Beer, wine and distilled spirits in Ontario: A comparison of recent policies, regulations and practices

Open access

Beer, wine and distilled spirits in Ontario: A comparison of recent policies, regulations and practices

AIMS-There is a long-standing discussion about whether some beverages are more likely to be linked with high-risk drinking and damage than others, and implications for beverage specific alcohol policies. While the evidence is inconclusive, when controlling for individual consumption, some studies have shown elevated risks by beverage type. This paper examines the situation in Ontario, Canada, from 1995 to present (2011) on several dimensions in order to assess the differences by beverage and their rationale with a specific focus on the most recent policie. METHODS-This paper draws on archival consumption statistics, taxation and pricing arrangements, and retailing and marketing practices. RESULTS-Off-premise sales, which represent an estimated 75% of ethanol, involve several channels: stores controlled by the Liquor Control Board (LCBO)-which sell all spirits, imported and domestic wines, and beer products; the Beer Store network which sell all beers; and Ontario winery stores-which sell Ontario wines. In LCBO stores Ontario wines are more prominently displayed than other beverages, and extensive print advertising tends to feature wine over beer and spirits. There are also differences by beverage in terms of taxation and price. The taxes on higher alcohol content beverage types account for a higher portion of the retail price than taxes on lower alcohol content beverage types. Furthermore, minimum price regulations allow for differential minimum pricing per standard drink [17.05 ml ethanol] across beverage types. CONCLUSIONS-The apparent rationale for these arrangements is not primarily that of favouring lighter-strength beverages in order to reduce harm, but rather to accommodate long-standing vested interests which are primarily financially based.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Advertising Standards Canada (2011): ASC Alcoholic Beverage Advertising Clearance Guide. Retrieved from http://www.adstandards.com/en/clearance/alcoholicBeverages/ASCAlcoholicBeverageAdvertisingClearanceGuide.pdf

  • Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (2002): Liquor Licence Act Regulatory Changes (October 2002). Retrieved from: http://www.agco.on.ca/en/faqs_lla_changes.aspx

  • Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (No date): Alcohol Liquor Licences. Retrieved from http://www.agco.on.ca/en/whatwedo/index.aspx

  • Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario. (July 2007). Information bulletin- No.014: Pricing and promotion of liquor by liquor sales licensees. Retrieved from http://www.agco.on.ca/en/services/bulletins_alcohol_LSL.aspx

  • Black H. & Gill J. & Chick J. (2010): The price of a drink: levels of consumption and price paid per unit of alcohol by Edinburgh's ill drinkers with a comparison of wider alcohol sales in Scotland. Addiction 106 (4): 729-736

  • Canadian Radio-television Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) (1996): Code for broadcast advertising of alcoholic beverages. Retrieved from http://www.crtc.gc.ca/ENG/archive/1996/PB96-108.HTM

  • Chavira C. & Bazargan-Hejazi S. & Lin J. & del Pino H. E. & Bazargan M. (2011): Type of alcohol drink and exposure to violence: an emergency department study. Journal of Community Health 36 (4): 597-604

  • Choi J. K. & Atkinson K. & Karlson E. W. & Willett W. & Curhan G. (2004): Alcohol intake and risk of incident gout in men: a prospective study. The Lancet 363 (9417): 1277-1281

  • Fortin R. B. & Rempel B. (2005): The effectiveness of regulating alcohol advertising: Policies and public health. Toronto ON: The Association to Reduce Alcohol Promotion in Ontario. Retrieved Dec 14 2011 from http://www.apolnet.ca/resources/pubs/rpt_Effectiveness-Dec05.pdf http://www.apolnet.ca/resources/pubs/rpt_Effectiveness-Dec05.pdf

  • Geller E. S. & Kalsher M. J. & Clarke S. W. (1991): Beer versus mixed drink consumption at fraternity parties: a time and place for low-alcohol alternatives. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 52: 197-204. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.qa.proquest.com/docview/617951799?accountid=14771 http://ezproxy.qa.proquest.com/docview/617951799?accountid=14771

  • Giesbrecht N. (2000): Roles of commercial interests in alcohol policies: recent developments in North America. Addiction 95 (12s4): 581-595

  • Giesbrecht N. & Thomas G. (2010): A complex picture. Trends in consumption harm and policy: Canada 1990-2010. Nordic Studies on Alcohol and Drugs 27 (5): 515-538

  • Greenfield T. K. & Rogers J. D. (1999): Alcoholic beverage choice risk perception and self-reported drunk driving: effects of measurement on risk analysis. Addiction 94 (11): 1735-1743

