Are Cooperative Banks Better Equipped to Weather Financial Crisis than their Commercial Counterparts? Evidence from the Italian Banking Sector before and during the Credit Crisis

Mitja Stefancic 1
  • 1 Via Frescobaldi, 31 - 34148 Trieste, Italy

Abstract

Background and Purpose: The aim of this paper is to empirically investigate the performance of different types of Italian banks before and during the recent credit crisis with an emphasis on the behaviour of cooperative banks. It is well established in theory that cooperative banks follow more conservative business strategies and care more for stakeholders in comparison to commercial banks. On this background, the paper tries to show the empirical effects of those characteristics on the cooperative bank’s performance during financial distress compared to commercial banks. In fact, the paper can prove that Italian cooperative banks were less exposed to the shocks of the crisis and showed a better performance.

Methodology: In order to assess whether cooperative banks performed differently at all from commercial banks during the 2005-2012 period, return on average assets (ROAA), cost efficiency and loan quality have been investigated by means of a sample of 594 Italian banks, pooled OLS and (when possible) a fixed effects estimator.

Results: Overall, Italian cooperative banks performed better than other Italian banks during the financial crisis. The quality of loans deteriorated less in these banks than in others, while no significant differences have been observed in terms of ROAA and cost efficiency between these and other banks.

Conclusion: My paper provides empirical evidence for a well established theoretically derived hypothesis: Italian cooperative banks operate differently than standard commercial banks which is especially noticeable during times of crisis. The fact empirically demonstrated that different banking models have shown different reactions to the financial crisis and economic downturn has important policy implications. Due to both characteristics of cooperative banks and severe limitations in the financial policies by the Italian government during the credit crisis an ironical pattern has emerged: While Italian cooperative banks were less exposed to the shocks of the crisis, they would have been less able to adjust to them since the financial rescue program was designed primarily for commercial banks.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Aiello, F., & Bonanno, G. (2013). Profit and cost efficiency in the Italian banking industry (2006-2011). Economics and Business Letters, 2(4), 190−205, http://dx.doi.org/10.17811/ebl.2.4.2013.190-205

  • Angelini, P., & Cetorelli, N. (2003). The Effects of Regulatory Reform on Competition in the Banking Industry. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 35(5), 663−684, http://dx.doi.org/10.17811/ebl.2.4.2013.190-205

  • Bank of England (2009). The Role of Macroprudential Policy. Discussion Paper November 2009.

  • Bank of International Settlements (2010). Principles for Enhancing Corporate Governance. Basel: Bank for International Settlements Communications.

  • Battistin, E., Graziano, C., & Parigi, B. (2006). Connections or Performance: What Determines Turnover of Italian Bankers? WP 05-06-eco Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche. Udine: Università degli Studi di Udine, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.966429

  • Battistin, E., Graziano, C., & Parigi, B. (2012). Connection and performance in bankers’ turnover. European Economic Review, 56(3), 470−487, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.euroecorev.2011.11.006

  • Bonanno, G. (2012). L’efficienza del sistema bancario italiano dal 2006 al 2010. Un’applicazione delle frontiere stocastiche. MPRA WP 46684.

  • Boot, A.W.A. (1999). Relationship Banking: What Do We Know? Journal of Financial Intermediation, 9, 7−25, http://dx.doi.org/10.1006/jfin.2000.0282

  • Boot, A.W.A., & Thakor, A.V. (2000). Can Relationship Banking Survive Competition? Journal of Finance, 55(2), 679−713, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00223

  • Cesarini, F. (2003). Il rapporto banca-impresa. Impresa, risparmio e intermediazione finanziaria: aspetti economici e giuridici, October, Trieste.

  • Chiaramonte, L., Poli, F. & Oriani, M. (2013). Are Cooperative Banks a Lever for Promoting Bank Stability? Evidence from the Recent Financial Crisis in OECD Countries. European Financial Management, 21(3), 491-523, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-036x.2013.12026.x

  • De Bonis, R. (2008). La banca. Rome: Carocci.

  • Dewatripont, M., & Freixas, X. (2012). The Crisis Aftermath: New Regulatory Paradigms. London: CEPR.

  • Di Salvo, R., Lopez, J. S., & Pezzotta, A. (2004). L’evoluzione del relationship banking nei mercati creditizi locali: il ruolo delle Banche di Credito Cooperativo. Cooperazione al Credito, January-June, 81−113.

  • Dietrich, A. & Wanzenried, G. (2009). What determines the profitability of commercial banks? New evidence from Switzerland. IFZ WP. 10/2009.

  • Dietrich, A. & Wanzenried, G. (2011). Determinants of bank profitability before and during the crisis: evidence from Switzerland. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 21(3), 307−327, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.intfin.2010.11.002

  • EACB (2010). European Co-Operative Banks in the Financial and Economic Turmoil: First Assessment. Brussels: EACB Secretariat.

  • Fahlenbrach, R., Prilmeier, R., &. Stulz, R.M. (2012). This Time is the Same: Using Bank Performance in 1998 to Explain Bank Performance during the Recent Financial Crisis. Journal of Finance, 67(6), 2139−2185, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2012.01783.x

  • Ferraresi, M., Nordi, F., & Rizzo, L. (2016). Una soluzione provinciale per le banche di credito cooperativo. Lavoce.info, 26 January 2016.

  • Ferri, G. (2008). Why Cooperative Banks Are Particularly Important in a Time of Credit Crunch (Mimeo). Bari: Università di Bari.

  • Ferri, G., Kalmi, P., & Kerola, E. (2010). Organizational Structure and Performance in European Banks: A Reassessment. Paper presented at the conference “Financial Co-operative Approaches to Local Development Through Sustainable Innovation”,

  • University of Trento, 10-11 June 2010 (Conference Proceedings).

