An Attempt to Assess the Quantitative Impact of Institutions on Economic Growth and Economic Development

Open access


This study aims at assessing to what extent institutional environment is responsible for worldwide differences in economic growth and economic development. To answer this question, we use an innovative approach based on a new concept of the institutions-augmented Solow model which is then estimated empirically using regression equations. The analysis covers 180 countries during the 1993-2012 period. The empirical analysis confirms a large positive impact of the quality of institutional environment on the level of economic development. The positive link has been evidenced for all five institutional indicators: two indices of economic freedom (Heritage Foundation and Fraser Institute), the governance indicator (World Bank), the democracy index (Freedom House), and the EBRD transition indicator for post-socialist countries. Differences in physical capital, human capital, and institutional environment explain about 70-75% of the worldwide differences in economic development. The institutions-augmented Solow model, however, performs slightly poorer in explaining differences in the rates of economic growth: only one institutional variable (index of economic freedom) has a statistically significant impact on economic growth. In terms of originality, this paper extends the theoretical analysis of the Solow model by including institutions, on the one hand, and shows a comprehensive empirical analysis of the impact of various institutional indicators on both the level of development and the pace of economic growth, on the other. The results bring important policy implications.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Acemoglu D. Johnson S. Robinson J.A. 2001 Te Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical Investigation American Economic Review No. 91 pp. 1369-1401

  • Aghion P. 2006 On Institutions and Growth in: Eicher T.S. García-Peñalosa C. ed. Institutions Development and Economic Growth Te MIT Press Cambridge - London

  • Barro R.J. 1996 Determinants of Economic Growth: A Cross-Country Empirical Study NBER Working Papers No. 5698

  • Barro R.J. Sala-i-Martin X. 2003 Economic growth Te MIT Press Cambridge-London Białowolski P. Kuszewski T. Witkowski B. 2010 Prognozy kombinowane wskaźników makroekonomicznych z użyciem danych z testów koniunktury Contemporary Economics No. 4 pp. 41-58

  • De Haan J. Siermann C.L.J. 1998 Further Evidence on the Relationship Between Economic Freedom and Economic Growth Public Choice No. 95 pp. 363-380

  • De Haan J. Sturm J.-E. 2000 On the Relationship Between Economic Freedom and Economic Growth European Journal of Political Economy No. 16 pp. 215-241 EBRD 2013 Economic Research and Data: (1.02.2013)

  • Eicher T.S. García-Peñalosa C. Teksoz U. 2006 How Do Institutions Lead Some Countries to Produce So Much More Output per Worker than Others? [in:] Eicher T.S. García-Peñalosa C. ed. Institutions Development and Economic Growth Te MIT Press Cambridge–London

  • Feng Y. 1997 Democracy Political Stability and Economic Growth British Journal of Political Science No. 27 pp. 391-418

  • Fraser Institute 2013 Economic Freedom of the World Annual Report: (1.02.2013)

  • Freedom House 2013 Freedom in the World: (1.02.2013) Graca-Gelert P. 2012 Income Inequality and Poverty in Poland in: Weresa M.A. ed. Poland. Competitiveness Report 2012. Focus on Education World Economy Research Institute Warsaw School of Economics Warsaw Hall R.E. Jones Ch.I. 1999 Why Do Some Countries Produce So Much More Output Per Worker Tan Others? Quarterly Journal of Economics No. 114 pp. 83-116

  • Heckelman J.C. Stroup M.D. 2000 Which Economic Freedoms Contribute to Growth? Kyklos No. 53 pp. 527-544

  • Hendry D.F. Krolzig H.-M. 2004 We Ran One Regression Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics No. 66 pp. 799-810

  • Heritage Foundation 2013 Index of Economic Freedom: (1.02.2013) Heston A. Summers R. Aten B. 2011 Penn World Table Version 7.0 Center for International Comparisons of Production Income and Prices at the University of Pennsylvania March: (1.02.2013).

  • IMF 2012 World Economic Outlook Database: (1.02.2013)

  • Leblang D.A. 1997 Political Democracy and Economic Growth: Pooled Cross-Sectional and Time-Series Evidence British Journal of Political Science No. 27 pp. 453-466

  • Mankiw N.G. Romer D. Weil D.N. 1992 A Contribution to the Empirics of Economic Growth Quarterly Journal of Economics No. 107 pp. 407-437

  • Mo P.H. 2001 Corruption and Economic Growth Journal of Comparative Economics No. 29 pp. 66-79

  • Nonneman W. Vanhoudt P. 1996 A Further Augmentation of the Solow Model and the Empirics of Economic Growth for OECD Countries Quarterly Journal of Economics No. 111 pp. 943-953

  • Persson K.G. 2010 An Economic History of Europe: Knowledge Institutions and Growth 600 to the Present Cambridge University Press Cambridge

