Effect of different organic manures and fertilizers on growth and yield of knol-khol (Brassica oleracea var. gongylodes L.)

Md. Anichhul Islam 1 , Md. Yamin Kabir 1 , Nubayra Tasnim Shuvra 2 , Md. Amirul Islam 3 ,  and Md. Hasibur Rahaman Hera 4
  • 1 Agrotechnology Discipline, Khulna University, Bangladesh
  • 2 Department of Horticulture, Bangladesh Agricultural University, 2202, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
  • 3 Sustainable Intensification Program, International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center, , Dhaka, Bangladesh
  • 4 Plant Pathology Division, Bangladesh Rice Research Institute, , 1701, Gazipur, Bangladesh


A field experiment was carried out to investigate the effect of different manures and fertilizers on the growth and yield of knol-khol (Brassica oleracea var. gongylodes) at Dr. Purnendu Gain Field Laboratory of Agrotechnology Discipline, Khulna University, Khulna from November 2014 to February 2015. The single factor experiment comprised of different types of fertilizers and manures viz., T0 (Control), T1 (Recommended doses of NPK), T2 (Cow dung), T3 (Vermicompost), T4 (Poultry manure), T5 (50 % Cow dung + 50 % NPK), T6 (50% Vermicompost + 50% Cow dung), T7 (50% Vermicompost + 50 % Poultry manure) and T8 (25% Cow dung+ 25% Vermicompost+ 25% Poultry manure + 25% NPK). The Experiment was laid out in Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with four replications. The maximum plant height was obtained from the treatment T1 at 25, 35 and 45 Days after transplanting (DAT). The maximum spread of canopy was 36.75 cm, 52.50 cm and 66.05 cm from the treatment T3, T7 and T2, respectively. The maximum economic yield (21.92 t/ha) and biological yield (40.083 t/ha) were found in the treatment T1 and T7, respectively. Highest benefit cost ratio (3.07) was obtained from the treatment T1whilethe minimum (0.57) was obtained from T3 which indicates that high cost of vermicompost affect net return severely. Although, T1 produced maximum benefit cost ratio, the treatment T4 and T2 are very close to T1 and also statistically similar. So, we can consider poultry manure and cow dung for our soil health, environmental benefits and ecological safety.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] K.G. Shanmugavelu, “Production Technology of Vegetable Crops”, Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd., Chap., 26, Pp. 364-365, 1989.

  • [2] J.A. Duke, and E.S. Ayensu, “Medical Plants of China”, National Book foundation, Beijing, China, Pp. 389, 1985.

  • [3] E.S. Chauhan, A. Tiwari, and A. Singh, “Phytochemical screening of Knol-Khol (Brassica caulorapa) owder and juice – A comparative study”, International Journal of Home Science, 2, Pp. 123–126, 2016.

  • [4] I.J. Chaudhary, and R.P. Singh, “Applied with organic matrix based slow release bio fertilizers”, International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, 7 Pp. 3221–3238, 2018.

  • [5] V. Singh, K.N. Shah, I.J. Chaudhary, D.K. Rana, “Impact assessment of different organic manures on growth, morphology and yield of onion (Allium cepa L.) cultivar”, Asian Journal of Agricultural Research, 13, Pp. 20–27, 2019. Doi: 10.3923/ajar.2019.20.27.

  • [6] H.C. Thompson, and W.C. Kelly, “Cole Crops In: H. C. Thompson and W. C. Kelly (eds.) Vegetable crops”, McGraw Hil Book Co., New York, Pp. 230-300, 2007.

  • [7] L. Cavazza, and V.V. Bianco, “Fertilizer trials with vegetable crops using composted solid town refuse”, Rivista di Agronomia, 9(1), Pp. 9-16. Cited from HortAbst., 46(3), Pp. 2087, 2005.

  • [8] I.U. Haque, and A.K. Jakhro, “Soil and fertilizer nitrogen”. Soil Sci., National Book Foundation, Islamabad, Pakistan, Pp. 266, 1996.

  • [9] K.S. Memon, “Soil and Fertilizers. Soil Science Department”, National Book Foundation Islamabad, Pakistan, Pp. 92, 1996.

  • [10] G. Chandra, “Nutrient management In: Fundamentals of Agronomy”, Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. New Delhi, India. pp. 156, 1989.

  • [11] Anonymous, “Chinese cabbage or pet-saiIn: Vegetable production in the Sub-Tropics and Tropics. (Ed.)”, Overseas Technical Cooperation Agency, Japan, 25, Pp. 146-157, 1992.

  • [12] L. Taiz, and E. Zeiger, “Plant physiology, the cellular basis of growth and morphogenesis”, 4th edn. Cummings Publishing Company, California, Pp. 245-250, 2011.

  • [13] UNDP, “Land Resource Appraisal of Bangladesh for Agricultural Development”, Report 2: Agro-ecological Regions of Bangladesh. FAO, Rome, Pp. 577, 1988.

  • [14] M.S. Alam, T.M.T. Iqbal, M.S. Amin, and M.A. Gaffer, “Production and improvement of agronomic crop (in Bangali)”, T.M. Jubair Bin Iqbal, Manik Potal, Meghi, Serajgonj, Pp. 231-239, 1989.

  • [15] K.A. Gomez, and A.A. Gomez, “Statistical procedure for Agricultural Research. Second Edition”, A Willey Inter-Science Publication, John Willey and Sons, New York, Pp. 680, 1984.

  • [16] A.R. Reddy, and G. Padmaja, “Effect of phosphorus and zinc on curd yield and quality of cauliflower”, J. Res. Angrau, 33(1), Pp. 65-98, 2005.

  • [17] S. Eimhoit, P. Schjonning, and L.J. Munkholm, “Soil aggregation – a matter of proper management”. Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming. Denmark, Pp. 100-120, 2005.

  • [18] P.L. Krupkin, I.A. Kil-bi-I-Ya, M.A. Kakrinova, and I.Y.Y., Yaltonsky, “Effectiveness of lignin base fertilizers in Sibena”, Agriokhimiya, 12, Pp. 53-64. Cited from Hort. Abst., 64(11), Pp. 8539, 1994.

  • [19] K.L. Steffen, M.S. Dann, K. Fagaer, S.J. Fleischer, J.K. Harper, “Short term and long term impact of an initial large scale SMS soil amendment on vegetable crop productivity and resource use efficiency”, Comp. Sci. Util. 2(4): 75-83. Cited from Hort. Abst., 99(8), Pp. 112007, 1994.

  • [20] M. Fink, “Consideration of nitrogen from harvest residues in the calculation of fertilizer recommendations”, Proceeding of the workshop on the ecological aspects of vegetable fertilization integrated crop production in the field, Neustadt and weinstrasse, 428, Pp. 235-242. Cited from Hort. Abst., 66(6):5003, 1998.

  • [21] Y. Zhang, Q. Shen, J. Yu, L. Sun, H. Liu, H. Xin, and Z. Wang. “Effect of application of nitrogen fertilizers of different N forms on yields and quality of Chinese cabbage”, Research Centre of Agricultural Resources and Environments, Jiangsu Academy of Agricultural Sciences Nanjing 210014, China. Jiangsu J. Agril. Sci., 20(3), Pp. 184-188, 2004.


Journal + Issues