Federalism in Germany, Italy, and the European Union: History, Characteristics, and Perspectives

Open access


Federalism is always torn between the principles of subsidiarity and solidarity. Defining the federal structure of a country by finding the welfare-maximizing amount and design of government layers is challenging. Thereby, the financial endowment of different layers of government which they need to fulfill their respective tasks is an important aspect. European countries have chosen quite different federal designs to address the question of an optimal degree of fiscal decentralization. The aim of this paper is to analyze these different approaches for Germany, Italy, and the European Union. Parallels can be found in that all the three entities share a form of institutional asymmetry, a kind of fiscal bailout system, and a sort of fiscal equalization scheme.

Baskaran T., Tax decentralization and public deficits in OECD countries, J Federalism, 42 (4), 688-707, 2012.

Benz A., From joint decision traps to over-regulated federalism: adverse effects of a successful constitutional reform, German Polit, 17 (4), 440-456, 2008.

Blöchliger H., Vammalle C., Italy: law 42 on fiscal federalism, In: Reforming fiscal federalism and local government: beyond the zero-sum game, OECD Publishing, Paris, 2012.

Bönke T., Jochimsen B., Schröder C., Fiscal equalization and tax enforcement, German Econ Rev, 18 (3), 377-409, 2017.

Brennan G., Buchanan J.M., The power to tax: analytical foundations of a fiscal constitution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1980.

Broschek J., Historical institutionalism and the varieties of federalism in Germany and Canada, J Federalism, 42 (4), 662-687, 2012.

Bundesverfassungsgericht, Urteil des Zweiten Senats vom 19, Oktober 2006 – 2 BvF 3/03 – Rn. (1-256), 2006.

Calabresi S.G., Bickford L.D., Federalism and subsidiarity: perspectives from U.S. constitutional law, In: Fleming J.E., Levy J.T. (Eds.), Federalism and subsidiarity, 123-189, NYU Press, New York, 2014.

Eurostat, General government gross debt by subsector, percentage of total gross debt, non-consolidated between subsectors, 2016. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/File:General_government_gross_debt_by_subsector,_percentage_of_total_gross_debt,_non-consolidated_between_subsectors,_2016.png#filelinks (access Aug 21, 2018).

Frey B., Stutzer A., Happiness, economy and institutions, Econ J, 110, 918-938, 2000.

Funk A., Kleine Geschichte des Föderalismus – Vom Fürstenbund zur Bundesrepublik, Ferdinand Schöningh, 2010.

Giannotti V., I limiti di indebitamento degli enti locali nel V decreto correttivo e i vincoli del pareggio di bilancio, Bilancio e Contabilità, 2016. Available at: http://www.bilancioecontabilita.it/i-limiti-di-indebitamento-degli-enti-locali-nel-v-decreto-correttivo-e-i-vincoli-del-pareggio-di-bilancio-il-commento-di-v-giannotti.html (access Aug 21, 2018).

Giuriato L., Gastaldi F., The domestic stability pact in Italy: a rule for discipline? In: MPRA Paper No 15183, Munich, 2009.

Golemboski D., Federalism and the catholic principle of subsidiarity, J Federalism, 45 (4), 526-551, 2015.

Goodspeed T.J., Bailouts in a federation, Int Tax Public Finance, 9 (4), 409-421, 2002.

Green A., The federal alternative? A new view of modern German history, Hist J, 46 (1), 187-202, 2003.

Hitler A., Mein Kampf: English edition, translated by Marco Roberto, MVR, 1924/2015.

Jochimsen B., Fiscal federalism in Germany, German Polit, 17 (4), 541-558, 2008.

Keating M., Wilson A., Reforming Italy: institutional change and the federal option, Edinburgh Europa Paper Series, 2010.

Lanzilotta L., Evolution and transformation of the Italian federalism, speech at the European Institute, London School of Economics and Political Science, March 12, 2007.

Oates W.E., Fiscal federalism, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York, 1972.

Statistisches Bundesamt (Federal Statistical Office), Development of volume and structure of public debt in Germany. Available at: https://www.destatis.de/DE/ZahlenFakten/GesellschaftStaat/OeffentlicheFinanzenSteuern/OeffentlicheFinanzen/Schulden/Tabellen/SchuldenNichtOeffentlich_Insgesamt.html (access Aug 21, 2018).

Tiebout C., A pure theory of local expenditure, J Polit Econ, 64, 416-424, 1956.

Wicksell K., Finanztheoretische Untersuchungen nebst Darstellung und Kritik des Steuerwesens Schwedens, Jena, Gustav Fischer, 1896.

Wildasin D., Externalities and bailouts: hard and soft budget constraints in intergovernmental fiscal relations, In: World Bank policy research working paper No. 1843, 1997.