakeem A. and Watson K. (2002) “Two phylogenetic specializations in the human brain” The Neuroscientist 8(4) 335-346.
Allman J.M. Hakeem A. Erwin J.M. Nimchinsky E. and Hof P. (2001) “The anterior cingulate cortex: The evolution of an interface between emotion and cognition” Annals of the New York Academy of Science 935 107-117.
Antonakis J. and Atwater L. (2002) “Leader distance: A review and a proposed theory” Leadership Quarterly 13(6) 673-687.
Ashforth B.E. and Humphrey R.H. (1995) “Emotions in the workplace: a reappraisal” Human Relations 48 97-125.
Avolio B Walumbwa F. and Weber T.J. (2009) “Leadership: current theories research and future directions” Annual Review of Psychology 60 421-449
Barsade S.G. (2002) “The ripple effect: emotional contagion and its influence on group behaviour” Administrative Science Quarterly 47(4) 644-675.
Bass B.M. (1985) Leadership and performance beyond expectations Free Press New York.
Bass B.M. and Bass R. (2008) The Bass handbook of leadership. Theory research & managerial applications Free Press New York.
Bolden R. (2007) “Trends and perspectives in management and leadership development” Business Leadership Review 4(2) 1-13.
Bono J.E. and Ilies R. (2006) “Charisma positive emotions and mood contagion” Leadership Quarterly 17 317–334.
Cicourel A.V. (1958) “The front and back of organizational leadership: A case study” The Pacific Sociological Review 1(2) 54-58.
Do Amaral J.R. and de Oliveira J.M. (n.d.) “Limbic system: The center of emotions” available at: www.healing-arts.org/n-r-limbic.htm (accessed May 2 2017).
Erskine L. and Johnson S.D. (2012) “Effective learning approaches for sustainability: A student perspective” Journal of Education for Business 87(4) 198-205.
Erskine L. (2009) “A question of leadership: What does effective leadership look like in a virtual work environment and can Web-based leadership operate the same way that face-to-face leadership does?”. Leadership in Action 28(6) 12–13.
Erskine L. (2012) “Defining relational distance for today’s leaders” International Journal of Leadership Studies 7(1) 96-113.
Gardner L. and Stough C. (2002) “Examining the relationship between leadership and emotional intelligence in senior level managers” Leadership & Organizational Development Journal 23(2) 68-78.
Gardner W.L. Fischer D. and Hunt J.G. (2009) “Emotional labor and leadership: A threat to authenticity?” The Leadership Quarterly 20 466-482.
Gazzola V. Aziz-Zadeh L. and Keysers C. (2006) “Empathy and the somatotopic auditory mirror system in humans” Current Biology 16 1824-1829.
Goffman E. (1959) The presentation of the self in everyday life Doubleday Anchor. New York.
Goleman D. (2004) “What makes a leader?” Harvard Business Review available at: hbr.org/2004/01/what-makes-a-leader (accessed May 2 2017).
Goleman D. and Boyatzis R. (2008) “Social intelligence and the biology of leadership” Harvard Business Review available at: hbr.org/2008/09/social-intelligence-and-the-biology-of-leadership (accessed May 2 2017).
Hambley L.A. O’Neil T.A. and Kline T.J. (2007) “Virtual team leadership: Perspectives from the field” International Journal of e-Collaboration 3( 1 pp. 40-64.
Heyes C. (2009) “Where do mirror neurons come from?” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 34(4) 575-583.
Howell J.M. and Shamir B. (2005) “The role of followers in the charismatic leadership process: relationships and their consequences” Academic Management Review 30(1) 96–112.
Keysers C. and Gazzola V. (2007) “Integrating simulation and theory of mind: from self to social cognition” Trends in Cognitive Science 11(5) 194-196.
Kim J.H. Kim C.S. and Kim J.M. (2011) “Analysis of the effect of leadership and organizational culture on the organizational effectiveness of radiological technologist’s working environments” Radiography 17 201-206.
Popper M. (2012) Fact and fantasy about leadership Edward Elgar London.
Popper M. (2013) “Leaders perceived as distant and close. Some implications for psychological theory on leadership” The Leadership Quarterly 24 1-8.
Schippers M.B. Roebroeck A. Renken R. Nanetti L. and Keysers C. (2010) “Mapping the information flow from one brain to another during gestural communication” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107(20) 9388-9393.
Shamir B. House R. and Arthur M. (1993) “The motivational effects of charismatic leadership: A self-concept based theory”. Organizational Science 4 577-593.
Tiberius J. (2002) “Genetics and intelligence” available at: http://www.molwick.com/en/intelligence/050-genetics-intelligence.html (accessed May 2 2017).