Facilitators and Constraints of Policy Learning for Administrative Capacity in the Western Balkans

Artan Karini


Drawing on the policy-transfer literature, where processes such as Europeanization accentuate the role of policy networks as facilitators or constraints in the implementation of acquis, in addition to the familiar mechanism of “conditionality”, the principal objective of this article is to explore the challenges of policy learning toward administrative-capacity building and, more specifically, the role of what I refer to here as “donor-bureaucrat-contractor” networks in the Western Balkans. By employing a qualitative methodology consisting of forty semi-structured interviews and focus groups with policymakers, donor officers, civil-society experts and consultants in the region during the period of January 2011 to December 2016, a critical analysis of aid-supported policy learning via training as a conduit to administrative capacity-building reveals a series of context-specific dimensions, such as the informality of such networks, overreliance on local NGOs as “capacitybuilding” implementation partners and the ability of the context to affect donor behaviour - all ultimately contributing to the (non-) occurrence of policy transfer. Th e overarching conclusion this article draws is that potential answers to problems with aid-supported policy learning in the region may probably lie in the invisible workings of the aforementioned networks rather than solely in the official channels of communication between Brussels and regional governments. From a policymaking standpoint, this conclusion in itself may as well be construed as a recommendation to mobilize future research surrounding the impact of such networks on European Union (EU) accession processes in the region. Th is may encourage research organizations both in the EU and the region to (re) orient future endeavors towards this dimension of administrative capacity-building - a core requirement for EU accession - especially as the EU itself faces its own enlargement dilemmas following Brexit while the region faces threats of a potential revival of “old” ethnic conflicts, both affecting the progress of administrative reforms and prospects of EU accession.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Abouassi, Khaldoun. 2010. “International Development Management Th rough a Southern Lens.” Public Administration and Development 30, 116 - 123.

  • Bennett, Colin. 1991. “How States Utilize Foreign Evidence.” Journal of Public Policy 33, 4.

  • Benson, David and Andrew Jordan. 2011. “What Have We Learned from Policy Transfer Research: Dolowitz and Marsh Revisited.” Political Studies Review 9, 366 - 378.

  • Blunt, Peter; Mark Turner and Henrik Lindroth. 2012. “Patronage’s Progress in Post-Soeharto Indonesia.” Public Administration and Development 32(1), 64 - 81.

  • Booth, David. 2011. “Aid Eff ectiveness: Bringing Country Ownership (and Politics) back in.” Working paper series 336, Overseas Development Institute (ODI).

  • Browne, Stephen. 2006. Aid and Infl uence: Do Donors Help or Hinder ? London: EarthScan.

  • Celasun, Oya and Jan Walliser. 2008. “Predictability of Aid: Do Fickle Donors Undermine Aid Eff ectiveness ?” Economic Policy (IBRD and IMF Journal Compilation), July, 545 - 594.

  • Collier, Paul. 2006. “‘Is Aid Oil ?’ An Analysis of Whether Africa Can Absorb More Aid.” Journal of World Development 34(9), 1482 - 1497.

  • Common, Richard. 1998. “Th e New Public Management and Policy Transfer: The Role of International Organizations.” In Martin Minogue, Charles Polidano and David Hulme (eds). Beyond the New Public Management: Changing Idea sand Practices in Governance. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Edgar Publishing.

  • Djelic, Marie-Laurie. 2001. Exporting the American Model: The Post-War Transformation of European Business. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Dolowitz, David and David Marsh. 1996. “Who Learns What from Whom: A Review of the Policy Transfer Literature.” Political Studies 44, 343 - 357.

  • Dolowitz, David and David Marsh. 2000. “Learning from Abroad: The Role of Policy Transfer in Contemporary Policy-Making.” Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration 13(1), 5 - 24.

  • Dussauge-Laguna, Mauricio I. 2012. “On the Past and Future of Policy Transfer Research: Benson and Jordan Revisited.” Political Studies Review 10(3), 313 - 324.

  • Easterly, William. 2003. Th e White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good. New York: Penguin.

  • Easterly William. 2010. “Making Foreign Aid Work, Religion and Ethics.” Available at http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/2010/02/19/february-19-2010-making-foreign-aid-work/5718/ (last accessed in August 2012).

  • Easterly, William and Tobias Pfutze T. 2008. “Where does the Money Go ? Best and Worst Practices in Foreign Aid.” Working Paper 21, Brookings Global Economy and Development.

  • Evans, Mark. 2009. “Policy Transfer in Critical Perspective.” Policy Studies 30(3), 243 - 268.

