Correspondence of butterfly and host plant diversity: foundation for habitat restoration and conservation

Open access

Abstract

At a spatial scale, the diversity of butterflies varies with numerous factors including the availability of the host plant species. In parity with this proposition, the correspondence of diversity of butterfly and plant in the background of the urban–rural gradient was evaluated using Kolkata, India, as a model study area. The results reveal significant positive correlation between the diversity of butterflies and the plants, with the different values for the suburban, rural, and urban areas. Identification of the butterfly loads for the plants in the respective areas can be useful in enhancing the conservation of the butterflies through enhanced plantation of the concerned plant species. Alternatively, the disclosure of the generalist and specialist pattern of the plant species preference by the butterflies may be useful in enhancing the population of the respective species in the concerned areas. The conservation strategy for butterfly species may be refined through the use of both or any one of the quantitative assessment of the butterfly–plant links in the urban–rural gradient in Kolkata, India, and similar places in the world.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Addinsoft S.A.R.L. (2010). XLSTAT software Version 10.0 Paris France.

  • Araújo M.B. & Luoto M. (2007) The importance of biotic interactions for modelling species distributions under climate change. Global Ecology and Biogeography 16 743–753.

  • Barranco-León M.N. Luna-Castellanos F. Vergara C.H. & Badano E.I. (2016) Butterfly conservation within cities: a landscape scale approach integrating natural habitats and abandoned fields in central Mexico. Tropical Conservation Science 9 (2)607-628.

  • Bassa M. Chamorro L. Jose´-María L. Blanco-Moreno J.M. & Sans F.X. (2012) Factors affecting plant species richness in field boundaries in the Mediterranean region. Biodiversity Conservation 211101–1114.

  • Benadi G. (2015) Requirements for plant coexistence through pollination niche partitioning. Proceedings of the Royal Society 282: i.d. 20150117.

  • Bergerot B. Fontaine B. Julliard R. & Baguette M. (2011) Landscape variables impact the structure and composition of butterfly assemblages along an urbanization gradient. Landscape Ecology 26 83–94.

  • Blair R.B. & Launer A.E. (1997) Butterfly diversity and human land use: Species assemblages along an urban gradient. Biological Conservation 80113–125.

  • Bonebrake T.C. Ponisio L.C. Boggs C.L. & Ehrlich P.R. (2010) More than just indicators: a review of tropical butterfly ecology and conservation. Biological Conservation 143(8) 1831-1841.

  • Cameron G.N. Culley T.M. Kolbe S.E. Miller A.I. & Matter S.E. (2015) Effects of urbanization on herbaceous forest vegetation: the relative impacts of soil geography forest composition human access and an invasive shrub. Urban Ecosystem 18(4)1051–1069.

  • Clark. P.J. Reed J.M. & Chew F.S. (2007) Effects of urbanization on butterfly species richness guild structure and rarity. Urban Ecosystem 10321–337.

  • Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (2006) Paying for Parks Eight Models for Funding Urban Green Spaces. Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment London UK http://www.cabe.org.uk/AssetLibrary/8899.pdf.

  • Courtney S.P. (1986) The ecology of pierid butterflies: dynamics and interactions. Advances in Ecological Research 15 51–116.

  • Croxton P.J. Hann J.P. Greatorex-Davies J.N. & Sparks T.H. (2005) Linear hotspots? The floral and butterfly diversity of green lanes. Biological Conservation 121(4) 579–584.

  • Farhat Y.A. Janousek W.M. McCarty J.P. Rider N. & Wolfenbarger L.L. (2014) Comparison of butterfly communities and abundances between marginal grasslands and conservation lands in the eastern Great Plains. Journal of Insect Conservation 18(2) 245-256.

  • Ferrer–Paris J.R. Sánchez–Mercado A. Viloria Á.L. & Donaldson J. (2013) Congruence and diversity of butterfly–host plant associations at higher taxonomic levels. PLoS One 8(5): e63570.

  • Feltwell J. (1986) The natural history of butterflies. London: Croom Helm.

  • Grimm N.B. Foster D. Groffman P. Grove J.M. Hopkinson C.S. Nadelhoffer K.J. et.al. (2008) The changing landscape: ecosystem responses to urbanization and pollution across climatic and societal gradients. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6(5) 264-272.

  • Hardy P.B. Sparks T.H. Isaac N.J. & Dennis R.L. (2007) Specialism for larval and adult consumer resources among British butterflies: implications for conservation. Biological conservation 138(3-4) 440-452.

