Rethinking Global Care Chains through the Perspective of Heterogeneous States, Discursive Framings and Multi-Level Governance

Open access


In investigating global and regional care chains, scholars have traditionally adopted a sociological bottom–up approach, but more attention has recently been focussed on the role of the state. Despite this new attention to states and how they condition care chains, the existing frameworks cannot grasp the complexity of potential struggles and tensions within states and at the various state levels. In outlining a broad and tentative analytical framework for exploration of the role of the state in shaping global care chains, this theoretical article combines feminist state theory, discursive policy analysis and multi-level governance theories. Paying attention to the role of the state, we focus on the framing of policy problems that are important for care chains and on potential tensions between different framings within a state and across the different state levels. We argue that these framings should be investigated in both receiving and sending states.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anttonen A & Sipilä J 1996 ‘European social care services: is it possible to identify models?’ Journal of European Social Policy vol. 5 no. 2 pp. 87-100.

  • Bacchi CL 2009 Analysing policy: what’s the problem represented to be? Pearson Education Australia.

  • Bache I & Flinders M 2004b Multi-level governance published to Oxford Scholarship DOI:10.1093/0199259259.001.0001.

  • Baldassar L & Merla L (eds) 2014 Transnational families migration and the circulation of care: understanding mobility and absence in family life Routledge New York.

  • Bartolomei MR 2010 ‘Migrant male domestic workers in comparative perspective: four case studies from Italy India Ivory Coast and Congo’ Men and Masculinities vol. 13 no. 1 pp. 87-110.

  • Bettio F & Plantenga J 2004 ‘Comparing care regime in Europe’ Feminist Economics vol. 10 no. 1 pp. 85-113.

  • Brodin H 2005 Does anybody care? public and private responsibilities in Swedish eldercare 1940-2000 Ekonomisk historia Umeå. Available from: <>

  • Brown W 1992 ‘Finding the man in the state’ Feminist Studies vol. 18 no. 1 pp. 7-34.

  • Conrad C 2011 ‘Social Policy history after the transnational turn’ in Beyond welfare state models – Transnational historical perspectives on social policy eds P Kettunen & K Petersen Edward Elgar Cheltenham pp. 218-240.

  • Da Roit B & Weicht B 2013 ‘Migrant care work and care migration and employment regimes: a fuzzy-set analysis’ Journal of European Social Policy vol. 23 no. 5 pp. 469-486.

  • Dahl HM 2000 Fra kitler til eget tøj – Diskurser om professionalisme omsorg og køn Politica Århus.

  • Dahl HM 2009 ‘New public management care and struggles about recognition’ Critical Social Policy vol. 29 no. 4 pp. 634-654.

  • Dahl HM 2012 ‘Tavshed som magt og afmagt Antropologi vol. 33 no. 66 pp. 3-16.

  • Dahl HM 2017 Struggles about (elderly) care – a feminist view Palgrave Macmillan New York.

  • Daly M 2001 Care work: the quest for security International Labour Office (Report).

  • Deneva N 2012 ‘Transnational aging carers: on transformation of kinship and citizenship’ in the context of migration among bulgarian muslims in Spain’ Social Politics vol. 19 no. 1 pp. 105-128.

  • Gavanas A 2010 Who cleans the welfare state? Migration informalization social exclusion and domestic services in Stockholm Institute for Futures Studies Research Report No. 2010/3.

  • Gavanas A 2013 ‘Migrant domestic workers social network strategies and informal markets for domestic services in Sweden’ Women’s Studies International Forum vol. 36 pp. 54-64.

  • Guevarra AR 2006 ‘Managing ‘vulnerabilities’ and ‘empowering’ migrant Filipina workers: the Philippines’ overseas employment program’ Social Identities: Journal for the Study of RaceNation and Culture vol. 12 no. 5 pp. 523-541.

  • Hochschild A 2001 ‘Global care chains and emotional surplus value’ in On the edge. Living with global capitalism eds W Hutton & A Giddens Vintage London pp. 130–146.

  • Hooren FV 2012 ‘Varieties of migrant care work comparing patterns of migrant labour in social care’ Journal of European Social Policy vol. 22 no. 2 pp. 133-147.

  • Huang S Thang LL & Toyota M 2012 ‘Transnational mobilities for care: rethinking the dynamics of care in Asia’ Global Networks vol. 2 no. 2 pp. 129-134.