  • Goodwin B. (2010): Minimum pricing of alcohol: Ontario's experience. Presentation at International perspectives on pricing and taxation as techiques to reduce harm from alcohol and promote public health and social responsibility. Toronto Ontario December 8

  • Gruenewald P. & Stockwell T. & Beel A. & Dyskin E. (1999): Beverage sales and drinking and driving: the role of on-premise drinking places. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 60 (1): 47-53

  • Gruenewald P. J. & Jonson F. W. & Millar A. & Mitchell P. B. (2000): Drinking and driving: Explaining beverage-specific risks. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 61: 515-523

  • Gruenewald P. J. & Ponicki W. R. & Holder H. D. & Romelsjö A. (2006): Alcohol prices beverage quality and the demand for alcohol: quality substitutions and price elasticities. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 30 (1): 96-105

  • Han X. & Tongzhang Z. & Foss F.M & Ma S. & Holford T. R. & Boyle P. & Leaderer B. & Zhao P. & Dai M. & Zhang Y. (2010): Alcohol consumption and non-hodgkin lymphoma survival. Journal of Cancer Survivorship 4 (2): 101

  • Harding A. H. & Sargent L. A. & Khaw K.-T. & Welch A. & Oakes S. & Luben R. N. & Bingham S. & Day N. E. & Wareham N.J (2002): Cross-sectional association between total level and type of alcohol consumption and glycosylated haemoglobin level: the EPIC-Norfolk study. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 56: 882-890

  • Hasking P. & Shortell C. & Machalek M. (2005): University students' knowledge of alcoholic drinks and their perception of alcohol-related harm. Journal of Drug Education 35 (2): 95-109

  • Herttua K. & Mäkelä P. & Martikainen P. (in press): The effects of a large reduction in alcohol prices on hospitalizations related to alcohol: a population-based natural experiment. Addiction

  • Hogan E. & Boffa J. & Rosewarne C. & Bell S. & Chee D. H. (2006): What price do we pay to prevent alcohol-related harms in Aboriginal communities? The Alice Springs trial of liquor licensing restrictions. Drug and Alcohol Review 25: 207-212

  • Jensen M. K. & Andersen A. T. & Sørensen T. I. A. & Becker U. & Thorsen T. & Grønbæk M. (2002): Alcoholic beverage preference and risk of becoming a heavy drinker. Epidemiology 13: 127-132

  • Johansen D. & Frils K. & Skovenbaek M. (2006): Food buying habits of people who buy wine or beer: cross-sectional study. British Medical Journal 332: 519-522

  • Liquor Control Act Regulation 116/10 (2010): Minimum pricing of liquor and other pricing matters Liquor Control Board of Ontario (2009-2010): LCBO Annual Report The Pursuit of Excel-lence. http://www.lcbo.com/aboutlcbo/annualreport2009.shtml

  • Liquor Control Board of Ontario (2011a): Ontario Minimum Reference Pricing Attachment 1 and 2 [Data file]. Retrieved from LCBO Sale of Data Program

  • Liquor Control Board of Ontario (2011b): Backgrounder: LCBO support for Ontario wines. LCBO Media Centre. Retrieved from http://www.lcbo.com/lcbo-ear/media_releases/content?content_id=1324

  • Liquor Control Board of Ontario (2011c): Supporting Ontario's wine industry craft brewers. Retrieved from http://www.lcbo.com/aboutlcbo/todayslcbo.shtml#supportingontarios

  • Ludbrook A. (2009): Editorial: Minimum pricing of alcohol. Health Economics 18: 1357-1360

  • Mann R. E. & Flam Zalcman R. & Asbridge M. & Suurvali H. & Giesbrecht N. (2006): Drinking and driving fatalities and consumption of beer wine and spirits. Drug and Alcohol Review 25: 321-325

  • Meier P. & Purshouse R. & Brennan A. (2009): Policy options for alcohol price regulation: The impact of modeling population heterogeneity. Addiction 105: 383-393

