Review of pallet pooling studies

Open access


Development of sharing economy has brought new opportunities to the development of green logistics. Pallet pooling is a typical type of sharing economy. It has been recently promoted in almost every country in the world. Researchers have reached a common agreement that establishing an effective pallet pool is of great importance to the pallets use efficiency. It is also believed that the implementation of pallet pool will substantially contribute to the economic and social development. Detailed analysis of pallet pooling such as benefit analysis, mode choose, pallet allocation model & algorithm, quality control, etc. are discussed in this paper. Based on literature review, several important problems are listed for future study. These problems are information management, supply chain management, rental pricing, pallets tracking and allocation, quality control, sustainable development (carbon emissions), and “internet plus pallet pooling”. Some suggestions on China’s pallet pooling development are proposed as well.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] Ren J. W. (2012). Study on pallet allocation optimization over a pallet pool. Southwest Jiaotong University Chengdu China.

  • [2] Harris J. S. & Worrell J. S. (2008). Pallet management system: a study of the implementation of UID/RFID technology for tracking shipping materials within the department of defence distribution network. NAVAL Postgraduate School Monterey USA.

  • [3] Wu Q. Y. (2013). Study on unit logistic: part one. Logistics & Material Handling 16(6): 108-111.

  • [4] Jiang H. & Liu L. (2001). Pallet pooling is helpful to logistics operation. Logistics & Material Handling 6(4): 9-12.

  • [5] Wu Q. Y. (2003). Discussion on set up of china pallet pool system. Logistics & Material Handling 8(12): 1-4.

  • [6] Sakai K. J. (2003). Pallet pooling and environment. Logistics & Material Handling 8(6): 46-49.

  • [7] Auguston K. A. (1991). Is the U.S. ready for pallet pooling. Modern Materials Handling 46(8): 76.

  • [8] Don M. (1996). What makes reusable packaging systems work. Logistics Information Management 9(4): 39-42.

  • [9] Witt C. E. (1999). Economics of pallet rental. Material Handling Engineering 54(9): 47-48.

  • [10] Raballand G. & Carroll E. A. (2007). How do differing standards increase trade costs? The case of pallets. The World Economy 30(4): 685-702.

  • [11] Meng G. Q. & Sun K. Suggestions for China’ pallet pooling. China Logistics & Purchasing (23): 12-16.

  • [12] Li T. P. (2006). Study on the problem of China logistics pallet exchange system and its counter measure. East China Economic Management 20 (5): 58-98.

  • [13] Murray J. (1967). Pallet pool is key to Swedish cargo handling efficiency. The Journal of ICHCA 3(3): 27-29.

  • [14] Brindley C. (2010). Pallet math = profit$ for all: experts study the economic feasibility of an industry cooperative pool. Pallet Enterprise (4): 22-26.

  • [15] Brindley C. (2010). A look into china’s expanding logistical framework and its path toward palletization. Pallet Enterprise (11): 44-47.

  • [16] Brindley C. (2014). Asian expansion: LOSCAM reveals key insights for Asian pallet market growth. Pallet Enterprise (8): 18-22.

  • [17] Ray C. D. Michael J. H. & Scholnick B. N. (2006). Supply-chain system costs of alternative grocery industry pallet systems. Forest Products Journal 56(10): 52-57.

  • [18] Roy D. Carrano A. L. Pazour J. A. & Gupta A. (2016). Cost-effective pallet management strategies. Transportation Research Part E 93(9): 358-371.

  • [19] Lacefield S. (2004). What’s more “palatable”-renting or owning?. Logistics Management 43(4):63-66.

  • [20] Mosqueda A. (2009). Pallet user education series: Red white & blue: a cost analysis of rental vs. white wood pallets. Pallet Enterprise (7): 32-35 38.

  • [21] Michel R. (2014). Pallet Survey: How pallet trends stack up. Modern Materials Handling (10): 30-34.

  • [22] Lai Y. C. (2010). TPL plays a vital role in pallet pooling. China Logistics & Purchasing (18): 60-61.

  • [23] Yu L. (2008). Research on the development policies and measures of railway pallets transport. Beijing Jiaotong University Beijing China.

  • [24] Wang S. P. & Gu X. M. (2014). China pallet pool. China Business and Market 28(9): 21-27.

  • [25] Jin S. S. Xiong Q. X. Jiang M. X. Wang Y. L. & Feng D. Z. (2008). Study on Chinese pallet pool Co.Ltd and its construction strategy. Industrial Engineering Journal 11(4): 19-23.

  • [26] Ge H. Q. (2008). Study on the model and some related technical problems of Chinese pallet pool system. Zhejiang University of Technology Hangzhou China.

  • [27] Elia V. & GnonI M. G. (2015). Designing an effective closed loop system for pallet management. International Journal of Production Economics 170 (12): 730-740.

  • [28] Xu Q. (2010). Pallet pool supply chain management. China Business and Market 24(3):22-25.

  • [29] Gnoni M. G. & Rollo A. (2010). A scenario analysis for evaluating RFID investments in pallet management. International Journal of RF Technology Research 2(1): 1–21.

