In discussions on loess, two types are often demarcated: glacial loess and desert loess. The origin of the idea of desert loess appears to lie with V.A. Obruchev who observed wind-carried silt on the Potanin expedition to Central Asia in 1895. It might be considered that desert loess would be defined as loess associated with deserts but it came to be thought of as loess produced in deserts. This led to some controversy as no mechanism for producing silt particles in deserts was readily available. Bruce Butler in Australia in particular cast doubt on the existence of desert-made loess.
Butler indicated loess-like deposits in Australia which he called Parna; these are very like loess but the silt sized particles are actually clay mineral agglomerates of silt size- formed in dry lake regions.
At the heart of the desert loess discussion is the problem of producing loess material in deserts. It has been suggested that there are no realistic mechanisms for forming large amounts of loess dust but there is a possibility that sand grain impact may produce particle shattering and lead to the formation of quartz silt. This would appear to be a reasonable mechanism for the African deposits of desert loess, but possibly inadequate for the huge deposits in China and Central Asia. The desert loess in China and Central Asia is loess associated with a desert. The material is formed in cold, high country and carried by rivers to the vicinity of deserts. It progresses then from deserts to loess deposit.
Adobe ground may be defined as desert loess. Adobe occurs on the fringe of deserts, notably in the Sahelian region of Africa, and in SW USA. The use of adobe in construction represents the major utilization of desert loess in a social context. More understanding of adobe is required, in particular with respect to the adobe reaction, the low order chemical reaction which provides modest cementitious properties, and can be likened to the pozzolanic reactions in hydrating cement systems.
The location of loess and loess-like ground on the peripheries of deserts is aided by the observation of the nesting sites of bee-eater birds. These birds have a determined preference for loess ground to dig their nesting tunnels; the presence of nest tunnels suggests the occurrence of desert loess, in desert fringe regions.
We seek amalgamation and contrast: ten main topics are considered: words and terms, particles, parna, geotechnical, adobe, people, birds, Africa, Central Asia, Mars. The aim is some large generalizations which will benefit all aspects of desert loess investigation.
Brewer R. 1964. Fabric and Mineral Analysis of Soils. Wiley New York 470 pp.
Brewer R. 1968. Clay illuviation as a factor in particle-size differentiation in soil profiles. Transactions of 9thInternational Congress of Soil Science 4 489–499.
Bullard J.E. & Livingstone I. 2009. Dust. [In:] A.J. Parsons & A.D. Abrahams (Eds): Geomorphology of Desert Environments Springer Dordrecht 629–655.
Butler B.E. 1956. Parna – an aeolian clay. Australian Journal of Science 18 145–151 (reprinted in part in Loess Letter 54 2004 www.loessletter.msu.edu.)
Crouvi O. Amit R. Enzel Y. & Gillespie A.R. 2010. Active sand seas and the formation of desert loess. Quaternary Science Reviews 29 2087–2098.
Crouvi O. Enzel Y. Ben-Dor Y. & Amit R. (Eds) 2015. Atmospheric dust dust deposits (loess) and soils in the Negev Desert: guidebook for the Batsheva de Rothschild Seminar on Atmospheric Dust Dust Deposits (Loess) and Soils in Deserts and the Desert Fringe. Jerusalem & Negev Israel. Report GS1/22/2015.
Crouvi O. Amit R. Enzel Y. Porat N. & Sandler A. 2008. Sand dunes as a major proximal dust source for late Pleistocene loess in the Negev desert Israel. Quaternary Research 70 275–282.
Dare-Edwards A.J. 1983. Loessic clays of south-eastern Australia. Loess Letter Supplement 2 (Dust mantles in Australia) 3–15.
Dare-Edwards A.J. 1984. Aeolian clay deposits of south-eastern Australia: parna or loessic clay? Tranactions of the Institution of British Geographers 9 337–344.
Fitzsimmons K.E. Sprafke T. Zielhofer C. Gunter C. Deom J.-M. Sala R. & Iovita R. 2018. Loess accumulation in the Tien Shan piedmont: implications for palaeoenvironmental change in arid Central Asia. Quaternary International 469A 30–43.
Greeley R. & Williams S.H. 1994. Dust deposits on Mars; the ‘parna’ analog. Icarus 110 165–177.
Haberlah D. 2007. A call for Australian loess. Area 39 224–229.
Haberlah D. 2008. Response to Smalley’s discussion of ‘A call for Australian loess’. Area 40 135–136.
Heller F. & Liu T.S. 1982. Magnetostratigraphical dating of loess deposits in China. Nature 300 431–433.
Jefferson I. Rosenbaum M. & Smalley I.J. 2002. Mercia Mudstone as a Triassic Aeolian desert sediment. Mercian Geologist 15 157–162.
Keilhack K. 1920. Das Ratsel der Loessbildung. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Geologische Gesellschaft 72 146–161.
Li L. Chen J. Chen Y. Hedding D.W. Li T. Li L. Liu X. Zeng F. Wu W. Zhao L. & Li G. 2018. Uranium isotopic constraints on the provenance of dust on the Chinese Loess Plateau. Geologyhttps://doi.org/10.1130/G45130.1
Mavlyanov G.A. 1958. Genetical types of loesses and loess-like rocks in the central and southern parts of Central Asia and their engineering-geological properties. Izdatelstvo Akademii Nauk Uzbekistanskovo SSSR Tashkent 609 pp. (in Russian).