  • Isaksen LW (ed) 2010 Global care work: gender and migration in Nordic societies Nordic Academic Press Lund.

  • Isaksen LW 2011 ‘Gendering the stranger: nomadic care workers in Europe – a Polish-Italian example’ in Europeanization care and gender eds HM Dahl M Keränen & A Kovalainen Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke pp. 141-151.

  • Isaksen LW 2012 ‘Transnational spaces of care: migrant nurses in Norway’ Social Politics vol. 19 no. 1 pp. 58-77.

  • Isaksen LW Devi SU & Hochschild A 2008 ‘Global care crisis: a problem of capital care chain or commons?’ American Behavioral Scientist vol. 52 no. 3 pp. 405–425.

  • Kantola J 2006 Feminists theorize the state Palgrave Macmillan New York.

  • Kantola J & Dahl HM 2005 ‘Gender and the state: from differences between to differences within’ International Feminist Journal of Politics vol. 7 no. 1 pp. 49-70.

  • Kantola J & Squires J 2004 ‘Discourses surrounding prostitution in the UK’ European Journal of Women’s Studies vol. 11 no. 1 pp. 77–101.

  • Kelstrup M Martinsen DS & Wind M 2008 Europa i forandring – en grundbog i EU’s politiske og retslige system Hans Reitzels Publishers Copenhagen.

  • Kilkey M 2010 ‘Domestic-sector work in the UK: locating men in the configuration of gendered care and migration regimes’ Social Policy and Society vol. 9 no. 3 pp. 443-454.

  • Kilkey M Lutz H & Palenga-Möllenbeck E 2010 ‘Introduction’ in the special issue ‘Domestic and care work at the intersection of welfare gender and migration regimes: European experiences’ Social Policy and Society vol. 9 no. 3 pp. 379-384.

  • Kilkey M & Merla L 2013 ‘Situating transnational families care-giving arrangements: the role of institutional contexts’ Global Networks DOI:10.1111/glob.12034.

  • Kofman E Phizacklea A Raghuram P & Sales R 2001 Gender and international migration in Europe: employment welfare and politics Routledge London.

  • Lister R Williams F & Anttonen A 2007 Gendering citizenship in Western Europe: new challenges for citizenship research in a cross-national context. Policy Press Bristol.

  • Lombardo E & Forest M 2012 The Europeanization of gender equality policies. A discursive-sociological approach. Palgrave MacMillan Basingstoke.

  • Lutz H 2008 ‘Introduction: Migrantmdomestic workers in Europe’ in Migration and domestic work. A European perspective on a global theme ed H Lutz Ashgate Aldershot pp. 1-12.

  • Lutz H 2011 The New Maids. Transnational women and the care economy Zed Books London.

  • Lutz H & Palenga-Möllenbeck E 2012 ‘Care worker care drain and care chains: reflections on care migration and citizenship’ Social Politics vol. 19 no. 1 pp. 15-37.

  • Manalansan M 2006 ‘Queer intersections: sexuality and gender in migration studies’ International Migration Review vol. 40 no. 1 pp. 224-249.

  • Marks G Hooghe L & Blank K 1996 ‘European integration from the 1980s: state centric v. multi-level governance’ Journal of common Market Studies vol. 34 no. 3 pp. 341-378.

  • Masselink LE & Lee S-YD 2010 ‘Nurses inc.: expansion and commercialization of nursing education in the Philippines’ Social Science & Medicine vol. 71 pp. 166-172.

  • Ortiga YY 2014 ‘Professional problems: the burden of producing the “global” Filipino nurse’ Social Science and Medicine vol. 115 pp. 64–71.

  • Parreñas RS 2001 ‘Mothering from a distance: emotions gender and intergenerational relations in Filipino transnational families’ Feminist Studies vol. 27 no. 2 pp. 361-390.

  • Parreñas RS 2005 ‘Gender inequalities in the new global economy’ in Domestic service and the formation of European identity. Understanding the globalization of domestic work 16th-21st centuries ed A Fauve-Chamoux Peter Lang Oxford pp. 369-378.

  • Peterson E 2011 Beyond the “women-friendly” welfare state. Framing gender inequality as a policy problem in Spanish and Swedish politics of care Doctoral thesis Department of Political Science and Administration II Complutense University Madrid.