  • Heip C.H.R. Herman P.M.J. & Soetaert K. (1998) Indices of diversity and evenness. Institute of Oceanography 24 (4) 61–87.

  • Hogsden K.L. & Hutchinson T.C. (2004) Butterfly assemblages along a human disturbance gradient in Ontario Canada. Canadian Journal of Zoology 82(5)739-748.

  • Huang L. Chen H. Ren H. Wang J. & Guo Q. (2013) Effect of urbanization on the structure and functional traits of remnant subtropical evergreen broad-leaved forests in South China. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 185(6) 5003–5018.

  • Humpden N.N. & Nathan G.N. (2010) Effects of plant structure on butterfly diversity in Mt. Marsabit Forest–northern Kenya. African Journal of Ecology 48(2) 304–312.

  • Jonason D. Andersson G.K.S. Öckinger E. Rundlöf M. Smith H.G. & Bengtsson J. (2011) Assessing the effect of the time since transition to organic farming on plants and butterflies. Journal of Applied Ecology 48 543–550.

  • José-María L. Armengot L. Blanco-Moreno J.M. Bassa M. & Sans F.X. (2010) Effects of agricultural intensification on plant diversity in Mediterranean dryland cereal fields. Journal of Applied Ecology 47 832–840.

  • Josephitis E.S. (2014) Central Florida butterfly conservation: The importance of host plants in Sandhill and urban habitats. Honors Program Theses. Paper 2.

  • Kamimura Y. (2004) Nectar-source plants and their usage patterns by an adult butterfly community in a riparian biotope. National Environment Science Research 17107–115.

  • Kehimkar I. (2000) Common Indian wild flower. Mumbai: Bombay Natural History Society/Oxford University Press.

  • Kinnear P.R. & Gray C.D. (2000) SPSS for windows made simple. Release 10. Sussex: Psychology Press.

  • Kitahara M. & Sei K. (2001) A comparison of the diversity and structure of butterfly communities in semi-natural and human-modified grassland habitats at the foot of Mt. Fuji central Japan. Biodiversity and Conservation 10 331–351

  • Kitahara M. Yumoto M. & Kobayashi. T. (2008) Relationship of butterfly diversity with nectar plant species richness in and around the Aokigahara primary woodland of Mount Fuji central Japan. Biodiversity and Conservation 17(11)2713-2734.

  • Kocher S.D. & Williams EH (2000) The diversity and abundance of North American butterflies vary with habitat disturbance and geography. Journal of Biogeography 27(4) 785-794.

  • Koh L.P. & Sodhi N.S. (2004) Importance of reserves fragments and parks for butterfly conservation in a tropical urban landscape. Ecological Applications 14(6) 1695-1708.

  • Konvicka M. & Kadlec T. (2011) How to increase the value of urban areas for butterfly conservation? A lesson from Prague nature reserves and parks. European Journal of Entomology 108(2) 219–229.

  • Kristoffersen P. Rask A.M. Grundy A.C. Franzen I. Kempenaar C. Raisio J. et al. (2008) A review of pesticide policies and regulations for urban amenity areas in seven European countries. Weed Research 48 201–214.

  • Lee C.M. & Kwon T-S. (2012) Characterization of the butterfly community of a fragmented urban forest Hongneung Forest. Korean Journal of Applied Entomology 51 317-323.

  • Lee C.M. Park J.W. Kwon T-S. Kim S-S. Ryu J.W. Jung S.J. et. al. (2015) Diversity and density of butterfly communities in urban green areas: an analytical approach using GIS. Zoological Studies 54(4)1-12.

  • Legendre P. & Legendre L. (1998) Numerical Ecology Developments in Environmental Modelling. The Netherlands : Elsevier Science BV.

  • Lepczyk C.A. Aronson M.F. Evans K.L. Goddard M.A. Lerman S.B. & Macivor J.S. (2017) Biodiversity in the city: fundamental questions for understanding the ecology of urban green spaces for biodiversity conservation. BioScience 67(9) 799-807.

  • Leston L. & Koper N. (2017) Urban rights-of-way as extensive butterfly habitats: A case study from Winnipeg Canada. Landscape and Urban Planning 157 56–62.

  • Liivamägi A. Kuusemets V. Kaart T. Luig J. & Diaz-Forero I. (2014) Influence of habitat and landscape on butterfly diversity of semi-natural meadows within forest-dominated landscapes. Journal of Insect Conservation 18(6) 1137-1145.

