Identifying Industry-Specific Components of Product Liability Response System Using Delphi-AHP Method

Open access


PL (product liability) response system is an enterprise-wide system that prevents company’s financial loss due to PL-related accidents. Existing researches on PL response system are mainly focused on preventive and/or defense strategies for the companies. Also, it is obvious that each industry has their original characteristics related on PL issues. It means industry-specific characteristics should be considered to adopt PL response strategies. Thus, this paper aims to discuss industry-specific PL response system and their components. Based on prior researches, we tried to reveal the possibility of its application to manufacturing companies of existing PL response strategies using Delphi method with PL experts. Based on first round results, we tried to classify existing PL strategies of manufacturing companies into several categories. To validate our suggestion for essential components of PL response system, second round Delphi method are applied. Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) technique will be applied to identify a prioritized list of each components and strategies. Existing PL response strategies could be categorized with six components – strategy, technology, investment, training, awareness, and organization. Among six components, Technology – it represents the technology needed for improving the safety of all products – is the most important components to prepare PL accidents. The limitation of this paper is on the size of survey and variety of examples. However, the future study will enhance the potential of the proposed method. Regardless of rich research efforts to identify PL response strategies, there is no effort to categorize these strategies and prioritized them. Well-coordinated and actionable PL response strategies and their priorities could help small-and-medium sized enterprise (SME) to develop their own PL response system with their limited resources.

[1] Park Y.T., Quality Management, Korean Standards Association Media, 2014.

[2] Jeong Y.S., Toyota recall related trends, Korea Consumer Agency, 10, 2010.

[3] Kim Y.H., Cause of occurrence and Lessons of Toyota Recalls situation, World Economy Today, Korea Institute for International Economic Policy, 10, 1, 2010.

[4] Seo J.H., Ko B.S., Bae S.M., Extracting Priorities of Strategic Components of Product Liability Response System using AHP, Journal of Korean Society for Quality Management, 42, 2, 235–252, 2014.

[5] Song J.H., Product Liability Act and Corporate Strategies, Seongandang, 2002.

[6] Kim K.S., Lim G.C., Chung S.S., A Study on the PL Response by Integrated Management System, Journal of Korean Society for Quality Management, 39, 1, 120–130, 2011.

[7] Choi S.W., Lee R.G., Product Liability Prevention by ISO9001:2000 Quality Management System, Journal of Korea Safety Management & Science, 2, 2, 57–69, 2000.

[8] Hong S.W., Kim I.H., Shin J.H., Ahn Y.S., A Study on the Countermeasure against the Products Liability Law in the Construction Industry, Journal of the Regional Association of Architectural Institute of Korea, 7, 2, 87–94, 2005.

[9] Hyun O.S., Park R.G., Jung S.I., An Empirical Study on the Correspondence Level to Product Liability, Journal of Korea Safety Management & Science, 8, 4, 53–62, 2006.

[10] Kim J.B., Production Liability; the Corporation Response, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Institute of Economics, 7, 3, 239–262, 1998.

[11] Lee H.K., Cho M.G., A Study on Effective Response to Product Liability for Diamond Tool Industry, Journal of the Korea Safety Management & Science, 14, 2, 71–82, 2012.

[12] Lee S.M., Choi S.C., A Study on the Strategies for Product Liability in the Food Service Industry, Journal of Digital Contents Society, 5, 5, 219–227, 2005.

[13] Baram M, Liability and its influence on designing for product and process safety, Safety Science, 45, 11–30, 2007.

[14] Park J.S., Sung H.K., Kang G.S., A Study Countermeasures Method of Domestic Small and Medium Enterprise According to Product Liability Law, Journal of Korea Safety Management & Science, 4, 1, 81–92, 2002.

[15] Park R.G., Chang S.J., A Study on Strategic Countermeasure against product liability, Journal of Korea Safety Management & Science, 11, 1, 165–173, 2009.

[16] Goodden R., Product liability Prevention-the next dimension in quality, Total Quality Management, 12, 5, 623–628, 2010.

[17] Dowlatshahi S., The role or product safety and liability in concurrent engineering, Computer and Industrial Engineering, 41, 187–209, 2001.

[18] See S.H., Yang J.S., Kim G.S., Establishment of an Effective Product Liability Prevention Plan by Analyzing Product Liability Cases, Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 27, 4, 581–593, 2010.

[19] Yoo J.H., Kim D.H., Ko J.W., A Study on Product Liability Response System of Chemical Product by Using Failure Mode and Effect Analysis, Journal of Korean Institute of Gas, 7, 4, 30–35, 2003.

[20] Chang S.J., A Study on Product Liability Management Activity of Product Defectiveness, Journal of the Korean Institute of Plant Engineering, 15, 2, 95–102, 2010.

