The challenge of brain death for the sanctity of life ethic

  • 1 University Center for Human Values, Princeton University, School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, University of Melbourne


For more than thirty years, in most of the world, the irreversible cessation of all brain function, more commonly known as brain death, has been accepted as a criterion of death. Yet the philosophical basis on which this understanding of death was originally grounded has been undermined by the long-term maintenance of bodily functions in brain dead patients. More recently, the American case of Jahi McMath has cast doubt on whether the standard tests for diagnosing brain death exclude a condition in which the patient is not dead, but in a minimally conscious state. I argue that the evidence now clearly shows that brain death is not equivalent to the death of the human organism. We therefore face a choice: either we stop removing vital organs from brain dead patients, or we accept that it is not wrong to kill an innocent human who has irreversibly lost consciousness.

Falls das inline PDF nicht korrekt dargestellt ist, können Sie das PDF hier herunterladen.

  • AVIV, R. (2018): What does it mean to die? In: New Yorker, February 5.

  • BEECHER, H. (1967): Henry Beecher to Robert Ebert. In: D. Rothman (1991): Strangers at the Bedside. New York: Basic books, pp. 160–161.

  • ENGELHARDT, T., Jr. (1975): Defining death: A philosophical problem for medicine and law. In: American Review of Respiratory Disease, 112(5), pp. 587–590.

  • GREEN, M. & WIKLER, D. (1980): Brain Death and Personal Identity. In: Philosophy and Public Affairs, 9(2), pp. 105–133.

  • GRIZEZ, G. & BOYLE, J. (1979): Life and Death with Liberty and Justice. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.

  • JOHNSTON, M. (1987): Human beings. In: Journal of Philosophy, 84(2), pp. 59–83.

  • KUHSE, H. (1987): The Sanctity-of-Life Doctrine in Medicine: A Critique. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • LAMB, D. (1985): Death, brain death and ethics. London: Croom Helm.

  • LIZZA, J. (2006): Persons, Humanity, and the Definition of Death. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

  • LIZZA, J. (2018): Defining Death: Beyond Biology. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 1–19.

  • MACHADO, C. (1995): A New Definition of Death Based on the Basic Mechanism of Consciousness Generation in Human Beings. In: C. Machado (ed.): Brain Death: Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on Brain Death. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 57–66.

  • MCMAHAN, J. (1995): The Metaphysics of Brain Death. In: Bioethics, 9(2), pp. 91–126.

  • MILLER, F. & TRUOG, R. (2011): Death, Dying, and Organ Transplantation. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • PRESIDENT’S COMMISSION FOR THE STUDY OF ETHICAL PROBLEMS IN MEDICINE (1981): Defining Death: A Report on the Medical, Legal and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office.

  • PRESIDENT’S COUNCIL ON BIOETHICS (2008): Controversies in the Determination of Death. Washington, [online] [Retrieved August 30, 2018]. Available at:

  • REPETINGER, S. (2006): Long Survival Following Bacterial Meningitis-Associated Brain Destruction. In: Journal of Child Neurology, 21(7), pp. 591–595.

  • REPORT OF THE AD HOC COMMITTEE OF THE HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL (1968): A Definition of Irreversible Coma. In: Journal of the American Medical Association, 205(6), pp. 337–340.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (1998a): Chronic ‘Brain Death’: Meta-Analysis and Conceptual Consequences. In: Neurology, 51(6), pp. 1538–1545.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (1998b): ‘Brain-stem death’, ‘brain death’ and death: a critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. In: Issues in Law & Medicine, 14(2), pp. 125–145.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (1999): Chronic ‘Brain Death’: Meta-Analysis and Conceptual Consequences [response to letters]. In: Neurology, 53(6), pp. 1369–1372.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (2001): The Brain and Somatic Integration: Insights into the standard biological rationale for equating ‘brain death’ with death. In: Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 26(5), pp. 457–478.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (2012): You only die once: why brain death is not the death of a human being. In: Communio, 39(2), pp. 423–494.

  • SHEWMON, D. A. (2018): Truly Reconciling the Case of Jahi McMath. In: Neurocritical Care, 29(2), pp. 165–170.

  • SINGER, P. (1995): Rethinking life and death. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


  • THOMAS, A. G. (2012): Continuing the Definition of Death Debate: The Report of the President’s Council on Bioethics on Controversies in the Definition of Death. In: Bioethics, 26(2), pp. 101–107.

  • VEATCH, R. (1975): The whole-brain-oriented concept of death: An outmoded philosophical formulation. In: Journal of Thanatology, 3(1), pp. 13–30.


Zeitschrift + Hefte