  • Loos J. Dorresteijn I. Hanspach J. Fust P. Rakosy L. & Fischer J. (2014). Low-intensity agricultural landscapes in Transylvania support high butterfly diversity: implications for conservation. PLoS ONE 9(7) e103256.

  • Luoto M. Rekolainen S. Aakkula J. & Pykälä J. (2003) Loss of plant species richness and habitat connectivity in grasslands associated with agricultural change in Finland. Ambio 32(7)447-452.

  • Maccherini S. Bacaro G. Favilli L. Piazzini S. Santi E. & Marignani M. (2009) Congruence among vascular plants and butterflies in the evaluation of grassland restoration success. Acta Oecologica 35(2) 311-317.

  • Majumder J. Lodh R. & Agarwala B. (2012) Variation in butterfly diversity and unique species richness along different habitats in Trishna Wildlife Sanctuary Tripura northeast India. Check List 8(3)432-436.

  • Mandal S.K. & Jana D. (2012) Common Indian herbs and shrubs. Kolkata: Boikarigar.

  • McAleece N. Gage J.D. Lambshead P.J.D. & Paterson G.L.J. (1997) Biodiversity Professional. Oban: The Natural History Museum and The Scottish Association for Marine Science.

  • McKinney M.L. (2002) Urbanization biodiversity and conservation. Bioscience 52883–890.

  • Mckinney M.L. (2008) Effect of urbanization on species richness: A review of plants and animals. Urban Ecosystem 11161-176.

  • MicroImages Inc. 2015. TNTmips® 7.2 packages. MicroImages Inc. Lincoln Nebraska USA.

  • Moroń D. Przybyłowicz Ł. Nobis M. Nobis A. Klichowska E. Lenda M. et al. (2017) Do levees support diversity and affect spatial turnover of communities in plant-herbivore systems in an urban landscape. Ecological Engineering 105 198–204.

  • Mukherjee S. Aditya G. Basu P. & Saha G.K. (2016) Butterfly diversity in Kolkata metropolis: a synoptic check list. Check List 12(2) 1858.

  • Mukherjee S. Banerjee S. Basu P. Saha G.K. & Aditya G. (2015b) Lantana camara and butterfly abundance in an urban landscape: benefits for conservation or species invasion? Ekológia (Bratislava) 34(4)309–328.

  • Mukherjee S. Banerjee S. Saha G.K. Basu P. & Aditya G. (2015a). Butterfly diversity in Kolkata India: an appraisal for conservation management. Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 8(3) 210–221.

  • Myers N. Mittermeier R.A. Mittermeier C.G. Da Fonseca G.A. & Kent J. (2000) Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403(6772) 853.

  • Nimbalkar R.K. Chandekar S.K. & Khunte S.P. (2011) Butterfly diversity in relation to nectar food plants from Bhor Tahsil Pune District Maharashtra India. Journal of Threaten Taxa 3(3) 1601-1609.

  • Ouin A. & Burel F. (2002) Influence of herbaceous elements on butterfly diversity in hedgerow agricultural landscapes. Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment 93 45–53.

  • Paria N.D. (2005) Medicinal plant resources of South West Bengal. Kolkata: Directors of Forests Government of West Bengal Kolkata.

  • Paria N.D. (2010) Medicinal plant resources of South West Bengal volume II. Kolkata: Directors of Forests Government of West Bengal Kolkata.

  • Patel A.P. & Pandya N.R. (2014). Assessment of temporal and spatial variation in species richness and diversity of butterfly host plants. International Journal of Plant Animal Environment Science 4(3)235-245.

  • Pe’er G. van Maanen C. Turbé A. Matsinos Y.G. & Kark S. (2011) Butterfly diversity at the ecotone between agricultural and semi-natural habitats across a climatic gradient. Diversity and Distributions 17(6) 1186-1197.

  • Pickett S.T. Cadenasso M.L. Grove J.M. Boone C.G. Groffman P.M. Irwin E. et al. (2011) Urban ecological systems: Scientific foundations and a decade of progress. Journal of Environmental Management 92(3) 331-362.

  • Pollard E. (1977). A method for assessing changes in the abundance of butterflies. Biological Conservation 12 115–134.

  • Pollard E. & Yates T.J. (1993) Monitoring butterflies for ecology and conservation. London: Chapman and Hall.

  • Quinn R.M. Caston K.J. & Roy D.B. (1998) Coincidence in the distributions of butterflies and their food plants. Ecography 21 279-288.