  • [30] Zhang Q. H. Wei J. Cheng G. Q. Wang Z. A. Yan D. W. & Zhao S. S. (2009). Pallet rental information system based on RFID. In: Proceedings of 4th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (pp. 886-891). New York USA:IEEE.

  • [31] Kim T. & Glock C. H. (2014). On the use of RFID in the management of reusable containers in closed-loop supply chains under stochastic container return quantities. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics Transportation Research 64(4): 12–27.

  • [32] Chen X. Z. Fu P. H. & Lv G. F. (2009). Study on pallet rental system based on RFID. China Logistics & Purchasing (18): 70-71.

  • [33] Zhao N. (2011). Quick response system for logistics pallets pooling service supply chain based on XML data sharing. Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering 98(2): 367-374.

  • [34] Li J. B. He S. W. Yin W. C. (2018). The study of pallet pooling information platform based on cloud computing. Scientific Programming 2018 (5):1-5.

  • [35] Ren J. W. Chen C. H. Xu H. & Zhao Q. Q. (2018). An optimization model for the operations of a pallet pool with both radio-frequency identification-tagged pallets and non-tagged pallets. Advances in Mechanical Engineering 10(1): 1-13.

  • [36] Brindley C. (2011). Position is everything: rising transport costs make pallet logistics more critical for success. Pallet Enterprise (6): 24-28.

  • [37] Doungpattra N. Jarupan L. & Ongkunaruk P. (2012). Simulation for transport pallet cost reduction in pet food manufacturing: an empirical case study. Packaging Technology and Science 25(6): 311-319.

  • [38] Ren J. W. & Zhang X. Y. (2010). Pallet recovery model based on modified pallet pool system. Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University 45(3): 482-485.

  • [39] Ren J. W. & Zhang X. Y. (2010). Pallet recovery stochastic programming model of pallet pool system. Control and Decision 25(8):1211-1214.

  • [40] Ren J. W. & Zhang X. Y. (2011). Two stage stochastic chance constrained programming model of pallet pool system dispatch. Control and Decision 26(9):1353-1357.

  • [41] Ren J. W. Zhang X. Y. Zhang J. & Ma L. (2014). A multi-scenario model for pallets allocation over a pallet pool. Systems Engineering Theory & Practice 34(7):1788-1798.

  • [42] Zhou K. He S. W. Song R. & You L. J. (2014). Optimization model of railway empty pallet dispatching based on the mode of pallet pool. Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University 38(3): 22-26.

  • [43] Zhou K. He S. W. Song R. & You L. J. (2015). Decision scheme optimization for empty pallets dispatching based on pallet pool mode. Control and Decision 30(11): 2009-2013.

  • [44] Zhou K. He S. W. & Song R. (2016). Optimization for service routes of pallet service center based on the pallet pool mode. Computational Intelligence and Neuroscience 2016(3):1-11.

  • [45] Ni L. He Y. D. Zhou L. & Deng L. (2015). Robust control optimization of triple-echelon closed-loop pallet pool system in multi-uncertain environment. Journal of Information and Computational Science 12(7): 2635-2645.

  • [46] Ren J.W Liu B. Wang Z.Y. (2017). An optimization model for multi-type pallet allocation over a pallet pool. Advances in Mechanical Engineering 9(5):1-9.

  • [47] Johnson S. (1954). Optimal two-and-three stage production schedules with setup time include. Naval Research Logistics Quarterly 1(1): 61-68.

  • [48] Ji Q. K. Hu X. P. & Sun L. J. (2014). Empty container allocation: status and perspectives. Systems Engineering Theory & Practice 36(6): 1578-1586.

  • [49] Baker D. S. (2011). Proprietary pallets continue to plague recyclers proposed Arizona law raises legal liability issue. Pallet Enterprise (4): 38-45.

  • [50] Bilbao A. Carrano A. Hewitt M. & Thorn B. (2011). On the environmental impacts of pallet management operations. Management Research Review 34(11): 1222-1236.

  • [51] Carrano A. L. Pazour J. A. Roy D. & Thorn B. K. (2015). Selection of pallet management strategies based on carbon emissions impact. International Journal of Production Economics 164 (6): 258-270.

  • [52] Bengtssona J. & Logiea J. (2015). Life cycle assessment of one-way and pooled pallet alternatives. Procedia CIRP 29: 414-419.

  • [53] Tornese F. Carrano A. L. Thorn B. K. & Pazour J. A. (2016). Carbon footprint analysis of pallet remanufacturing. Journal of Cleaner Production 126 (7): 630-642.

  • [54] Tornese F. Pazour J. A. Thorn B. K. Roy D. & Carrano A. L.(2018). Investigating the environmental and economic impact of loading conditions and repositioning strategies for pallet pooling providers. Journal of Cleaner Production 172 (1):155-168.

  • [55] Wu Q. Y. (2013). Study on unit logistics: part two. Logistics & Material Handling. 18(7):104-106.

  • [56] Xu Q. (2011). Collaborated Optimal Pricing Strategy of Pallets Pooling Supply Chain System. China Business and Market 25(7): 54-59.

  • [57] Wu J. Ren J. W. & Zhang X. Y. (2015). Pallet rental pricing. Price: Theory and Practice (11):162-164.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 255 255 30
PDF Downloads 209 209 24