  • Finocchiaro, A. (2007). Il network delle banche di credito cooperativo. Studi economici e sociali, 3, 11−22.

  • Freixas, X. (2009). Monetary Policy in a Systemic Crisis. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 25(4), 630−653, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1503349

  • Gallo, M., Graziano, M., & Venturini, A. (2011). Gli effetti delle operazioni di concentrazione sulla crescita delle piccoli banche locali nel Nord Est. L’Economia del Nord Est (Bank of Italy proceedings), 441−479.

  • Girardone, C., Molyneux, P., & Gardener Edvard, P. M. (2004). Analysing the Determinants of Bank Efficiency: The Case of Italian Banks. Applied Economics, 36, 215−227, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0003684042000175334

  • Goddard, J., Molyneux, P., & Wilson, J.O. (2004). The Profitability of European Banks: A Cross-sectional and Dynamic Panel Analysis. The Manchester School, 72(3), 363−381, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9957.2004.00397.x

  • Groeneveld, H. (2015). European Co-Operative Banking: Actual and Factual Assessment. Tilburg: TIAS.

  • Gutierrez, E. (2008). The Reform of Italian Cooperative Banks: Discussion of Proposals. IMF Working Paper WP/08/84, http://dx.doi.org/10.5089/9781451869361.001

  • Hesse, H., & Cihak, M. (2007). Cooperative Banks and Financial Stability. IMF Working Paper WP/07/2, http://dx.doi.org/10.5089/9781451865660.001

  • Ianotta, G., Nocera, G., & Sironi, A. (2007). Ownership Structure, Risk and Performance in the European Banking Industry. Journal of Banking and Finance, 31(7), 2127−2149, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2006.07.013

  • Il Sole 24 Ore (2015). All you need to know about Italian cooperative banks (BCCs). 10 June 2015.

  • IMF (2013). Italy: Financial System Stability Assessment. IMF Country Report 13/300. Washington: International Monetary Fund, http://dx.doi.org/10.5089/9781484311516.002

  • Karr, J. (2005). Performance Measure in Banking: Beyond ROE. Journal of Performance Management, 18(3), 56−70.

  • Leaven, L. & Levine, R. (2006). Complex Ownership Structures and Corporate Valuations. NBER WP 12675, http://dx.doi.org/10.3386/w12675

  • Leonardi, A. (2009). Il credito cooperativo nella débâcle del sistema bancario italiano. Rivista della Cooperazione, 2, 152−172.

  • Lins, K.V., Volpin, P., & Wagner, H.W. (2013). Does Family Control Matter? International Evidence from the 2008-2009 Financial Crisis. Review of Financial Studies, 26(10), 2583-2619, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1964764

  • Manetti, G., & Bagnoli, L. (2013). Mutual and social efficiency of Italian co-operative banks: an empirical analysis. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 84(3), 289−308, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/apce.12015

  • Mattarocci, G., & Gibilaro, L. (2008). Characteristics of the Recovery Process for Small Financial Intermediaries: The Case of Italian Cooperative Banks. Proceedings of the Academy of Banking Studies, 8(2)

  • Mohsni, S., & Otchere, I. (2015). Financial crisis, liquidity infusion and risk-taking: The case of Canadian banks. Journal of Banking Regulation, 16, 146−167, http://dx.doi.org/10.1057/jbr.2014.2

  • Morgan Stanley Europe (2012). Italian Banks (February 6, 2012). London: Morgan Stanley Research.

  • Oliver Wyman (2014). Cooperative Banking: Leveraging the Cooperative Difference to Adapt to a New Environment. New York: Oliver Wyman.

  • PWC (2011). Basel 3 and Beyond: Systemically Important Financial Institutions. London: PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited.

  • Quagliariello, M. (2008). Does Macroeconomy Affect Bank Stability? Journal of Banking Regulation, 9(2), 102−105, http://dx.doi.org/10.1057/jbr.2008.4

  • Rasmusen, E. (1988). Stock Banks and Mutual Banks. Journal of Law and Economics, 31, 395−422, http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/467162

  • Stefancic, M. (2011). Cooperative Credit Network: Advantages and Challenges in Italian Cooperative Credit Banks. Euricse Working Paper 016/11, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1831078

  • Stefancic, M. (2014). Banke, finančna kriza in razprava o primernejši regulativi. Pravna Praksa, 2 (October 2014), 17−18.

  • Stefancic, M. (2014). Co-operative Banks in Italy. Review of International Co-operation, 6−16.

  • Stefancic, M. (2015). Alcuni spunti sull’abrogazione del voto capitario nelle banche popolari. nelmerito.com. 18 May 2015.

  • The Economist (2015). Not so popolari: Reform of Italy’s biggest cooperative banks will help the sector to consolidate. 23 January 2015.

  • Tidona Comunicazione (2013). Numero di Banche in Italia: 2000-2012. Milano: Tidona Comunicazione.

  • Tumpel−Gugerell, G.. (2005). Regulation, Competition and Integration in EU Banking: What Drives Performance? - Revisiting Freiburg. Freiburg: Faculty of Economics and Behavioural Sciences at the Albert- Ludwigs University.

  • Vallascas, F., & Hagendorff, J. (2013). The Risk Sensitivity of Capital Requirements: Evidence from an International Sample of Large Banks. Review of Finance, 17(6), 1947−1988, http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/rof/rfs042

  • Wintoki, M.B., Link, J.S., & Netter, J.M. (2012). Endogeneity and the dynamics of internal corporate governance. Journal of Financial Economics, 105, 581−606, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2012.03.005

OPEN ACCESS

Journal + Issues

Search