Trinitarianism In Didache, Barnabas, and the Shepherd: Sketchy, Scant, or Scandalous?

Open access


A survey of works on the development of nascent trinitarianism, especially in the last several decades, reveals that most treatments cut a wide path around three of the earliest Christian writings: Didache, Barnabas, and Shepherd of Hermas. Because these writings straddle the apostolic/post-apostolic eras (c. AD 50-150), they should be regarded as essential links in any historical account of the development of trinitarian theology. Nevertheless, these writings have sometimes been regarded as having sketchy, scant, or scandalous christologies and pneumatologies. This article argues that the typical critical estimations of these writings as nontrinitarian are under-supported by the textual evidence. Rather, Didache, Barnabas, and the Shepherd of Hermas may very well presuppose a basic christocentric and trinitarian creation-redemption narrative. Far from scandalous, these texts provide a positive link in the continuity from seminal apostolic trinitarian thought to the later trinitarian growth of the second century.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anatolios K (2011) Retrieving Nicaea: The Development and Meaning of Trinitarian Doctrine Grand Rapids MI: Baker Academic.

  • Barnard L (1958) The Problem of the Epistle of Barnabas. Church Quarterly Review 159(331): 211-230.

  • Barnard L (1993) The ‘Epistle of Barnabas’ and Its Contemporary Setting. In Haase W (ed) Aufstieg und Niedergang der Römischen Welt Part II Principat volume 27 part 1 Religion (Vorkonstantinische Christentum: Apostolischen Väter und Apologeten). Berlin: De Gruyter pp. 159-207.

  • Beisner C (1984) God in Three Persons. Wheaton IL: Tyndale House. Vätern 7). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.

  • Butin P (2001) The Trinity. Foundations of Christian Faith. Louisville KY: Geneva.

  • Clark GH (1990) The Trinity. 2nd edition. Jefferson MD: Trinity Foundation.

  • Coppedge A (2007) The God Who Is Triune: Revisioning the Christian Doctrine of God. Downers Grove IL: IVP Academic.

  • Cullmann O (1963) The Christology of the New Testament revised edition. London: SCM.

  • Dibelius M (1923) Der Hirt des Hermas (Handbuch zum Neuen Testament; Die Apostolischen Väter 4). Tübingen: Mohr.

  • Draper J (1996) The Jesus Tradition in the Didache. In Draper J (ed) The Didache in Modern Research (Arbeiten zur Geschichte des antiken Judentums und des Urchristentums 37). Leiden: Brill pp. 72-91.

  • Draper J (2007) The Didache. In Foster P (ed) The Writings of the Apostolic Fathers. London: T & T Clark pp. 13-20.

  • Dünzl F (2007) A Brief History of the Doctrine of the Trinity in the Early Church Bowden J (trans). London: T & T Clark.

  • Fairbairn D (2009) Life in the Trinity: An Introduction to Theology with the Help of the Church Fathers. Downers Grove IL: IVP Academic.

  • Fatula M (1990) The Triune God of Christian Faith (Zacchaeus Studies: Theology). Collegeville MN: Michael Glazier.

  • Fortman E (1972) The Triune God: A Historical Study of the Doctrine of the Trinity (Theological Resources). Philadelphia PA: Westminster.

  • Gieschen C (1998) Angelomorphic Christology: Antecedents and Early Evidence (Arbeiten zur Geschichte des antiken Judentums und des Urchristentums 42). Leiden: Brill.

  • Giet S (1963) Hermas et les Pasteurs: Les trois auteurs du Pasteur d’Hermas. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

  • Giles K (2002) The Trinity and Subordinationism: The Doctrine of God and the Contemporary Gender Debate. Downers Grove IL: IVP Academic.

  • Grant RM (1964) An Introduction. In Grant RM (ed) The Apostolic Fathers: A New Translation and Commentary volume 1. New York NY: Nelson.

  • Grant RM (ed) (1967) After the New Testament. Philadelphia PA: Fortress.

  • Grant RM (1990) Jesus after the Gospels: The Christ of the Second Century (The Hale Memorial Lectures of Seabury-Western Theological Seminary). Louisville KY: Westminster/John Knox.

