White Danish Love as Affective Intervention:

Open access


Through a close reading of media reporting from 2017 to 2018 on the case of the Chinese girl Liu Yiming, who was first denied then granted residency in Denmark due to public pressure, this article analyses how regulation of family reunification involving children is negotiated in the Danish public imaginary in the context of strong anti-immigration sentiments. This imaginary projects the white Danish public as eager to love Yiming and as affectively invested in reversing the injustice done to her and her family. The article suggests, however, that the outpouring of white love, which functions as an affective intervention imbued with the promises of reversing Yiming’s deportation, is deeply embedded in exceptionalist notions of the ‘integrated’ migrant and that it works to restore an idealised image of a Danish nation defined by ‘human decency’ as a core value. Thus, the analysis raises critical questions to the politics of white love and its promise of securing social change for the ‘integrated’ migrant through collective acts of white feeling.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Adamo S 2016 ‘What is “a successful integration”? family reunification and the rights of children in Denmark’. Retfaerd vol. 152 no. 1 pp. 38-58.

  • Ahmed S 2003 ‘In the name of love’ Borderlands ejournal vol. 2 no. 3 http://www.borderlands.net.au/vol2no3_2003/ahmed_love.htm.

  • Ahmed S 2004a The cultural politics of emotion Edinburgh University Press Edinburgh.

  • Ahmed S 2004b ‘Affective economies’ Social Text. vol. 22 no. 2 pp. 117-139 DOI:10.1215/01642472-22-2_79-117.

  • Ahmed S 2006 Queer phenomenology. orientations objects others Duke University Press Durham and London.

  • Andreassen R 2007 Der er et yndigt land. Medier minoriteter og danskhed Tiderne Skifter København.

  • Berlant L 1997 The queen of America goes to Washington city. Essays on sex and citizenship Duke University Press Durham and London.

  • Bissenbakker M 2019 ‘Attachment required: the affective governmentality of marriage migration in the Danish Aliens Act 2000-2018’ International Political Sociology vol. 13 no. 2 pp. 181-197. DOI:10.1093/ips/olz001.

  • Danbolt M & Myong L 2019 ‘Racial turns and returns: recalibrations of racial exceptionalism in Danish public debates on racism’ in Racialization racism and anti-racism in the Nordic countries ed. P Hervik Palgrave Macmillan London pp. 39-61.

  • D’Aoust AM 2013a ‘In the name of love: marriage migration governmentality and technologies of love’ International Political Sociology vol. 7 pp. 258-274.

  • D’Aoust AM 2013b ‘“Take a Chance on Me”. Premediation technologies of love and marriage migration management’ in Disciplining the transnational mobility of people eds. M Geiger & A Pécoud Palgrave Macmillan Hampshire and New York pp. 103-125.

  • Fair L 2010 ‘“Why can’t I get married?” – Denmark and the Twenty-four year law’ Social & Cultural Geography vol. 11 no 2 pp. 139-153. DOI:10.1080/14649360903514392.

  • Fortier AM 2010 ‘Proximity by design? Affective citizenship and the management of unease’ Cititzenship Studies vol. 14 no. 1 pp. 17-30. DOI:10.1080/13621020903466258.

  • Fortier AM 2013 ‘What’s the big deal? Naturalisation and the politics of desire’ Citizenship Studies vol. 17 no. 6-7 pp. 697-711. DOI:10.1080/13621025.2013.780761.

  • Foucault M 2003 “Society must be defended”. Lectures at the Collège de France 1975-76 Penguin Books London.

  • Frankenberg R 1993 White women race matters. The social construction of whiteness. University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis.

  • Hage G 1998 White nation. Fantasies of white supremacy in a multicultural society Routledge New York and London.

  • Hervik P 2011 The annoying difference. The emergence of Danish neonationalism neoracism and populism in the post-1989 world Berghahn Books New York and Oxford.

  • Hervik P & Boisen S 2013 ‘Danish Media Coverage of 22/7’ vol. 3 no. 4 pp. 197-204. DOI:10.2478/njmr-2013-0012.

  • Horsti K 2013 ‘De-ethnicized victims: mediatized advocacy for asylum seekers’ Journalism vol. 14 no. 1 pp. 78-95. DOI:10.1177/1464884912473895.