  • Michaud D. S. & Vrieling A. & Jiao L. & Mendelsohn J. B. & Steplowski E. & Lynch S. M. & Wactawski-Wende J. & Arslan A. A. & Bas Bueno-de-Mesquita H. & Fuchs C. S. & Gross M. & Helzlsouer K. & Jacobs E. J. & Lacroix A. & Petersen G. & Zheng W. & Allen N. & Ammundadottir L. & Bergmann M. M. & Boffetta P. & Buring J. E. & Canzian F. & Chanock S. J. & Clavel-Chapelon F. & Clipp S. & Freiberg M. S. & Michael Gaziano J. & Giovannucci E. L. & Hankinson S. & Hartge P. & Hoover R. N. & Allan Hubbell F. & Hunter D. J. & Hutchinson A. & Jacobs K. & Kooperberg C. & Kraft P. & Manjer J. & Navarro C. & Peeters P. H. & Shu X. O. & Stevens V. & Thomas G. & Tjønneland A. & Tobias G. S. & Trichopoulos D. & Tumino R. & Vineis P. & Virtamo J. & Wallace R. & Wolpin B. M. & Yu K. & Zeleniuch-Jacquotte A. & Stolzenberg-Solomon R. Z. (2010): Alcohol intake and pancreatic cancer: a pooled analylsis from the pancreatic cancer cohort consortium (PanScan). Cancer Causes Control 21: 1213-1225

  • Minister of Finance Government of Ontario (2009): Ontario's tax plan for jobs and growth. [Released November 16 2009] http://www.fin.gov.on.ca/en/publications/2009/fbbb.html#raf

  • Núñez-Córdoba J. M. & Martinez-González M. A. & Bes-Rastrollo M. & Toledo E. & Beunza J. J. & Alonso Á. (2009): Alcohol consumption and incidente of hipertensión in a mediterranean cohorte: The SUN study. Revista Espanola de Cardiologia 62 (6): 633-641

  • Ogborne A. & Stoduto G. (2006): Changes in federal regulation in broadcast advertisements for alcoholic beverages. In: Giesbrecht N. & Demers A. & Ogborne A. & Room R. & Stoduto G. & Lindquist E. (eds.): Sober Reflections: Commerce Public Health and the Evolution of Alcohol Policy in Canada 1980-2000 pp 237-259. Montreal McGill-Queen's University Press

  • Ontario Craft Brewer's (2011a): February 2011-Lovin' local beers this Valentine's Day; Ontario craft beer sales in LCBO up 52% in 2010: The OCB Media Centre. Retrieved from http://www.ontariocraftbrewers.com/content2.php?nextpage=ocb_press_recipe_valentine_feb11

  • Ontario Craft Brewer's (2011b): April 2011 - MPPs choose latest beers to be highlighted at Ontario's Legislative Assembly. News On Tap: The OCB Media Centre. Retrieved from http://www.ontariocraftbrewers.com/content2.php?nextpage=ocb_press_release_20Apr11_LegislativeBeers

  • Ontario Craft Brewer's (2007): September 2007- Ontario Craft Brewers want to hear from party leaders during the campaign regarding unfairness in beer retailing in Ontario. News On Tap: The OBC Media Centre. Retrieved from http://www.ontariocraftbrewers.com/content2.php?nextpage=ocb_press_release_sep07_leaders

  • Ontario Craft Brewer's (2005): June 2005- $5 Million in Funding from the Government of Ontario to Contribute to The Ontario Craft Brewers' Marketing Campaign and Job Creation. News On Tap: The OBC Media Centre. Retrieved from http://www.ontariocraftbrewers.com/content2.php?nextpage=ocb_press_release_june3

  • Pandeya N. & Williams G. & Green A. C. & Webb P. M. (2009): Alcohol consumption and the risk of Adenocarcinoma and Squamous cell carcinoma of the Esophagus. Gastroenterology 136: 1215-1224

  • Pedersen E. R. & Neighbors C. & Larimer M. E. (2010): Differential alcohol expectances based on type of alcoholic beverage consumed. Journal of Studies on Alcohol & Drugs 71: 9235-929

  • Purhouse R. C. & Meier P. S. & Brennan A. & Taylor K. B. & Rafia R. (2010): Estimating the effect of alcohol pricing policies on health and economic outcomes in England: an epidemiological model. Lancet 375: 1355-1364

  • Rehm J. & Baliunas D. Borges G. L. G. Graham K. Irving H. Kehoe T. Parry C. D. Patra J. Popova S. Poznyak V. Roerecke M. Room R.m Samokhvalov A. V. & Taylor B. (2010): The relation between different dimensions of alcohol consumption and burden of disease: an overview. Addiction 105: 817-843

  • Rimm E. B. & Williams P. & Fosher K. & Criqui M. & Stampfer M. J. (1999): Moderate alcohol intake and lower risk of coronary heart disease: meta-analysis of effects n lipids and haemostatic factors. British Medical Journal 319: 1523-1528