  • Graydon FS (1968) The Shepherd of Hermas. In Grant RM (ed) The Apostolic Fathers: A New Translation and Commentary volume 6. Camden NJ: Nelson.

  • Gunton C (1998) The Triune Creator: A Historical and Systematic Study (Edinburgh Studies in Constructive Theology). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

  • Hanson AT (1989) The Activity of the Pre-existent Christ as Reflected in the Epistle of Barnabas. Studia Patristica 21(3): 155-159.

  • Harnack A (1905) History of Dogma volume 1 Buchanen N (trans). London: Williams & Norgate.

  • Hartog PA (2014) The Nascent ‘Trinitarian’ Worship of Martyrdom of Poly-carp 14 and Ephesians 1. In Anatolios K (ed) The Holy Trinity in the Life of the Church. Grand Rapids MI: Baker Academic pp. 39-54.

  • Hauck RJ (1993) The Great Fast: Christology in the Shepherd of Hermas. Anglican Theological Review 75(2): 187-198.

  • Henne P (1988) À propos de la Christologie du Pasteur d’Hermas: la cohérence interne des niveaux d’explication dans la Cinquième Similitude. Revue des Sciences philosophiques et théologiques 72(4): 569-578.

  • Henne P (1992a) La christologie chez Clément de Rome et dans le Pasteur d’Hermas (Paradosis: Études de littérature et de théologie anciennes). Freiburg: Éditions Universitaires Fribourg Suisse.

  • Henne P (1992b) L’unité du Pasteur d’Hermas: Tradition et redaction. Paris: Gabalda.

  • Hildebrand SM (2011) The Trinity in the Ante-Nicene Fathers. In Emery G and Levering M (eds) The Oxford Handbook of the Trinity. Oxford: Oxford University Press pp. 95-108.

  • Hodgson L (1944) The Doctrine of the Trinity (Croall Lectures). New York NY: Charles Scriber’s Sons.

  • Holmes MW (ed) (2007) The Apostolic Fathers: Greek Texts and English Translations of Their Writings. 3rd edition. Grand Rapids MI: Baker Academic.

  • Holmes S (2012) The Quest for the Trinity: The Doctrine of God in Scripture History and Modernity. Downers Grove IL: IVP Academic.

  • Jeffers J (1990) Pluralism in Early Roman Christianity. Fides et Historia 22(1): 4-17.

  • Jefford C (2006) The Apostolic Fathers and the New Testament. Peabody MA: Hendrickson.

  • Joly R (1993) Le milieu complexe du ‘Pasteur d’Hermas’. In Haase W (ed) Aufstieg und Niedergang der Römischen Welt Part II Principat volume 27 part 1 Religion (Vorkonstantinische Christentum: Apostolischen Väter und Apologeten). Berlin: De Gruyter pp. 524-551.

  • Kirkland A (1992) The Literary History of the Shepherd of Hermas. Second Century 9(2): 87-102.

  • Kraft R (1965) Barnabas and the Didache. In Grant RM (ed) The Apostolic Fathers: A New Translation and Commentary volume 3. Camden NJ: Nelson.

  • Kuruvilla A (2013) Privilege the Text! A Theological Hermeneutic for Preaching. Chicago IL: Moody.

  • LaCugna CM (1991) God for Us: The Trinity and Christian Life. San Francisco CA: HarperCollins.

  • Lebreton J (1923) Histoire du dogme de la Trinité des origines au Concile de Nicée volume 2: De Saint Clément à Saint Irénée. 3rd edition [Bibliothèque de théologie historique]. Paris: Beauchesne.

  • Letham R (2004) The Holy Trinity: In Scripture History Theology and Worship. Phillipsburg NJ: P & R.

  • Loman J (2005) The Letter of Barnabas in Early Second-Century Egypt. In Hilhorst A and van Kooten GH (eds) The Wisdom of Egypt: Jewish Early Christian and Gnostic Essays in Honour of Gerard P. Luttikhuizen (Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity 59). Leiden: Brill pp. 247-265.

