In this paper, we use China’s 1986-2008 data to make an empirical analysis on the interrelationship between trade openness, economic growth and the structural change of labor-intensive industries by using simultaneous equation models and a VAR model. Our empirical study leads to the three conclusions. First, trade openness has accelerated economic growth, though with some negative impact on the development of labor-intensive industries; Second, economic growth has had a positive effect on trade openness, but again negatively impacted the development of labor-intensive industries. Third, the expansion of labor-intensive industries has had negative effects on both trade openness and economic growth.
Methodologically we rely on the transformation theory of industrial structure as an analytical framework to empirically study these three paradoxical outcomes. We introduce the three variables: trade openness, economic growth and the change of labor-intensive industries, as dependent as well as independent variables into our empirical models. And then we use technological progress, the share of secondary industries to GDP, total employment and investment ratio as control variables in order to test the robustness of the empirical results. In addition to explaining the factors responsible for changes in labor-intensive export industries we also provide two policy implications: First, labor-intensive industries should be scaled down to improve the efficiency of resources allocation. Second, China should timely transform its industrial structure of the export sectors from the one that is dominated by labor-intensive industries to the one that is dominated by capital (technology)-intensive industries so as to induce the export sectors to move in the direction favorable to the transformation of China’s present outward pattern of economic development.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Acemoglu A. (2002) Directed Technical Change Review of Economic Studies Vol. 69 pp. 781-809.
Cai F. Wang D.W. (2009) Flying Geese within Borders: How China Sustains its Labor-intensive Industries? (zhongguo chanye shengji de daguo yanzhen moxing fenxi) Economic Research Journal (jingji yanjiu) No. 9 pp. 4-14.
Chenery H. Robinson S. Syrquin M. (1986) Industrialization and Economic Growth: A Comparative Study The World Bank/Oxford University Press.
Gan C.H. Zheng R.G. (2009) An Empirical Study on Change of Industrial Structure and Productivity Growth since the Reform and Opening-up: A Test for the Structural Bonus Hypotheses from 1978 to 2007 in China (gaige kaifang yilai chanye jiegou yanjin yu shengchanlv zengzhang yanjiu: dui zhongguo 1978-2007 nian jiegou hongli jiashuo de jianyan) China Industrial Economics (zhongguo gongye jingji) No. 2 pp. 55-65.
Kuznets S. (1966) Economic Growth of Nations: Total Output and Production Structure Cambridge MA. USA Harvard University Press.
Kuznets S. (1971) Economic Growth of Nations: Total Output and Production Structure Cambridge MA. USA Harvard University Press.
Li G. Liao J.H. Xiang Y.N. (2011) Direction and Route of China’s Industrial Upgrading (zhongguo chanye shengji de fangxiang yu lujing) China Industrial Economics (zhongguo gongye jingji) No. 10 pp. 16-26.
Li G. Shen K.T. Guo C.X. (2009) Road to Enhance the Competitiveness of China’s Labor‑intensive Industries: A Survey after the Implement of China’s New Labor Contract Law (zhongguo laodong mijixing chanye jingzengli tisheng chulu hezai) China Industrial Economics (zhongguo gongye jingji) No. 9 pp. 37-46.
Li W. Zhang H. (2008) The Industrial Structure Change and Technological Progress in China’s Economic Growth (zhongguo jingji zengzhang zhong de chanye jiegou bianqian he jishu jinbu) Economic Research Journal (jingji yanjiu) No. 11 pp. 4-15.
Li X.P. Lu X.X. (2007) Structural Changes and Productivity Growth in China’s Manufacturing The Journal of World Economy (shijie jingji) No. 5 pp. 52-64.
Lin J.Y. (2012) New Structural Economics: A Framework for Rethinking Development and Policy Washington D.C. The World Bank.
Liu W. Li S.R. (2002) Industrial Structure and Economic Growth (chanye jiegou yu jingji zengzhang) China Industrial Economics (zhongguo gongye jingji) No. 5 pp. 14-21.
Nicet-Chenaf D. Rougier E. (2009) Human Capital and Structural Change: How do they Interact with each other in Growth? GRETHA UMR CNRS 5113 University of Bordeaux.
Peneder M. (2003) Industrial Structure and Aggregate Growth Structural Change and Economic Dynamics Vol. 14 No. 4 pp. 427-448.
Redding S. (1996) The Low=Skill Low‑Quality Trap: Strategic Complementarities between Human Capital and R&D Economic Journal Vol. 106 March pp. 458-470.
Ren B.Q. Huang H.W. Xu J.Y. (2005) A Review of Rough Labor‑intensive Industries in our Country (chongxin shenshi woguo chufangxing laodong miji chanye) Journal of International Trade (guoji maoyi wenti) No. 8 pp. 26-30.
Sun H. Shi Z.X. (2011) The Industrial Structure and Economic Growth of China: A Research Based on the Industry Labor Rate (zhongguo de chanye jiegou yu jingji zengzhang: jiyu hangye laodongli bilv de yanjiu) Population & Economics (renkou yu jingji) No. 2 pp. 1-6.
Syrquin M. (1988) Patterns of Structural Change in H.B. Chenery T.N. Srinivasan (eds.) Handbook of Development Economics Vol. 1 Elsevier Science Publishers B. V. pp. 203-273.
Timmer M. P. Szirmai A. (2000) Productivity Growth in Asian Manufacturing: The Structural Bonus Hypothesis Examined Structural Change and Economic Dynamics Vol. 11 pp. 371-392.
Wang D.W. Wang M.Y. Chen L. (2004) China’s Industrial Restructuring Efficiency and its Labour Allocation (zhongguo gongye de jiegou tiaozheng xiaolv yu laodong peizhi) Economic Research Journal (jingji yanjiu) No. 4 pp. 41-49.
Wang J. Zhang X.Z. (2012) A Study on the Curse Effects of China’s Labor Resources that Make Impacts on Economic Growth (zhongguo laodongli ziyuan yingxiang jingji zengzhang de zuzhou xiaoying yanjiu) Economic Science (jingji kexue) No. 6 pp. 48-58.
Westphal L.E. 1990 “Industrial Policy in an Export‑Propelled Economy: Lessons from South Korea’s Experience” Journal of Economic Perspectives Vol. 4 No. 3 pp. 41-59.
Xu Y. Zhang E.Z. (2008) Outsourcing and Productivity: Evidence From China (waibao yu shengchanlv jiyu gongye hnagshu shuju de jingyan yanjiu) Economic Research Journal (jingji yanjiu) No. 1 pp. 103-113.
Yuki K. (2008) Sectoral Shift Wealth Distribution and Development Macroeconomic Dynamics Vol. 12 pp. 527-559
Zhang M. Z. Li M. (2011) Impact of International Vertical Specialization on China’s Manufacturing Industry Upgrading: An Empirical Research (guoji chuizhi zhuanyehua fengong xia de zhongguo zhizaoye shengji ji jingyan fenxi) Journal of International Trade (guoji maoyi wenti) No. 1 pp. 118-128.
Zhang X.D. Sun J.W. (2006) An Analysis on International Competitiveness of Chinese Industries based on the Division of Labor of Vertical Specialization (jiyu chuizhi zhuanyehua fengong de zhongguo chanye guoji jingzhengli fenxi) The Journal of World Economy (shijie jingji) No. 5 pp. 12-21.