  • Horsti K & Pellander S 2015 ‘Conditions of cultural citizenship: intersections of gender race and age in public debates on family migration’ Citizenship Studies vol. 19 no. 6-7 pp. 751-767. DOI:10.1080/13621025.2015.1008998.

  • Hübinette T & Lundström C 2011 ‘ Sweden after the Recent Election: The Double-Binding Power of Swedish Whiteness through the Mourning of the Loss of “Old Sweden” and the Passing of “Good Sweden”‘ NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research vol. 19 no. 1 pp. 42-52. DOI: 10.1080/08038740.2010.547835

  • Keskinen S 2013 ‘Antifeminism and white identity politics: political antagonisms in radical right-wing populist and anti-immigration rhetoric in Finland’ Nordic Journal of Migration Research vol. 3 no. 4 pp. 225-232. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/njmr-2013-0015

  • Myong L & Bissenbakker M 2016 ‘Love without borders? White transraciality in Danish migration activism’ Cultural Studies vol. 30 no. 1 pp. 129-146 DOI:10.1080/09502386.2014.974643.

  • Myong L & Trige Andersen N 2015 ‘From immigration stop to intimizations of migration: cross-reading the histories of domestic(ated) labor migration and transnational adoption in Denmark 1973-2015’ Retfaerd vol. 38 no. 3 pp. 62-79.

  • Rytter M 2018 ‘Writing against integration: Danish imaginaries of culture race and belonging’ Ethnos vol. 84 no. 4 pp. 678-697 DOI:10.1080/00141844.2018.1458745.

  • Schultz-Nielsen L & Tranæs T 2009 Ægteskabsmønsteret for unge med indvandrerbaggrund: Konsekvenser af ændringer i udlændingelovgivningen i 2000 og 2002 [Marriage Patterns Among Young People of Immigrant Decent: The Result of Changes in Migration Legislation in 2000 and 20002]. Rockwool Fondens Forskningsenhed Copenhagen.

  • Smedegaard Nielsen A 2014 ”De vil os stadig til livs”. Betydningskonstruktioner i tv- nyhedsformidling om terrortruslen mod Danmark [”They Still Want Us Death”. Constructions of signification in television news communication about the threat of terror against Denmark] Ph.D. ThesisKøbenhavns Universitet Copenhagen.

  • Smedegaard Nielsen A 2019 ‘White fear: habitual whiteness and racialization of the threat of terror in Danish news journalism’ in Racialization racism and anti-racism in the Nordic countries ed. P Hervik Palgrave Macmillan London pp. 111-134.

  • Somerville SB 2005 ‘Notes toward a queer history of naturalization’ American Quarterly vol. 57 no. 3 pp. 659-675.

  • Stage C 2011 Tegningekrisen – som mediebegivenhed og danskhedskamp [The Cartoon Crisis – as media event and a battle for Danishness] Aarhus Universitetsforlag Aarhus.

  • Udlændinge- og Integrationsministeriet 2019 Bekendtgørelse af udlændingeloven § 9 stk. 20 LBK nr 239 af 10/03/2019 Available from: <https://www.retsinformation.dk/Forms/R0710.aspx?id=208100>. [Last accessed 9.9.2019].

  • Udlændingestyrelsen 2018 ‘Family reunification - children’s possibility to integrate successfully’ nyidanmark.dk Available from: <https://bit.ly/2xtqIbB>.

  • Yilmaz F 2016 How the workers became Muslim. Immigration culture and hegemonic transformation in Europe. University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor.

  • Yuval-Davis N 2011 The politics of belonging: intersectional contestations. Sage Publications London Thousand Oaks New Delhi Singapore.

  • Ballund M 2017 ‘Video: Kæmpe lettelse for Yiming Lius mor og stedfar’ [Video: Tremendous relief fro Yiming Liu’s mother and stepfather] mja.dk 31 May Available from: <https://www.mja.dk/artikel/video-kmpe-lettelse-for-yiming-lius-mor-og-stedfar>.

  • DR - P1 Dokumentar 2011 ‘De uintegrerbare’ [Those who cannot be integrated] DR P1 Dokumentar [radio documentary] 8 September 2011.

  • DR 2018 ‘Aftenshowet’ [Tonight’s Show] DR1 22 February.