  • Ronksley P. E. & Brien S. E. & Turner B. J. & Mukamal K. J. & Ghali W. A. (2011): Association of alcohol consumption with selected cardiovascular disease outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. British Medical Journal 342 [Feb 22 2011]

  • Room R. & Stoduto G. & Demers A. & Ogborne A. & Giesbrecht N. (2006): Alcohol in the Canadian context. In: Giesbrecht N. & Demers A. & Ogborne A. & Room R. & Stoduto G. & Lindquist E. (eds.): Sober Reflections: Commerce Public Health and the Evolution of Alcohol Policy in Canada 1980-2000. Montreal McGill-Queen's University Press

  • Rossow I. (2001): Alcohol and homicide: a cross-cultural comparison of the relationship in 14 European countries. Addiction 91 (S1): S77-92

  • Segal D. & Stockwell T. (2009): Low Alcohol Alternatives: A Promising Strategy for Reducing Alcohol Related Harm. International Journal of Drug Policy 20 (2): 183-187

  • Sesso H. D. & Paffenbarger Jr. R. S. & Lee I.-M. (2001): Alcohol consumption and risk of prostate cancer: The Harvard Alumni Health Study. International Journal of Epidemiology 30: 749-755

  • Smart R. G. (1996): Behavioral and social consequences related to the consumption of different beverage types. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 57 (1):77-84

  • Smart R. G. & Ognorne A. C. (1996): Northern Spirits: A social history of alcohol in Canada. Second ed. Toronto: Addiction Research Foundation

  • Statistics Canada (2011a). Table 183-0019-Volume of sales of alcoholic beverages in litres of absolute alcohol and per capita 15 years and over fiscal years ended March 31 annual (litres). Accessed February 15 2011

  • Statistics Canada (2011b). Table 051-0001-Estimates of population by age group and sex for July 1 Canada provinces and territories annual (persons unless otherwise noted) (table) CANSIM (database) Using E-STAT (distributor). Accessed February 17 2011

  • Statistics Canada (2011c). Table 326-0021-Consumer Price Index (CPI) 2005 basket annual (2002=100 unless otherwise noted) (table) CANSIM (database) Using E-STAT (distributor)

  • Stickley A. & Razvodovsky Y. (2011): The effects of beverage type on homicide rates in Russia 1970-2005. Drug and Alcohol Review Early View

  • Stockwell T. & Auld M. C. & Zhao J. & Martin G. (in press): Does minimum pricing reduce alcohol consumption? The experience of a Canadian province. Addiction

  • Stockwell T. R. & Crosbie D. (2001): Supply and Demand for Alcohol in Australia: Relationships between Industry Structures Regulation and the Marketplace. International Journal of Drug Policy 12 (2): 139-152

  • Stockwell T. & Leng J. & Sturge J. (2006): Alcohol pricing and public health in Canada: Issues and opportunities. Centre for Addictions Research of BC. February 2006

  • Stockwell T. & Masters L. & Phillips M. & Daly A. & Midford R. & Gahegan M. & Philp A. (1998): Consumption of Different Alcoholic Beverages as Predictors of Local Rates of Assault Road Crash and Hospital Admission. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 22 (2): 237-242

  • Stockwell T. & Zhao J. & Chikritzhs T. & Greenfield T. (2008): What did you drink yesterday? Public health relevance of a recent recall method used in the 2004 Australian National Drug Strategy Household Survey. Addiction 103 (6): 919-928

  • Thomas G. (2011): "Alcohol price policies in Canada". A presentation made at the bi-annual Issues of Substance Conference. November 6-9 2011 Vancouver British Columbia

  • Tjonneland A. & Gronbaek M. & Stripp C. & Overvad K. (1999): Wine intake and diet in a random sample of 48763 Danish men and women. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 69: 49-54

  • Wine Council of Ontario. (2008): Buying Ontario wine makes cents. Retrieved from http://winecountryontario.ca/sites/default/files/pressrelease/kpmgstudy08.pdf

  • Zimmerman P. R. & Benson B. L. (2007): Alcohol and rape: an "economics-of-crime" perspective. International Review of Law and Economics 27 (4): 442-473.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


IMPACT FACTOR 2017: 0.683
5-year IMPACT FACTOR: 0.752


CiteScore 2018: 0.64

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.313
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.456



Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 85 35 0
PDF Downloads 40 27 0