[21] Park R.G., Lee S.H., A Study on the Actual Condition of Counterplan for Product Liability in Small and Medium Enterprises, Journal of Korea Safety Management & Science, 12, 4, 99–105, 2010.

[22] Ross B., Product liability experiences of Japanese manufacturers in the USA, International Journal of Fatigue, 20, 2, 107–134, 1998.

[23] Choi B.R., Product Liability for the death of a child caused by Mini-cup Jelly, Law Research Institute the University of Seoul, 19, 3, 113–162, 2012.

[24] Becnel D.E. Jr., An overview of complex product liability litigation in the USA, International Journal of Fatigue, 20, 2, 93–98, 1998.

[25] Kim J.K., Product Liability Prevention Policies through Improvement of Product Safety and Reliability, IE interfaces, 15, 3, 270–278, 2002.

[26] Kim J.K., A study on the system construction to cope with the product liability based on the risk management system (master’s thesis), The Graduate School of Sungkyunkwan University, 2003.

[27] Huang S.-J., Wu M.-S., Chen L.-W., Critical success factors in aligning IT and business objectives: A Delphi study, Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 24, 9-10, 1219–1240, 2012.

[28] Tang Y., Sun H., Yao Q., Wang Y., The selection of key technologies by the silicon photovoltaic industry based on the Delphi method and AHP (analytic hierarchy process): Case study of China, Energy, 75, 474–482, 2014.

[29] Hong H.K., A Study on the case of PL prevention strategies and prevention systems in the domestic S-company, Journal of the Korean Society for Quality Management, 31, 1, 62–75, 2003.

[30] Cho H.R. et al., Management of Technology in the Perspective of Management Innovation, Hakhyunsa, 2013.

[31] Elmer O., Rescher N., On the epistemology of the inexact sciences, Management Science, 6, 1, 25–52, 1959.

[32] Kim K.D., Choi K., A Study on the Policy of Sustainable Domestic Timber Supply Using Delphi Technique and AHP, Jour. Korean For. Soc, 101, 3, 434–442, 2012.

[33] Seo J.H., Bae S.M., Extracting Essential Components of Product Liability Response System using Delphi Method, ANQ Congress 2015, 2015.

[34] Saizarbitoria I.H., How Quality Management models influence company results–Conclusions of an empirical study based on the Delphi method, Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 17, 6, 775–795, 2007.

[35] Delbecq A.L., van de Ven A.H., Gustafson D.H., Group techniques for program planning: A guide to nominal group technique and Delphi processes, Glenview, IL: Scott-Foresman, 1975.

[36] Okoli C., Pawlowski S.D., The Delphi method as a research tool: An example, design considerations and applications, Information & Management, 42, 1, 15–29, 2004.

[37] Lawshe C.H., A quantitative approach to content validity, Personnel Psychology, 28, 563–575, 1975.

[38] Cho G.T. et al., Analytic Hierarchy Process, DongHyeon Press, 2003.

[39] Kim S.Y., A Study on the Strategic priority for Defense Quality Management Factors by using Analytic Hierarchy Process, Journal of the Society of Korea Industrial and Systems Engineering, 35, 3, 217–224, 2012.

[40] Safety Korea, Korea Agency for Technology and Standards, 5, 2015.

[41] Safety Korea, Korea Agency for Technology and Standards, 4, 2014.

[42] Choi M.G., Defects of the car in the product liability, Journal of Korea Association of Comparative Private Law, 6, 1, 85–108, 1999.

[43] Kim J.I., A study about a strategy to cope with the product liability law of a food manufacturing company (master’s thesis), Graduate School of Medical Food of Chung-Ang University, 2005.

[44] Kim N.P., Study on the PL (product liability) of small-medium-sized enterprise and the improvement of their ability to cope with (Master’s thesis), Majoring in Digital Small Business Administration Graduate School of Digital Small Business Hansung University, 2006.

[45] Lim G.C., A Study on the PL Response by Integrated Management System (Master’s thesis), Graduate School of Industry of Korea National University of Transportation, 2010.

[46] Hong H.K., Analysis on the type of PL Accident by Major Industry, Journal of Economy and Business, 5, 1, 125–134, 2010.

[47] Kim S.C., Legal Liability in Claims of Food Accident, Journal of Korea International Trade Association, 40, 3, 49–71, 2015.

Management and Production Engineering Review

The Journal of Production Engineering Committee of Polish Academy of Sciences and Polish Association for Production Management

Journal Information

CiteScore 2016: 0.48

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2016: 0.126
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2016: 0.551

Cited By


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 179 179 13
PDF Downloads 61 61 8