The CJEU Crossing the Rubicon on the Same-Sex Marriages? Commentary on Coman Case

Open access


The article analyses the decision of the EU Court of Justice in Coman in which the Court derived residence rights for spouses in the same-sex marriages. The article outlines the basic grounds of the judgement and critically appraises them in the context of EU primary as well as secondary law and especially Directive 2004/38. The article raises concerns about the division of competences between the EU and its Mem­ber States, extended interpretation of the term “spouse” in the context of EU law, human rights considerations as well as potential effects of the decision on national family law.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Craig Paul De Búrca Gráinne. EU Law Text Cases And Materials. Oxford: Oxford Uni­versity Press 6th Ed. 2015.

  • Kruma Kristine. Family Reunification: A Toll To Shape The Concept Of EU Citizenship In: Maribel Gonzales Pascual Aida Torres Pérez. The Right To Family Life In The European Union. Routledge 2017.

  • Stehlík Václav Hamuľák Ondrej. Legal Issues Of EU Internal Market: Understanding Four Freedoms Palacký University Olomouc 2013.

  • Tryfonidu Alina. The Impact Of Union Citizenship On The EU’s Market Freedoms. Hart Publishing Oxford 2016.

  • Tryfonidou Alina. Purely Internal Situations And Reverse Discrimination In A Citi­zens’ Europe: Time To “Reverse” Reverse Discrimination? In: Xuereb Peter (Ed.) Issues In Social Policy: A New Agenda. Jean Monnet Seminar Series. Progress Press Valletta 2009.

  • Vries De Sybe Waele De Henri Granger Marie-Pierre (Eds.). Civil Rights And Eu Citizenship: Challenges At The Crossroads Of The European National And Private Spheres. Edward Elgar Publishing Cheltenham 2018

  • Bureš Pavel. Human Dignity: An Illusory Limit For The Evolutive Interpretation Of The Echr? Amicus Curiae Issue 110 Summer 2017

  • Dzehtsiarou Kanstantsin. European Consensus And The Evolutive Interpretation Of The European Convention On Human Rights. German Law Journal 12 2011

  • Sánchez Sara Iglesias. Purely Internal Situations And The Limits Of EU Law: A Consoli­dated Case Law Or A Notion To Be Abandoned? Euconst 14 2018

  • Lenaerts Koen. The Court Of Justice And The Comparative Law Method. Eli Annual Conference Eli Ferrara 9 September 2016 [Online]. Available Here: Https://Www.Europeanlawinstitute.Eu/Fileadmin/User_Upload/P_Eli/General_Assembly/2016/K._Lenaerts_ELI_AC_2016.Pdf Accessed: 30.10.2018

  • Stanciu Roxana. A Disturbing Decision By The EU’s Court Of Justice Redefines The Term ‘Spouses’ [Online]. Available Here: Http://Www.Europeandignitywatch.Org/Disturb­ing-Decision-By-The-Eu-Court-Of-Justice-Redefines-The-Term-Spouses/ Accessed: 30.10.2018

  • Tan Daron. Adrian Coman V. Romania: A Small Victory With Wasted Potential. Oxhrh Blog 19 June 2018 [Online]. Available Here: Http://Ohrh.Law.Ox.Ac.Uk/Adrian-Coman-V-Romania-A-Small-Victory-With-Wasted-Potential Accessed: 30.10.2018

  • Tryfonidou Alina. Free Movement Of Same-Sex Spouses Within The Eu: The Ecj’s Coman Judgment [Online]. Available Here: Https://Europeanlawblog.Eu/2018/06/19/Free-Movement-Of-Same-Sex-Spouses-Within-The-Eu-The-Ecjs-Coman-Judgment Accessed: 30.10.2018.

Journal information
Target audience: researchers and experts in the field of International law and EU Law
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 176 176 9
PDF Downloads 183 183 13