  • Hoffmann, Judith. 2005. “Integrating Albania: Th e Role of the European Union in the Democratization Process.” Albanian Journal of Politics 1(1), 55 - 74.

  • Holmberg, Sören and Bo Rothstein. 2009. “Quality of Government: What You Get.” Annual Review of Political Science VOL. 12: 135 - 161.

  • Hyden, Goran. 2008. “Aft er the Paris Declaration: Taking on the Issue of Power.” Development Policy Review 26(3), 259 - 274.

  • James, Oliver and Martin Lodge. 2003. “The Limitations of Policy Transfer and Lesson Drawing for Public Policy Research.” Political Studies Review 1, 179 - 193.

  • Karini, Artan. 2013. “Aid-Supported Public Service Reform and Capacity Development in Post-Communist Albania.” International Journal of Public Administration (Routledge) 36(7), 469 - 481.

  • Karini, Artan. 2016. “Coordination Without Eff ectiveness ? A Critique of the Paris Agenda in the Experience of Development Aid in Albania.” European Journal of Development Research (Palgrave) 28(4), 741 - 757.

  • Ladi, Stella. 2005. Globalization, Policy Transfer and Policy Research Institutes. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

  • Lancaster, Carol. 2007. Foreign Aid: Diplomacy, Development, Domestic Politics. Chicago, IL: Th e University of Chicago Press.

  • Lavergne, Real and John Saxby. 2001. “Capacity Development: Vision and Implications. Capacity Development.” Occasional Paper Series. Hull, Quebec: Policy Branch, CIDA.

  • Marsh, David and Mark Evans. 2012. “Policy Transfer: Into the Future, Learning from the Past.” Policy Studies 33(6), 587 - 591.

  • Miller, David. 1998. “Collision and Collusion Reviews.” Chronicle of Higher Education #27, A16.

  • Mosse, David and David Lewis. 2005. Th e Aid Eff ect: Giving and Governing in International Development. London: Chase Publishing Services, Ltd.

  • Moyo, Dambisa. 2009. Why Aid Is Not Working and How Th ere Is Another Way for Africa. New York, NY: Farrar, Strauss and Giroux.

  • Murshed, Syed M. 2009. “On the Non-Contractual Nature of Donor-Recipient Interaction in Development Assistance.” Review of Development Economics 13(3), 416 - 428.

  • Page, Edward. 2000. Future Governance and the Literature on Policy Transfer and Lesson Drawing. ESRC Future Governance Programme paper series. London: Britannia House.

  • Painter, Martin and Guy B. Peters. 2010. Tradition and Public Administration. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Pal, Leslie. 2014. Frontiers of Governance: The OECD and Global Public Management Reform. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Petersen, Anne H. 2010. “EU Conditionality - and Public Administration Reform in the Western Balkans.” Available at http://rudar.ruc.dk (last accessed 20 August 2013).

  • Pollitt, Chris and Geert Bouckaert. 2011. Public Management Reform: A Comparative Analysis - New Public Management, Governance and the Neo-Weberian State. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Riddell, Roger C. 2007. Does Foreign Aid Really Work ? Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Rodrik, Dani. 2007. One Economics, Many Recipes: Globalization, Institutions and Economic Growth. Princeton: Princeton University.

  • Rose, Richard. 2005. Learning from Comparative Public Policy: A Practical Guide. London: Routledge.

  • Sabatier, Paul A. 1999. Th eories of the Policy Process. 2nd edn. Davis: University of California, Westview Press.

  • Schedler, Kuno and Isabella Proeller (eds). 2007. Cultural Aspects of Public Management Reform. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Stewart, Jenny. 2011. “Tradition and Public Administration.” Australian Journal of Public Administration 70, 106 - 108.

  • Stone, Diane. 1999. “Lesson Drawing and Policy Transfer.” Politics 19(1), 51 - 59.

  • Stone, Diane. 2004. “Transfer Agents and Global Networks in the ‘Transnationalization’ of Policy.” Journal of European Public Policy 11(3), 545 - 566.

  • Wedel, Janine. 2000. Collision and Collusion: Th e Strange Case of Western Aid to Eastern Europe. New York and Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Wedel, Janine. 2004. “Studying through a Globalizing World: Building Method through Aidnographies.” In J. Gould and H. Secher Marcussen (eds). Ethnographies of Aid: Exploring Development Texts and Encounters. International Development Studies, Occasional Paper 24. Roskilde: Roskilde University, 149 - 173.


Journal + Issues