Driving under the influence…..”Of social factors”

Open access

Abstract

The bulk of the research that seeks to understand driving behavior and decision making has been performed by behavioral psychologists and engineers. These studies have a tendency to focus on the individual driver, examining such topics as road and vehicle design, cognitive skills, and the effects of collisions on the human body. This disparate research has produced a wealth of knowledge but with little unifying theory. The act of driving occurs within social environments that exist at many levels; the same act can be viewed through multiple lenses. In its exploration of the social context, this paper moves from an analysis of the global scale to the regional to the local. Our roads are monitored by police services and illegal acts are punished by judicial systems; these social institutions attempt to modify behavior through punitive measures. These punitive measures are derived from social theories of deviance and deterrence, methods shown here to be flawed. Empirical data derived from observations in Al Ain, UAE, are used in a quasi-experimental design that describes how drivers alter their choice of speed based on their observations of other drivers. This paper concludes by suggesting that, both by examining and legislating for driver behavior, there is a pressing need to situate the driver within his/her social environment.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Arthur RM 2011 ‛Examining traffic flow and speed data: Determining imitative behaviour’ Traffic Injury Prevention vol. 12 pp. 266–273.

  • Arthur RM 2009 ‛Using social theory and GIS to create a safer road environment’ Transportation Planning and Technology vol. 32. No. 4 Pp. 355–375.

  • Average traffic speeds are less than 20 mph in London 2012. Available from: <www.itv.com/news/london/update/2012-11-19/tfl-average-traffic-speeds-are-less-than-20-mph-in-London/>. [19 November 2012].

  • Benson D & Gresham K 2007 ‛Social contagion theory and information literacy dissemination; a theoretical model’. Paper presented at: ACRL 13th. National Conference. 29 March to 1 April 2007 Baltimore Maryland.

  • Bohm S Jones C Land C & Patterson M 2006 ‛Introduction: Impossibilities of automobility’ The Sociological Review Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Oxford U.K. pp. 116.

  • Bowie Jr Noble N. & Walz M 1994 ‛Data analysis of the speed-related crash issue’ Auto Traffic and Safety pp. 3138.

  • Breckenridge JN 1989 ‛Replicating Cluster Analysis method consistency and validity’ Multivariate Behavioral Research vol. 24 pp. 147161.

  • Connolly T & Aberg L 1993 ‛Some contagion models of speeding’ Accident Analysis and Prevention vol. 25 pp. 57–66.

  • Dauvergne P 2005 ‛Dying of consumption. Accidents or casualties of global morality?’ Global Environmental Politics vol. 5 no. 3 pp. 33–44.

  • Deutschman Linda B 1994 Deviance and social control Nelson Scarborough Canada.

  • Dubai Police issue 5232 speeding tickets a day 2014. Available from <http://www.arabianbusiness.com/revealed-dubai-police-issue-5-232-speeding-tickets-day-545380.html>. [7 April 2014]

  • Elvik R 1997 ‛Effects on accident speed enforcement in Norway’ Transportation Research Record vol. 1594: pp. 14–19.

  • Factor R Mahalel D & Gad Y 2007 ‛The social accident: a theoretical model and a research agenda for studying the influence of social and cultural characteristics on motor vehicle accidents’ Accident Analysis and Prevention vol. 39 pp. 914–921.

  • Giuliano G 2001 ‛Urban travel patterns’ in Modern Transport Geography: second. revised edition ed B Hoyle & R Knowles. Wiley pp. 115–134.

  • Huguinen RD 2005 ‛Traffic psychology in a (new) social setting’ in Traffic and Transport Psychology. Theory and Application ed G Underwood Elsevier Amsterdam.

  • Kelly DH (ed.) 1990 Deviant behavior. A text reader in the dociology of deviance 5th Edition St. Martin’s Press New York.

  • Latimer J & Munro R 2006 ‛Driving the social’ The Sociological Review vol. 54: pp. 32–53.

  • Lave LB & Lave CA 1990 ‛Barriers to increasing highway safety’ in Challenging the old order. Towards new directions in traffic safety theory ed JP Rothe. Transaction Publishers pp. 77–93.

  • Liu GX & Popoff A 1997 ‛Provincial-wide travel speed and traffic safety study in Saskatchewan’ Transportation Research Record vol. 1595 pp. 8–13.

  • Mendes SM 2004 ‛Certainty severity and their relative deterrent effects. Questioning the implications of the role of risk in criminal deterrence policy’ Policy Studies Journal vol. 32 issue 1 pp. 59–74.

  • Mendes SM & MacDonald MD 2001 ‛Putting severity of punishment back in the deterrence package’ Policy Studies Journal vol. 29 issue 4 pp. 588–610.

  • Miller HJ & Shaw SL 2000 Geographic information systems for transportation. Principles and applications Oxford University Press.

  • Nastos P Paliatos AG Anthracopoulos MB Roma ES & Priftis KN 2010 ‛Outdoor particulate matter and childhood asthma admissions in Athens Greece: a time-series study’ Environmental Health pp. 9–45.

  • OECD 2004 OECD Territorial Reviews: Athens Greece. OECD Publishing.

  • Phillips D 1986 ‛Natural experiments of the effect of mass media on fatal aggression’ in Advances in experimental social psychology ed L Berkowitz vol. 19 Academic Press New York.

  • Ross HL 1961 ‛Traffic law violation. A folk crime’ Social Problems vol. 8 no. 3 pp. 231–241.

  • Rothengatter JA 1991 ‛Automatic policing and information systems’. Enforcement and rewarding strategies and effects. Proceedings of the international road safety Symposium in Copenhagen ed MJ Koonstra & J Christianson September 19-21 Liedschendam The Netherlands SWOV Institute on Road Safety Research pp. 60–64.

  • Sacco VF. (ed.) 1992 Deviance. Conformity and control in Canadian Society 2nd Edition Prentice Hall New Jersey.

  • Sheller M & Urry J 2000 ‛The city and the car’ International Journal of Urban and Regional Research vol. 24 pp. 737– 757.

  • Urban logistics practices – Case Study. Joint delivery systems in Tokyo 2011 Available from <http://www.transport-research.info/Upload/Documents/201307/20130703_154723_64123_D3.6_casestudyTokyoJapan.pdf>. [10 March 2011]

  • Urry J 2000 Sociology beyond societies. London Routledge.

  • Urry J. 2004 ‛The ‘system’ of automobility’ Theory Culture and Society vol. 21 (4/5) pp. 25–24.

  • Urry J. 2006 ‛Inhabiting the car’ The Sociological Review vol. 54 pp. 17–31.

  • WHO/World Bank 2006 World report on Traffic Injury and Prevention Geneva World Health Organization.

  • William A 1996 ‛Faster but deadlier’ Speed vol. 7 no. 2 pp. 89.

  • Transport research 2014. Available from: <www.transport.research.com/info/upload/documents/201307/2013073_154723_64123_D3.6_casestudyTokyoJapan,pdf>. [10 December 2014].

  • Zaidel DM 1992 ‛A modeling perspective on the culture of driving’ Accident Analysis and Prevention vol. 24 pp. 585–597.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.62

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.236
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.378

Covered by e.g. Web of Science Core Collection by Clarivate Analytics, and SCOPUS by Elsevier
70 points in the Ministerial journal value rating scale

Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 853 500 80
PDF Downloads 126 92 5