Control of Electric Drives in the Best Efficiency Region of Pumping System

Open access


The paper concentrates on improving the efficiency of the pumping system in which pumps are run by variable speed drives. The method is applicable to system consisting of several centrifugal pumps. Problems arising from running the pumps outside the optimal efficiency region are discussed. Common principles of operation and control of typical boosting pumping station are represented. Methods of regulation of productivity of the system are described. The proposed method is based on prediction of future efficiency of pumps before making adjustments of pumping system productivity. The proposed method is basing on tracking the working point of pump on efficiency graph. Monitoring the location of working point vs. efficiency graph enables to evaluate its current and future distances from the best efficiency point of the pump. Knowing the current number of running pumps it is possible to predict the location of working point after adjustment of productivity of the system. Ability to predict the increase or decrease of efficiency enables to enhance the adjustment of productivity of the system. Methods of graphical analysis of working state of the pumping system are representing topic for future research.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • [1] Iea Report 2009 Iea Statistics Co2 Emissions from fuel combustion.

  • [2] I. I. Ionel Pumps and Pumping with Particular Reference to Variable-Duty Pumps Amsterdam: Elsevier 1986 p. 715.

  • [3] V. Vodovozov I. Bakman. (2013) “Slip Compensation in Sensorless Scalar Electric Drive of a Pump” 54th International Scientific Conference of Riga Technical University. Riga: Riga Technical University 2013 pp. 27.1–27.4.

  • [4] T. Ahonen. Monitoring of Centrifugal Pump Operation by a Frequency Converter Doctoral Thesis Lappeenranta University of Technology 2011 p. 134.

  • [5] L. Szychta “Analysis of efficiency characteristics of squirrelcage induction motor for pump applications” 14th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference Epe-Pemc 2009 pp. 73 – 78.

  • [6] R. C. Dorf Modern Control Systems Prentice Hall 2001 831 p.

  • [7] I. J. Karassik and T. McGuire Centrifugal Pumps Ny Usa: Chapman & Hall 1998.

  • [8] M. Pechenik O. Kiselychnyk S. Buryan and D. Petukhova “Sensorless control of water supply pump based on neural network estimation”

  • [9] Z. Raud V. Vodovozov and M. Egorov “A toolbox to design and study electric drives” 14th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference Epe-Pemc 2010 Ohrid Macedonia 2010 pp. T5-142-T5-148.

  • [10] V. Vodovozov I. Bakman “Sensorless pressure control of centrifugal pumps” 8th International Conference-Workshop on Compatibility and Power Electronics Cpe 2013 Ljubljana Slovenia 2013 pp. 304–309.

  • [11] V. Vodovozov I. Bakman “Control of liquid density to prevent abnormal pumping performance” 7th Wseas International Conference on Waste Management Water Pollution Indoor Climate Wwai 2013 Lemesos Cyprus 2013 pp. 217–222.

  • [12] ABB Product Notes: Flow Calculation in ABB Industrial Drives ABB Helsinki Finland 2006.

  • [13] T. Ahonen J. Tamminen J. Ahola and J. Kestilä “Frequency-converter-based hybrid estimation method for the centrifugal pump operational state“IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics vol. 59 no. 12 2012 pp. 4803–4809.

  • [14] Z. Raud V. Vodovozov T. Lehtla and E. Pettai “Simulation tools to study power electronics” 13th European Conference on Power Electronics and Applications Epe 2009 Barcelona Spain 2009 paper 0013.

  • [15] F. Abrahamsen F. Blaabjerg J. K. Pedersen P. Z. Grabowski and P. Thøgersen “On the energy optimized control of standard and high efficiency induction motors in Ct and Hvac applications” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Applications v. 34 n. 4 1998 pp. 822–831.

  • [16] ABB Technical Guide No. 1: Direct Torque Control ABB Helsinki Finland 2002.

  • [17] IEC 60034-2-1: Rotating Electrical Machines – Part 2–1: Standard Methods for Determining Losses and Efficiency from Tests (Excluding Machines for Traction Vehicles) 2007.

  • [18] P. Girdhar Centrifugal Pumps Design Operation and Maintenance London: Elsevier 2005 p. 244.

  • [19] ABB ACQ810 Firmware manual ABB Helsinki Finland 2012.

  • [20] I. Bakman L. Gevorkov V. Vodovozov “Predictive Control of a Variable-Speed Multi-Pump Motor Drive” 2014 IEEE 23 rd International Symposium on Industrial Electronics (ISIE 2014) Istanbul Turkey June 1st to 4th 2014.

Journal information
Cited By
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 1408 1294 7
PDF Downloads 120 101 5