McLaren S.M. Svircev Z. O’Hara-Dhand K. Heneberg P. & Smalley I.J. 2014. Loess and bee-eaters II: The ‘loess’ of North Africa and the nesting behaviour of the Northern Carmine Bee-eater (Merops rubicus Gmelin 1788). Quaternary International 334/5 112–118.
Merzbacher G. 1913. Die Frage der Entstehung des Lösses. Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen 59 16–130.
Obruchev V.A. 1911. The question of the origin of loess in defense of the aeolian hypothesis. Izvestia Tomskovo Tekhnologiceskovo Instituta 33 (in Russian).
O’Hara-Dhand K. Taylor R.L.S. Smalley I.J. Krinsley D.H. & Vita-Finzi C. 2010. Loess and dust on Earth and Mars: particle generation by impact mechanisms. Open Geosciences 2 45–51.
Ojha L. Lewis K. Karunatillake S. & Schmidt M. 2018. The Medusae Fossae formation as the single largest source of dust on Mars. Nature Communications 9 2867.
Penck A. 1909. Die Morphologie der Wüsten. Geographische Zeitschrift 15 545–558.
Penck A. 1930. Central Asia. Geographical Journal 76 477–487.
Rahmani A. Hazzab A. & Aimer H. 2018. Identification et classification geotechnique du Loess de Ghardaia (Sud Algerien). Algerian Journal of Arid Environments 8 88–103.
Rogers C.D.F. & Smalley I.J. 1995. The adobe reaction and the use of loess mud in construction. Engineering Geology 40 137–138.
Smalley I.J. & Krinsley D.H. 1979. Eolian sedimentation on Earth and Mars: some comparisons. Icarus 40 276–288.
Smalley I.J. & Markovic S.B. 2018a. Four loess pioneers: Ch. Lyell F. von Richthofen V.A. Obruchev L.S. Berg. Quaternary International 469A 4–10.
Smalley I.J. & Markovic S.B. 2018b. Controls on the nature of loess particles and the formation of loess deposits. Quaternary International doi: org/10.1016/j.quaint.2017.08.021.
Smalley I.J. & Vita-Finzi C. 1968. The formation of fine particles in sandy deserts and the nature of ‘desert’ loess. Journal of Sedimentary Research 38 766–774.
Smalley I.J. McLaren S. & O’Hara-Dhand K. 2016. Loess and bee eaters IV: distribution of the Rainbowbird (Merops ornatus Latham 1801) in Australia. Quaternary International 399 240–245.
Smalley I.J. O’Hara-Dhand K. McLaren S. Svircev Z. & Nugent H. 2012. Loess and bee-eaters I: Ground properties affecting the nesting behaviour of European bee-eaters (Merops apiaster L 1758) in loess deposits. Quaternary International 296 220–226.
Stevens T. Carter A. Watson T.P. Vermeesch P. Ando S. Bird A.F. Lu H. Garzanti E. Cottam M.A. & Sevastjanova I. 2013. Genetic linkage between the Yellow River the Mu Us desert and the Chinese loess plateau. Quaternary Science Reviews 78 355–368.
Stuut J.-B. Smalley I.J. & O’Hara-Dhand K. 2009. Aeolian dust in Europe: African sources and European deposits. Quaternary International 198 234–245.
Sun J. & Windley B.F. 2015. Onset of aridification by 34 Ma across the Eocene-Oligocene transition in Central Asia. Geology 43 1015–1018.
Tsoar H. & Pye K. 1987. Dust transport and the question of desert loess formation. Sedimentology 34 139–153.
Whalley W.B. Marshall J.R. & Smith B. 1982. Origin of desert loess from some experimental observations. Nature 300 433–435.
Wright J.S. 1995. Glacial comminution of quartz sand grains and the production of loessic silt: a simulation study. Quaternary Science Reviews 14 669–680.
Wright J.S. 2001a. ‘Desert’ loess versus ‘glacial’ loess: quartz silt formation source areas and sediment pathways in the formation of loess deposits. Geomorphology 36 231–256.
Wright J.S. 2001b. Making loess-sized quartz silt: data from laboratory simulations and implications for sediment transport pathways and the formation of ‘desert’ loess deposits associated with the Sahara. Quaternary International 76 7–19.
Wright J.S. 2007. An overview of the role of weathering in the production of quartz silt. Sedimentary Geology 202 337–351.
Wright J.S. & Smith B. 1993. Fluvial comminution and the production of loess-sized quartz silt: a simulation study. Geografiska Annaler Physical Geography 75 25–34.
Wright J.S. Smith B. & Whalley W.B. 1998. Mechanisms of loess-sized quartz silt production and their relative effectiveness: laboratory simulations. Geomorphology 23 15–34.
Yaalon D.H. 1969. Origin of desert loess. Etudes Quaternaire du Monde Proceedings of the 8thINQUA Congress Paris 2 755 (reprinted in Smalley 1975).
Yaalon D.H. 1991. Mountain loess is not a suitable term. Area 23 255–256.