  • Pitlik H. 2002 Te Path of Liberalization and Economic Growth Kyklos No. 55 pp. 57-79

  • Plümper T. Martin Ch.W. 2003 Democracy Government Spending and Economic Growth: A Political-Economic Explanation of the Barro-Efect Public Choice No. 117 pp. 27-50

  • Próchniak M. 2013 To What Extent Institutional Environment Is Responsible for Worldwide Diferences in Economic Development? Contemporary Economics (in print)

  • Próchniak M. Witkowski B. 2012a Konwergencja gospodarcza typu β w świetle bayesowskiego uśredniania oszacowań Bank i Kredyt No. 43 pp. 25-58

  • Próchniak M. Witkowski B. 2012b Bayesian Model Averaging in Modelling GDP Convergence with the Use of Panel Data Roczniki Kolegium Analiz Ekonomicznych SGH No. 26 pp. 45-60

  • Próchniak M. Witkowski B. 2013 Time Stability of the Beta Convergence among EU Countries: Bayesian Model Averaging Perspective Economic Modelling No. 30 pp. 322-333

  • Qian Y. Wu J. 2008 Transformation in China in: Kornai J. Mátyás L. Roland G. ed. Institutional Change and Economic Behaviour Palgrave - Macmillan Hampshire - New York

  • Rapacki R. 2007 Structural Reforms in: Rosati D. ed. New Europe. Report on Transformation XVII Economic Forum Krynica-Zdrój Poland 5-8 September 2007 Instytut Wschodni Warszawa

  • Rapacki R. 2009 Wzrost gospodarczy w krajach transformacji: konwergencja czy dywergencja? PWE War-szawa

  • Rapacki R. Próchniak M. 2006 Charakterystyka wzrostu gospodarczego w krajach postsocjalistycznych w la-tach 1990-2003 Ekonomista No. 6 pp. 715-744

  • Rapacki R. Próchniak M. 2009 Te EU Enlargement and Economic Growth in the CEE New Member Countries Economic Papers 367 European Commission

  • Rapacki R. Próchniak M. 2010 Wpływ rozszerzenia Unii Europejskiej na wzrost gospodarczy i realną kon-wergencję krajów Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej Ekonomista No. 4 pp. 523-546

  • Rapacki R. Próchniak M. 2012 Wzrost gospodarczy w krajach Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej na tle wybra-nych krajów wschodzących Gospodarka Narodowa No. 1-2 pp. 65-96

  • Rivera-Batiz F.L. 2002 Democracy Governance and Economic Growth: Teory and Evidence Review of Development Economics No. 6 pp. 225-247

  • Rodrik D. 2007 One Economics Many Recipes. Globalization Institutions and Economic Growth Princeton University Press Princeton – Oxford

  • Scully G.W. 2002 Economic Freedom Government Policy and the Trade-Of Between Equity and Economic Growth Public Choice No. 113 pp. 77-96

  • Solow R.M. 1956 A Contribution to the Teory of Economic Growth Quarterly Journal of Economics No. 70 pp. 65-94

  • Sturm J.-E. Leertouwer E. de Haan J. 2002 Which Economic Freedoms Contribute to Growth? A Comment Kyklos No. 55 pp. 403-416

  • Sulejewicz A. 2009 Czynniki instytucjonalne w badaniach wzrostu gospodarczego krajów transformacji [in:] ed. R. Rapacki Wzrost gospodarczy w krajach transformacji: konwergencja czy dywergencja? PWE Warszawa Sulejewicz A. Graca P. 2005 Measuring the Transaction Sector in the Polish Economy 1996-2002 paper presented at the 9th Annual Conference of International Society for New Institutional Economics Barcelona Śledziewska K. Witkowski B. 2012 Światowy kryzys gospodarczy a handel międzynarodowy Ekonomista No. 4 pp. 427-448

  • Tridico P. 2011 Institutions Human Development and Economic Growth in Transition Economies Palgrave - Macmillan Hampshire - New York

  • Weede E. Kämpf S. 2002 Te Impact of Intelligence and Institutional Improvements on Economic Growth Kyklos No. 55 pp. 361-380

  • Wojtyna A. 2002 Nowe kierunki badań nad rolą instytucji we wzroście i transformacji Gospodarka Narodo-wa No. 10 pp. 1-24

  • Wojtyna A. 2007 Teoretyczny wymiar zależności między zmianami instytucjonalnymi polityką ekonomiczną a wzrostem gospodarczym Gospodarka Narodowa No. 5-6 pp. 1-23

  • World Bank 2013 World Development Indicators and Doing Business Databases: www.databank.worldbank. org/ (1.02.2013)

  • Wu W. Davis O.A. 1999 Te Two Freedoms Economic Growth and Development: An Empirical Study Public Choice No. 100 pp. 39-64

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 410 150 4
PDF Downloads 208 62 8