  • Gøttler K 2017a ‘Orlogskaptajnen Kjeld beskytter Danmark: Nu skal hans 13-årige papdatter udvises’ [Commander Kjeld protects Denmark: Now his 13 year old stepdaughter is set for deportation] ekstrabladet.dk 26 May Available from: <https://ekstrabladet.dk/nyheder/samfund/orlogskaptajnen-kjeld-beskytter-danmark-nu-skal-hans-13-aarigepapdatter-udvises/6682924>.

  • Gøttler K 2017b ‘Orlogskaptajns steddatter udvises: Du kan ikke integreres’ [Stepdaughter of commander to be deported: You are not able to integrate] Ekstra Bladet 27 May p. 5.

  • Harder T 2017 ‘Kaptajn Kjelds datter udvises: Så afleverer jeg mine medaljer tilbage [Commander Kjeld’s daughter to be deported: Then I will return my medals] ekstrabladet.dk 30 May Available from: <https://ekstrabladet.dk/nationen/kaptajn-kjelds-datter-udvises-saa-afleverer-jeg-mine-medaljer-tilbage/6687541>.

  • Hejlskov Thomsen J 2017 ‘Stedfar: fornuften har sejret’ [Stepdad: Common sense has prevailed] tvmidtvest.dk 31 May Available from: <https://www.tvmidtvest.dk/artikel/stedfar-fornuften-har-sejret>.

  • Husum K 2017a ‘Skolen støtter Yiming’ [The school supports Yiming] Midtjyllands Avis 29 May p. 9.

  • Husum K 2017b ‘Forældre samler underskrifter’ [Parents collecting signatures] Midtjyllands Avis 29 May p. 9.

  • Husum K 2017c ‘Yimings stedfars brev til statsministeren: Hvad er det for et system Danmark har skabt’ [Letter to the prime minister from Yiming’s stepfather: What kind of system has Denmark created] mja.dk 8 December Available from: <https://www.mja.dk/artikel/yimings-stedfars-brev-til-statsministeren-hvad-er-det-for-et-system-danmark-har-skabt>.

  • Jørgensen KK 2017 ‘Far til udvisningstruet pige: “Hvis Yiming ikke er integreret så burde man fjerne ordet integration fra den danske ordbog” [Father of girl in risk of deportation. ”If Yiming is unintegrated the word integration should be removed from the Danish dictionary] jyllands-posten.dk 30 May Available from: <https://jyllands-posten.dk/indland/ECE9615235/far-til-udvisningstruet-pige-hvis-yiming-ikke-er-integreret-saaburde-man-fjerne-ordet-integration-fra-den-danske-ordbog/>.

  • Krabbe H 2017 ‘1. omgang til den sunde fornuft’ [First round to common sense] Midtjyllands Avis 1 June p. 47.

  • Lysgaard AL 2018 ‘Afgørelse trækker ud: Yiming Liu venter stadig’ [Decision drags on: Yiming Liu is still waiting] tvmidtvest.dk 5 January Available from: <https://www.tvmidtvest.dk/artikel/afgoerelse-traekker-ud-yiming-liu-venter-stadig>.

  • Møldrup Sørensen C 2017 ‘13-årig kinesisk pige skal alligevel ikke forlade landet i dag’ [13 year old Chinese girl does not have to leave the country today] jyllands-posten.dk 31 May Available from: <https://jyllands-posten.dk/indland/ECE9616872/13aarig-kinesisk-pige-skal-alligevel-ikke-forlade-landet-i-dag/>.

  • Nielsen C 2017 ‘13-årigs stedfar: Hvis de udviser hende udviser de også mig’ [Stepfather to 13 year old: if they deport her they also deport me] tv2ostjylland.dk 30 May Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/artikel/13-aarigs-stedfar-hvis-de-udviser-hende-udviser-de-ogsaa-mig>.

  • Nielsen C & Skou-Hansen PS 2017 ‘Udvisning sat i bero: 13-årig pige får lov at blive i Danmark’ [Deportation halted: 13 year old girl allowed to stay in Denmark] tv2ostjylland.dk 31 May Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/artikel/13-aarige-yiming-liu-fra-silkeborg-faar-lov-blive-i-danmark>.

  • Nielsen S 2017a ‘Støtten strømmer ind til udvisningsramt pige i Silkeborg’ [Support pouring in for girl from Silkeborg who is at risk of deportation] Midtjyllands Avis 28 May Available from: <https://www.mja.dk/artikel/sttten-strmmer-ind-til-udvisnings-ramt-pige-i-silkeborg>.