  • Longenecker RN (1970) The Christology of Early Jewish Christianity. Grand Rapids MI: Baker.

  • Longenecker RN (1999) Biblical Exegesis in the Apostolic Period. 2nd edition. Grand Rapids MI: Eerdmans.

  • de Margerie B (1975) La Trinité Chrétienne dans L’histoire (Théologie Historique 31). Paris: Beauchesne.

  • Marmion D and van Mieuwenhove R (2011) An Introduction to the Trinity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Mascall EL (1986) The Triune God: An Ecumenical Study. Allison Park PA: Pickwick.

  • McGuckin JA (2011) The Trinity in the Greek Fathers. In Phan P (ed) The Cambridge Companion to the Trinity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press pp. 49-69.

  • Moxnes H (1974) God and His Angel in the Shepherd of Hermas. Studia Theologica 28(1): 49-56.

  • Niederwimmer K (1998) The Didache: A Commentary (Hermeneia). Minneapolis MA: Fortress.

  • O’Collins G (1999) The Tripersonal God: Understanding and Interpreting the Trinity. New York NY: Paulist.

  • O’Hagen AP (1963). Early Christian Exegesis Exemplified from the Epistle of Barnabas. Australian Biblical Review 11(1): 39-40.

  • Ohlig K-H (1999) Ein Gott in drei Personen? Vom Vater Jesu zum ‘Mysterium’ der Trinität. Mainz: Matthias-Grünewald-Verlag.

  • Olson R. and Hall C (2002) The Trinity (Guides to Theology). Grand Rapids MI: Eerdmans.

  • Osiek C (1999) The Shepherd of Hermas: A Commentary (Hermeneia). Minneapolis MN: Fortress.

  • Paget JC (1994) The Epistle of Barnabas: Outlook and Background (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament n. s. 64). Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.

  • Paine L (1900) A Critical History of the Evolution of Trinitarianism and Its Outcome in the New Christology. Boston MA: Houghton Mifflin and Company.

  • Panadrea J (2016) The Earliest Christologies: Five Images of Christ in the Postapostolic Age Downers Grove IL: IVP Academic.

  • Pannenberg W (1991) Systematic Theology volume 1 Bromiley GW (trans). Grand Rapids MI: Eerdmans.

  • Pittenger N (1977) The Divine Trinity. Philadelphia PA: United Church Press.

  • Prigent P (1961) Les Testimonia dans le christianisme primitif: L’épître de Barnabé I-XVI et ses sources (Études bibliques). Paris: Gabalda.

  • Prostmeier F-R (1999) Der Barnabasbrief (Kommentar zu den Apostolischen Vätern 8). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.

  • Stewart-Sykes A (1997) The Christology of Hermas and the Interpretation of the Fifth Similitude. Augustinianum Rome 37(2): 273-284.

  • Svigel MJ (2016) The Center and the Source: Second Century Incarnational Chris-tology and Early Catholic Christianity (Gorgias Studies in Early Christianity and Patristics 66). Piscataway NJ: Gorgias.

  • Verheyden J (2007) The Shepherd of Hermas. In Foster P (ed) The Writings of the Apostolic Fathers. London: T & T Clark pp. 63-71.

  • Vermes G (2014) Christian Beginnings: From Nazareth to Nicaea. New Haven CT: Yale University Press.

  • Wengst K (1984) Didache (Apostellehre) Barnabasbrief Zweiter Klemensbrief Schrift an Diognet: Eingeleitet herausgegeben übertragen und erläutert (Schrift des Urchristentums 2). Munich: Kösel.

  • Wilson J (1995) Five Problems in the Interpretation of the Shepherd of Hermas: Authorship Genre Canonicity Apocalyptic and the Absence of the Name ‘Jesus Christ’ (Biblical Series 34). Lewiston NY: Mellen.

  • Witherington B (1998) The Many Faces of the Christ: The Christologies of the New Testament and Beyond (Companions to the New Testament). New York NY: Crossroad.

Journal information
Impact Factor

CiteScore 2018: 0.18

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.100
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.526

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 236 236 33
PDF Downloads 143 143 15