  • Peterson E 2015 Framing caregiving work for older people in Spanish public policy: gender power and social justice Revista Española de Ciencia Política 39 pp. 221-237.

  • Peterson E 2016 ‘Paid domestic work in Spain: gendered framings of work and care in policies on social citizenship’ in Paid migrant domestic labour in a changing Europe: questions of gender equality and citizenship eds B Gullikstad GK Kristensen & P Ringrose Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke pp. 79-100.

  • Pfau-Effinger B 2005 ‘Culture and welfare state policies: reflections on a complex interrelation’ Journal of Social Policy vol. 34 no. 1 pp. 3-20.

  • Prado CG 1995 Starting with Foucault – an introduction to genealogy Westview Press Boulder.

  • Pringle R & Watson S 2004 ‘Women’s interests and the post-structuralist state’ in Feminism and Politics ed A Phillips Oxford University Press Oxford pp. 203-223.

  • Raghuram P 2012 ‘Global care local configurations – challenges to conceptualizations of care’ Global Networks vol. 12 no. 2 pp. 155-174.

  • Sainsbury D 2014 ‘Gender care and welfare’ in Oxford handbook of gender and politics eds G Waylen K Celis J Kantola & SL Weldon Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • Saraceno C & Keck W 2010 ‘Can we identify intergenerational policy regimes in Europe?’ European Societies vol. 12 no. 5 pp. 675-696.

  • Seeberg ML 2012 ‘Immigrant careworkers and Norwegian gender equality: institutions identities intersections’ European Journal of Women’s Studies vol. 19 no. 2 pp. 173-185.

  • Skilbrei M-L & Spanger M 2018 (forthcoming) Understanding Sex for Sale: Meanings and Moralities of Sexual Commerce Routledge Oxon.

  • Skornia AK 2014 Entangled inequalities in transnational care chains – practices across the borders of Peru and Italy Transcript Verlag Bielefeld.

  • Spanger M 2011 ‘Human trafficking as lever for feminist voices? Transformations of the Danish policy field of prostitution’ Critical Social Policy Vol. 31 no. 4 pp. 517-539.

  • Spanger M & Skilbrei M-L 2017 Prostitution Research in Context. Methodology Representation and Power Routledge Oxon.

  • Stenum H 2010 ‘Au-pair migration and new inequalities. The transnational production of corruption’ in Global care work. Gender and migration in Nordic societies ed LW Isaksen Nordic Academic Press Lund pp. 23-48.

  • Walton-Roberts M 2012 ‘Contextualizing the global nursing care chain: international migration and the status of nursing in Kerala India’ Global Networks vol. 12 no. 2 pp. 175–194.

  • Walton-Roberts M 2016 ‘Global nursing care chains and the internationalization of nurse education in Punjab’ in Migration mobility and multiple affairs. Punjabis in a transnational world eds S Irudaya Rajan VJ Varghese & AK Nanda Cambridge University Press Cambridge pp. 296-318.

  • Williams F 2010 ‘Migration and care: themes concepts and challenges’ Social Policy and Society vol. 9 no. 3 pp. 385-396.

  • Williams F 2011 ‘Care migration and citizenship: migration and home-based care in Europe’ in Europeanization care and gender – global complexities eds HM Dahl M Keränen & A Kovalainen Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke pp. 41-58.

  • Williams F 2012 ‘Converging variations in migrant care work in Europe’ Journal of European Social Policy vol. 22 no. 4 pp. 363-376.

  • Williams F & Gavanas A 2008 ‘The intersection of childcare regimes and migration’ in Migration and domestic work ed H Lutz Ashgate Aldershot pp. 13-28.

  • Wrede S & Näre L 2013’Glocalising care in the Nordic countries. An introduction to the special issue’ Nordic Journal of Migration and Relation vol. 3 no. 2 pp. 57-62.

  • Yeates N 2010 ‘The globalisation of paid care labour migration: policy issues approaches and responses’ International Labour Review vol. 149 no. 4 pp. 423-440.

  • Yeates N 2009a Globalizing care economies and migrant workers Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke.

  • Yeates N 2009b ‘Production for export: the role of the state in the development and operation of global care chains’ Population Space and Place vol. 15 no. 2 pp. 205-228.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 953 619 24
PDF Downloads 296 214 6