  • Ramírez-Restrepo L. & Halffter G. (2013) Butterfly diversity in a regional urbanization mosaic in two Mexican cities. Landscape and Urban Planning 115 39–48.

  • Ramírez-Restrepo L. & MacGregor-Fors I. (2017) Butterflies in the city: a review of urban diurnal Lepidoptera. Urban Ecosystems 20(1) 171–182.

  • Rundlöf M. Bengtsson J. & Smith H. (2008) Local and landscape effects of organic farming on butterfly species richness and abundance. Journal of Applied Ecology 45 813-820.

  • Sagwe R.N. Muya S.M. & Maranga R. (2015) Effects of land use patterns on the diversity and conservation status of butterflies in Kisii highlands Kenya. Journal of Insect Conservation 191119–1127.

  • Sakuratani Y. & Fujiyama S. (1991) Influence of highway construction on butterfly communities. Japanese Journal of Environmental Entomology and Zoology 3 15-23.

  • Schultz C.B. & Dlugosch K.M. (1999) Nectar and host plant scarcity limit populations of an endangered oregon butterfly. Oecologia 119231-238

  • Shreeve T.G. (1992) “Adult behaviour.” The ecology of butterflies in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Smallidge P.J. & Leopold D.J. (1997). Vegetation management for the maintenance and conservation of butterfly habitats in temperate human-dominated landscapes. Landscape and Urban Planning 38(3)259-280.

  • Soga M. & Koike S. (2012) Relative importance of quantity quality and isolation of patches for butterfly diversity in fragmented urban forests. Ecological Research 27(2) 265–271.

  • Soga M. Kawahara T. Fukuyama K. Sayama K. Kato T. Shimomura M. et. al. (2015) Landscape versus local factors shaping butterfly communities in fragmented landscapes: Does host plant diversity matter? Journal of Insect Conservation 19781–790.

  • Sparks T.H. Bellamy P.E. Eversham B.C. Greatorex-Davies J.N. Hinsley S.A. Jones S.M. et.al (1996) The effects of three hedge management treatments on the wildlife of a Cambridgeshire Hedgerow. Annals of Applied Biology 44277–284.

  • Stout J.C. & Casey L.E. (2014) Relative abundance of an invasive alien plant affects insect-flower interaction networks in Ireland. Acta Oecologia 5578–85.

  • Tam K.C. & Bonebrake T.C. (2016) Butterfly diversity habitat and vegetation usage in Hong Kong urban parks. Urban Ecosystem 19721–733.

  • Tiple A.D. Deshmukh V.P. & Dennis R.L.H. (2006) Factors influencing nectar plant resource visits by butterflies on a university campus: implications for conservation. Nota Lepidopterologica 28 (3/4) 213–224.

  • Tiple A.D. Khurad A.M. & Dennis R.L.H. (2009) Adult butterfly feeding-nectar flower associations: constraints of taxonomic affiliation butterfly and nectar flower morphology. Journal of Natural History 43(13–14) 855–888.

  • Tiple A.D. Khurad A.M. & Dennis R.L.H. (2011) Butterfly larval host plant use in a tropical urban context: Life history associations herbivory and landscape factors. Journal of Insect Science 11 (1) 65.

  • Tudor O. Dennis R.L.H. Greatorex-Davies J.N. & Sparks T.H. (2004) Flower preferences of woodland butterflies in the UK: nectaring specialists are species of conservation concern. Biological Conservation 119(3) 397–403.

  • van Halder I. Barbaro L. Corcket E. & Jactel H. (2008) Importance of semi-natural habitats for the conservation of butterfly communities in landscapes dominated by pine plantations. Biodiversity and Conservation 17(5) 1149-1169.

  • Von der Lippe M. & Kowarik I. (2008) Do cities export biodiversity? Traffic as dispersal vector across urban–rural gradients. Divers Distributions 14(1) 18-25.

  • Wilson K.A. Cabeza M. & Klein C.J. (2009) Fundamental concepts of spatial conservation prioritization. Spatial conservation prioritization: quantitative methods and computational tools. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Yamamoto N. Yokoyama J. & Kawata M. (2007) Relative resource abundance explains butterfly biodiversity in island communities. PNAS 104 10524-10529.

  • Zar J.H. (1999) Biostatistical analysis. IV edn. New Delhi (Indian Branch): India Pearson Education (Singapore) (P) Ltd.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 0.84

Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.365

Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 87 87 37
PDF Downloads 62 62 33