  • Nielsen S 2017b ‘Silkeborg-familie kæmper mod udvisning af datter’ [Family from Silkeborg fight deportation of daughter] Midtjyllands Avis 29 May p. 8.

  • Niskanen S 2017 ‘Kærlighed og journalistik’ [Love and journalism] Midtjyllands Avis 30 May p. 22.

  • Norup CA 2017 ‘Stedfar i tårer: Jeg forlader Danmark med Yiming’ [Stepdad in tears: I leave behind Denmark with Yiming] mja.dk 30 May Available from: <https://www.mja.dk/artikel/stedfar-i-trer-jeg-forlader-danmark-med-yiming>.

  • Ravn A 2018 ‘14-årige Yiming efter udskudt udvisningssag: - Jeg er bange’ [14 year old Yiming after postponed deportation case: I am afraid] tv2ostjylland.dk 17 February Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/artikel/14-aarige-yiming-efter-udskudt-udvisningssag-jeg-er-bange>.

  • Rosenquist J 2017a ‘Lærere fortørnet over udvisning af 13-årig pige’ [Teacher outraged by deportation of 13 year old girl] mja.dk 29 May Available from: <https://www.mja.dk/artikel/lrere-fortrnet-over-udvisning-af-13-rig-pige>.

  • Rosenquist J 2017b ‘6. klasse holder fast i Yiming’ [Sixth grade holds on to Yiming] Midtjyllands Avis 30 May p. 2.

  • Rosenquist J & Husum K 2017 ‘Kampen for at blive i Danmark’ [The fight to stay in Denmark] Midtjyllands Avis 1 June p. 20.

  • Søndergaard LG 2018a ‘14-årige Yiming må fortsat leve i uvished: Sag udskydes i månedsvis’ [14 year old Yiming will have to live in uncertainty: case postponed for months] tv2ostjylland.dk 16 February Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/artikel/udvisningssag-udskydes-5-maaneder-yiming-maa-vente-igen>.

  • Søndergaard LB 2018b ‘14-årige Yiming har fået opholdstilladelse: - Vi er herre over egen fremtid igen’ [14 year old Yiming has obtained residency: - we are in charge of our own future again] tv2ostjylland.dk 14 March Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/artikel/yiming-har-faaet-opholdstilladelse-vi-er-herre-over-egen-fremtid-igen>.

  • Steenberg A 2017 ‘Yiming-sagen viser hvor langt ud Danmark er kommet’ [The Yiming case shows how out of one’s depth Denmark has become] Midtjyllands Avis 1 June p. 48.

  • Stender Pedersen M 2017a ‘Vi stod alle sammen og skreg’ [We all stood and screamed] tv2. dk 31 May Available from: <http://tv.tv2.dk/video/MTA0NzM4OEE>.

  • Stender Pedersen M 2017b ‘Rørende besked til mor og stedfar: 13-årig pige får lov til at blive’ [Emotional message to mom and stepdad: 13 year old girl allowed to stay] tv2.dk 31 May Available from: <http://nyheder.tv2.dk/samfund/2017-05-31-roerende-besked-tilmor-og-stedfar-13-aarig-pige-faar-lov-at-blive>.

  • TV-MV 2017a ‘Byråd og borgmester bakker op om Yiming’ [Town council and mayor support Yiming] 2017 TV-MV 30 May Available from: <https://www.tvmidtvest.dk/nyheder/30-05-2017/1930/byrad-og-borgmester-bakker-op-om-yiming?autoplay=1#player>

  • TV-MV 2017b ‘Vennerne er glade for nyheden om Yiming’ [Friends are happy for the news about Yiming] tvmidtvest.dk 31 May Available from: <https://www.tvmidtvest.dk/nyheder/31-05-2017/1930/vennerne-er-glade-nyheden-om-yiming?autoplay=1#player>.

  • TV2 Østjylland 2017 ‘13-årig skal forlade Danmark’ [13 year old must leave Denmark] tv2ostjylland.dk 30 May Available from: <https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/nyheder/30-05-2017/2220/13-arig-skal-forlade-danmark?autoplay=1#player>.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 56 56 15
PDF Downloads 57 57 21